Why is resistance a pervasive feature of organizations? We seek to add to the established ways of understanding resistance by arguing that it may emerge owing to the rationality and irrationality, order and disorder that imbues organizations. We explore how such conditions create ambivalent situations that can generate resistance that is ambivalent itself as it can both facilitate and hinder the operation of organizations. Drawing on ethnographic research conducted in a manufacturing organization, we introduce the concept of pragmatic resistance as a means to grasp the everyday resistance that emerges through and reflects cracks in the rational model of organizations. Rather than being anti-work, we demonstrate how pragmatic resistance is bound up with organizational disorder/irrationality, competing work demands and the prioritization of what is interpreted as ‘real work’. Overall, the concept of pragmatic resistance indicates that resistance may be far more pervasive and organizations more fragile and vulnerable to disruption than is often assumed to be the case.
AgarM (1986) Speaking of Ethnography. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
3.
AllenVL (2009) The year-long miners’ strike, March 1984–March 1985: A memoir. Industrial Relations Journal40(4): 278–291.
4.
AlvessonM (1984) Questioning rationality and ideology: On critical organization theory. International Studies of Management and Organization14(1): 61–79.
5.
AlvessonM (2009) At-home ethnography: Struggling with closeness and closure. In: YbemaSYanowDWelsHKamsteegF (eds) Organizational Ethnography: Studying the Complexities of Everyday Life. London: SAGE, 156–174.
6.
AlvessonMSpicerA (2012) A Stupidity-based theory of organizations. Journal of Management Studies49(7): 1194–1220.
7.
AlvessonMSpicerA (2016) The stupidity paradox: The power and pitfalls of functional stupidity at work. London: Profile Books.
8.
AnsariSReineckeJSpaanA (2014) How are practices made to vary? Managing practice adaptation in a multinational corporation. Organization Studies35(9): 1313–1341.
9.
AshcraftKL (2005) Resistance through consent? Occupational identity, organizational form, and the maintenance of masculinity among commercial airline pilots. Management Communication Quarterly19(1): 67–90.
10.
AshcraftKL (2008) Our stake in struggle (or is resistance something only others do?). Management Communication Quarterly21(3): 380–386.
11.
AshcraftKLTrethewayA (2004) Developing tension: An agenda for applied research on the ‘organization of irrationality’. Journal of Applied Communication Research32(2): 171–181.
12.
AstleyWGVan de VenAH (1983) Central perspectives and debates in organization theory. Administrative Science Quarterly28(2): 245–273.
13.
BainPTaylorP (2000) Entrapped by the ‘electronic panopticon’? Worker resistance in the call centre. New Technology, Work and Employment15(1): 2–18.
14.
BarkerJR (1993) Tightening the iron cage: Concertive control in self-managing teams. Administrative Science Quarterly38(3): 408–437.
15.
BattilanaJCasciaroT (2013) Overcoming resistance to organizational change: Strong ties and affective cooptation. Management Science59(4): 819–836.
16.
BauerM (1991) Resistance to change—A monitor of new technology. Systems Practice4(3): 181–196.
17.
BeirneM (2013) Interpretations of management and modernization at the UK Royal Mail: Shifting boundaries and patterns of resistance?New Technology, Work and Employment28(2): 116–129.
18.
BhuiyanNBaghelAWilsonJ (2006) A sustainable continuous improvement methodology at an aerospace company. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management55(8): 671–687.
19.
BörjessonU (2013) From shadow to person: Exploring roles in participant observations in an eldercare context. Qualitative Social Work13(1): 406–420.
20.
BoveyWHHedeA (2001) Resistance to organizational change: The role of cognitive and affective processes. Leadership and Organization Development Journal23(8): 372–282.
21.
BravermanH (1974) Labour and Monopoly Capital. New York: Monthly Review Press.
22.
BrunssonN (2006) Mechanisms of Hope: Maintaining the dream of the Rational Organization. Copenhagen: Copenhagen Business School Press.
23.
BrymanA (1984) Organization studies and the concept of rationality. Journal of Management Studies21(4): 391–408.
24.
BurawoyM (1979) Manufacturing Consent. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
25.
BurrellG (1999) Pandemonium: Towards a Retro-organizational Theory. London: SAGE.
26.
CaruthDMiddlebrookBRachelF (1985) Overcoming resistance to change. SAM Advanced Management Journal50(30): 23–27.
27.
ClarkeCAKnightsD (2015) Careering through academia: Securing identities or engaging ethical subjectivities?Human Relations68(12): 1865–1888.
28.
ClarkeCABrownADHaileyVH (2009) Working identities? Antagonistic discursive resources and managerial identity. Human Relations62(3): 323–352.
29.
CliffordJ (1986) Introduction: Partial truths. In: CliffordJMarcusGE (eds) Writing Culture. London: University of Chicago Press, 1–26.
30.
CohenL (1993) Anthem. In: FaggenR (ed.) Stranger Music: selected poems and songs. London: Jonathan Cape.
31.
CohenMMarchJGOlsenJ (1972) A garbage can model of organizational choice. Administrative Science Quarterly17(1): 1–25.
32.
CollinsonD (1988) ‘Engineering humour’: Masculinity, joking and conflict in shop-floor relations. Organization Studies9(2): 181–199.
33.
CollinsonD (1992) Managing the Shopfloor: Subjectivity, Masculinity and Workplace Culture. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
34.
CollinsonD (1994) Strategies of resistance: Power, knowledge and subjectivity in the workplace. In: JermierJKnightsDNordW (eds) Power and Resistance in Organizations. London: Routledge, 25–68.
35.
ContuA (2008) Decaf resistance. Management Communication Quarterly21(3): 364–379.
36.
CostasJ (2012) ‘We are all friends here’: Reinforcing paradoxes of normative control in a culture of friendship. Journal of Management Inquiry21(4): 377–395.
37.
CostasJGreyC (2014) The temporality of power and the power of temporality: Imaginary future selves in professional service firms. Organization Studies35(6): 909–937.
38.
CouplandCBlytonPBaconN (2005) Them and us: A longitudinal study of the impact of a team working initiative. Human Relations58(8): 1055–1081.
39.
CourpassonD (2016) Impactful resistance: The persistence of recognition politics in the workplace. Journal of Management Inquiry25(1): 96–100.
40.
CourpassonD (2017) Beyond the hidden/public resistance divide: How bloggers defeated a big company. Organization Studies38(9): 1277–1302.
41.
CourpassonDDanyFCleggS (2012) Resisters at work: Generating productive resistance in the workplace. Organization Science23(3): 801–819.
42.
CunliffeAL (2010) Retelling tales of the field in search of organizational ethnography 20 years on. Organizational Research Methods13(2): 224–239.
43.
CzarniawskaB (2007) Shadowing and Other Techniques for doing Fieldwork in Modern Societies. Malmö: Liber.
44.
DeetzSA (1992) Democracy in an Age of Corporate Colonization. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
45.
DelbridgeR (1995) Surviving JIT: Control and resistance in a Japanese transplant. Journal of Management Studies32(6): 803–817.
46.
DelbridgeRTurnbullPWilkinsonB (1992) Pushing back the frontiers: Management control and work intensification under JIT/TQM factory regimes. New Technology, Work and Employment7(2): 97–106.
47.
DeWaltKMDeWaltBRWaylandCB (2010) Participant observation. In: DeWaltKMDeWaltBRParticipant Observation: A Guide for Fieldworkers. Walnut Creek, CA: Altamira, 259–299.
48.
Du GayPSalamanG (1992) The cult[ure] of the customer. Journal of Management Studies29(5): 615–633.
49.
EmersonRMFretzRIShawLL (2001) Participant observation and fieldnotes. In: AtkinsonPCoffeyADelamontS, et al. (eds) Handbook of Ethnography. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE, 352–368.
50.
EmersonRMFretzRIShawLL (2011) Writing Ethnographic Fieldnotes. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
51.
EzzamelMWillmottHWorthingtonF (2001) Power, control and resistance in ‘the factory that time forgot’. Journal of Management Studies38(8): 1053–1079.
52.
FlemingP (2005) Workers’ playtime? Boundaries and cynicism in a ‘culture of fun’ program. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science41(3): 285–303.
53.
FlemingPSpicerA (2003) Working at a cynical distance: Implications for power, subjectivity and resistance. Organization10(1): 157–179.
54.
FlemingPSpicerA (2008) Beyond power and resistance: New approaches to organizational politics. Management Communication Quarterly21(3): 301–309.
55.
FlemingPSturdyA (2009) Just be yourself!: Towards neo-normative control in organisations. Employee Relations31(6): 569–583.
56.
FlemingPSturdyA (2011) Being yourself’ in the electronic sweatshop: New forms of normative control. Human Relations64(2): 177–200.
57.
FordJDFordLW (2009) Decoding resistance to change. Harvard Business Review87(4): 99–103.
58.
FordJDFordLW (2010) Stop blaming resistance to change and start using it. Organizational Dynamics39(1): 24–36.
59.
FordJDFordLWD’AmelioA (2008) Resistance to change: The rest of the story. Academy of Management Review33(2): 362–377.
60.
GagnonSCollinsonD (2017) Resistance through difference: The co-constitution of dissent and inclusion. Organization Studies38(9): 1253–1276.
61.
GouldnerAW (1954) Wildcat Strike. New York: Atioch Press.
62.
HammersleyMAtkinsonP (2007) Ethnography: Principles in Practice, 3rd edn. London: Routledge.
63.
HymanR (1975) Strikes. London: Fontana.
64.
JacquesR (1996) Manufacturing the Employee. London: SAGE.
65.
JermierJMKnightsDNordWR (eds) (1994) Resistance and Power in Organization. London: Routledge.
66.
KanMMParryKW (2004) Identifying paradox: A grounded theory of leadership in overcoming resistance to change. The Leadership Quarterly15(4): 467–491.
67.
KärremanDAlvessonM (2009) Resisting resistance: Counter-resistance, consent and compliance in a consultancy firm. Human Relations62(8): 1115–1144.
68.
KnightsDMcCabeD (1997) ‘How would you measure something like that?’: Quality in a retail bank. Journal of Management Studies34(3): 371–388.
69.
KnightsDMcCabeD (2000) Ain’t misbehavin’? Opportunities for resistance under new forms of ‘quality’ management. Sociology34(3): 421–436.
70.
KnightsDMcCabeD (2003) Governing through teamwork: Reconstituting subjectivity in a call centre. Journal of Management Studies40(7): 1587–1619.
71.
KorczynskiM (2011) The dialectical sense of humour: Routine joking in a Taylorized factory. Organization Studies32(10): 1421–1439.
72.
KosteraM (2007) Organisational Ethnography: Methods and Inspirations. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
73.
KundaG (1992) Engineering Culture. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
74.
LaneTRobertsK (1971) Strike at Pilkingtons. London: Fontana.
75.
LaNuezDJermierJM (1994) Sabotage by managers and technocrats: Neglected patterns of resistance at work. In: JermierJMKnightsDNordWR (eds) Resistance and Power in Organisations. London: Routledge, 219–251.
76.
LindermanKSchroederRGZaheerSChooAS (2003) Six Sigma: A goal-theoretic perspective. Journal of Operations Management21(2): 193–203.
77.
MarsG (1982) Cheats at Work. London: Allen and Unwin.
78.
McCabeD (1996) ‘The best laid schemes o’TQM’: Strategy, politics and power. New Technology, Work and Employment11(1): 28–38.
79.
McCabeD (2004) ‘A land of milk and honey’? Reengineering the ‘past’ and ‘present’ in a call centre. Journal of Management Studies41(5): 827–856.
80.
McCabeD (2010) Taking the long view: A cultural analysis of memory as resisting and facilitating organizational change. Journal of Organizational Change Management23(3): 230–250.
81.
McCabeD (2014) Making out and making do: How employees resist and make organizational change work through consent in a UK bank. New Technology, Work and Employment29(1): 57–71.
82.
McCabeD (2016) ‘Curiouser and curiouser!’: Organizations as Wonderland–a metaphorical alternative to the rational model. Human Relations69(4): 945–973.
83.
MilesMBHubermanAM (1994) Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook. London: SAGE.
84.
MooreF (2011) Holistic ethnography: Studying the impact of multiple national identities on post-acquisition organizations. Journal of International Business Studies42(5): 654–671.
85.
MumbyDK (1997) The problem of hegemony: Rereading Gramsci for organizational communication studies. Western Journal of Communication61(4): 343–375.
86.
MumbyDK (2005) Theorising resistance in organization studies: A dialectical approach. Management Communication Quarterly19(1): 19–44.
OregS (2006) Personality, context, and resistance to organizational change. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology15(1): 73–101.
89.
PideritSK (2000) Rethinking resistance and recognizing ambivalence: A multidimensional view of attitudes toward an organizational change. Academy of Management Review25(4): 783–794.
90.
PrasadPPrasadA (2000) Stretching the iron cage: The constitution and implications of routine workplace resistance. Organization Science11(4): 387–403.
91.
PutnamLLGrantDMichelsonGCutcherL (2005) Discourse and resistance targets, practices, and consequences. Management Communication Quarterly19(1): 5–18.
92.
RoyD (1954) Efficiency and ‘the fix’: Informal intergroup relations in a piecework machine shop. American Journal of Sociology5(7): 255–266.
93.
ScottJC (1990) Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
94.
SchneiderDMGoldwasserD (1998) Be a model leader of change. Management Review87(3): 41–45.
95.
SelfDRSchraederM (2009) Enhancing the success of organizational change: Matching readiness strategies with sources of resistance. Leadership & Organization Development Journal30(2): 167–182.
96.
SewellG (1998) The discipline of teams: The control of team-based industrial work through electronic and peer surveillance. Administrative Science Quarterly43(2): 397–428.
97.
SilvermanD (2000) Doing Qualitative Research: A Practical Handbook. London: SAGE.
98.
SimonHA (1957) Administrative Behaviour, 2nd edn. New York: Macmillan.
99.
SmetsMBurkeGJarzabkowskiPSpeeP (2014) Charting new territory for organizational ethnography: Insights from a team-based video ethnography of reinsurance trading. Journal of Organizational Ethnography3(1): 10–26.
100.
SturdyA (1992) Clerical consent: ‘Shifting’ work in the insurance office. In: SturdyAKnightsDWillmottH (eds) Skill and Consent. London: Routledge, 115–149.
101.
TaylorPBainP (2003) ‘Subterranean worksick blues’: Humour as subversion in two call centres. Organization Studies24(9): 1487–1509.
102.
ThomasRDaviesA (2005) Theorizing the micro-politics of resistance: New public management and managerial identities in the UK public services. Organization Studies26(5): 683–706.
103.
ThomasRHardyC (2011) Reframing resistance to organizational change. Scandinavian Journal of Management27(3): 322–331.
104.
ThomasRSargentLDHardyC (2011) Managing organizational change: Negotiating meaning and power-resistance relations. Organization Science22(1): 22–41.
105.
ThompsonPSmithC (2010) Debating labour process theory and the sociology of work. In: ThompsonPSmithC (eds) Working Life: Renewing Labour Process Analysis. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 11–28.
106.
TurnbullPSapsfordD (2001) Hitting the bricks: An international comparative study of conflict on the waterfront. Industrial Relations40(2): 231–257.
107.
Van MaanenJ (1988) Tales of the Field: On Writing Ethnography. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
108.
VásquezCSchoenebornDSergiV (2016) Summoning the spirits: Organizational texts and the (dis) ordering properties of communication. Human Relations69(3): 629–659.
109.
WaddellDSohalAS (1998) Resistance: A constructive tool for change management. Management Decision36(8): 543–548.
110.
WatsonTJ (2011) Ethnography, reality, and truth: The vital need for studies of ‘how things work’ in organizations and management. Journal of Management Studies48(1): 202–217.
111.
WeberM (1964) The Theory of Social and Economic Organization. New York: Free Press.
WeiskopfRTobias-MierschY (2016) Whistleblowing, parrhesia and the contestation of truth in the workplace. Organization Studies37(11): 1621–1640.
114.
WestwoodRJohnstonA (2012) Reclaiming authentic selves: Control, resistive humour and identity work in the office. Organization19(6): 787–808.
115.
WillmottH (1993) Strength is ignorance; slavery is freedom: Managing culture in modern organizations. Journal of Management Studies30(4): 515–552.
116.
WolcottHF (1999) Ethnography: A Way of Seeing. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press.
117.
YbemaSHorversM (2017) Resistance through compliance: The strategic and subversive potential of frontstage and backstage resistance. Organization Studies38(9): 1233–1251.
118.
YbemaSKamsteegF (2009) Making the familiar strange: A case for disengaged organizational ethnography. In: YbemaSYanowDWelsHKamsteegF (eds) Organizational Ethnography: Studying the Complexities of Everyday Life. London: SAGE, 101–119.
119.
YbemaSYanowDWelsHKamsteegF (eds) (2009) Organizational Ethnography: Studying the Complexities of Everyday Life. London: SAGE.
120.
YuJZaheerS (2010) Building a process model of local adaptation of practices: A study of Six Sigma implementation in Korean and US firms. Journal of International Business Studies41(3): 475–499.
