The author compares winning bids on state and federal highway maintenance projects in Colorado between 2000 and 2011 to determine whether federal prevailing wage and disadvantaged business enterprise regulations are associated with increased construction costs. The effect of the Davis-Bacon Act is evaluated when average wage rates prevail for almost all workers involved in highway maintenance for most of the period of the study. The federal minimum for work completed by disadvantaged businesses is 10%. The goal for Colorado exceeds this minimum by two to three percentage points. Summary data indicate that federal projects are more expensive than state projects, but projects funded by the federal government are also larger and more complex. Regression results indicate that, with controls for project size and complexity, no statistically significant difference is found in the cost of federal and state projects. Results also indicate that federal regulations are not associated with reduced bid competition, an important determinant of project cost.
AllenSteven. 1983. Much ado about Davis-Bacon: A critical review and new evidence. Journal of Law and Economics2(3): 707–36.
2.
Azari-RadHamidPhilipsPeterPrusMark. 2002. Making hay when it rains: The effect prevailing wage regulations, scale economies, seasonal, cyclical and local business patterns have on school construction costs. Journal of Education Finance23(Spring): 997–1012.
3.
Azari-RadHamidPhilipsPeterPrusMark. 2003. State prevailing wage laws and school construction costs. Industrial Relations42(3): 445–57.
4.
BilginsoyCihanPhilipsPeter. 2000. Prevailing wage regulations and school construction costs: Evidence from British Columbia. Journal of Education Finance24(Winter): 415–32.
De SilvaDakshinaDunneTimothyKosmopoulouGeorgia. 2003. An examination of entrant and incumbent bidding in road construction auctions. Journal of Industrial Economics21(3): 295–316.
11.
De SilvaDakshinaDunneTimothyKosmopoulouGeorgiaLamarcheCarlos. 2012. Disadvantaged business enterprise goals and procurement contracting: An analysis of bidding behavior and costs. International Journal of Industrial Organization30(4): 377–88.
12.
DuncanKevinPrusMark. 2005. Prevailing wage laws and construction costs: Evidence from British Columbia’s Skills Development and Fair Wage Policy. In Azari-RadHamidPhilipsPeterPrusMark (Eds.), The Economics of Prevailing Wage Laws, pp. 123–48. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
13.
DunnSarahQuigleyJohnRosenthalLarry. 2005. The effect of prevailing wage regulations on the cost of low-income housing. Industrial & Labor Relations Review59(1): 141–57.
FraundorfMarthaFarrellJohnMasonRobert. 1984. The effect of the Davis-Bacon Act on construction costs in rural areas. Review of Economics and Statistics66(1): 142–46.
16.
GoldfarbJohnMorrallJohn. 1978. The cost implications of changing Davis-Bacon administration. Policy Analysis4(4): 439–53.
17.
GoldfarbJohnMorrallJohn. 1981. The Davis-Bacon Act: An appraisal of recent studies. Industrial & Labor Relations Review34(2): 191–206.
18.
GouldJohn. 1971. Davis-Bacon Act: The Economics of Prevailing Wage Laws. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research.
19.
GouldJohnBittlingmayerGeorge. 1980. The Economics of the Davis-Bacon Act: Analysis of Prevailing Wage Laws. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research.
20.
GreenSamuel. 1991. How many subjects does it take to do a regression analysis?Multivariate Behavioral Research26(3): 499–510.
21.
GujaratiDamodar. 1967. The economics of the Davis-Bacon Act. Journal of Business40(July): 303–16.
22.
HirschBarryMacphersonDavid. 2013. Index of Tables, Union Membership and Coverage Database from CPS. Accessed athttp://www.unionstats.com/.
23.
Jofre-BonetMireiaMartinPesendorfer. 2000. Bidding behavior in a repeated procurement auction: A summary. European Economic Review44(4–6): 1006–20.
24.
Jofre-BonetMireiaMartinPesendorfer. 2001. Estimation of a dynamic auction game. Working paper. Yale University.
25.
EdwardKellerHartmanWilliam. 2001. Prevailing wage rates: The effects on school construction costs, levels of taxation, and state reimbursements. Journal of Education Finance27(2): 713–28.
26.
KimJaewhanKuo-LiangChangPhilipsPeter. 2012. The effect of prevailing wage regulations on contractor bid participation and behavior: A comparison of Palo Alto, California with four nearby prevailing wage municipalities. Industrial Relations51(4): 874–91.
27.
KrasnokutskayaElenaSeimKatja. 2011. Bid preference programs and participation in highway procurement auctions. American Economic Review101(6): 2653–86.
28.
LeefGeorge. 2010. Prevailing wage laws: Public interest or special interest legislation?Cato Journal30(1):137–54.
29.
MarionJustin. 2007. Are bid preferences benign? The effect of small business subsidies in highway procurement auctions. Journal of Public Economics91(7–8): 1591–1624.
30.
MarionJustin. 2009. How costly is affirmative action? Government contracting and California’s Proposition 209. Review of Economics and Statistics91(3): 503–22.
U.S. General Accounting Office. 1979. The Davis-Bacon Act should be repealed. Prepared for the Congress of the United States. HRD-79-18.
37.
VincentJeffreyMonkkonenPaavo. 2010. The impact of state regulations on the cost of public school construction. Journal of Education Finance35(4): 313–30.
