A Return to State-Led Integrated Regional Planning? Emerging Approaches from Three U.S. States

Abstract

After decades of neglect, several U.S. states have increased support for regional development planning, creating new programs, organizations, and funding streams to support it. Analysis of programs in three states (New York, Michigan, and Indiana) shows similarities among them as well as contrasts with prior episodes of state-led regional planning. The new programs deliberately sidestep older regional planning organizations like COGs and RPCs in favor of new organizations with larger roles for the private sector and greater access to public funds. The resulting plans focus on individual projects within a pro-development agenda, but still have potential to coordinate action at a regional scale.

Keywords

regional governance regional planning regional organizations state development policy state-local relations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abbott

Carl

. 1997. The Portland region: Where city and suburbs talk to each other—and often agree. Housing Policy Debate 8 (1): 11–51.

Abels

Michael

. 2014. Strategic alignment for the new normal: Collaboration, sustainability, and deliberation in local government across boundaries. State and Local Government Review 46 (3): 211–18.

Bowman

Ann O’M.

Franke

James L.

. 1984. The decline of substate regionalism. Journal of Urban Affairs 6 (4): 51–63.

Bureau of Transportation Statistics, U. S. Dept. of Transportation. 2015. State transportation statistics 2015. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Transportation.

Burnham

Edward H.

Bennett

Edward Herbert

. 1909. Plan of Chicago. Chicago, IL: Commercial Club of Chicago.

Chakraborty

Arnab

. 2010. Scenario planning for effective regional governance: Promises and limitations. State and Local Government Review 42 (2): 156–67.

Chapin

Timothy S.

2012. Introduction: From growth controls, to comprehensive planning, to smart growth: Planning’s emerging fourth wave. Journal of the American Planning Association 78 (1): 5–15.

Committee on Regional Plan of New York and Its Environs. 1929. Regional plan of New York and its environs. Philadelphia, PA: Wm. F. Fell Co. Printers.

Dabson

Brian

. 2019. Regional solutions for rural and urban challenges. State and Local Government Review 51 (4): 283–91.

10.

Utah

Envision

. 2016. Envision Utah: Mission and history. https://www.envisionutah.org/about/mission-history. (accessed June 27, 2020).

11.

Finn

Donovan

Chandrasekhar

Divya

Xiao

. 2019. A region recovers: Planning for resilience after superstorm Sandy. Journal of Planning Education and Research. https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X19864145

12.

Fishman

Robert

. 2000. The death and life of American regional planning. In Reflections on regionalism, ed. Katz

Bruce

, 107–26. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.

13.

Friedmann

John

Bloch

Robin

. 1990. American exceptionalism in regional planning, 1933–2001. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 14 (4): 576–601.

14.

Friedmann

John

Weaver

Clyde

. 1979. Territory and function: The evolution of regional planning. Berkeley: University of California Press.

15.

Frug

Gerald E.

Barron

David J.

. 2008. City bound: How states stifle urban innovation. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

16.

Green

Timothy

. 2016. The relationship between formal analysis and regional marketing: Evidence from a national survey of regional economic development partnerships. Regional Studies Association Second North America Conference, Atlanta, GA.

17.

Green

Timothy

Finn

Donovan

. 2019. Collaborative governance or private sector power grab? An analysis of the changed governance of regional development planning in three U.S. states. Association of Collegiate Schools of Planning 59th Annual Conference, Greenville, SC.

18.

Grigsby

Eugene J.

III . 2003. Regional governance and regional councils. In Regional government innovations: A handbook for citizens and public officials, ed. Kemp

Roger L.

, 287–93. Jefferson, NC: Mcfarland and Company, Inc.

19.

Hanlon

Bernadette

Short

John Rennie

Vicino

Thomas J.

. 2009. Cities and suburbs: New metropolitan realities in the US. New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group.

20.

Hansen

Niles

Higgins

Benjamin

Savoie

Donald J.

. 1990. Regional policy in a changing world. New York: Plenum Press.

21.

Indiana Economic Development Corporation. 2014. Benchmarking U.S. regional cities: A study and guide for transformation. Indianapolis, IN: Indiana Economic Development Corporation.

22.

Indiana Economic Development Corporation. 2020. What is the regional cities initiative? https://www.iedc.in.gov/programs/regional-cities-initiative/home (accessed June 26, 2020).

23.

Julnes

George

Pindur

Wolfgang

. 1994. Determinants of local governmental support for alternative forms of regional coordination. The American Review of Public Administration 24 (4): 411–28.

24.

Lewis

Rebecca

Knaap

Gerrit-Jan

. 2012. Institutional structures for state growth management: An examination of state development plans. State and Local Government Review 44 (1): 33–44.

25.

Meck

Suart

. 2002. Growing smart legislative guidebook: Model statutes for planning and the management of change. Chicago: American Planning Association.

26.

Michigan Dept. of Technology, Management, and Budget. 2017. Regional prosperity initiative fiscal year 2018 evaluation criteria. https://www.michigan.gov/documents/dtmb/Evaluation_437058_7.pdf (accessed June 21, 2020).

27.

Michigan Dept. of Technology, Management, and Budget. 2020a. Regional prosperity initiative—the basics. https://www.michigan.gov/dtmb/0,5552,7-358-82547_56345_66155-310319--,00.html (accessed June 27, 2020).

28.

Michigan Dept. of Technology, Management, and Budget. 2020b. Regional prosperity initiative grant recipients. https://www.michigan.gov/dtmb/0,5552,7-358-82547_56345_66155---,00.html (accessed June 17, 2020).

29.

Miller

David

Nelles

Jen

. 2020. Order out of chaos: The case for a new conceptualization of the cross-boundary instruments of American regionalism. Urban Affairs Review 56 (1): 325–59.

30.

Mogulof

Melvin B.

1971. Regional planning, clearances and evaluation: A look at the A-95 process. Journal of the American Institute of Planners 37 (6): 418–22.

31.

Morrill

Richard L.

1989. Regional governance in the United States: For whom? Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 7 (1): 13–26.

32.

New York State. 2011. Governor Cuomo Announces $785 Million in Economic Development Funding Through Regional Councils, December 8, 2011. https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-cuomo-announces-785-million-economic-development-funding-through-regional-councils (accessed June 7, 2020).

33.

New York State. 2014. Regional Economic Development Council Awards. https://regionalcouncils.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2018-02/REDCAwardsBooklet2014.pdf (accessed June 2, 2020).

34.

New York State. 2015. Governor Cuomo Announces More Than $2 Billion in Economic Development Resources Awarded Through Upstate Revitalization Initiative and Regional Economic Development Council Competition. https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-cuomo-announces-more-2-billion-economic-development-resources-awarded-through-upstate (accessed June 29, 2020).

35.

New York State. 2019a. Providing the tools for prosperity. https://regionalcouncils.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2019-04/2019REDCGuidebook.pdf (accessed June 12, 2020).

36.

New York State. 2019b. Regional Economic Development Councils: 2019 Awards. https://www.ny.gov/sites/ny.gov/files/atoms/files/2019REDCA2f79hkFinal.pdf (accessed June 3, 2020)

37.

New York State. 2019c. Governor Cuomo and Legislative Leaders Announce FY 2020 Enacted Budget Includes $100 Million for Fourth Round of Downtown Revitalization Initiative, April 19, 2019. https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-cuomo-and-legislative-leaders-announce-fy-2020-enacted-budget-includes-100-million (accessed June 19, 2020).

38.

New York State. n.d. Regional economic development councils—about us. https://regionalcouncils.ny.gov/about (accessed June 27, 2020).

39.

Northeast Indiana Regional Partnership and Greater Fort Wayne, Inc. 2015. The road to one million: Northeast Indiana regional cities initiative proposal. https://assets.neindiana.com/resources/the-road-to-one-million-plan.pdf (accessed June 9, 2020)

40.

Olberding

Julie Cencula

. 2002. Diving into the ‘third waves’ of regional governance and economic development strategies: A study of regional partnerships for economic development in U.S. metropolitan areas. Economic Development Quarterly 16 (3): 251–72.

41.

Orfield

Myron

. 1997. Metropolitics: A regional plan for community and stability. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.

42.

Pelham

Thomas G.

2017. A historical perspective for evaluating Florida’s evolving growth management process. In Growth management in Florida: Planning for paradise, eds. Chapin

Timothy Stewart

Connerly

Charles E.

Higgins

Harrison T.

, 33–48. New York: Routledge.

43.

Piro

Rocky

Leiter

Robert

Rooney

Sharon

. 2017. Emerging trends in regional planning. Planning Advisory Service Report 586. Chicago: American Planning Association.

44.

Regional Cities of Northern Indiana. 2015. Innovate Indiana Regional Development Plan. https://iedc.in.gov/docs/default-source/iedc-assets/regional-cities/innovate-indiana_northern-in-regional-development-plan-2015-371-pgs.pdf?sfvrsn=4 (accessed June 11, 2020).

45.

Renski

Henry

. 2009. A new era of federal involvement in regional economic development? The case of the wired initiative. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 27 (4): 593–611.

46.

Rothblatt

Donald N.

1994. North American metropolitan planning. Journal of the American Planning Association 60 (4): 501–20.

47.

Seltzer

Ethan

Carbonell

Armando

. 2011. Planning regions. In Regional planning in America: Practice and prospect, ed. Seltzer

Ethan

and Armando, 1–16. Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

48.

Southwest Indiana Regional Development Authority. 2015. Indiana’s great southwest regional development plan. https://www.iedc.in.gov/docs/default-source/iedc-assets/regional-cities/southwestern-indiana-rda-regional-development-plan-application_upload-2-220-pgs.pdf?sfvrsn=12c142d1_6 (accessed June 13, 2020).

49.

Southwest Michigan Prosperity Region. 2014. 5 Year Prosperity Plan, Volume 2. https://www.swmpc.org/downloads/rpivolume2110315final.pdf (accessed June 14, 2020).

50.

U.S. Department of Commerce. 1928. A standard city planning enabling act. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

51.

Wallis

Allan D.

1992. New life for regionalism? Maybe. National Civic Review 81 (1): 19–26.

52.

Weitz

Jerry

Seltzer

Ethan

. 1998. Regional planning and regional governance in the United States 1979-1996. Journal of Planning Literature 12 (3): 361–92.

53.

Wheeler

Stephen M.

2000. Planning for metropolitan sustainability. Journal of Planning Education and Research 20 (2): 133–45.

54.

Whisman

Holly Erin Cooper

. 2013. Regional councils and the influence of state laws on regional g. PhD diss., University of North Carolina at Charlotte, Charlotte. ProQuest (3608510).

55.

Yin

Robert K.

2009. Case study research design and methods, 4th ed. Applied Social Research Methods Series , Vol. 5. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.