Unique to the construction industry, project labor agreements (PLAs) are pre-hire labor contracts between project owners and unions. The impact of PLAs is debated among industry stakeholders, scholars, and policymakers. While prior research on PLAs has focused on construction costs and bid competition, this is the first known study to assess whether PLAs affect project duration. Through an analysis of 313 public works construction projects in Sacramento County, California, the authors find that PLAs are associated with 15 to 17% faster time to completion than non-PLA projects when controlling for factors such as project cost, project type, and awarding agency. Further, PLA projects are 43% more likely to be completed in the following year than non-PLA projects. This study supports the notion that PLAs protect construction contractors and owners from risk and promote faster completion of projects by ensuring access to skilled labor and harmonizing work arrangements across the various trades.
AllisonPaul. 2010. Survival analysis. In HancockGregory R.MuellerRalph O. (Eds.), The Reviewer’s Guide to Quantitative Methods in the Social Sciences, pp. 413–25. New York: Routledge.
BachmanPaulBurkeWilliam F.TuerckDavid G.2019. The anticompetitive effects of government-mandated project labor agreements on construction in Washington state. Report. Washington, DC: Washington Policy Center.
4.
BachmanPaulChisholmDarlene C.HaughtonJonathanTuerckDavid G.2003. Project labor agreements and the cost of school construction in Massachusetts. Report. Boston: Beacon Hill Institute at Suffolk University.
5.
BachmanPaulHaughtonJonathan. 2007. Do project labor agreements raise construction costs?Case Studies in Business, Industry and Government Statistics1(1):71–79.
6.
BachmanPaulHaughtonJonathanTuerckDavid G.2004. Project labor agreements and the cost of public school construction in Connecticut. Report. Boston: Beacon Hill Institute at Suffolk University.
7.
BachmanPaulTuerckDavid G.2006. Project labor agreements and public construction costs in New York State. Report. Boston: Beacon Hill Institute at Suffolk University.
8.
BachmanPaulTuerckDavid G.2017. Project labor agreements and the cost of school construction in Ohio. Report. Boston: Beacon Hill Institute at Suffolk University.
9.
BaskinMaurice. 1998. The case against union-only labor project labor agreements in government construction projects. Journal of Labor Research19(1):115–24.
BelmanDaleOrmistonRussellKelsoRichardSchriverWilliamFrankKenneth. 2010. Project labor agreements’ effect on school construction costs in Massachusetts. Industrial Relations49(1):44–60.
13.
ButtonChelsea. 2019. “Fair and open competition” or death to the union? Project labor agreements in today’s politically contentious atmosphere. UIC Law Review52(2):531–80.
Caltrans. 2023. California invests more than $3.1 billion in projects to rebuild and upgrade state’s transportation infrastructure. News Release, August2023. Accessed September 28, 2023, https://dot.ca.gov/news-releases/news-release-2023-027
16.
ChimientiElizabeth Ann. 2002. Breaking down barriers, building up communities: Implementing project labor agreements with targeted hiring goals. Unpublished master’s thesis. Cornell University.
FigueroaMariGrabelskyJeffLamareJ. Ryan. 2013. Community workforce agreements: A tool to grow the union market and to expand access to lifetime careers in the unionized building trades. Labor Studies Journal38(1):7–31.
20.
[GAO] General Accounting Office. 1998. Project labor agreements: The extent of their use and related information. Report GGD-98-82. Washington, DC. Accessed September 26, 2021, https://www.gao.gov/assets/ggd-98-82.pdf
21.
HerreraLucero E.WaheedSabaKoonseTiaOvando-LacrouxClarine. 2014. Exploring targeted hire: An assessment of best practices in the construction industry. Report. UCLA Labor Center.
22.
Johnston-DoddsKimberly. 2001. Construction California: A Review of Project Labor Agreements. Sacramento: California State Library, California Research Bureau.
23.
LopezliraEnriqueFarmandAida. 2024Evaluating the impact of project labor agreements on the cost of affordable housing projects: Proposition HHH in Los Angeles. Report. UC Berkeley Labor Center.
24.
LundJohnOswaldJoe. 2001. Public project labor agreements: Lessons learned, new directions. Labor Studies Journal26(3):1–23.
25.
KoppRobert W.GaalJohn. 1999. The case for project labor agreements. The Construction LawyerJanuary:5–13.
26.
KotlerFred B.2009. Project labor agreements in New York State: In the public interest. Report. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University, School of Industrial and Labor Relations – Extension Division, Construction Industry Program.
27.
ManzoFrankIVBrunoRobert. 2015. Efficiencies of project labor agreements: Illinois Capital Development Board Projects, 2011–2013. ILEPI-LEP Economic Commentary No. 19. Illinois Economic Policy Institute and University of Illinois Labor Education Program.
28.
ManzoFrankIVBrunoRobert. 2024. The impacts of project labor agreements on competition, costs, apprenticeships, and diversity: Evidence from Port of Seattle projects. Report. Illinois Economic Policy Institute. Accessed June 21, 2024, ilepi-pmcr-port-of-seattle-pla-study-final.pdf
29.
MayerGerald. 2010. Project labor agreements. CRS Report for Congress, 7-5700. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service.
ParkinJason. 2004. Constructing meaningful access to work: Lessons from the Port of Oakland project labor agreement. Columbia Human Rights Law Review35(2):375–414.
33.
PhilipsPeterLittlehaleScott. 2015. Did PLAs on LA affordable housing projects raise construction costs? Working Paper No. 2015-03. University of Utah, Economics Department.
34.
PhilipsPeterWaitzmanEmma. 2021. Do project labor agreements reduce the number of bidders on public projects? The case of community colleges in California. Public Works Management & Policy26(4):337–58.
35.
TuerckDavid G.GlassmanSarahBachmanPaul. 2009. Project labor agreements on federal construction projects: A costly solution in search of a problem. Report. Boston: Beacon Hill Institute at Suffolk University.
36.
WaddoupsC. JeffreyMayDavid C.2014. Do responsible contracting policies increase construction bid costs?Industrial Relations53(2):273–94.
37.
WardJason. 2021The effects of project labor agreements on the construction of affordable housing: Evidence from Proposition HHH. Research Report. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation.
