Women's underrepresentation in higher organizational ranks is often attributed to low attitudinal commitment. This study examines attitudinal commitment to determine its origins and whether it differs for men and women. Previous research indicates that men and women have different levels of attitudinal commitment. Two explanations of attitudinal commitment differences are the gender model and the job model. The gender model contends that socialization shapes attitudinal commitment; in contrast, the job model suggests that workplace experiences determine attitudinal commitment. This study tests these models using 328 accountants as subjects; controlling for subjects' professional and educational background minimizes the confounding of extraneous factors found in previous research. Attitudinal commitment and workplace experiences were measured using subjects' evaluation of organizational involvement and job satisfaction. Stepwise regression models predicted significant amounts of variation and identified the antecedents of both concepts. The results replicate previous findings that women are less committed to their organizations than men. Men and women reported lower organizational involvement but higher job satisfaction. Regression models overwhelmingly supported the job model to describe men and women's attitudinal commitment. The results suggest that women's underrepresentation in upper management ranks can likely be decreased, while increasing their organizational involvement and job satisfaction, by altering factors within the organization's control, factors that shape the job experience.
ABDEL-HAIM, A. A.A reexamination of ability as a moderator of role perceptions-satisfaction relationship . Personnel Psychology, 1981, 34, 549-561 .
2.
AICPA . Survey on women's status and work/family issues in public accounting. New York: AICPA , 1994.
3.
ALLEN, N. J. , & MEYER, J. P.Organizational commitment: Evidence of career state effects?Journal of Business Research, 1993, 26, 49-61 .
4.
ANGLE, H. L. , & PERRY, J. L.Organizational commitment and organizational effectiveness: An empirical assessment . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1981, 26, 1-14 .
5.
ARANYA, N. , KUSHNIR, T. , & VALENCY, A.Organizational commitment in a male dominated profession . Human Relations, 1986, 39, 433-448 .
6.
AVEN, F. F. , PARKER, B. , & McEVOY, G. M.Gender and attitudinal commitment to organizations: A meta-analysis . Journal of Business Research, 1993, 26, 63-73 .
7.
BATEMAN, T. S. , & ORGAN, D. W.Job satisfaction and the good soldier: The relationship between affect and employee citizenship . Academy of Management Journal, 1983, 26, 587-595 .
8.
BATEMAN, T. S. , & STRASSER, S.A longitudinal analysis of the antecedents of organizational commitment , Academy of Management Journal, 1984, 27, 95-112 .
9.
BEDIAN, A. , & ARMENAKIS, A.A path-analytic study of the consequences of role conflict and ambiguity . Academy of Management Journal, 1981, 24(2), 417-424 .
10.
BLINE, D. M. , DUCHON, D. , & MEIXNER, W. F.The measurement of organizational and professional commitment: An examination of the psychometric property of two commonly used instruments . Behavioral Research in Accounting, 1991, 3, 1-12 .
11.
BRASS, D. J.Structural relationships, job characteristics, and worker satisfaction and performance . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1981, 26, 331-348 .
12.
BROOKE, P. P. , RUSSELL, D. W. , & PRICE, J. L.Discriminant validation of measures of job satisfaction, job involvement, and organizational commitment . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1988, 73, 139-145 .
13.
COHEN, A.Antecedents of organizational commitment across occupational groups: A meta-analysis . Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1992, 13, 539-558 .
14.
COOK, E. P.The gendered context of life: Implications for women's and men's career-life plans . The Career Development Quarterly, 1993, 41, 227-237 .
15.
CROMIE, S.Women as managers in Northern Ireland . Journal of Occupational Psychology, 1981, 54, 297-334 .
16.
DECI, E. L.The hidden costs of rewards . Organizational Dynamics, 1976, 4, 61-72 .
17.
DEWAR, R. , & WERBEL, J.Universalistic and contingency predictions of employee satisfaction and conflict . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1976, 24, 426-446 .
18.
FELDMAN, R. , & GLENN, E.Male and female: Job versus gender models in the sociology of work . Social Problems, 1979, 26, 525-535 .
19.
FRY, L. W. , & GREENFELD, S.An examination of attitudinal differences between policewomen and policemen . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1980, 65, 123-126 .
20.
GERHART, B.How important are dispositional factors as determinants of job satisfaction? Implications for job design and other personnel programs . Journal of Applied Psychology, 72, 366-373 .
21.
GLADSTEIN, D.Groups in context: A model of task group effectiveness . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1984, 29, 499-517 .
22.
GLISSON, C. , & DURNICK, M.Predictors of job satisfaction and organizational commitment in human service organizations . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1988, 33, 61-81 .
23.
GRADDICK, M. M. , & FARR, J. L.Professionals in scientific disciplines: Sex-related differences in working life commitments . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1983, 68, 641-645 .
HACKMAN, J. R. , & OLDHAM, G. R.Development of the job diagnostic survey . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1975, 60, 159-170 .
26.
HALL, D. T. , & RABINOWITZ, S.Caught up in work . Wharton Magazine, 1977, 2, 19-25 .
27.
HALL, D. T. , & SCHNEIDER, B.Correlates of organizational identification as a function of career pattern and organizational type . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1972, 17, 340-350 .
28.
HALL, D. T. , SCHNEIDER, B. , & NYGREN, H. T.Personal factors in organizational identification . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1970, 15, 176-190 .
29.
HAMMOND, T. The Minority Recruitment Efforts of Major Public Accounting Firms in New York City: A Sociological Analysis. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Wisconsin, 1990.
30.
HAYNES, K.Job satisfaction of mid-managerial social workers . Administration in Social Work, 1979, 3, 207-217 .
31.
HOOKS, K. L. , & CHERAMY, S. J.Facts and myths about women CPAs . Journal of Accountancy, 1994, 10, 79-82 .
32.
HREBINIAK, L. G.Effects of job level and participation on employee attitudes and perceptions of influence . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1974, 17, 649-662 .
33.
HULIN, C. L. , & BLOOD, M. L.Job enlargement, individual differences, and worker responses . Psychological Bulletin, 1968, 69, 41-45 .
34.
JACOBS, D. L.Back from the mommy track . The New York Times Business, 1994, 3, Oct. 9, 1994.
35.
JENSEN, L. C. , CHRISTENSEN, R. , & WILSON, D. J.Predicting young women's role preference for parenting and work . Sex Roles, 1985, 13, 507-514 .
36.
KANTER, R. M.Men and women of the corporation. New York: Basic Books , 1977.
37.
KATZ, D. , & KAHN, R. L.The social psychology of organizations (2nd ed.). New York: Wiley , 1978.
38.
KATZ, R.Job longevity as a situational factor in job satisfaction . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1978, 23, 204-223 .
39.
KINNIER, R. T. , KATZ, E. C. , & BERRY, M. A.Successful resolutions to the career-versus-family conflict . Journal of Counseling and Development, 1991, 2, 152-177 .
40.
KONRAD, A. M. , & LINNEHAN, F.Formalized HRM structures: Coordinating equal employment opportunity or concealing organizational practices . Academy of Management Journal, 1995, 38, 787-820 .
41.
LARWOOD, L. , FALBE, C. , KRIGER, M. , & MIESING, P.Structure and meaning of organizational vision . Academy of Management Journal, 1995, 38, 740-769 .
42.
MATHIEU, J. E. , & ZAJEC, D. M.A review and meta-analysis of the antecedents, correlates, and consequences of organizational commitment . Psychological Bulletin, 1990, 108, 171-194 .
43.
McNEELEY, R. L.Occupation, gender, and work satisfaction in a comprehensive human services departmentAdministration in Social Work, 1984, 8, 35-47 .
44.
MORRIS, J. H. , & SHERMAN, D. J.Generalizability of organizational commitment model . Academy of Management Journal, 1981, 24, 512-526 .
45.
MOWDAY, R. , PORTER, L. , & STEERS, R.Employee-organization linkages. New York: Academic Press , 1982.
46.
O'REILLY, C. , & CALDWELL, D. F.The commitment and job tenure of new employees: Some evidence of postdecisional justification . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1981, 26, 597-616 .
47.
O'REILLY, C. , & CHATMAN, J.Organizational commitment and psychological attachment: The effects of compliance, identification, and internalization on prosocial behavior . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1986, 71, 492-499 .
48.
PILLSBURY, C. M. , CAPOZZOLI, L. , & CIAMPA, A.A synthesis of research studies regarding the upward mobility of women in public accounting . Accounting Horizons, 1989,1, 63-70 .
49.
POWEIL, G.One more time: Do female and male managers differ?Academy of Management Executive, 1990, 4, 68-74 .
50.
RIZZO, J. , HOUSE, R. , & LIRTZMAN, S.Role conflict and ambiguity in complex organizations . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1970, 15, 150-163 .
51.
ROMZEK, B. S.Personal consequences of employee commitment . Academy of Management Journal, 1989, 32, 649-661 .
52.
SCHWARTZ, F.Management women and the new facts of life . Harvard Business Review, 1990, 65-76 .
53.
SHARPE, R.The waiting game-women make strides but men stay firmly in top company jobs . The Wall Street Journal, April 22, 1994.
54.
STAW, B. M. , & ROSS, J.Stability in the midst of change: A dispositional approach to job attitudes . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1985, 70, 469-480 .
55.
STAW, B. M. , BELL, N. E. , & CLAUSEN, J. A.The dispositional approach to job attitudes: A lifetime longitudinal test . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1986, 31, 56-77 .
56.
STEERS, R. M.Antecedents and outcomes of organizational commitment . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1977, 22, 46-56 .
57.
STEERS, R. M. , & SPENCER, D. G.The role of achievement motivation in job design . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1977, 62, 472-479 .
58.
STEFFY, B. D. , & JONES, J. W.The impact of family and career variables on the organizational, career, and community commitment of professional women . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 1988, 32, 196-212 .
59.
STEVENS, J. M. , BEYER, J. M. , & TRICE, H. M.Assessing personal role, and organizational predictors of managerial commitment . Academy of Management Journal, 1978, 21, 380-396 .
60.
TERBORG, J. R.Women in management: A research review . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1977, 62, 647-664 .
61.
VANDENBERG, R. J. , & LANCE, C. E.Examining the causal order of job satisfaction and organizational commitment . Journal of Management, 1992, 18(1), 153-167 .
62.
WILLIAMS, L. J. , & HAZER, J. T.Antecedents and consequences of satisfaction and commitment in turnover models: A reanalysis using latent variable structural equation methods . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1986, 71, 219-231 .
