This article uses two longitudinal cohort studies (Growing Up in Ireland and the National Educational Panel Study) to examine how shadow education relates to academic performance in Ireland and Germany. Patterns of take-up of, and outcomes from, shadow education are found to reflect the particular country context—aimed at maintaining performance to avoid grade retention in Germany and preparing for a high-stakes upper secondary exam in Ireland. Participation enhances academic performance but only for students with lower levels of prior achievement. However, the relationship is not much stronger than with engagement in structured out-of-school activities. Thus, shadow education appears to be one of a number of strategies used by more privileged families to secure educational advantage.
BakerDP (2020) An inevitable phenomenon: Reflections on the origins and future of worldwide shadow education. European Journal of Education55(3): 311–315.
2.
BakerDPAkibaMLeTendreGK, et al (2001) Worldwide shadow education: Outside-school learning, institutional quality of schooling, and cross-national mathematics achievement. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis23(1): 1–17.
3.
BakerDPLeTendreGK (2005) National Differences, Global Similarities: World Culture and the Future of Schooling. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
4.
BenckwitzLGuillKRoloffJ, et al (2022) Investigating the relationship between private tutoring, tutors’ use of an individual frame of reference, reasons for private tutoring, and students’ motivational-affective outcomes. Learning and Individual Differences95: 102137.
5.
BlossfeldH-PRoßbachH-G (2019) Education as a Lifelong Process: The German National Educational Panel Study (NEPS), Edition ZfE (2nd ed.). Wiesbaden: Springer.
6.
BourdieuP (1986) Forms of capital. In: RichardsonJG (ed.) Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. Greenwood Press, pp. 241–258.
7.
BrayM (2014) The impact of shadow education on student academic achievement: Why the research is inconclusive and what can be done about it. Asia Pacific Education Review15: 381–389.
8.
BrayM (2021) Shadow education in Europe: Growing prevalence, underlying forces, and policy implications. ECNU Review of Education4(3): 442–475.
9.
BrayMHajarA (2022) Shadow Education in the Middle East: Private Supplementary Tutoring and Its Policy Implications. London: Taylor & Francis.
10.
BreenRGoldthorpeJH (1997) Explaining educational differentials: Towards a formal rational action theory. Rationality and Society9(3): 275–305.
11.
BrohBA (2002) Linking extracurricular programming to academic achievement: Who benefits and why?Sociology of Education75(1): 69–95.
12.
BuchmannCCondronDJRoscignoVJ (2010) Shadow education, American style: Test preparation, the SAT and college enrollment. Social Forces89(2): 435–461.
13.
ByunSY (2014) Shadow education and academic success in South Korea. In: ParkHKimK (eds) Korean Education in Changing Economic and Demographic Contexts. Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 39–58.
14.
ByunSYParkH (2012) The academic success of East Asian American youth: The role of shadow education. Sociology of Education85(1): 40–60.
15.
ByunSYChungHJBakerDP (2018) Global patterns of the use of shadow education: Student, family, and national influences. Research in the Sociology of Education20: 71–105.
16.
CabaneCHilleALechnerM (2016) Mozart or Pelé? The effects of adolescents’ participation in music and sports. Labour Economics41: 90–103.
17.
CarrollJB (1963) A model of school learning. Teacher College Record64: 723–733.
18.
CoulangeonP (2018) The impact of participation in extracurricular activities on school achievement of French middle school students: Human capital and cultural capital revisited. Social Forces97(1): 55–90.
19.
CovayECarbonaroW (2010) After the bell: Participation in extracurricular activities, classroom behavior, and academic achievement. Sociology of Education83(1): 20–45.
EntrichSR (2018) Shadow Education and Social Inequalities in Japan: Evolving Patterns and Conceptual Implications. Cham: Springer.
22.
EntrichSR (2021) Worldwide shadow education and social inequality: Explaining differences in the socio-economic gap in access to shadow education across 63 societies. International Journal of Comparative Sociology61(6): 441–475.
23.
EntrichSRLauterbachW (2019) Shadow education in Germany: Compensatory or status attainment strategy? Findings from the German LifE Study. International Journal for Research on Extended Education7(2): 143–159.
24.
EriksonRJonssonJO (1996) Can Education Be Equalized? The Swedish Case in Comparative Perspective. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
25.
ESRI (2021) Growing up in Ireland Cohort ’98 (Child Cohort) Wave 4–20 years, 2019. [dataset]. Version 1. Irish Social Science Data Archive (SN: 0020-04). Available at: https://www.ucd.ie/issda/data/guichild/guichildwave4/
26.
FredericksJA (2012) Extracurricular participation and academic outcomes: Testing the over-scheduling hypothesis. Journal of Youth and Adolescence41(3): 295–306.
27.
FredericksJAEcclesJS (1996) Is extracurricular participation associated with beneficial outcomes?Concurrent and Longitudinal Relations, Developmental Psychology42(4): 698–713.
28.
GuillKBosW (2014) Effectiveness of private tutoring in mathematics with regard to subjective and objective indicators of academic achievement. Evidence from a German secondary school sample. Journal for Educational Research Online6(1): 34–67.
29.
GuillKLintorfK (2019) Private tutoring when stakes are high: Insights from the transition from primary to secondary school in Germany. International Journal of Educational Development65: 172–182.
30.
GuillKLüdtkeOKöllerO (2020a) Assessing the instructional quality of private tutoring and its effects on student outcomes: Analyses from the German National Educational Panel Study. British Journal of Educational Psychology90(2): 282–300.
31.
GuillKLüdtkeOSchwanenbergJ (2020b) A two-level study of predictors of private tutoring attendance at the beginning of secondary schooling in Germany: The role of individual learning support in the classroom. British Educational Research Journal46(2): 437–457.
32.
GuillKÖmeroğullarıMKöllerO (2021) Intensity and content of private tutoring lessons during German secondary schooling: Effects on students’ grades and test achievement. European Journal of Psychology of Education.
33.
HanSSuhH (2023) The effects of shadow education on high school students’ creative thinking and academic achievement in mathematics: The case of the Republic of Korea. Educational Studies49(2): 314–333.
34.
HilleASchuppJ (2015) How learning a musical instrument affects the development of skills. Economics of Education Review44: 56–82.
35.
IresonJRushforthK (2009) Private tutoring at transition points in the English education system: Its nature, extent and purpose. Research Papers in Education26(1): 1–19.
36.
JansenDElffersLJakS (2021) A cross-national exploration of shadow education use by high and low SES families. International Studies in Sociology of Education32: 653–674.
37.
KeithTZ (1982) Time spent on homework and high school grades: A large-sample path analysis. Journal of Educational Psychology74(2): 248–253.
38.
KimTJangHKimJ (2022) Do peers affect private tutoring engagement in Korea? Evidence from a quasi-experimental approach. Asia Pacific Educational Review23: 271–283.
39.
KnifesendCAGrahamS (2012) Too much of a good thing? How breadth of extracurricular participation relates to school-related affect and academic outcomes during adolescence. Journal of Youth and Adolescence41(3): 379–389.
40.
KristenCGranatoN (2007) The educational attainment of the second generation in Germany. Ethnicities7(3): 343–366.
41.
LareauA (2003) Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
42.
LiuY (2018) When choices become chances: Extending Boudon’s positional theory to understand university choices in contemporary China. Comparative Education Review62(1): 125–146.
43.
LorenzJStubbeTC (2020) Private tutoring as a means for maintaining social status. Journal for Educational Research Online12(2): 89–113.
44.
LoyalkaPZakharovA (2016) Does shadow education help students prepare for college? Evidence from Russia. International Journal of Educational Development49: 22–30.
45.
LucasSR (2001) Effectively Maintained Inequality: Transitions, Track Mobility, and Social Background Effects. American Journal of Sociology106(6): 1642–1690.
46.
LuplowNSchneiderT (2014) Nutzung und Effektivität privat bezahlter Nachhilfe im Primarbereich. Zeitschrift für Soziologie43(1): 31–49.
47.
MaazKTrautweinULüdtkeO, et al (2008) Educational transitions and differential learning environments: How explicit between-school tracking contributes to social inequality in educational outcomes. Child Development Perspectives2(2): 99–106.
48.
McCoySByrneD (2022) Shadow education uptake among final year students in secondary schools in Ireland: Wellbeing in a high stakes context. ESRI Working Paper no 724. Available at: https://www.esri.ie/system/files/publications/WP724_1.pdf
49.
McCoySByrneDBanksJ (2012) Too much of a good thing? Gender, “concerted cultivation” and unequal achievement in primary education. Child Indicators Research5(1): 155–158.
50.
MatsuokaR (2015) School socio-economic compositional effect on shadow education participation: Evidence from Japan. British Journal of Sociology of Education36(2): 270–290.
51.
MetsäpeltoRLPulkkinenL (2011) Socioemotional behavior and school achievement in relation to extracurricular activity participation in middle childhood. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research56(2): 167–182.
52.
MischoCHaagL (2002) Expansion and effectiveness of private tutoring. European Journal of Psychology of Education17(3): 263–273.
53.
MontebonDRT (2016) Shadow education: Effects on students’ self-efficacy in science. International Journal of Research Studies in Education5(1): 31–40.
54.
NEPS Network (2021) National Educational Panel Study, Scientific Use File of Starting Cohort Grade 5 [dataset]. Bamberg: Leibniz Institute for Educational Trajectories (LIfBi).
55.
ÖmeroğullarıMGuillKKöllerO (2020) Effectiveness of private tutoring during secondary schooling in Germany: Do the duration of private tutoring and tutor qualification affect school achievement?Learning and Instruction66: 101306.
56.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (2015) The ABC of Gender Equality in Education. Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.
57.
OttoBKarbachJ (2019) The effects of private tutoring on students’ perception of their parents’ academic involvement and the quality of their parent-child relationship. Educational Psychology39(7): 923–940.
58.
PanZLienDWangH (2022) Peer effects and shadow education. Economic Modelling111: 105822.
59.
PfeiferCCornelißenT (2010) The impact of participation in sports on educational attainment—New evidence from Germany. Economics of Education Review29(1): 94–103.
60.
Rabe-HeskethSSkrondalA (2022) Multilevel and Longitudinal Modeling Using Stata, 4th edn.College Station, TX: Stata Press.
61.
ReayDCrozierGClaytonJ (2009) Strangers in paradise? Working-class students in elite universities. Sociology43(6): 1103–1121.
62.
SchneiderSLTiebenN (2011) A healthy sorting machine? Social inequality in the transition to upper secondary education in Germany. Oxford Review of Education37(2): 139–166.
63.
SkopekJPassarettaG (2021) Socio-economic inequality in children’s achievement from infancy to adolescence: The case of Germany. Social Forces100(1): 86–112.
64.
SmythE (2009) Buying your way into college? Private tuition and the transition to higher education in Ireland. Oxford Review of Education35(1): 1–22.
65.
SmythE (2016a) Arts and Cultural Participation among Children and Young People: Insights from the Growing Up in Ireland Study. Dublin: ESRI/Arts Council.
66.
SmythE (2016b) Students’ Experiences and Perspectives on Secondary Education: Institutions, Transitions and Policy. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
67.
SmythEBanksJ (2011) From Leaving Certificate to Leaving School: A Longitudinal Study of Sixth Year Students. Dublin: The Liffey Press.
68.
StevensonDLBakerDP (1992) Shadow education and allocation in formal schooling: Transition to university in Japan. American Journal of Sociology97(6): 1639–1657.
69.
TakashiroN (2021) Determinants of middle school students’ participation in shadow education in Japan. Social Indicators Research155: 1119–1136.
70.
TsiplakidesI (2018) Shadow education and social class inequalities in secondary education in Greece: The case of teaching English as a foreign language. International Journal of Sociology of Education7(1): 71–93.
71.
ZhangYDangYHeY, et al (2021) Is private supplementary tutoring effective? A longitudinally detailed analysis of private tutoring quality in China. Asia Pacific Education Review22: 239–259.
72.
ZwierDGevenSvan de WerfhorstHG (2021) Social inequality in shadow education: The role of high-stakes testing. International Journal of Comparative Sociology61(6): 412–440.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
