Beginning in 2012, several states enacted right-to-work laws, which hamper the ability of labor unions to collect agency fees to finance union services and activities. Because the processes by which these adoptions took place are arguably exogenous, identification of the causal effect of right-to-work on unionization within a state becomes possible. The author uses a set of semi-independent cross-sections drawn from the Current Population Survey for years 2000 to 2018 to investigate the impact of right-to-work on the probability of unionization in the five states that adopted it after 2011. The empirical analysis reveals an economically meaningful and statistically significant adverse effect from right-to-work adoption on union density that is distinct from other factors influencing unionization during that time period.
AbrahamSteven E.VoosPaula B.2000. Right-to-work laws: New evidence from the stock market. Southern Economic Journal67(2): 345–62.
2.
AngristJoshua D.PischkeJorn-Steffen. 2010. The credibility revolution in empirical economics: How better research design is taking the con out of econometrics. Journal of Economic Perspectives24(2): 3–30.
3.
———. 2015. Mastering ‘Metrics: The Path from Cause to Effect. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
BlanchflowerDavid G.BrysonAlex. 2002. Changes over time in union relative wage effects in the UK and US revisited. NBER Working Paper No. 9395. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
BrunoRobertZulloRolandManzo IVFrankIVDicksonAlison. 2015. The economic effects of adopting a right-to-work law: Implications for Illinois. Labor Studies Journal40(4): 319–61.
8.
CardDavid. 2001. The effect of unions on wage inequality in the U.S. labor market. Industrial and Labor Relations Review54(2): 296–315.
EllwoodDavid T.FineGlenn. 1987. The impact of right-to-work laws on union organizing. Journal of Political Economy95(2): 250–73.
18.
ErenOzkanOzbeklikSerkan. 2016. What do right-to-work laws do? Evidence from a synthetic control method analysis. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management35(1): 173–94.
19.
FarberHenry S.1984. Right-to-work laws and the extent of unionization. Journal of Labor Economics2(3): 319–52.
20.
———. 2005. Nonunion wage rates and the threat of unionization. Industrial and Labor Relations Review58(3): 335–52.
21.
FarberHenry S.WesternBruce. 2001. Accounting for the decline of unions in the private sector, 1973–1998. Journal of Labor Research22(3): 459–85.
22.
FeigenbaumJamesHertel-FernandezAlexanderWilliamsonVanessa. 2019. From the bargaining table to the ballot box: Political effects of right to work laws. NBER Working Paper No. 24259. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
23.
FlanaganRobert J.2005. Has management strangled U.S. unions?Journal of Labor Research26(1): 33–63.
24.
FreemanRichard B.1988. Contraction and expansion: The divergence of private sector and public sector unionism in the United States. Journal of Economic Perspectives2(2): 63–88.
25.
———. 2003. What do unions do . . . to voting? NBER Working Paper No. 9992. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
26.
FreemanRichard B.MedoffJames L.1984. What Do Unions Do?New York: Basic Books.
27.
GouldEliseKimballWill. 2015. “Right-to-work states” still have lower wages. EPI Briefing Paper No. 395. Washington, DC: Economic Policy Institute.
28.
GouldEliseShierholzHeidi. 2011. The compensation penalty of “right-to-work” laws. EPI Briefing Paper No. 299. Washington, DC: Economic Policy Institute.
29.
Hertel-FernandezAlexander. 2019a. State Capture: How Conservative Activists, Big Businesses, and Wealthy Donors Reshaped the American States—and the Nation. New York: Oxford University Press.
30.
———. 2019b. Asymmetric partisan polarization, labor policy, and cross-state political power-building. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science685(1): 64–79.
31.
HirschBarry T.MacPhersonDavid A.2003. Union membership and coverage database from the Current Population Survey: Note. Industrial and Labor Relations Review56(2): 349–54.
32.
HoglerRaymondShulmanStevenWeilerStephan. 2004. Right-to-work legislation, social capital, and variations in state union density. Review of Regional Studies34(1): 95–111.
33.
HolmesThomas J.1998. The effect of state policies on the location of manufacturing: Evidence from state borders. Journal of Political Economy106(4): 667–705.
KochanThomas A.KimballWilliam T.2019. Unions, worker voice, and management practices: Implications for a high-productivity, high-wage economy. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences5(5): 88–108.
37.
KoellerC. Timothy. 1985. Wages, trade union activity, and the political environment of unionism: A simultaneous equation model. Journal of Labor Research6(2): 147–65.
38.
KuhnJames W.1961. Right-to-work laws: Symbols or substance?Industrial and Labor Relations Review14(4): 587–94.
39.
LumsdenKeithPetersenCraig. 1975. The effect of right-to-work laws on unionization in the United States. Journal of Political Economy83(6): 1237–48.
40.
MacLeanNancy. 2017. Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right’s Stealth Plan for America. New York: Penguin Books.
41.
ManzoFrankIVBrunoRobert. 2017. The impact of right-to-work laws on labor market outcomes in three Midwestern states: Evidence from Indiana, Michigan, and Wisconsin (2010–2016). Project for Middle Class Renewal Report. Urbana-Champaign, IL: Illinois Economic Policy Institute.
42.
MayerJane. 2016. Dark Money: The Hidden History of the Billionaires behind the Rise of the Radical Right. New York: Anchor Books.
43.
MettenAnne. 2021. Rethinking trade union density: A new index for measuring union strength. Industrial Relations Journal52(6): 528–49.
44.
MishelLawrenceBivensJosh. 2021. Identifying the policy levers generating wage suppression and wage inequality. Report. Washington, DC: Economic Policy Institute.
45.
MooreWilliam J.1998. The determinants and effects of right-to-work laws: A review of the recent literature. Journal of Labor Research19(3): 445–69.
46.
MooreWilliam J.DunlevyJames A.NewmanRobert J.1986. Do right to work laws matter? Comment. Southern Economic Journal53(2): 515–24.
47.
MurphyRichard. 2020. Why unions survive: Understanding how unions overcome the free-rider problem. Journal of Labor Economics38(4): 1141–88.
48.
ReedW. Robert. 2003. How right-to-work laws affect wages. Journal of Labor Research24(4): 713–30.
SkocpolThedaHertel-FernandezAlexander. 2016. The Koch network and Republican Party extremism. Perspectives on Politics14(3): 681–99.
51.
SlaughterMatthew J.2007. Globalization and declining unionization in the United States. Industrial Relations46(2): 329–46.
52.
StansburyAnnaSummersLawrence H.2020. The declining worker power hypothesis: An explanation for the recent evolution of the American economy. NBER Working Paper No. 27193. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
53.
StevansLonnie K.2009. The effect of endogenous right-to-work laws on business and economic conditions in the United States: A multivariate approach. Review of Law and Economics5(1): 595–614.
54.
VachonTodd E.WallaceMichael. 2018. Red state, blue state: Neoliberalism, politics and public sector union membership in the US states. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society11(3): 519–39.
55.
WarrenRonald S.StraussRobert P.1979. A mixed logit model of the relationship between unionization and right-to-work legislation. Journal of Political Economy87(3): 648–55.
56.
WartzmanRick. 2017. The End of Loyalty: The Rise and Fall of Good Jobs in America. New York: Public Affairs.
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
