Dual Commitment Among Unionized Faculty: A Longitudinal Investigation

Abstract

This study investigated changes in union, organizational, and dual commitment among 267 faculty of a public university in the U.S. over a 6.5-month period (from the beginning of contract negotiations to contract settlement). Specifically, it was hypothesized that labor-management relationship climate, union involvement, perceived pay equity, and the implementation of a multi-tier salary plan would differentially affect faculty members' commitment levels. In addition, three established methods of measuring dual commitment were utilized to assess their convergent validity. Results indicated that organizational commitment and, in some cases, dual commitment increased over the time period. Further, the correlational and classification methods of measuring dual commitment detected changes in commitment, while Angle and Perry's (1986) five-item dual commitment scale was found to have questionable reliability and validity. Theoretical, methodological, and practical implications of the study's findings were discussed.

Keywords

union commitment organizational commitment dual commitment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ANGLE, H. L. , & PERRY, J. L. Organizational commitment: Individual and organizational influences. Work and Occupations, 1983, 10, 123-146.

ANGLE, H. L. , & PERRY, J. L. Dual commitment and labor-management relationship climates. Academy of Management Journal, 1986, 29, 31-50.

BROOKE, P. P., Jr. Beyond the Steers and Rhodes model of employee attendance. Academy of Management Review, 1986, 11, 345-361.

CONLON, E. J. , & GALLAGHER, D. G. Commitment to employer and union: Effects of membership status. Academy of Management Journal, 1987, 30, 151-162.

DALTON, D. R. , & TODOR, W. D. Antecedents of grievance filing behavior. Academy of Management Journal, 1982, 25, 158-169.

DEAN, L. R. Union activity and dual loyalty. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 1954, 12, 526-636.

FUKAMI, C. V. , & LARSON, E. W. Commitment to company and union: Parallel models. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1984, 69, 367-371.

FULLAGAR, C. , & BARLING, J. A longitudinal test of a model of antecedents and consequences of union loyalty. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1989, 74, 213-227.

GALLAGHER, D. G. The relationship between organizational and union commitment among federal government employees. Academy of Management Proceedings, 1984, 319-323.

10.

GARBARINO, J W. Faculty collective bargaining: A status report. In S. M. Lipset (Ed.), Unions in transition: Entering the second century. San Francisco, California: ICS Press, 1986.

11.

GORDON, M. E. , PHILPOT, J. W. , BURT, R. E. , THOMPSON, C. A. , & SPILLER, M.W E. Commitment to the union: Development of a measure and an examination of its correlates. Journal of Applied Psychology Monograph, 1980, 65, 479-499.

12.

INSTITUTE FOR SOCIAL RESERCH . Michigan Organizational Assessment Package: Project Report II. Survey Research Center, Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1975.

13.

KERR, W. A. Dual allegiance and emotional acceptance-rejection in industry. Personnel Psychology, 1954, 7, 59-66.

14.

KLEINGARTNER, A. Professionalism and salaried worker organization. Madison, Wisconsin: Industrial Relations Institute, 1967.

15.

KOCHAN, T. A. How American workers view unions. Monthly Labor Review, 1979, 102, 23-31.

16.

KOKKELENBERG, E. C. , & SOCKELL, D. R. Union membership in the United States 1973-1981. Industrial and labor Relations Review, 1985, 38, 497-543.

17.

MAGENAU, J. M. , MARTIN, J. E. , & PETERSON, M. M. Dual and unilateral commitment among stewards and rank-and-file union members. Academy of Management Journal, 1988, 31, 359-376.

18.

MARTIN, J. E. Dual allegiance in public sector unionism: A case study. International Review of Applied Psychology, 1981, 30, 245-260.

19.

MARTIN, J. E. , & PETERSON, M. M. Two tier wage structures: Implications for equity theory. Academy of Management Journal, 1987, 30, 297-315.

20.

MARTIN, J. E. , MAGENAU, J. M. , & PETERSON, M. F. Variables related to patterns of union stewards' commitment. Journal of Labor Research, 1986, 7, 323-336.

21.

MOTTAZ, C. J. Determinants fo organizational commitment. Human Relations, 1988, 41, 467-482.

22.

MOWDAY, R. T. , STEERS, R. M. , & PORTER, L. W. The measurement of organizational commitment. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 1979, 14, 224-247.

23.

MOWDAY, R. T. , PORTER, L. W. , & STEERS, R. M. Employee-organization linkages: The psychology of commitment, absenteeism, and turnover. New York: Academic Press, 1982.

24.

PURCELL, T. V. Blue collar man. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1960.

25.

RHODES, S. R. , & STEERS, R. M. Conventional vs. worker-owned organizations. Human Relations, 1981, 34, 1013-1035.

26.

SCHOLL, R. W. , COOPER, E. A. , & McKENNA, J. F. Referent selection in determining equity perceptions: Differential effects on behavior and attitudinal outcomes. Personnel Psychology, 1987, 40, 113-124.

27.

STAGNER, R. Dual allegiance as a problem in modern society. Personnel Psychology, 1954, 7, 41-46.

28.

STAGNER, R. Psychology of industrial conflict. New York: John Wiley, 1956.

29.

STAGNER, R. , & ROSEN, H. Psychology of union-management relations. Belmont, California: Brooks-Cole, 1965.

30.

STEERS, R. M. Antecedents and outcome of organizational commitment. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1977, 22, 46-56.