The authors adopt a person-centered approach to the investigation of the dimensionality of the union commitment construct by capitalizing on a 10-year longitudinal study (from 1992 to 2002) of 637 union members in their first year of employment measured again 1 and 10 years later. Results reveal four distinct profiles of union commitment, presenting a stable structure over time. These profiles demonstrate consistency in commitment level across the three most common union commitment dimensions, thus questioning the necessity of adopting a multidimensional approach. Results show that union members became more similar to other members of their profiles over time, and that their union commitment became slightly less extreme as union tenure increased. Finally, results show that union commitment profiles predict union participation, in accordance with our expectations, and suggest that endorsing positive attitudes toward unions and their instrumentality was a stronger predictor of profile membership than was satisfaction with the actions of one’s own union.
BambergerPeter A.KlugerAvraham N.SuchardRonena. 1999. The antecedents and consequences of union commitment: A meta-analysis. Academy of Management Journal42(3): 304–18.
2.
BayazitMahmutHammerTove H.WazeterDavid L.2004. Methodological challenges in union commitment studies. Journal of Applied Psychology89(4): 738–47.
3.
CatanoVictor M.PondMorganKellowayKevin. 2001. Exploring commitment and leadership in volunteer organizations. Leadership & Organizational Development Journal22(6): 256–63.
4.
ChanAndySnapeEdRedmanTom. 2011. Multiple foci and bases of commitment in a Chinese workforce. International Journal of Human Resource Management22(16): 3290–3304.
5.
CiarrochiJosephMorinAlexandre J. S.SahdraBaljinder K.LitalienDavidParkerPhilip D.2017. A longitudinal person-centered perspective on youth social support: Relations with psychological wellbeing. Developmental Psychology53(6): 1154–69.
6.
CollinsLindaLanzaStephanie. 2010. Latent Class and Latent Transition Analysis: With Applications in the Social, Behavioral, and Health Sciences. New York: Wiley.
7.
DeshpandeSatish P.FioritoJack. 1989. Specific and general beliefs in union voting models. Academy of Management Journal32(4): 883–97.
8.
FieldsMitchell W.ThackerJames. 1992. Influence of quality of work life on company and union commitment. Academy of Management Journal35(2): 439–50.
9.
FioritoJackGallagherDaniel G.FukamiCynthia. 1988. Satisfaction with union representation. Industrial and Labor Relations Review41(2): 294–307.
10.
FriedmanLeeHarveyRobert. 1986. Factors of union commitment: The case for a lower dimensionality. Journal of Applied Psychology71(3): 371–76.
11.
FullagarClive. 1986. A factor analytic study on the validity of a union commitment scale. Journal of Applied Psychology71(1): 129–36.
12.
FullagarCliveBarlingJulian. 1989. A longitudinal test of a model of the antecedents and consequences of union loyalty. Journal of Applied Psychology74(2): 213–27.
13.
FullagarCliveBarlingJulian. 1991. Predictors and outcomes of different patterns of organizational and union loyalty. Journal of Occupational Psychology64(2): 129–43.
14.
FullagarCliveMcCoyDonShullCarla. 1992. The socialization of union loyalty. Journal of Organizational Behavior13(1): 13–27.
15.
FullagarCliveClarkPaul F.GallagherDaniel G.GordonMichael. 1994. A model of the antecedents of early union commitment: The role of socialization experiences and steward characteristics. Journal of Organizational Behavior15(6): 517–33.
16.
FullagarCliveGallagherDaniel G.GordonMichaelClarkPaul F.1995. Impact of early socialization on union commitment and participation: A longitudinal study. Journal of Applied Psychology80(1): 147–57.
17.
FullagarCliveGallagherDaniel G.ClarkPaul F.CarrollAnthony. 2004. Union commitment and participation: A 10-year longitudinal study. Journal of Applied Psychology89(4): 730–37.
18.
GetmanJulius G.GoldbergStephenHermanJeanne. 1976. Union Representation Elections: Law and Reality. New York: Russell Sage.
19.
GilletNicolasMorinAlexandre J. S.CougotBaptisteGagnéMarylène. 2017. Workaholism profiles: Associations with determinants, correlates, and outcomes. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology90(4): 559–86.
20.
GilletNicolasMorinAlexandre J. S.HuyghebaertTiphaineBurgerLucieMaillotAxelPoulinAurélieTricardElodie. 2018. University students’ need satisfaction trajectories: A growth mixture analysis. Learning & Instruction. doi:10.1016/j.learninstruc.2017.11.003.
21.
GordonMichael E.PhilpotJohn W.BurtRobert E.ThompsonCynthiaSpillerWilliam. 1980. Commitment to the union: Development of a measure and an examination of its correlates. Journal of Applied Psychology65(4): 479–99.
22.
HammerTove H.BayazitMahmutWazeterDavid. 2009. Union leadership and member attitudes: A multi-level analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology94(2): 392–410.
23.
HippJohn R.BauerDaniel J.2006. Local solutions in the estimation of growth mixture models. Psychological Methods11(1): 36–53.
24.
HoellRobert. 2004. How employee involvement affects union commitment. Journal of Labor Research25(2): 268–77.
25.
HorsmanPatrickGallagherDaniel G.KellowayKevin. 2016. The rise, resurrection, and growth of union commitment research. In MeyerJohn P. (Ed.), The Handbook of Employee Commitment, pp. 165–77. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.
26.
HsuLouis. 1995. Regression toward the mean associated with measurement error and the identification of improvement and deterioration in psychotherapy. Journal of Consulting & Clinical Psychology63(1): 141–44.
27.
IversonRoderickKuruvillaSarosh. 1995. Antecedents of union loyalty: The influence of individual dispositions and organizational context. Journal of Organizational Behavior16(6): 557–82.
28.
KamChesterMorinAlexandre J. S.MeyerJohn P.TopolnytskyLaryssa. 2016. Are commitment profiles stable and predictable?Journal of Management42(6): 1462–90.
29.
KellowayKevinBarlingJulian. 1993. Members’ participation in local union activities: Measurement, prediction and replication. Journal of Applied Psychology78(2): 262–79.
30.
KellowayKevinCatanoVictor M.SouthwellRobert. 1992. The construct validity of union commitment: Development and dimensionality of a shorter scale. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology65(3): 197–211.
31.
KlandermansBert. 1989. Union commitment: Replications and tests in the Dutch context. Journal of Applied Psychology74(6): 869–75.
32.
KuruvillaSaroshIversonRoderick. 1993. A confirmatory factor analysis of union commitment in Australia. Journal of Industrial Relations35(3): 436–52.
33.
LaddRobert T.GordonMichael E.BeauvaisLaura L.MorganRichard L.1982. Union commitment: Replication and extension. Journal of Applied Psychology67(5): 640–44.
34.
LoYungtaiMendellNancyRubinDonald. 2001. Testing the number of components in a normal mixture. Biometrika88(5): 767–78.
35.
MagenauJohnMartinJamesPetersonMelanie. 1988. Dual and unilateral commitment among stewards and rank-and-file members. Academy of Management Journal31(2): 359–76.
36.
MäkikangasAnneTolvanenAskoAunolaKaisaFeldtTaruMaunonSaijaKinnunenUlla. 2018. Multilevel latent profile analysis with covariates. Organizational Research Methods. doi:10.1177/1094428118760690.
37.
MarshHerbert W.HauKit-Tai. 2007. Applications of latent-variable models in educational psychology: The need for methodological-substantive synergies. Contemporary Educational Psychology32(1): 151–71.
38.
MarshHerbert W.LödtkeOlivierTrautweinUlrichMorinAlexandre J. S.2009. Classical latent profile analysis of academic self-concept dimensions: Synergy of person- and variable-centered approaches to theoretical models of self-concept. Structural Equation Modeling16(2): 191–225.
McDonaldRoderick. 1970. Theoretical foundations of principal factor analysis and alpha factor analysis. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology23(1): 1–21.
41.
McShaneSteven. 1986. General union attitude: A construct validation. Journal of Labor Research7(4): 403–17.
42.
MellorSteven. 1992. The influence of layoff severity on post-layoff union commitment among survivors: The moderating effect of the perceived legitimacy of the layoff account. Personnel Psychology45(3): 549–600.
43.
MellorStevenMathieuJohnSwimJanet. 1994. Cross-level analysis of the influence of local union structure on women’s and men’s union commitment. Journal of Applied Psychology79(2): 203–10.
44.
MeyerJohn P.AllenNathalie J.1997. Commitment in the Workplace: Theory, Research and Application. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
45.
MeyerJohn P.MorinAlexandre J. S.2016. A person-centered approach to commitment research: Theory, research, and methodology. Journal of Organizational Behavior37(4): 584–612.
46.
MillsapRoger. 2011. Statistical Approaches to Measurement Invariance. New York: Taylor & Francis.
47.
MonnotMatthewWagnerStephenBeehrTerry. 2011. A contingency model of union commitment and participation: Meta-analysis of the antecedents of militant and nonmilitant activities. Journal of Organizational Behavior32(8): 1127–46.
48.
MorinAlexandre J. S.2016. Person-centered research strategies in commitment research. In MeyerJohn P. (Ed.), The Handbook of Employee Commitment, pp. 490–508. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.
MorinAlexandre J. S.WangJohn J. C. K.2016. A gentle introduction to mixture modeling using physical fitness data. In NtoumanisNikosMyersNicholas D. (Eds.), An Introduction to Intermediate and Advanced Statistical Analyses for Sport & Exercise Scientists, pp. 183–210. London: Wiley.
51.
MorinAlexandre J. S.MaïanoChristopheNagengastBenjaminMarshHerbert W.MorizotJulienJanoszMichel. 2011. Growth mixture modeling of adolescents’ developmental trajectories of anxiety: The impact of untested invariance assumptions on substantive interpretations. Structural Equation Modeling18(4): 613–48.
52.
MorinAlexandre J. S.VandenbergheChristianTurmelMarie-JoséeMadoreIsabelleMaïanoChristophe. 2013. Probing into commitment’s nonlinear relationships to work outcomes. Journal of Managerial Psychology28(2): 202–23.
53.
MorinAlexandre J. S.BoudriasJean-SébastienMarshHerbert W.MadoreIsabelleDesrumauxPascale. 2016. Further reflections on disentangling shape and level effects in person-centered analyses. Structural Equation Modeling23(3): 438–54.
54.
MorinAlexandre J. S.MeyerJohn P.CreusierJordaneBiétryFranck. 2016. Multiple-group analysis of similarity in latent profile solutions. Organizational Research Methods19(2): 231–54.
55.
MorinAlexandre J. S.BoudriasJean-SébastienMarshHerbert W.McInerneyDennis M.Dagenais-DesmaraisVéroniqueMadoreIsabelleLitalienDavid. 2017. Complementary variable- and person-centered approaches to the dimensionality of psychometric constructs. Journal of Business & Psychology32(4): 395–419.
56.
MorishimaMotohiro. 1995. Union loyalty among white-collar workers in Japan. Journal of Organizational Behavior16(6): 609–35.
57.
MuthénBengt. 2002. Beyond SEM: General latent modeling. Behaviormetrika29(1): 81–117.
58.
MuthénBengt. 2003. Statistical and substantive checking in growth mixture modeling: Comment on Bauer and Curran, 2003. Psychological Methods8(3): 369–77.
59.
MuthénLindaMuthénBengt. 2014. Mplus User’s Guide. Los Angeles: Muthén & Muthén.
60.
PeughJamesFanXitao. 2013. Modeling unobserved heterogeneity using latent profile analysis: A Monte Carlo simulation. Structural Equation Modeling20(4): 616–39.
61.
PorterLymanCramponWilliamSmithFrank. 1976. Organizational commitment and managerial turnover: A longitudinal study. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance15(1): 87–98.
62.
PurcellTheodore V.1953. The Worker Speaks His Mind on Company and Union. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
63.
QuinnRobertStaines.Graham1978. The 1977 Quality of Employment Survey. Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
64.
RaykovTenkoMarcoulidesGeorge. 2004. Using the delta method for approximate interval estimation of parameter functions in SEM. Structural Equation Modeling11(4): 621–37.
65.
RedmanTomSnapeEd. 2005. Exchange ideology and member-union relationships: An evaluation of moderation effects. Journal of Applied Psychology90(4): 765–73.
66.
RogosaDavid. 1995. Myths and methods: “Myths about longitudinal research” plus supplemental questions. In GottmanJohn M. (Ed.), The Analysis of Change, pp. 3–65. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
67.
ShoreLynnTetrickLoisSinclairRobertNewtonLucy. 1994. Validation of a measure of perceived union support. Journal of Applied Psychology79(6): 971–77.
68.
SinclairRobertTetrickLois. 1995. Social exchange and union commitment: Comparison of union instrumentality and union support perceptions. Journal of Organizational Behavior16(S1): 669–80.
69.
SkarlickiDanielLathamGary. 1996. Increasing citizenship behavior within a labor union: A test of organizational justice theory. Journal of Applied Psychology81(2): 161–69.
70.
SkrondalAndersLaakePetter. 2001. Regression among factor scores. Psychometrika66(4): 563–76.
71.
SnapeEdRedmanTomChanAndy. 2000. Commitment to the union: A survey of research and the implications for industrial relations and trade unions. International Journal of Management Reviews2(3): 205–30.
72.
SnapeEdRedmanTomGould-WilliamsJulian. 2014. How “collective” is union citizenship behavior?Industrial and Labor Relations Review67(4): 1306–25.
73.
StagnerRoss. 1954. Dual allegiance as a problem in modern society. Personnel Psychology7(1): 41–47.
74.
SverkeMagnusSjöbergAnders. 1994. Dual commitment to company and union in Sweden: An examination of predictors and taxonomic split methods. Economic and Industrial Democracy15(4): 531–64.
75.
TanHweeAryeeSamuel. 2002. Antecedents and outcomes of union loyalty: A constructive replication and an extension. Journal of Applied Psychology87(4): 715–22.
76.
TeinJenn-YunCoxeStefanyChamHeining. 2013. Statistical power to detect the correct number of classes in latent profile analysis. Structural Equation Modeling20(4): 640–57.
77.
TetrickLoisThackerJamesFieldsMitchell. 1989. Evidence of the stability of the four dimensions of the commitment to union scale. Journal of Applied Psychology74(5): 819–22.
78.
ThackerJamesFieldsMitchellTetrickLois. 1989. The factor structure of union commitment: An application of confirmatory factor analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology74(2): 228–32.
79.
TofighiDavoodEndersCraig. 2008. Identifying the correct number of classes in growth mixture models. In HancockGregory R.SamuelsenKaren M. (Eds.), Advances in Latent Variable Mixture Models, pp. 317–41. Charlotte, NC: Information Age.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
