Does formal strategic planning matter? An analysis of strategic management and perceived usefulness in Norwegian municipalities

Abstract

This article assesses whether municipal managers perceive strategic planning as most useful when integrated into mandatory area or financial-planning processes or conducted in processes with separate strategic planning documents. Despite being widely adopted in practice and being extensively debated in scholarly discourse for decades, current research has little empirical grounding for providing advice for policymakers and public managers on such common design choices. Multiple regression analysis of 128 Norwegian municipalities shows that using a voluntary separate strategic planning document was related to top management’s perceived usefulness of strategic planning. Integrating strategic planning into other management processes was also related to the perceived usefulness of strategic planning. Unexpectedly, using mandatory planning documents (such as four-year financial plans and long-term area plans) as the main strategic planning documents, formality and stakeholder involvement in the planning processes were not related to the perceived usefulness of strategic planning.

Points for practitioners

Planning, and in particular formal strategic planning, is often criticized both by scholars and practitioners as being useless when the environments are uncertain and turbulent, and for draining the organizations’ resources from other important management tasks. This article shows that many municipalities voluntarily produced separate strategic planning documents and that municipal top management found these plans more useful than using mandatory financial plans or area plans as their main strategic planning documents.

Keywords

impact implementation involvement New Public Management planning regional and local government strategy as practice top management

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andrews

Boyne

Walker

(2006) Strategy content and organizational performance: An empirical analysis. Public Administration Review 66(1): 52–63.

Andrews

Boyne

Law

, et al. (2012) Strategic Management and Public Service Performance. Houndsmill, Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan.

Baldersheim

Ståhlberg

(eds) (1994) Towards the Self-regulating Municipality: Free Communes and Modernization in Scandinavia. Aldershot: Dartmouth.

Boyne

(2010) Strategic planning. In: Ashworth

Boyne

Entwistle

(eds) Public Service Improvement: Theory and Evidence. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 60–77.

Brunsson

(1985) The Irrational Organization: Irrationality as a Basis for Organizational Action and Change. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.

Bryson

Edwards

(2017) Strategic planning in the public Sector. In: Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Business and Management. DOI: 10.1093/acrefore/9780190224851.013.128.

Bryson

(2011) Strategic Planning for Public and Nonprofit Organizations (4th edn). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Bryson

Crosby

Bryson

(2009) Understanding strategic planning and the formulation and implementation of strategic plans as ways of knowing: The contributions of actor-network theory. International Public Management Journal 12(2): 172–207.

Elbanna

Andrews

Pollanen

(2016) Strategic planning and implementation success in public service organizations: Evidence from Canada. Public Management Review 18(7): 1017–1042.

10.

Desmidt S and Meyfroodt K (2018) Debate: Unravelling strategic planning effectiveness–what about strategic consensus?. Public Money and Management 38(4): 255–256.

11.

Ervin

(1992) Administration and change: American practices in strategic planning. International Review of Administrative Sciences 58(4): 539–554.

12.

Favoreu

Carassus

Maurel

(2016) Strategic management in the public sector: A rational, political or collaborative approach? International Review of Administrative Sciences 82(3): 435–453.

13.

Ferlie

Ongaro

(2015) Strategic Management in Public Services Organizations: Concepts, Schools and Contemporary Issues. London: Routledge.

14.

George

Desmidt

(2014) A state of research on strategic management in the public sector: An analysis of the empirical evidence. In: Joyce

Drumaux

(eds) Strategic Management in Public Organizations: European Practices and Perspectives. New York, NY: Routledge, pp. 151–172.

15.

George

Pandey

(2017) We know the yin – but where is the yang? Toward a balanced approach on common source bias in public administration scholarship. Review of Public Personnel Administration 37(2): 245–270.

16.

George

Desmidt

De Moyer

(2016) Strategic decision quality in Flemish municipalities. Public Money & Management 36(5): 317–324.

17.

George

Desmidt

Cools

, et al. (2018) Cognitive styles, user acceptance and commitment to strategic plans in public organizations: An empirical analysis. Public Management Review 20(3): 340–359.

18.

Goldsmith

(1997) Private-sector experience with strategic management: Cautionary tales for public administration. International Review of Administrative Sciences 63(1): 25–40.

19.

Hansen

(2011) Application of strategic management tools after an NPM-inspired reform: Strategy as practice in Danish schools. Administration & Society 43(7): 770–806.

20.

Hofstad

(2013) Planning models in Sweden and Norway: Nuancing the picture. Scandinavian Political Studies 36(3): 270–292.

21.

Hofstede

(1984) Culture’s Consequences: International Differences in Work-related Values. London: Sage.

22.

Hood

(1991) A public management for all seasons? Public Administration 69(1): 3–19.

23.

Jakobsen

Jensen

(2015) Common method bias in public management studies. International Public Management Journal 18(1): 3–30.

24.

Johanson

(2019) Strategy Formation and Policy Making in Government. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

25.

Johnsen

(2016) Strategic planning and management in local government in Norway: Status after three decades. Scandinavian Political Studies 39(4): 333–365.

26.

Johnsen

(2018) Impacts of strategic planning and management in municipal government: An analysis of subjective survey and objective production and efficiency measures in Norway. Public Management Review 20(3): 397–420.

27.

Joyce

(2017) Strategic Leadership in the Public Services (2nd edn). London: Routledge.

28.

Lindblom

(1959) The science of ‘muddling through’. Public Administration Review 19(2): 79–88.

29.

Mazouz

Rousseau

, with the collaboration of Hudon PA (2016) Strategic management in public administrations: A results-based approach to strategic public management. International Review of Administrative Sciences 82(3): 411–417.

30.

Meier

O’Toole

Jr LJ

(2013) Subjective organizational performance and measurement error: Common source bias and spurious relationships. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 23(2): 429–456.

31.

Mintzberg

(1994) The Rise and Fall of Strategic Planning. New York, NY: Prentice Hall.

32.

Moore

(1995) Creating Public Value: Strategic Management in Government. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

33.

Mulgan

(2009) The Art of Public Strategy: Mobilizing Power and Knowledge for the Common Good. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

34.

Nylehn

(1996) Strategy in local government. Scandinavian Political Studies 19(4): 359–377.

35.

Poister

Streib

(2005) Elements of strategic planning and management in municipal government: Status after two decades. Public Administration Review 65(11): 45–56.

36.

Poister

Edwards

Pasha

, et al. (2013) Strategy formulation and performance: Evidence from local public transit companies. Public Performance & Management Review 36(4): 585–615.

37.

Proeller

(2007) Strategic Management for the State: International Approaches in Comparison. Gütersloh: Bertelsmann Foundation.

38.

Rumelt

(2011) Good Strategy/Bad Strategy: The Difference and Why it Matters. London: Profile Books.

39.

Van Gunsteren

(1976) The Quest for Control: A Critique of the Rational-central-rule Approach in Public Affairs. London: John Wiley and Sons.

40.

Vinzant

(1996) Strategy and organizational capacity: Finding a fit. Public Productivity & Management Review 20(2): 139–157.

41.

Walker

Andrews

(2015) Local government management and performance: A review of evidence. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 25(1): 101–133.

42.

Whittington

(2006) Completing the practice turn in strategy research. Organization Studies 27(5): 613–634.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.47 MB