The effect of bias on the advancement of working mothers: Disentangling legitimate concerns from inaccurate stereotypes as predictors of advancement in academe
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online December, 2008
The effect of bias on the advancement of working mothers: Disentangling legitimate concerns from inaccurate stereotypes as predictors of advancement in academe
Drawing from social role theory, it is theorized that stereotypes about working mothers will drive biased perceptions about their attitudes toward work and family that will partially account for the `maternal wall'. Survey responses from a sample of 166 junior faculty members with children and 93 of their senior colleagues suggested that parent gender influences superiors' ratings of junior faculty's work involvement, commitment, and flexibility. Moreover, after accounting for self-reports of these attitudes, senior colleagues' ratings partially explained the relationship between parent gender and advancement. Thus, this research provides evidence of maternal bias by demonstrating gender differences in perceptions of work—family attitudes that influence success.
Baltes, B.B. & Heydens-Gahir, H.A.Reduction of work-family conflict through the use of selection, optimization, and compensation behaviors. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2003, 88, 1005-18.
2.
Barnett, R.C. & Hyde, J.S.Women, men, work, and family: An expansionist theory. American Psychologist, 2001, 56, 781-96.
3.
Baron, R.M. & Kenny, D.A.The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1986, 41, 1173-82.
4.
Bielby, D.D.V. & Bielby, W.T.Work commitment, sex-role attitudes, and women's employment. American Sociological Review, 1984, 49, 234-47.
5.
Brand, J.E. & Halaby, C.N.Regression and matching estimates of the effects of elite college attendance on educational and career achievement. Social Science Research , 2006, 35, 749-70.
6.
Brett, J.M., Stroh, L.K. & Reilly, A.H.Pulling up roots in the 1990s: Who's willing to relocate?Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1993, 14, 49-60.
7.
Budig, M.J. & England, P.The wage penalty for motherhood. American Sociological Review , 2001, 66, 204-25.
8.
Carlson, D.S. & Frone, M.R.Relation of behavioral and psychological involvement to a new four-factor conceptualization of the work-family interface. Journal of Business and Psychology, 2003, 17, 515-35.
9.
Correll, S.J. & Benard, S.Getting a job: Is there a motherhood penalty? American Journal of Sociology, 2007, 112, 1297-338.
10.
Crittenden, A.The price of motherhood. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 2001.
11.
Crosby, F.J., Williams, J.C. & Biernat, M.The maternal wall. Journal of Social Issues, 2004, 60, 675-82.
12.
Cuddy, A.J.C., Fiske, S.T. & Glick, P.When professionals become mothers, warmth doesn't cut the ice. Journal of Social Issues, 2004, 60, 701-18.
13.
De Souza, G.A study of the influence of promotions on promotion satisfaction and expectations of future promotions among managers. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 2002, 13, 325-40.
14.
Diekman, A.B. & Eagly, A.H.Stereotypes as dynamic constructs: Women and men of the past, present, and future. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2000, 26, 1171-88.
15.
Dovidio, J.F. & Gaertner, S.L.Aversive racism and selection decisions: 1989 and 1999. Psychological Science, 2000, 11, 319-23.
16.
Dreher, G.F. & Ash, A.A.A comparative study of mentoring among men and women in managerial, professional, and technical positions. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1990, 75, 539-46.
17.
Eagly, A.H.Sex differences in social behavior: A social role interpretation. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum, 1987.
18.
Eagly, A.H. & Karau, S.J.Role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders. Psychological Review, 2002, 109, 573-98.
19.
Eagly, A.H. & Steffen, V.J.Gender stereotypes, occupational roles, and beliefs about part-time employees . Psychology of Women Quarterly, 1986, 10, 252-62.
20.
Eby, L.T., Allen, T.D. & Douthitt, S.S.The role of nonperformance factors on job-related relocation opportunities: A field study and laboratory experiment. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1999 , 79, 29-55.
21.
Eby, L.T., Casper, W.J., Lockwood, A., Bordeaux, C. & Brinley, A.Work and family research in IO/OB: Content analysis and review of the literature (1980-2002). Journal of Vocational Behavior , 2005, 66, 124-97.
22.
Edwards, J.R.Alternatives to difference scores as dependent variables in the study of congruence in organizational research. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1995, 64, 307-24.
23.
Edwards, J.R.Alternatives to difference scores: Polynomial regression analysis and response surface methodology. In F. Drasgow & D. Schmitt (Eds), Measuring and analyzing behavior in organizations: Advances in measurement and data analysis. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass , 2002, pp. 350-400.
24.
Epstein, C., Seron, C., Oglensky, B. & Saute, R.The part time paradox: Time norms, professional lives, family, and gender . New York: Routledge, 1999.
25.
Foster, J.B. & Hebl, M.R.Penalties for mothers at work. Unpublished manuscript, Rice University, 2008.
26.
Fredriksen-Goldsen, K.I. & Scharlach, A.E.Families and work: New directions in the twenty-first century. New York: Oxford University Press, 2001.
27.
Freedman, L.S. & Schatzkin, A.Sample size for studying intermediate endpoints within intervention trials of observational studies. American Journal of Epidemiology , 1992, 136, 1148-59.
28.
Frone, M.R. & Rice, R.W.Work-family conflict: The effect of job and family involvement. Journal of Occupational Behavior, 1987, 8, 45-53.
29.
Fuegen, K., Biernat, M., Haines, E. & Deaux, K.Mothers and fathers in the workplace: How gender and parental status influence judgments of job competence. Journal of Social Issues , 2004, 60, 737-54.
30.
Galinsky, E., Bond, J. & Friedman, D.The role of employers in addressing the needs of employed parents . Journal of Social Issues, 1996, 52, 111-36.
31.
Greenhaus, J.H., Parasuraman, S.J. & Wormley, W.M.Effects of race on organizational experiences, job performance evaluations, and career outcomes. Academy of Management Journal, 1990, 33, 64-86.
32.
Hammer, L.B., Allen, E. & Grigsby, T.D.Work-family conflict in dual-earner couples: Within-individual and crossover effects of work and family. Journal of Vocational Behavior , 1997, 50, 185-203.
33.
Harris, M.M. & Schaubroeck, J.A meta-analysis of self-supervisor, self-peer, and peer-supervisor ratings. Personnel Psychology, 1988, 41, 43-62.
34.
Hays, S.Cultural contradictions of motherhood. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1996 .
35.
Hebl, M.R. & Foster, J.B.Parental status and discrimination: Are mothers too feminine to make it in a man's world? Unpublished manuscript, Rice University , 2005.
36.
Hebl, M.R., King, E.B., Glick, P., Singletary, S. & Kazama, S.Hostile and benevolent reactions toward pregnant women: Complementary interpersonal punishments and rewards that maintain traditional roles. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2007, 92, 1499-511.
37.
Jacobs, J.A. & Winslow, S.E.Overworked faculty: Job stresses and family demands. The Annals of the American Academy, 2004, 596, 104-29.
38.
Judge, T. & Cable, D.The effect of physical height on workplace success and income: Preliminary test of a theoretical model. Journal of Applied Psychology , 2004, 89, 428-41.
39.
Judge, T., Higgins, C.A., Thoreson, C. & Barrick, M.R.The big five personality traits, general mental ability, and career success across the lifespan. Personnel Psychology, 1999, 52, 621-52.
40.
Judiesch, M.K. & Lyness, K.S.Left behind? The impact of leave of absence on manager's career success . Academy of Management Journal, 1999, 37, 1047-60.
41.
Kammeyer-Mueller, J.D., Judge, T.A. & Piccolo, R.F.Self-esteem and extrinsic career success. Applied Psychology: An International Review, 2008, 57, 204-24.
42.
Kanungo, R.N.Measurement of job and work involvement. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1982, 67, 341-9.
43.
Karambayya, R. & Reilly, A.H.Dual earner couples: Attitudes and actions in restructuring work for family . Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1992 , 13, 585-601.
44.
Katz, D. & Kahn, R.L.The social psychology of organizations, 2nd edn. New York: Wiley, 1978.
45.
Keene, J.R. & Reynolds, J.R.The job costs of family demands: Gender differences in negative family-to-work spillover. Journal of Family Issues , 2005, 26, 275-99.
46.
King, E.B., Hebl, M.R., George, J.M. & Matusik, S.F.Understanding tokenism: Antecedents and consequences of climate for gender inequity. Unpublished manuscript, George Mason University , 2008.
47.
Kobrynowicz, D. & Biernat, M.Decoding subjective evaluations: How stereotypes provide shifting standards . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1997, 33, 579-601.
48.
LeBlanc, M.M. & Kelloway, E.K.Predictors and outcomes of workplace violence and aggression. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2002, 87, 444-53.
49.
Lennon, M.C. & Rosenfield, S.Relative fairness and the division of housework: The importance of options. American Journal of Sociology, 1994, 100, 506-31.
50.
MacKinnon, D.P.Contrasts in multiple mediator models. In J.S. Rose, L. Chassin, C.C. Presson & S.J. Sherman (Eds), Multivariate applications in substance use research: New methods for new questions. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum, 2000, pp. 141-60.
51.
MacKinnon, D.P., Kruss, J.L. & Lockwood, C.M.Equivalence of the mediation, confounding, and suppression effect. Prevention Science, 2000 , 1, 173-81.
52.
MacKinnon, D.P., Lockwood, C.M., Hoffman, J.M., West, S.G. & Sheets, V.A comparison of methods to test mediation and other intervening variables . Psychological Methods, 2002, 7, 83-104.
53.
Madden, J.F.Preface to special issue. The Annals of the American Academy , 2004, 596, 6-18.
54.
Major, B.Gender, entitlement, and the distribution of family labor. Journal of Social Issues, 1993, 3, 141-59.
55.
Marsden, P.V., Kalleberg, A.L. & Cook, C.R.Gender differences in organizational commitment. Work and Occupations, 1993, 20, 368-90.
Mason, M.A. & Goulden, M.Marriage and baby blues: Redefining gender equity in the academy. The Annals of the American Academy, 2004, 86-103.
58.
Melamed, T.Career success: An assessment of a gender-specific model. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 1996 , 69, 217-42.
59.
Meyer, J.P. & Allen, N.J.A three-component conceptualization of organizational commitment. Human Resource Management Review, 1991, 1, 61-98.
60.
Meyer, J.P., Allen, N.J. & Smith, C.A.Commitment to organizations and occupations: Extension and test of a three-component conceptualization. Journal of Applied Psychology , 1993, 78, 538-51.
61.
Ng, T.W.H., Eby, L.E., Sorensen, K.L. & Feldman, D.C.Predictors of objective and subjective career success: A meta-analysis . Personnel Psychology, 2005, 58, 367-408.
62.
O'Neill, J.The shrinking pay gap. The Wall Street Journal, 7 October 1994, p. A10.
63.
Parasuraman, S. & Simmers, C.Type of employment, work-family conflict and well-being: A comparative study . Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2001 , 22, 551-68.
64.
Paullay, I.M., Alliger, G.M. & Stone-Romero, E.F.Construct validation of two instruments designed to measure job involvement and work centrality. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1994, 79, 224-8.
65.
Peluchette, J.V.E.Subjective career success: The influence of individual difference, family, and organizational variables. Journal of Vocational Behavior , 1993, 43, 198-208.
66.
Pinker, S.The science of gender and science: A debate. May 2005 , available online at [http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/debate05/debate05_index.html ].
67.
Pleck, J.H.The work-family role system. Social Forces, 1977, 24, 417-27.
68.
Pratt, M.G. & Rosa, J.A.Transforming work-family conflict into commitment in network marketing organizations . Academy of Management Journal, 2003, 46, 395-418.
69.
Ridgeway, C.L. & Correll, S.J.Motherhood as a status characteristic. Journal of Social Issues , 2004, 60, 638-700.
70.
Rothbard, N.P. & Edwards, J.R.Investment in work and family roles: A test of identity and utilitarian motives . Personnel Psychology, 2003, 56, 699-730.
71.
Ruderman, M.N., Ohlott, P.J., Panzer, K. & King, S.N.Benefits of multiple roles for managerial women. Academy of Management Journal, 2002, 45, 369-86.
72.
Rynes, S. & Rosen, B.A comparison of male and female reactions to career advancement opportunities . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 1983, 22, 105-16.
73.
Schaubroeck, J. & Lam, S.K.How similarity to peers and supervisor influences organizational advancement in different cultures. Academy of Management Journal, 2002, 45, 1120-36.
74.
Schneer, J.A. & Reitman, F.Effects of alternate family structures on managerial career paths . Academy of Management Journal, 1993, 36, 830-43.
75.
Seibert, S.E., Crant, J.M. & Kramer, M.L.Proactive personality and career success. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1999, 84, 416-27.
76.
Shore, L.M. & Thornton, G.C.Effects of gender on self- and supervisory ratings . Academy of Management Journal, 1986 , 29, 115-29.
77.
Shore, L.M. & Wayne, S.J.Commitment and employee behavior: Comparison of affective commitment and continuance commitment with perceived organizational support. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1993, 78, 774-80.
78.
Shore, L.M., Barksdale, K. & Shore, T.H.Managerial perceptions of employee commitment to the organization . Academy of Management Journal, 1995, 38, 1593-615.
79.
Stoner, C.R. & Hartman, R.I.Family responsibilities and career progress: The good, the bad, and the ugly . Business Horizons, May/June 1990 , pp. 7-14.
80.
Stroh, L.K., Brett, J.M. & Reilly, A.H.All the right stuff: A comparison of female and male managers' career progression . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1992, 77, 251-60.
81.
Stroh, L.K., Brett, J.M. & Reilly, A.H.Family structure, glass ceiling, and traditional explanations for the differential turnover of female and male managers. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 1996, 49, 99-118.
82.
Suitor, J., Mecom, D. & Feld, I.S.Gender, household labor, and scholarly productivity among university professors . Gender Issues, 2001, 19, 50-67.
83.
Tharenou, P.Managerial career advancement. International Review of Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 1997, 12, 39-93.
84.
Tharenou, P.Is there a link between family structures and women's and men's managerial career advancement?Journal of Organizational Behavior, 1999, 20, 837-63.
85.
Tharenou, P.Going up? Do traits and informal social processes predict advancing in management?Academy of Management Journal, 2001, 44, 1005-17.
86.
Tharenou, P., Latimer, S. & Conroy, D.How do you make it to the top? An examination of influences on women's and men's managerial advancement. Academy of Management Journal , 1994, 37, 899-931.
87.
Turban, D.B. & Dougherty, T.W.Role of protégé personality in receipt of mentoring and career success. Academy of Management Journal, 1994, 37, 688-702.
88.
Turner, R.J.Sponsored and contest mobility and the school system. American Sociological Review, 1960, 25, 855-67.
89.
Waldfogel, J.Understanding the `family gap' in pay for women with children. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 1998, 12, 137-56.
90.
Wellin, C.Telling tales out of school: Dilemmas of race and inclusiveness in the liberal academy. American Behavioral Scientist, 2008 , 51, 686-708.
91.
Williams, J.E.Unbending gender: Why work and family conflict and what to do about it. Oxford: Oxford University Press , 2001.
92.
Williams, J.C. & Segal, N.Beyond the maternal wall: Relief for family caregivers who are discriminated against on the job. Harvard Women's Law Journal, 2004, 26, 77-162.
93.
Witt, L.A., Kacmar, K.M. & Andrews, M.C.The interactive effects of procedural justice and exchange ideology on supervisor-rated commitment. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2001, 22, 505-15.
94.
Woehr, D.J., Sheehan, M. & Bennett, W.Assessing measurement equivalence across rating sources: A multitrait-multirater approach. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2005 , 90, 592-600.
95.
Wood, W. & Eagly, A.H.Once again, the origins of sex differences. American Psychologist , 2000, 55, 1062-3.
96.
Wood, W., Christensen, P.N., Hebl, M. & Rothgerber, H.Conformity to sex-typed norms, affect, and the self-concept. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 1997, 73, 523-35.
97.
Zedeck, S. & Moiser, K.L.Work in the family and employing organization. American Psychologist , 1990, 45, 240-50.
