The transformational leader as pedagogue,physician,architect,commander,and saint: Five root metaphors in Jack Welch's letters to stockholders of General Electric
Restricted accessOtherFirst published online December, 2007
The transformational leader as pedagogue,physician,architect,commander,and saint: Five root metaphors in Jack Welch's letters to stockholders of General Electric
We analyse the corpus of CEO letters to stockholders that were signed by a widely revered business leader, Jack Welch, during his tenure as CEO of the General Electric Company [GE], 1981—2000. Our discussion is located within theory pertaining to transformational leadership. We examine Welch's language from the standpoint of how transformational leadership can be conceived as a rhetorical artefact of one-sided dialogue emanating from a powerful leader. We give particular attention to the saturation of Welch's discourse with metaphors, and argue that metaphors illuminate how transformational leadership and the accompanying construct of charisma manifest themselves in practice. Five root metaphors that heightened Welch's persuasive and rhetorical impact on his audience are identified and discussed: Welch as pedagogue , physician, architect, commander and saint . We advocate greater awareness of the rhetorical techniques employed by transformational leaders in attempts to broker compliance with their views.
Abetti, P.A.Case study: Jack Welch's creative revolutionary transformation of General Electric and the Thermidorean reaction (1981—2004). Creativity and Innovation Management, 2006, 15, 74—84.
Alvesson, M. & Deetz, S.Critical theory and postmodern approaches to organization studies . In S. Clegg, C. Hardy, T. Lawrence & W. Nord (Eds), The Sage handbook of organization studies. London: Sage, 2006, pp. 255—83.
4.
Alvesson, M. & Karreman, D.Varieties of discourse: On the study of organizations through discourse analysis . Human Relations, 2000, 53, 1125—49.
5.
Amernic, J. & Craig, R.CEO-speak: The language of corporate leadership. Montreal : McGill Queen's University Press, 2006.
6.
Ancona, D., Malone, T., Orlikowski, N. & Senge, P.In praise of the incomplete leader. Harvard Business Review , February 2007, pp. 92—100.
7.
Awamleh, R. & Gardner, W.Perceptions of leader charisma and effectiveness: The effects of vision content, delivery, and organizational performance. The Leadership Quarterly , 1999, 10, 345—73.
8.
Bass, B.Leadership and performance beyond expectations. New York : Free Press, 1985.
Bass, B.The ethics of transformational leadership. In J. Ciulla (Ed.), Ethics: The heart of leadership, 2nd edn. Westport, CT: Praeger, 2004, pp. 169—92.
11.
Bass, B. & Riggio, R.Transformational leadership, 2nd edn. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2006 .
12.
Bell, E. & Taylor, S. `From outward bound to inward bound': The prophetic voices and discursive practices of spiritual management development. Human Relations , 2004, 57, 439—66.
13.
Bennis, W.Get real! Leadership as a performing art. Keynote address, Leadership 2002 Conference, Kennedy School of Government, 2002.
14.
Benoit, W.L.Framing through temporal metaphor: The `bridges' of Bob Dole and Bill Clinton in their 1996 acceptance speeches. Communication Studies , 2001, 52, 70—84.
15.
Boje, D.Narrative methods for organizational and communication research. London: Sage, 2001.
16.
Brown, A.D.Narcissism, identity, and legitimacy. Academy of Management Review, 1997, 22, 643—86.
17.
Buzzanell, P.M.Book review of Fairhurst, G.T. & R.A. Sarr, The art of framing: Managing the language of leadership. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1996. Management Communication Quarterly, 1996, 10, 243—54.
18.
Byrne, J.A.Jack: A close-up look at how America's number 1 manager runs GE. Business Week, 1998, 3581 (8 June), 90.
Cheney, G., Christensen, L., Conrad, C. & Lair, D.Corporate rhetoric as organizational discourse. In D. Grant, C. Hardy , C. Oswick & L. Putnam (Eds), The Sage handbook of organizational discourse. London: Sage, 2004, pp. 79—104.
21.
Chrislip, D. & Larson, C.Collaborative leadership: How citizens and civil leaders can make a difference . San Francisco, CA: Jossey Bass , 1995.
22.
Clampitt, P. & DeKoch, R.Embracing uncertainty: The essence of leadership . New York : Sharpe, 2001.
23.
Clegg, S., Courpasson, D. & Phillips, N.Power and organizations. London: Sage, 2006.
24.
Conger, J.The dark side of leadership. Organizational Dynamics , 1990, 19, 44—55.
25.
Conger, J. & Kanungo, R.Charismatic leadership in organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1998.
26.
Cornelissen, J.What are we playing at? Theatre, organization, and the use of metaphor . Organization Studies, 2004, 25, 705—26.
27.
Cornelissen, J.Beyond compare: Metaphor in organizational theory. Academy of Management Review, 2005, 30, 751—64.
28.
Cornelissen, J.Metaphor and the dynamics of knowledge in organizational theory: A case study of the organizational identity metaphor. Journal of Management Studies, 2006, 43, 683—709.
29.
Cuno, J.Telling stories: Rhetoric and leadership, a case study. Leadership , 2005, 1, 205—13.
30.
Deetz, S.Critical theory. In S. May & D. Mumby (Eds), Engaging organizational communication: Theory and research. London : Sage, 2005, pp. 85—112.
31.
Den Hartog, D.N. & Verburg, R.M.Charisma and rhetoric: Communicative techniques of international business leaders. Leadership Quarterly, 1997, 8(4), 355—91.
32.
Entman, R.M.Framing: Towards clarification of a fractured paradigm. Journal of Communication, 1993, 43, 51—8.
33.
Eubanks, P.Conceptual metaphor as rhetorical response: A reconsideration of metaphor . Written Communication, 1999, 16(2), 171—99.
Fairhurst, G. & Sarr, R.The art of framing: Managing the language of leadership. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, 1996.
36.
Fanelli, A. & Grasselli, N.Defeating the minotaur: The construction of CEO charisma and the US stock market. Organization Studies, 2005, 27, 811—32.
37.
Fiol, C.M.A semiotic analysis of corporate language: Organizational boundaries and joint venturing. Administrative Science Quarterly,1989, 34, 277—303.
38.
Fleming, P. `Kindergarten cop': Paternalism and resistance in a high-commitment workplace. Journal of Management Studies, 2005, 42, 1469—89.
39.
Fry, L.Toward a theory of spiritual leadership. The Leadership Quarterly , 2003, 14, 693—727.
40.
Gabriel, Y.Storytelling in organisations: Stories, fantasies, and subjectivity . Oxford: Oxford University Press , 2000.
41.
Gabriel, Y.Narratives, stories and texts. In D. Grant , C. Hardy, C. Oswick & L. Putnam (Eds), The Sage handbook of organizational discourse. London: Sage, 2004, pp. 61—77.
42.
Gibbs, R.Process and products in making sense of tropes. In A. Ortony (Ed.), Metaphor and thought, 2nd edn. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993, pp. 252—76.
43.
Goffman, E.Frame analysis: An essay on the organization of experience. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press , 1986. (Originally published 1974.)
44.
Greiner, L.Steve Kerr and his years with Jack Welch at GE. Journal of Management Inquiry, 2002, 11, 343—50.
45.
Grint, K.The arts of leadership. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000.
46.
Hardy, C. & Phillips, N.Discourse and power. In D. Grant , C. Hardy, C. Oswick & L. Putnam (Eds), The Sage handbook of organizational discourse. London: Sage, 2004, pp. 299—316.
47.
Hardy, C., Palmer, I. & Phillips, N.Discourse as a strategic resource. Human Relations , 2000, 53, 1227—48.
48.
Harré, R.The philosophies of science, 2nd edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1984.
49.
Hegele, C. & Kieser, A.Control the construction of your legend or someone else will: An analysis of texts on Jack Welch. Journal of Management Inquiry, 2001, 10, 298—309.
50.
Heifetz, R.Leadership without easy answers. Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press, 1994 .
51.
Heracleous, L.Interpretivist approaches to organizational discourse. In D. Grant, C. Hardy , C. Oswick & L. Putnam (Eds), The Sage handbook of organizational discourse. London: Sage, 2004, pp. 175—92.
52.
Heracleous, L.A tale of three discourses: The dominant, the strategic and the marginalized . Journal of Management Studies, 2006, 43, 1059—87.
53.
House, R.A 1976 theory of charismatic leadership. In J. Hunt & L. Larson (Eds), Leadership: The cutting edge. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1977, pp. 189—207.
54.
House, R. & Baetz, M.Leadership: Some empirical generalizations and new research directions . In B. Staw (Ed.), Research in organizational behavior, vol. 1. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, 1979, pp. 341—423.
55.
Hyland, K.Exploring corporate rhetoric: Metadiscourse in the CEO's letter. Journal of Business Communication, 1998, 35, 224—45.
56.
Jones, D.Using the Web to rebuild trust in CEOs. IR Web Report , 26 January 2005, available online at: [ http://www.irwebreport.com/perspectives/2005/ceosonline.htm ], accessed 19 September 2006.
57.
Kassing, J.From the look of things: Assessing perceptions of organizational dissenters . Management Communication Quarterly, 2001 , 14, 442—70.
58.
Keeley, M.The trouble with transformational leadership: Towards a federalist ethic for organizations. In J. Ciulla (Ed.), Ethics, the heart of leadership. Westport, CT: Praeger, 1998, pp. 111—44.
59.
Kendall, J.E.Good and evil in the chairmen's `boiler plate': An analysis of corporate visions of the 1970s. Organization Studies, 1993, 14, 571—92.
60.
Kets de Vries, M.The leadership mystique. Academy of Management Executive , 1994, 8(3), 73—89.
61.
Kets de Vries, M.Organizations on the couch: A clinical perspective on organizational dynamics . European Management Journal, 2004 , 22, 183—200.
62.
Lakoff, G.The contemporary theory of metaphor. In A. Ortony (Ed.), Metaphor and thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993, pp. 202—51.
63.
Loewenstein, J. & Ocasio, W.Vocabularies of organizing: How language links culture, cognition, and action in organizations. McCombs School of Business Research Paper Series No. OSSM-03—05 , October 2005, The University of Texas at Austin, available online at the Social Science Research Network Electronic Paper Collection: [http://ssrn/abstract/813344 ].
64.
Martin, J.The culture of organizations: Three perspectives. Oxford : Oxford University Press, 1992.
65.
Meindl, J.The romance of leadership as a follower-centric theory: A social constructionist approach. Leadership Quarterly, 1995, 6, 329—41.
66.
Mindell, A.The leader as martial artist: Techniques and strategies for resolving conflict and creating community. Portland, OR: Lao Tse Press, 2000.
67.
Mio, J.S., Riggio, R.E., Levin, S. & Reese, R.Presidential leadership and charisma: The effects of metaphor. Leadership Quarterly, 2005, 16, 287—94.
68.
Moravec, M., Gyr, H. & Friedman, L.A 21st century communication tool. HR Magazine, 1993, July, 77—81.
69.
Morgan, G.Images of organization. London: Sage, 1986.
70.
Morris, D.Power plays: Win or lose — How history's great political leaders play the game. New York: Harper Collins , 2002.
71.
Morrison, E. & Milliken, E.Organizational silence: A barrier to change and development in a pluralistic world. Academy of Management Review, 2003, 25, 706—25.
72.
Nutt, P.Why decisions fail: Avoiding the blunders and traps that lead to debacles . San Francisco, CA: Berret-Koehler , 2002.
73.
Oberlechner, T. & Mayer-Schoenberger, V.Through their own words: Towards a new understanding of leadership through metaphors. John F. Kennedy School of Government (Harvard University) Faculty Research Working Papers Series, 2002.
74.
Oswick, C. & Grant, D. (Eds). Organizational development: Metaphorical explorations . London: Pitman, 1996.
75.
Oswick, C., Putnam, L. & Keenoy, T.Tropes, discourse and organizing. In D. Grant, C. Hardy, C. Oswick & L. Putnam (Eds), The Sage handbook of organizational discourse. London: Sage, 2004, pp. 105—28.
76.
Palmer, I., King, A.W. & Kelleher, D.Listening to Jack: GE's change conversations with shareholders. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 2004 , 17, 593—614.
Postman, N.The end of education. New York: Vintage Books, 1996.
79.
Prasad, A. & Mir, R.Digging deep for meaning: A critical hermeneutic analysis of CEO letters to shareholders in the oil industry. The Journal of Business Communication, 2002, 39, 92—116.
80.
Putnam, L. & Boys, S.Revisiting metaphors of organizational communication. In S. Clegg, C. Hardy , T. Lawrence & W. Nord (Eds), The Sage handbook of organization studies. London: Sage, 2006, pp. 541—76.
81.
Putnam, L. & Fairhurst, G.Discourse analysis in organizations. In F. Jablin & L. Putnam (Eds), The new handbook of organizational communication. London : Sage, 2001, pp. 78—136.
82.
Rafferty, A. & Griffin, M.Dimensions of transformational leadership: Conceptual and empirical extensions . The Leadership Quarterly, 2004 , 15, 329—54.
83.
Ricoeur, P.On interpretation. In A. Montefiore (Ed.), Philosophy in France today. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1983, pp. 175—97.
84.
Roberto, M.Why great leaders don't take yes for an answer: Managing for conflict and consensus. Philadelphia, PA: Wharton School Publishing, 2005.
85.
Shamir, B.Social distance and charisma: Theoretical notes and an exploratory study. Leadership Quarterly, 1995, 6, 19—47.
86.
Shamir, B., House, R. & Arthur, M.The motivational effects of charismatic leadership: A self-concept based theory . Organization Science, 1993, 4, 577—94.
87.
Sheard, C.M.The public value of epideictic rhetoric. College English , 1996, 58, 765—94.
88.
Skapinker, M.Different game, same winners. Financial Times, 17 January 2003.
89.
Slater, R.The new GE: How Jack Welch revived an American institution. Homewood, IL: Irwin, 1993.
90.
Slater, R.Get better or get beaten! 31 leadership secrets from GE's Jack Welch . New York: McGraw-Hill, 1994.
91.
Slater, R.The GE way fieldbook: Jack Welch's battle plan for corporate revolution . New York: McGraw-Hill, 1999a.
92.
Slater, R.Jack Welch and the GE way. New York: McGraw Hill, 1999b.
93.
Smith, R. & Eisenberg, E.Conflict at Disneyland: A root-metaphor analysis. Communication Monographs, 1987, 54, 367—80.
Staw, B., McKechnie, P. & Puffer, S.The justification of organizational performance. Administrative Science Quarterly,1983, 28, 582—600.
96.
Strange, J. & Mumford, M.The origin of vision: Charismatic versus ideological leadership. The Leadership Quarterly, 2002, 13, 343—77.
97.
Summers, K.Epideictic rhetoric in the Englishwoman's review. Victorian Periodicals Review, 2001, 34, available online at: [http://www.utpjournals.com/product/vpr/343/rhetoric13.html], accessed 17 November 2006 (unpaginated).
98.
Tichy, N. & Cohen, E.The leadership engine: How winning companies build leaders at every level . New York, Harper Business , 1997.
99.
Tourish, D.Critical upward communication: Ten commandments for improving strategy and decision making. Long Range Planning, 2005 , 38, 485—503.
100.
Tourish, D. & Pinnington, A.Transformational leadership, corporate cultism and the spirituality paradigm: An unholy trinity in the workplace?Human Relations, 2002, 55, 147—72.
101.
Tourish, D. & Robson, P.Sensemaking and the distortion of critical upward communication in organizations . Journal of Management Studies, 2006, 43, 711—30.
102.
Tourish, D. & Vatcha, N.Charismatic leadership and corporate cultism at Enron: The promotion of conformity, the elimination of dissent and organizational collapse. Leadership , 2005, 1, 455—80.
103.
Tsoukas, H.The missing link: A transformational view of metaphors in organizational science . Academy of Management Review, 1991 , 16, 566—85.
104.
Waldman, D. & Yammarino, F.CEO charismatic leadership: Levels of management and levels of analysis effects . Academy of Management Review, 1999 , 24, 266—85.
105.
Weick, K. & Ashford, S.Learning in organizations. In F. Jablin & L. Putnam (Eds), The new handbook of organizational communication: Advances in theory, research and methods . London: Sage, 2001, pp. 704—31.
106.
Weissman, R.Global management by stress. Multinational Monitor , 2001, 22, available online at: [www.essential.org], accessed 24 December 2001.
107.
Welch, J. (with J.A. Byrne). Jack: Straight from the gut. New York: Warner Business Books, 2001.
108.
Westley, F. & Mintzberg, H.Visionary leadership and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 1989, 10, 17—32.
109.
Westphal, J. & Zajac, E.The symbolic management of stockholders: Corporate governance reforms and shareholder reactions. Administrative Science Quarterly,1998, 43, 127—53.
