Managers frequently offer unconditional bonuses and profit-sharing payments to their employees. The isolated effects of the former payment type on job satisfaction, in particular, have received little empirical attention. This study uses German panel data and shows that workers report significantly higher levels of job satisfaction when wages contain such bonuses, mostly regardless of their relative size. This result persists even when income is held constant. Conversely, profit-sharing payments show a positive association with satisfaction only if they are sufficiently large. When endogeneity issues are taken into account, however, the latter correlation becomes weaker or vanishes. Findings have significant implications for managers when designing salary packages. They imply that monetary gifts in the form of unconditional bonus payments can be a beneficial alternative to incentives in efforts to enhance employees’ job satisfaction.
AkerlofGeorge A.1982. Labor contracts as partial gift exchange. Quarterly Journal of Economics97(4):543–69.
2.
AllanJulia L.AndelicNicoleBenderKeith A.PowellDanielStoffelSandroTheodossiouIoannis. 2021. Employment contracts and stress: Experimental evidence. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization187:360–73.
3.
ArtzBenjamin. 2008. The role of firm size and performance pay in determining employee job satisfaction brief: Firm size, performance pay, and job satisfaction. Labour22(2):315–43.
4.
ArtzBenjamin. 2010. Fringe benefits and job satisfaction. International Journal of Manpower31(6):626–44.
5.
BaktashMehrzad B.HeywoodJohn S.JirjahnUwe. 2022. Worker stress and performance pay: German survey evidence. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization201:276–91.
6.
BellemareCharlesShearerBruce. 2009. Gift giving and worker productivity: Evidence from a firm-level experiment. Games and Economic Behavior67(1):233–44.
7.
BenderKeith A.TheodossiouIoannis. 2014. The unintended consequences of the rat race: The detrimental effects of performance pay on health. Oxford Economic Papers66(3):824–47.
8.
BhattiKomal KhalidQureshiTahir Masood. 2007. Impact of employee participation on job satisfaction, employee commitment and employee productivity. International Review of Business Research Papers3(2):54–68.
9.
BöckermanPetriIlmakunnasPekka. 2012. The job satisfaction-productivity nexus: A study using matched survey and register data. ILR Review65(2):244–62.
10.
BogliacinoFrancescoGrimaldaGianlucaPipke.David2021. Kind or contented? An investigation of the gift-exchange hypothesis in a natural field experiment in Colombia. Kiel Working Paper No. 2199. Kiel, Germany: Kiel Institute for the World Economy.
BrysonAlexClarkAndrew E.FreemanRichard B.GreenColin P.2016. Share capitalism and worker wellbeing. Labour Economics42:151–58.
13.
BuchanNancy R.CrosonRachel T.A.SolnickSara. 2008. Trust and gender: An examination of behavior and beliefs in the investment game. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization68(3–4):466–76.
14.
BuelensMarcVan den BroeckHerman. 2007. An analysis of differences in work motivation between public and private sector organizations. Public Administration Review67(1):65–74.
15.
CadsbyC. BramSongFeiTaponFrancis. 2007. Sorting and incentive effects of pay for performance: An experimental investigation. Academy of Management Journal50(2):387–405.
16.
CadsbyC. BramSongFeiTaponFrancis. 2016. The impact of risk-aversion and stress on the incentive effect of performance-pay. In GeorgSebastian J.HammanJohn R. (Eds.), Experiments in Organizational Economics, pp. 189–227. Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
17.
CarterMary E.FrancoFrancescaGineMireia. 2017. Executive gender pay gaps: The roles of female risk aversion and board representation. Contemporary Accounting Research34(2):1232–64.
18.
CharnessGary. 2004. Attribution and reciprocity in an experimental labor market. Journal of Labor Economics22(3):665–88.
19.
ChenChung-An. 2018. “A little is better than zero” or “Pay enough or don’t pay at all”? Evidence on the size of pay-for-performance across the sectors. Public Personnel Management47(2):119–43.
20.
ChoiJongwoon. 2014. Can offering a signing bonus motivate effort? Experimental evidence of the moderating effects of labor market competition. Accounting Review89(2):545–70.
21.
ClarkAndrew E.MavromarasKostasWeiZhang. 2015. Happy to stay: Job satisfaction and retirement. Conference Paper. Scottish Economic Society 2015 Annual Conference. Perth, Scotland.
22.
CornelissenThomasHeywoodJohn S.JirjahnUwe. 2011. Performance pay, risk attitudes and job satisfaction. Labour Economics18(2):229–39.
23.
CurrieJanetLinWanchuanMengJuanjuan. 2013. Social networks and externalities from gift exchange: Evidence from a field experiment. Journal of Public Economics107:19–30.
24.
DahlMichael S.PierceLamar. 2020. Pay-for-performance and employee mental health: Large sample evidence using employee prescription drug usage. Academy of Management Discoveries6(1):12–38.
25.
De ReeJoppeMuralidharanKarthikPradhanMennoRogersHalsey. 2018. Double for nothing? Experimental evidence on an unconditional teacher salary increase in Indonesia. Quarterly Journal of Economics133(2):993–1039.
26.
DittrichMarcus. 2015. Gender differences in trust and reciprocity: Evidence from a large-scale experiment with heterogeneous subjects. Applied Economics47(36):3825–38.
27.
DohmenThomasFalkArmin. 2011. Performance pay and multidimensional sorting: Productivity, preferences, and gender. American Economic Review101(2):556–90.
28.
DohmenThomasFalkArminHuffmanDavidSundeUwe. 2008. Representative trust and reciprocity: Prevalence and determinants. Economic Inquiry46(1):84–90.
29.
DonohueSusan M.HeywoodJohn S.2004. Job satisfaction and gender: An expanded specification from the NLSY. International Journal of Manpower25(2):211–38.
30.
EnglmaierFlorianLeiderStephen. 2020. Managerial payoff and gift-exchange in the field. Review of Industrial Organization56(2):259–80.
31.
FehrErnstGächterSimon. 2000. Fairness and retaliation: The economics of reciprocity. Journal of Economic Perspectives14(3):159–81.
32.
FirthLucyMellorDavid J.MooreKathleen A.LoquetClaude. 2004. How can managers reduce employee intention to quit?Journal of Managerial Psychology19(2):170–87.
33.
GanzeboomHarry B. G.TreimanDonald J.2019. International Stratification and Mobility File (ISMF): Conversion Tools. Sample survey data. http://www.harryganzeboom.nl/ismf/index.htm
34.
GeorgellisYannisIossaElisabettaTabvumaVurain. 2011. Crowding out intrinsic motivation in the public sector. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory21(3):473–93.
35.
GilchristDuncan S.LucaMichaelMalhotraDeepak. 2016. When 3 + 1 > 4: Gift structure and reciprocity in the field. Management Science62(9):2639–50.
36.
GneezyUriRustichiniAldo. 2000. Pay enough or don’t pay at all. Quarterly Journal of Economics115(3):791–810.
37.
GoebelJanGrabkaMarkus M.LiebigStefanKrohMartinRichterDavidSchröderCarstenSchuppJürgen. 2019. The German Socio-Economic Panel (SOEP). Jahrbücher für Nationalökonomie und Statistik239(2):345–60.
38.
GreenColinHeywoodJohn S.2008. Does performance pay increase job satisfaction?Economica75(300):710–28.
39.
GrundChristianSliwkaDirk. 2010. Evidence on performance pay and risk aversion. Economics Letters106(1):8–11.
40.
HalkosGeorgeBousinakisDimitrios. 2010. The effect of stress and satisfaction on productivity. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management59(5):415–31.
HeywoodJohn S.WeiXiangdong. 2006. Performance pay and job satisfaction. Journal of Industrial Relations48(4):523–40.
43.
HimmelreicherRalfKraikosKatjaOhlertClemensSchneider.Sascha2023. Sonderzahlungen im Jahr 2018: Wer bekommt sie in welcher Höhe. Bundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin, Preprint.
IsselhardRaoulMantheiKathrinVogelsangTimo. 2024. Performance pay, gifts, and the relative bonus size. Working Paper. https://ssrn.com/abstract=4038176
46.
JudgeTimothy A.PiccoloRonald F.PodsakoffNathan P.ShawJohn C.RichBruce L.2010. The relationship between pay and job satisfaction: A meta-analysis of the literature. Journal of Vocational Behavior77(2):157–67.
47.
KautonenTeemuHyttiUllaBogenholdDieterHeinonenJarna. 2012. Job satisfaction and retirement age intentions in Finland: Self-employed versus salary earners. International Journal of Manpower33(4):424–40.
48.
KubeSebastianMarechalMichel AndréPuppeClemens. 2012. The currency of reciprocity: Gift-exchange in the workplace. American Economic Review102(4):1644–62.
49.
KunzAlexis H.PfaffDieter. 2002. Agency theory, performance evaluation, and the hypothetical construct of intrinsic motivation. Accounting, Organizations and Society27(3):275–95.
50.
LawlerEdward E.III. 1992. The Ultimate Advantage: Creating the High-Involvement Organization. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
51.
LazearEdward P.2000. Performance pay and productivity. American Economic Review90(5):1346–61.
52.
LongRichard J.2000. Employee profit sharing: Consequences and moderators. Relations Industrielles55(3):477–504.
53.
NeckermannSusanneYangXiaolan. 2017. Understanding the (unexpected) consequences of unexpected recognition. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization135:131–42.
54.
OswaldAndrew J.ProtoEugenioSgroiDaniel. 2015. Happiness and productivity. Journal of Labor Economics33(4):789–822.
PeruginiMarcoGallucciMarcelloPresaghiFabioErcolaniAnna Paola. 2003. The personal norm of reciprocity. European Journal of Personality17(4):251–83.
57.
PouliakasKonstantinos. 2010. Pay enough, don’t pay too much or don’t pay at all? The impact of bonus intensity on job satisfaction. Kyklos63(4):597–626.
58.
PouliakasKonstantinosTheodossiouIoannis. 2009. Confronting objections to performance pay: The impact of individual and gain-sharing incentives on job satisfaction. Scottish Journal of Political Economy56(5):662–84.
59.
ScottK. DowTaylorG. Stephen. 1985. An examination of conflicting findings on the relationship between job satisfaction and absenteeism: A meta-analysis. Academy of Management Journal28(3):599–612.
60.
Sendel-MullerMarkusWeckesMarion. 2013. Gewinn- und Erfolgsbeteiligung. Betriebs-und Dienstvereinbarungen. Frankfurt am Main: Hans Böckler Stiftung.
61.
SockinJasonSockinMichael. 2019. A pay scale of their own: Gender differences in variable pay. Working Paper. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3512598
62.
WeberThomasBeckMartin. 2015. Sonderzahlungen in Deutschland: Eine Analyse auf Basis der Verdienststrukturerhebung 2010. Wirtschaft und Statistik4:69–83.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
