Alienation is seen as endemic to the labour process and organizations. Put simply, if workers do not own the means, conditions and results of production they will remain alienated from their product, productive activity, species being and fellow human and non-human others. Some scholars have highlighted that, through their structures of democratic control and collective ownership of the means, conditions and results of labour, worker cooperatives reverse the capital-labour relationship to create a non-exploitative class process and therefore hold possibilities for ‘disalienation’. However, the idea that worker cooperatives can be ‘disalienating’ is by no means universally accepted, with others arguing that subsumption of labour to capital can only be partially addressed through a cooperative’s internal structure. Central to this debate is a worker cooperative’s position within the capitalist market, and we argue, their use of wage labour. This article, based on an 18-month ethnography with 2 worker cooperatives, addresses the question: To what extent are members of worker cooperatives, engaged in wage labour, able to resist the forces of alienation?
AlakavuklarON (2024) Untangling alternative organising within and beyond capitalist relations: The case of a free food store. Human Relations77(11): 1596–1619.
2.
ArnaudCChâteau-TerrisseP (2024) Constructing an alternative and resisting degeneration: The case of a multi-stakeholder cooperative in the field of regulated professions. M@n@gement27(5): 19–37.
3.
AshforthBEReingenPH (2014) Functions of dysfunction: Managing the dynamics of an organizational duality in a natural food cooperative. Administrative Science Quarterly59(3): 474–516.
4.
AtzeniMGhiglianiP (2007) Labour process and decision-making in factories under workers’ self-management: Empirical evidence from Argentina. Work, Employment and Society21(4): 653–671.
5.
AtzeniMVietaM (2014) Between class and the market: Self-management in theory and in the practice of the worker-recuperated enterprises in Argentina. In: ParkerMCheneyGFournierVLandC (eds) The Routledge Companion to Alternative Organization. London: Routledge, 47–61.
6.
AudebrandLK (2017) Expanding the scope of paradox scholarship on social enterprise: The case for (re) introducing worker cooperatives. M@n@gement20(4): 368–393.
7.
AzambujaRIslamG (2019) Working at the boundaries: Middle managerial work as a source of emancipation and alienation. Human Relations72(3): 534–564.
8.
AzzelliniD (2018) Labour as a commons: The example of worker-recuperated companies. Critical Sociology44(4–5): 763–776.
9.
Ben-NerAJonesDC (1995) Employee participation, ownership, and productivity: A theoretical framework. Industrial Relations34(4): 532–554.
10.
BöhmSDinersteinACSpicerA (2010) (Im) possibilities of autonomy: Social movements in and beyond capital, the state and development. Social Movement Studies9(1): 17–32.
11.
BorowiakCJiM (2019) Taxi co-ops versus Uber: Struggles for workplace democracy in the sharing economy. Journal of Labor and Society22(1): 165–185.
12.
BousalhamYVidailletB (2018) Contradiction, circumvention and instrumentalization of noble values: How competition undermines the potential of alternatives. Organization25(3): 401–427.
13.
BrannickTCoghlanD (2007) In defense of being “native”: The case for insider academic research. Organizational Research Methods10(1): 59–74.
14.
BravermanH (1974) Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century. London: Monthly Review Press.
15.
BretosIErrastiAMarcuelloC (2017) Ownership, governance and the diffusion of HRM practices in multinational worker cooperatives: Case-study evidence from the Mondragon group. Human Resource Management Journal28(1): 76–91.
16.
ByrneKHealyS (2006) Cooperative subjects: Toward a post-fantasmatic enjoyment of the economy. Rethinking Marxism18(2): 241–258.
17.
ByronC (2016) Essence and alienation: Marx’s theory of human nature. Science & Society80(3): 375–394.
18.
CameronJ (2005) Focusing on the focus group. In: HayI (ed.) Qualitative Research Methods in Human Geography, 2nd edn.Melbourne, Australia: Oxford University Press, 56–174.
19.
CameronJ (2009) Experimenting with economic possibilities: Ethical economic decision-making in two Australian community enterprises. In: AminA (ed.) The Social Economy: International Perspectives on Economic Solidarity. London: Zed Books, 92–115.
20.
CameronJHicksJ (2014) Performative research for a climate politics of hope: Rethinking geographic scale, “impact” scale, and markets. Antipode46(1): 53–71.
21.
CatoMS (2012) The green economy: Why ownership and control matter. Journal of Co-operative Studies45(1): 61–68.
22.
CharmazK (2004) Grounded theory. In: Hesse-BiberSLeavyP (eds) Approaches to Qualitative Research: A Reader on Theory and Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 497–521.
23.
ChattertonP (2006) ‘Give up activism’ and change the world in unknown ways: Or, learning to walk with others on uncommon ground. Antipode38(2): 259–281.
24.
CheneyGSanta CruzIPeredoAM, et al. (2014) Worker cooperatives as an organizational alternative: Challenges, achievements and promise in business governance and ownership. Organization21(5): 591–603.
25.
CleaverH (2000) Reading Capital Politically. Edinburgh: Anti/Theses.
26.
ConnellyFMClandininDJ (1990) Stories of experience and narrative inquiry. Educational Researcher19(5): 2–14.
27.
CornforthC (1995) Patterns of cooperative management: Beyond the degeneration thesis. Economic and Industrial Democracy16(4): 487–523.
28.
CornforthC (2004) The governance of co-operatives and mutual associations: A paradox perspective. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics75(1): 11–32.
CornwellJ (2012) Worker co-operatives and spaces of possibility: An investigation of subject space at collective copies. Antipode44(3): 725-744.
31.
CourpassonD (2017) The politics of everyday. Organization Studies38(6): 843–859.
32.
CunliffeA (2010) Retelling tales of the field: In search of organizational ethnography 20 years on. Organizational Research Methods13(2): 224–239.
33.
DahlmanSMygindduPlessisEHustedE, et al. (2022) Alternativity as freedom: Exploring tactics of emergence in alternative forms of organizing. Human Relations75(10): 1961–1985.
34.
DeMartinoG (2003) Realizing class justice. Rethinking Marxism15(1): 1–31.
35.
DufaysFO’SheaNHuybrechtsB, et al. (2020) Resisting colonization: Worker cooperatives’ conceptualization and behaviour in a Habermasian perspective. Work, Employment and Society34(6): 965–984.
36.
ErrastiABretosINunezA (2017) The viability of cooperatives: The fall of the Mondragon cooperative Fagor. Review of Radical Political Economics49(2): 181–197.
37.
FuchsC (2018) Universal alienation, formal and real subsumption of society under capital, ongoing primitive accumulation by dispossession: Reflections on the Marx@200-Contributions by David Harvey and Michael Hardt/Toni Negri. tripleC16(2): 454–467.
Gibson-GrahamJKRoelvinkG (2011) The nitty gritty of creating alternative economies. Social Alternatives30(1): 29–33.
40.
GilmoreSKennyK (2014) Work-worlds colliding: Self-reflexivity, power and emotion in organizational ethnography. Human Relations68(1): 55–78.
41.
GuilleminMGillamL (2004) Ethics, reflexivity, and “ethically important moments” in research. Qualitative Inquiry10(2): 261–280.
42.
HarneckerCP (2012) Democracy and solidarity: A study of Venezuelan cooperatives. In: AtzeniM (ed.) Alternative Work Organisations. Basingstoke; New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan, 103–128.
43.
HarveyD (2018a) Universal alienation and the real subsumption of daily life under capital: A response to Hardt and Negri. tripleC16(2): 449–453.
44.
HarveyD (2018b) Universal alienation. Journal for Cultural Research22(2): 137–150.
45.
Heras-SaizarbitoriaI (2014) The ties that bind? Exploring the basic principles of worker-owned organizations in practice. Organization21(5): 645–665.
46.
HustedEdu PlessisEMDahlmanS (2026) A processual perspective on alternative organization: Reorienting critical research through a study of two political parties. Human Relations79(1): 32–58.
47.
HustedEPlesnerU (2017) Spaces of open-source politics: Physical and digital conditions for political organization. Organization24(5): 648–670.
48.
JaeggiR (2014) Alienation. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
49.
JaumierS (2017) Preventing chiefs from being chiefs: An ethnography of a co-operative sheet-metal factory. Organization24(2): 218–239.
50.
JaumierSDaudigeosT (2021) Resisting work degeneration in collectivist-democratic organizations: Craft ethics in a French cooperative sheet-metal factory. Research in the Sociology of Organizations72: 55–79.
51.
JensenPR (2020) Alternative logics: A discursive approach to normative and alternative organizing. Human Relations74(8): 1156–1177.
52.
JiM (2020) With or without class: Resolving Marx’s Janus-faced interpretation of worker-owned cooperatives. Capital and Class44(3): 345–369.
53.
JossaB (2014) Alienation and the self-managed firm system. Review of Radical Political Economics46(1): 5–14.
54.
JosselsonR (1996) On writing other people’s lives: Self-analytic reflections of a narrative researcher. In: JosselsonR (ed.) Ethics and Process in the Narrative Study of Lives. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 60–71.
55.
JustSNDe CockCSchaeferSM (2021) From antagonists to allies? Exploring the critical performativity of alternative organization. Culture and Organization27(2): 89–97.
56.
KociatkiewiczJKosteraMParkerM (2021) The possibility of disalienated work: Being at home in alternative organizations. Human Relations74(7): 933–957.
57.
KokkinidisG (2014) Alternative Organizations in a Global Context: Tensions, challenges and potentialialities. Ephemera14(4): 1031–1039.
58.
KokkinidisG (2015) Spaces of possibilities: Workers’ self-management in Greece. Organization22: 847–71.
59.
LaclauEMouffeC (1985) Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics. London: Verso.
60.
LangmeadK (2016) Challenging the degeneration thesis: The role of democracy in worker cooperatives?Journal of Entrepreneurial and Organizational Diversity5(1): 79–98.
61.
LebowitzMA (2003) Beyond Capital Marx’s Political Economy of the Working Class. New York: Palgrave McMillan.
62.
LuhmanJT (2007) Worker-ownership as an instrument for solidarity and social change. Ephemera7(3): 462–474.
63.
LuhmanJTNazarioAF (2015) Alienation, police stories, and Percival. Journal of Business Ethics130(3): 665–681.
64.
MarxK ([1844] 2009) Economic & Philosophic Manuscripts. New York: Marxists Internet Archive.
65.
MarxK ([1891] 2010) Wage Labour and Capital. New York: Marxists Internet Archive.
66.
MarxK ([1894] 2010) Capital: A Critique of Political Economy. Volume III The Process of Capitalist Production as a Whole. New York, NY: International Publishers.
67.
MarxK ([1939] 2015) Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy. London: Penguin Books/New Left Review.
68.
MeiraFB (2014) Liminal organization: Organizational emergence within solidary economy in Brazil. Organization21(5): 713–729.
69.
NgCWNgE (2009) Balancing the democracy dilemmas: Experiences of three women workers’ cooperatives in Hong Kong. Economic and Industrial Democracy30(2): 182–206.
70.
OllmanB (1976) Alienation: Marx’s Conception of Man in a Capitalist Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
71.
PanseraMRizziF (2020) Furbish or perish: Italian social cooperatives at a crossroads. Organization27(1): 17–35.
72.
ParkerMCheneyGFournierV, et al. (2014) The Routledge Companion to Alternative Organization. Abingdon: Routledge.
73.
ParkerSParkerM (2017) Antagonism, accommodation and agonism in Critical Management Studies: Alternative organizations as allies. Human Relations70(11): 1366–1387.
74.
RobertsB (2011) Exploitation, appropriation, and subsumption. Rethinking Marxism23(3): 341–351.
75.
RothschildJChenKKSmithDH, et al. (2016) Avoiding bureaucratization and mission drift in associations. In: SmithDHStebbinsRAGrotzJ (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Volunteering, Civic Participation, and Nonprofit Associations. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan, 1007–1024.
76.
RothschildJWhittJA (1986) The Cooperative Workplace: Potentials and Dilemmas of Organisational Democracy and Participation. Cambridge: Cambride University Press.
77.
RuccioDF (2011) Cooperatives, surplus, and the social. Rethinking Marxism23(3): 344–340.
78.
RyanGBernardR (2003) Techniques to identify themes. Field Methods15(1): 84–109.
79.
SageD (2025) Alternative organization without vertical hierarchies of spatial scale?Organization32(6): 914–924.
80.
Seda-IrizarryIJ (2011) Crisis, class, and cooperatives: Some comments on the United Steelworkers -Mondragón Alliance. Rethinking Marxism23(3): 374–383.
81.
ShanahanG (2025) Two routes to degeneration, two routes to utopia: The impure critical performativity of alternative organizing. Organization32(4): 489–507.
82.
ShanahanGJaumierSDaudigeosT, et al. (2024) Why reinvent the wheel? Materializing multiplicity to resist reification in alternative organizations. Organization Studies45(6): 855–879.
83.
SoffiaMWoodAJBurchellB (2022) Alienation is not ‘bullshit’: an empirical critique of Graeber’s theory of BS jobs. Work, Employment and Society36(5): 816–840.
84.
SomervilleP (2007) Co-operative identity. Journal of Co-operative Studies40(1): 5–17.
85.
StoreyJBasterretxeaISalamanG (2014) Managing and resisting ‘degeneration’ in employee-owned businesses: A comparative study of two large retailers in Spain and the UK. Organization21(5): 626–644.
86.
Van MaanenJSørensenJBMitchellTR (2007) The interplay between theory and method. Academy of Management Review32(4): 1145–1154.
87.
VietaM (2010) The social innovations of autogestión in Argentina’s worker-recuperated enterprises: Cooperatively reorganizing productive life in hard times. Labor Studies Journal35(3): 295–321.
88.
VietaM (2018) From capitalist firms to worker cooperatives: Democratizing the labour process and transforming communities via Argentina’s worker-recuperated enterprises. In: 35th international labour process conference 2018, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
89.
VietaM (2019) Recuperating and (re)learning the language of autogestión in Argentina’s empresas recuperadas worker cooperatives. Journal of Cultural Economy12(5): 401–422.
90.
VietaM (2021) Recuperating and (re) learning the language of autogestion in Argentina’s empresas recuperadas worker cooperatives. In: ScottSM (ed.) Languages of Economic Crises. London: Routledge, 69–90.
91.
WatsonDJ (2020) Working the fields: The organization of labour in community supported agriculture. Organization27(2): 291–313.
ZamagniSZamagniV (2010) Cooperative Enterprise: Facing the Challenge of Globalization. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
95.
ZanoniP (2020) Prefiguring alternatives through the articulation of post-and anti-capitalistic politics: An introduction to three additional papers and a reflection. Organization27(1): 3–16.
96.
ZoubirZ (2018) “Alienation” and critique in Marx’s manuscripts of 1857–58 (“Grundrisse”). The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought25(5): 710–737.
