This article examines the role of strategic leadership groups in radical organisational change. Previous research has focused on how ‘heroic’ individual leaders guide change. In contrast, we argue that strategic leadership groups are indispensable to understanding and supporting radical organisational change. Building on a longitudinal study in a global European company, our research identifies four phases of ‘negotiated order’ that shape group and organisational responses to change. Our findings reveal that strategic leadership groups help manage emotions and understand the shifting authority relations that inevitably arise during periods of change. Drawing upon the psychoanalytic concept of ‘projective identification’, we develop a theoretical framework for understanding the tensions of change. The model shows how emotional coalitions that develop in strategic leadership groups afford a source of political and psychological containment against the anxieties of radical organisational change. These formations offer transitional spaces for change, providing opportunities for progress. The advantage of this new perspective on radical change is that it helps to move the organisation beyond periods of ambivalence and conflict, with positive implications for leadership practice.
AndersonPJJBlattRChristiansonMK, et al. (2006) Understanding mechanisms in organisational research. Journal of Management Inquiry15(2): 102–113.
2.
AshbachCSchermerVL (1987) Object Relations, The Self and The Group: A Conceptual Paradigm. London: Routledge.
3.
AshforthBEHumphreyRH (1995) Emotion in the workplace: A reappraisal. Human Relations48(2): 97–125.
4.
AshforthBEReingenPH (2014) Functions of dysfunction: Managing the dynamics of an organisational duality in a natural food cooperative. Administrative Science Quarterly59(3): 474–516.
5.
BakerDTKelanEK (2019) Splitting and blaming: The psychic life of neoliberal executive women. Human Relations72(1): 69–97.
6.
BalogunJBartunekJMDoB (2015) Senior managers’ sensemaking and responses to strategic change. Organization Science26(4): 960–979.
7.
BarsadeSGRamarajanLWestenD (2009) Implicit affect in organisations. Research in Organisational Behavior29: 135–162.
8.
BionWR (1961) Experiences in Groups. London: Tavistock.
9.
BionWR (1963) Elements of Psychoanalysis. London: Heinemann.
10.
BrownADStarkeyK (2000) Organisational identity and Learning: A psychodynamic perspective. Academy of Management Review25(1): 102–120.
11.
CanatoARavasiDPhillipsN (2013) Coerced practice implementation in cases of low cultural fit: Cultural change and practice adaptation during the implementation of Six Sigma at 3m. Academy of Management Journal56(6): 1724–1753.
12.
CleggSRCourpassonDPhillipsN (2006) Power and Organisations. London: Sage.
13.
CollinsR (2004) Interaction Ritual Chains. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
14.
CramerP (2000) Defense mechanisms in psychology today: Further processes for adaptation. American Psychologist55(6): 637–646.
15.
DenisJ-LLamotheLLangleyA (2001) The dynamics of collective leadership and strategic change in pluralistic organisations. Academy of Management Journal44(4): 809–837.
16.
DenisJ-LLangleyASergiV (2012) Leadership in the plural. Academy of Management Annals6(1): 211–283.
17.
DiamondMAllcornS (2003) The cornerstone of psychoanalytic organisational analysis: Psychological reality, transference and counter-transference in the workplace. Human Relations56(4): 491–514.
18.
DokkoGNigamARosenkopfL (2012) Keeping steady as she goes: A negotiated order perspective on technological evolution. Organisation Studies 33(5–6): 681–703.
19.
EisenhardtKMGraebnerME (2007) Theory building from cases: Opportunities and challenges. Academy of Management Journal50(1): 25–32.
20.
EmirbeyerM (1997) Manifesto for a relational sociology. American Journal of Sociology103(2): 281–317.
21.
FairhurstGTJacksonBFoldyEG, et al. (2020) Studying collective leadership: The road ahead. Human Relations73(4): 598–614.
22.
FarjounM (2010) Beyond dualism: Stability and change as a duality. Academy of Management Review35(2): 202–225.
23.
FarnySKiblerEDownS (2019) Collective emotions in institutional creation work. Academy of Management Journal62(3): 765–799.
24.
FinkelsteinSHambrickDCCannellaAA (2009) Strategic Leadership: Theory and Research on Executives, Top Management Teams, and Boards. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
25.
FoldyEGBuckleyTR (2017) Reimagining cultural competence: Bringing buried dynamics into the light. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science53(2): 264–289.
26.
FotakiMHydeP (2015) Organisational blind spots: Splitting, blame and idealisation in the National Health Service. Human Relations68(3): 441–462.
27.
FrenchRVinceR (1999) Group Relations, Management and Organisation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
28.
GabrielY (1997) Meeting God: When organisational members come face to face with the supreme leader. Human Relations50(4): 315–342.
29.
GanzarainR (1983) Working through in analytic group psychotherapy. International Journal of Group Psychotherapy33(3): 281–296.
30.
GibeauÉLangleyADenisJ-L, et al. (2019) Bridging competing demands through co-leadership? Potential and limitations. Human Relations73(4): 464–489.
31.
GioiaDACorleyKGHamiltonAL (2013) Seeking qualitative rigor in inductive research. Organisational Research Methods16(1): 15–31.
32.
GoffmanE (1959) The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. New York, NY: Doubleday.
33.
Golden-BiddleK (2020) Discovery as an abductive mechanism for reorienting habits within organizational change. Academy of Management Journal63(6): 1951–1975.
34.
GreenwoodRHiningsCR (1988) Organisational design types, tracks and the dynamics of Strategic Change. Organisation Studies9(3): 293–316.
35.
GreenwoodRHiningsCR (1996) Understanding radical organizational change: Bringing together the old and the new institutionalism. Academy of Management Journal36(5): 1022–1054.
36.
HambrickDC (1995) Fragmentation and the other problems CEOS have with their top management teams. California Management Review37(3): 110–127.
37.
HambrickDCMasonPA (1984) Upper echelons: The organisation as a reflection of its top managers. Academy of Management Review9(2): 193–206.
38.
HodgkinsonGPWrightG (2002) Confronting strategic inertia in a top management team: Learning from failure. Organization Studies23(6): 949–977.
39.
HuyQNCorleyKGKraatzMS (2014) From support to mutiny: Shifting legitimacy judgments and emotional reactions impacting the implementation of radical change. Academy of Management Journal57(6): 1650–1680.
40.
JarrettMVinceR (2017) Psychoanalytic theory, emotion and organisational paradox. In: SmithWLewisMLangleyA (eds) Handbook of Organisational Paradox: Approaches to Plurality, Tensions and Contradictions. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 48–65.
41.
KahnWA (1995) Organisational change and the provision of a secure base: Lessons from the field. Human Relations48(5): 489–514.
42.
KahnWAKramKE (1994) Authority at work: Internal models and their organisational consequences. Academy of Management Review19(1): 17–50.
43.
KahnWABartonMAFellowsS (2013) Organisational crises and the disturbance of relational systems. Academy of Management Review38(3): 377–396.
44.
KleinM (1946) Notes on some schizoid mechanisms. In: KleinM (ed.) The Writings of Melanie Klein (vol. 4). Envy and Gratitude and Other Works, 1946–1963 (1975). London: The Hogarth Press and the Institute of Psychoanalysis, 1–24.
45.
KreinerGEHollensbeECSheepML (2009) Balancing borders and bridges: Negotiating the work-home interface via boundary work tactics. Academy of Management Journal52(4): 704–730.
46.
LangleyA (1999) Strategies for theorising from process data. Academy of Management Review24(4): 691–710.
47.
LawrenceGWBainAGouldL (1996) The fifth basic assumption. Free Associations6(1): 1–20.
48.
LiuDFisherGChenG (2018) CEO attributes and firm performance: A sequential mediation process model. Academy of Management Annals12(2): 789–816.
49.
LiuFMaitlisS (2014) Emotional dynamics and strategizing processes: A study of strategic conversations in top team meetings. Journal of Management Studies51(2): 202–234.
50.
LockeKD (2001) Grounded Theory in Management Research, 1st edn. London: Sage.
51.
LucianoMMNahrgangJDShropshireC (2020) Strategic leadership systems: Viewing top management teams and boards of directors from a multiteam systems perspective. Academy of Management Review45(3): 675–701.
52.
MaitlisS (2005) The social processes of organisational sensemaking. Academy of Management Journal48(1): 21–49.
53.
MartinJL (2017) Thinking Through Methods. A Social Science Primer. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
54.
MenziesIE (1960) A case study in the functioning of social systems as a defence against anxiety. Human Relations13(2): 95–121.
55.
OgdenTH (1979) On projective identification. International Journal of Psychoanalysis60: 357–373.
56.
OregSBartunekJMLeeG, et al. (2018) An affect-based model of recipients’ responses to change events. Academy of Management Review43(1): 65–86.
57.
PadavicIElyRJReidEM (2020) Explaining the persistence of gender inequality: The work–family narrative as a social defense against the 24/7 work culture. Administrative Science Quarterly65(1): 61–111.
58.
PetriglieriGPeshkamA (2022) Stranger leaders: A theory of marginal leaders’ conception of learning in organisations. Academy of Management Journal65(4): 1240–1273.
59.
PetriglieriGPetriglieriJL (2020) The return of the oppressed: A systems psychodynamic approach to organisation studies. Academy of Management Annals14(1): 411–449.
60.
PetriglieriGSteinM (2012) The unwanted self: Projective identification in leaders’ identity work. Organisation Studies33(9): 1217–1235.
61.
PitcherPSmithAD (2001) Top management team heterogeneity: Personality, power, and proxies. Organization Science12(1): 1–18.
62.
RiochMJ (1975) All we like sheep. In: ColmanADBextonWH (eds) Group Relations Reader. Washington, DC: AK Rice Institute Series, 159–178.
63.
SamimiMCortesAFAndersonMH, et al. (2022) What is strategic leadership? Developing a framework for future research. The Leadership Quarterly33(3): 101353.
64.
SchwarzGMBouckenoogheDVakolaM (2021) Organisational change failure: Framing the process of failing. Human Relations74(2): 159–179.
65.
SimsekZHeaveyCFoxBC (2018) Interfaces of strategic leaders: A conceptual framework, review, and research agenda. Journal of Management44(1): 280–324.
66.
SmithKKBergDN (1987) Paradoxes of Group Life: Understanding Conflict, Paralysis, and Movement in Group Dynamics. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
67.
SmithWKLewisMW (2022) Both/and Thinking Embracing Creative Tensions to Solve Your Toughest Problems. Boston, MA: Harvard Business Review Press.
68.
SpilliusEBO’ShaughnessyE (2012) Projective Identification: The Fate of a Concept. Hove, East Sussex: Routledge.
69.
StawBMSandelandsLEDuttonJE (1981) Threat rigidity effects in organisational behavior: A multilevel analysis. Administrative Science Quarterly26(4): 501–524.
70.
StocktonRMorranDKClarkMB (2004) An investigation of group leaders’ intentions. Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice8(3): 196–206.
71.
StraussAL (1978) Negotiations. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
72.
TurquetPM (1985) Leadership: The individual and the group. In: ColmanADGellerMH (eds) Group Relations Reader 2. Washington, DC: AK Rice Institute, 71–88.
73.
Van de VenAPooleSM (1995) Explaining development and change in organisations. Academy of Management Review20(3): 510–540.
74.
VinceR (2019) Institutional illogics: The unconscious and institutional analysis. Organisation Studies40(7): 953–973.
75.
VinceRBroussineM (1996) Paradox, defence and attachment: Accessing and working with emotions and relations underlying organisational change. Organisation Studies17(1): 1–21.
76.
Von ScheveCIsmerS (2013) Towards a theory of collective emotions. Emotion Review5(4): 406–413.
77.
Von ScheveCSalmelaM (2014) Collective emotions: An introduction. In: Von ScheveCSalmela (eds) Collective Emotions: Perspectives from Psychology, Philosophy, and Sociology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, xiii–xxiv.
78.
VoronovMVinceR (2012) Integrating emotions into the analysis of institutional work. Academy of Management Review37(1): 58–81.
79.
WalkerGHinshelwoodRD (2018) Is it a bird? Is it a plane? Operationalisation of unconscious processes. In: StamenovaKHinshelwoodRD (eds) Methods of Research into the Unconscious: Applying Psychoanalytic Ideas to Social Science. London: Routledge, 205–217.
80.
WellsLJ (1990) The group as a whole: A systemic socio-analytic perspective on interpersonal and group relations. In: GilletteJMcCollomM (eds) Groups in Context: A New Perspective on Group Dynamics. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 49–85.
81.
YammarinoFJSalasESerbanA, et al. (2012) Collectivistic leadership approaches: Putting the ‘we’ in leadership science and practice. Industrial and Organisational Psychology5(4): 382–402.
82.
ZietsmaCToubianaMVoronovM, et al. (2019) Emotions in Organisation Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
