Unbanked in India: A qualitative analysis of 24 years of financial inclusion policies

Abstract

Social work has historically engaged in pioneering interventions to improve the financial well-being of people. India is an interesting case as it has the highest number of unbanked people on one side and numerous policy interventions on the other. Using systematic review and Gioia methodology, we analyzed 24 years of financial inclusion policies. Our analysis revealed that the efficacy of policies was impeded by flawed designs, as the policymakers preferred ‘quick fixes’ over long-term solutions. Our study highlights the need for learning from the past and organizing complex information in a way that helps policymakers in taking informed policy design decisions.

Keywords

Financial inclusion India policymaking qualitative policy analysis social policy

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ballem

Mohammad

G.A.

Venkata

N.A.

(2012) Why Do People Not Join or Drop Out of SHGs? Lucknow: Microsave.

Banerjee

Karlan

Zinman

(2015) ‘Six Randomized Evaluations of Microcredit: Introduction and Further Steps’, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 7: 1–21.

Baruah

(2011) Women and Property in Urban India. Toronto: UBC Press.

Burgess

Pande

Wong

(2005) ‘Banking for the Poor: Evidence from India’, Journal of the European Economic Association 3: 268–78.

Burhouse

Chu

Ernst

Goodstein

Lloro

Lyons

Northwood

Osaki

Rhine

Sharma

Weinstein

(2016) ‘FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households 2015’, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Available at: https://www.fdic.gov/householdsurvey/2015/2015report.pdf

Catanach

I.J.

(1970) Rural Credit in Western India, 1875–1930. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Cerra

Saxena

S.C.

(2002) ‘What Caused the 1991 Currency Crisis in India?’, IMF Staff Papers 49: 395–425.

Chandrasekhar

C.P.

Ghosh

(2013) ‘Private Banks Don’t Help Financial Inclusion’, The Hindu Business Line, 15 April. Available online at: https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/columns/c-p-chandrasekhar/private-banks-dont-help-financial-inclusion/article23120321.ece

Charlesworth

(1972) ‘The Myth of the Deccan Riots of 1875’, Modern Asian Studies 6: 401–21.

10.

Dall

(1996) ‘Perceptions of Financial Counselling in Western Australia’, Master’s Thesis, Edith Cowan University, Perth, WA, Australia.

11.

Demirguc-Kunt

Beck

Honohan

(2008) ‘Access to Finance and Development: Theory and Measurement’, Finance for All? Policies and Pitfalls in Expanding Access. Washington, DC: World Bank, pp. 21–53. Available online at: https://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTFINFORALL/Resources/4099583-1194373512632/FFA_book.pdf

12.

Demirguc-Kunt

Klapper

Singer

Ansa

Richard

H. J.

(2018) The Global Findex Database 2017: Measuring Financial Inclusion and the Fintech Revolution. Washington, DC: World Bank.

13.

Deshpande

(2005) ‘Affirmative Action in India and the United States’, Washington, DC.

14.

Devarajan

(2004) ‘Service Area Approach and Utilisation of Bank Credit in Kerala – A Case Study of Kannur District’, Centre for Development Studies. Discussion Paper No. 75. Available online at: http://www.cds.ac.in/krpcds/publication/downloads/75.pdf

15.

Duriau

V.J.

Reger

R.K.

Pfarrer

M.D.

(2007) ‘A Content Analysis of the Content Analysis Literature in Organization Studies: Research Themes, Data Sources, and Methodological Refinements’, Organizational Research Methods 10: 5–34.

16.

Dymski

G.A.

(2005) ‘Financial Globalization, Social Exclusion and Financial Crisis’, International Review of Applied Economics 19: 439–57.

17.

Fisher

Sriram

(2002) Beyond Micro-Credit: Putting Development Back into Micro-Finance. Oxford: Oxfam Publishing.

18.

Friedline

Despard

(2016) ‘Life in a Banking Desert’, The Atlantic. Available online at: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/03/banking-desert-ny-fed/473436/ (accessed 5 September 2019).

19.

Gandhi

(2016) Rural Cooperatives: Repositioning, National Conference of Cooperative Banks – Regaining Leadership in Agricultural Finance. Lucknow: Bankers Institute of Rural Development.

20.

Ghosh

(1997) ‘India’s Structural Adjustment: An Assessment in Comparative Asian Context’, Economic and Political Weekly 32: 1113–31.

21.

Ghosh

(2013) ‘Microfinance and the Challenge of Financial Inclusion for Development’, Cambridge Journal of Economics 37: 1203–19.

22.

Gioia

D.A.

Corley

K.G.

Hamilton

A.L.

(2013) ‘Seeking Qualitative Rigor in Inductive Research Notes on the Gioia Methodology’, Organizational Research Methods 16: 15–31.

23.

Government of India (2008) Committee on Financial Inclusion. Mumbai, India: NABARD.

24.

Habib

(1964) ‘Usury in Medieval India’, Comparative Studies in Society and History 6: 393–419.

25.

Hamnett

(2014) ‘Shrinking the Welfare State: The Structure, Geography and Impact of British Government Benefit Cuts’, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 39: 490–503.

26.

Kapoor

Sinha

(2013) ‘Factors Influencing New Product Development in Microfinance Institutions: A Perspective from North Indian Microfinance Institutions’, Journal of Innovation Economics & Management 1: 83–105.

27.

Ketkar

K.W.

Ketkar

S.L.

(1992) ‘Bank Nationalization, Financial Savings, and Economic Development: a Case Study of India’, The Journal of Developing Areas 27(1): 69–84.

28.

Kingdon

J.W.

(2003) Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. Harlow: Longman Publishing.

29.

Kumar

(1965) ‘The Deccan Riots of 1875’, The Journal of Asian Studies 24: 613–35.

30.

Larquemin

(2015) ‘An Overview of the Financial Inclusion Policies in India’. Available online at: https://www.microfinancegateway.org/sites/default/files/publication_files/larquemin_a._an_overview_of_the_financial_inclusion_policies_in_india_ifmr_lead_august_2015.pdf

31.

Lenton

Mosley

(2012) Financial Exclusion and the Poverty Trap: Overcoming Deprivation in the Inner City. London: Routledge.

32.

Mader

(2013) ‘Rise and Fall of Microfinance in India: The Andhra Pradesh Crisis in Perspective’, Strategic Change 22(1–2): 47–66.

33.

Makkar

(2018) ‘Economic Survey 2018: Social Sector Spending Continues to Hover around 6%’. Business Standard, New Delhi. Available online at: https://medium.com/@krushapatel005/economic-survey-2018-social-sector-spending-continues-to-hover-around-6-df9f6828c4b4

34.

Mathew

(2014) Lok Sabha Election Results: Final Tally of Seats. Livemint: HT Media.

35.

Ministry of Finance (2015) ‘PMJDY Brochure’. Available online at: https://pmjdy.gov.in/files/E-Documents/PMJDY_BROCHURE_ENG.pdf

36.

Mohanty

(2012) ‘Perspectives on India’s Balance of Payments’, School of Management, KIIT University. Bhubaneswar, India: Central Bankers’ Speeches, Bank for International Settlement.

37.

Münkner

H.-.H.

(2006) One Hundred Years: Co-operative Credit Societies Act in India: A Unique Experience of Legal Social Engineering. Alliance de recherche universités-communautés en économie sociale, U. du Québec à Montréal.

38.

Nair

Tankha

(2013) Microfinance India: State of the Sector Report 2013. New Delhi: SAGE India.

39.

Nanda

(2000) Significance of Establishing Linkages with Self-Help Groups and Banks. Mumbai: National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development.

40.

National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) (2017) Themes in Indian History: Part III. New Delhi: National Council of Educational Research and Training.

41.

Parekh

Ashta

(2018) ‘An Institutional Logics Perspective to Evolution of Indian Microcredit Business Models’, Strategic Change 27(4): 313–27.

42.

Pollitt

(2008) Time, Policy, Management: Governing with the Past. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

43.

Pollitt

Bouckaert

(2011) Public Management Reform: A Comparative Analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

44.

Porter

Hewitt

(2015) ‘Achieving an Impact’, in Dingwall

(ed.) The SAGE Handbook of Research Management, pp. 399–422. London: SAGE.

45.

Powell

T.J.

Garrow

Woodford

M.R.

Perron

(2013) ‘Policymaking Opportunities for Direct Practice Social Workers in Mental Health and Addiction Services’, Advances in Social Work 14: 367–78.

46.

Ramji

(2009) Financial Inclusion in Gulbarga: Finding Usage in Access. Chennai: Institute of Financial Management and Research-Centre for Micro Finance.

47.

Randolph

Viswanath

(2004) ‘Lessons Learned from Public Health Mass Media Campaigns: Marketing Health in a Crowded Media World’, Annual Review of Public Health 25: 419–37.

48.

Rayudu

(1991) Rural Credit in India: A Study of Andhra Pradesh. New Delhi: Mittal Publications.

49.

Reserve Bank of India (2005) Annual Policy Statement for the Year 2005–06. Mumbai: Reserve Bank of India.

50.

Reserve Bank of India (2013) Financial Inclusion in India – An Assessment. Mumbai: Reserve Bank of India.

51.

Reserve Bank of India (2015) Quarterly Statistics on Deposits and Credit of Scheduled Commercial Banks (31 Mar 2009–31 Dec 2014). Mumbai: Reserve Bank of India.

52.

Sen

(1995) Inequality Reexamined. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

53.

Sen

(1999) Development as Freedom. New York: Anchor Books.

54.

Senge

P.M.

(2006) The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization. New York: Doubleday.

55.

Seymour

(2018) ‘The Impact of Public Health Awareness Campaigns on the Awareness and Quality of Palliative Care’, Journal of Palliative Medicine 21: S30.

56.

Sherraden

Barr

M.S.

(2005) ‘Institutions and Inclusion in Social Policy’, in Retsinas

N.P.

Belsky

E.S.

(eds) Building Assets, Building Credit: Creating Wealth in Low-Income Communities, pp. 286–315. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

57.

Sherraden

M.S.

Huang

Frey

J.J.

Birkenmaier

Callahan

Clancy

M.M.

(2015) ‘Financial Capability and Asset Building for All’, Working Paper No. 13. American Academy of Social Work and Social Welfare, Columbia, SC.

58.

Shipler

D.K.

(2008) The Working Poor: Invisible in America. New York: Vintage.

59.

Sinha

(2016) ‘Overlooked or Ignored – Missing Elements in the Entrepreneurial Finance Policies: A Case of Introducing MUDRA Bank in India’, Strategic Change 25(5): 569–83.

60.

Sinha

Tan

Zhan

(2018) ‘Patterns of Financial Attributes and Behaviors of Emerging Adults in the United States’, Children and Youth Services Review 93: 178–85.

61.

Srinivasan

(2010) Microfinance India: State of the Sector Report 2009. Chennai: SAGE.

62.

Stuart

P.H.

(2013) ‘Social Workers and Financial Capability in the Profession’s First Half-Century’, in Birkenmaier

Sherraden

M.S.

Curley

J.C.

(eds) Financial Capability and Asset Development: Research, Education, Policy, and Practice, pp. 44–61. New York; Oxford: Oxford University Press.

63.

Swain

Varghese

(2009) ‘Does Self Help Group Participation Lead to Asset Creation?’ World Development. Available online at: http://www.cermi.eu/documents/Final_RanjulaBaliSwainVarghese.pdf

64.

Thyagarajan

Venkatesan

(2008) ‘Cost–Benefit and Usage Behaviour Analysis of No Frills Accounts: A Study Report on Cuddalore District’. College of Agricultural Banking and Institute for Financial Management and Research, Chennai, India.

65.

Venkatesh

S.A.

(2008) Off the Books. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

66.

Walgrave

Van Aelst

(2016) ‘Political Agenda Setting and the Mass Media’, in Thompson

W.R.

(ed.) Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics, pp. 1–26. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

67.

Weinraub

(1991) ‘Economic Crisis Forcing Once Self-Reliant India to Seek Aid’, The New York Times, 29 June. Available online at: https://www.nytimes.com/1991/06/29/world/economic-crisis-forcing-once-self-reliant-india-to-seek-aid.html

68.

Wilson

W.J.

(2009) More Than Just Race: Being Black and Poor in the Inner City (Issues of Our Time). New York: WW Norton & Company.