Is the effectiveness of tobacco image-based warning labels likely to vary by socio-demographic variable? Findings from an online survey of 19,000 members of the UK Public

Abstract

Objective:

Smoking continues to be a major global cause of mortality and morbidity. Countries have increasingly adopted the use of images as warnings on cigarette packs. We aimed to investigate the likely differential impact of varied images and messages on sub-groups of the United Kingdom (UK) smoking population.

Methods:

Forty two images developed and approved by the European Union (EU) were viewed by participants in an online survey. Respondents indicated which images they felt would most effectively reduce rates of smoking. Socio-demographic data was sought from participating adults including age, sex, occupation, ethnicity and current smoking behaviour. There were 19,810 participants in the survey.

Results:

Three images, with graphic content, were found to consistently stand out as the most popular across all sub-groups. Smokers (as opposed to ex- and non-smokers) and men were found to vote for significantly fewer images, potentially indicating greater scepticism regarding the efficacy of images. Significant socio-demographic variations across a number of images were found suggesting that particular images and messages may have a differential impact on particular sub-groups.

Conclusion:

Images may vary significantly in their impact on different social sub-groups. Careful consideration is required when selecting which images to use. Attaching images targeting a sub-group to tobacco brands with that socio-demographic market may enhance the effectiveness of such warnings.

Keywords

Behaviour labels smoking warnings

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Mackay

Eriksen

. The Tobacco Atlas. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization, 2002.

Guidon

Boisclair

. Past, current and future trends in tobacco use. Health, Nutrition and Population Discussion Paper. Washington, DC: World Bank Human Development Network, 2003.

Robinson

Bugler

. Smoking and Drinking Among Adults, 2008. General Lifestyle Survey 2008. Newport, UK: Office for National Statistics, 2010.

Department of Health. Consultation on the Introduction of Picture Warnings on Tobacco Packs. London: Department of Health, 2006.

Department of Health. Consultation on the Introduction of Picture Warnings on Tobacco Packs: Report on Consultation. London: Departent of Health, 2007.

Commission

. Tobacco or Health in the European Union: Past, Present and Future: The Aspect Consortium. The European Commission, 2004.

Health

. BMRB Tobacco Education Campaign Tracking Study. London: Department of Health, 2004.

Slade

. The pack as advertisement. Tob. Control, 1997: 6(3): 169–70.

Willemsen

. The Altered View of Tobacco Products: The Effects of the New Health Warnings on Smokers. The Hague, The Netherlands: DEFACTO, 2002.

10.

Fong

. A Review of the Research on Tobacco Warning Labels, With Particular Emphasis on the New Canadian Warning Labels. Expert report submitted to Justice Canada in JTI_Macdonald and Imperial Tobacco Canada and Rothmans, Benson & Hedges v. The Attorney General of Canada, 2001.

11.

Davy

. Socio-economic inequalities in smoking: An examination of generational trends in Great Britain. Health Statistics Quarterly, 2007: 34: 26–33.

12.

Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) AoSaH. Smoking Statistics: Illness & Death. ASH Fact Sheet No. 2. ASH, 2001.

13.

Health

. Tackling Health Inequalities - Cross Cutting Review. London: Department of Health, 2002.

14.

Hammond

Fong

McDonald

Brown

Cameron

. The impact of cigarette warning labels and smoke-free bylaws on smoking cessation. Canadian Journal of Public Health, 2004: 95(3): 201–4.

15.

Hammond

Fong

McDonald

Brown

Cameron

. Graphic Canadian cigarette warning labels and adverse outcomes: Evidence from Canadian smokers. Am. J. Public Health, 2004: 94(8): 1442–45.

16.

Hammond

Fong

Borland

Cummings

McNeill

Driezen

. Text and graphic warnings on cigarette packages: findings from the international tobacco control four country study. Am. J. Prev. Med., 2007: 32(3): 202–9.

17.

Gallopel-Morvan

Gabriel

Gall-Ely

Rieunier

Urien

. The use of visual warnings in social marketing: The case of tobacco. Journal of Business Research 2011: 64(1): 7–11.

18.

Bradley

Lang

. Fearfulness and affective evaluations of pictures. Motivation and Emotion, 1999: 23(1): 1–13.

19.

Carver

Sutton

Scheier

. Action, emotion, and personality: Emerging conceptual integration. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2000: 26: 741–51.

20.

Irving

Feshbach

. Effects of fear arousing communications. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1953: 48: 78–92.

21.

Hastings

MacFayden

. The limitations of fear messages. Tob. Control, 2002: 11: 73–75.

22.

Hastings

Stead

Webb

. Fear appeals in social marketing: Strategic and ethical reasons for concern. Psychology and Marketing, 2004: 21(11): 961–86.

23.

Witte

Allen

. A meta-anslysis of fear appeals: Implications for effective public health campaigns. Health Educ. Behav., 2000: 27: 608–32.

24.

Boote

Telford

Cooper

. Consumer involvement in health research: A review and research agenda. Health Policy, 2002: 61: 231–36.

25.

Health Do. Research Governance Framework for Health and Social Care (2nd edition). London: Department of Health, 2005.

26.

National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE). NICE Citizens Council Meeting: The Use of Incentives to Improve Health. London: National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, 2010.

27.

LMcDaniels

. Comparing expressed and revealed preferences for risk reduction: Different hazards and question frames. Risk Anal., 1988: 8(4): 593–604.

28.

Ausburn

. Visual literacy: Background, theory and practice. PLET 1978: 15(4): 291–7.

29.

Avgerinou

Ericson

. A review of the concept of visual literacy. British Journal of Educational Technology, 1997: 28(4): 280–91.

30.

Cameron

. Conceptualizing and assessing risk perceptions: A self-regulatory perspective. Paper presented at the Conceptualizing and Measuring Risk Perception Workshop, February 13-14,Washington DC, 2003.

31.

Shahab

Hall

Marteau

. Showing smokers with vascular disease images of their arteries to motivate cessation: A pilot study. British Journal of Health Psychology, 2007: 12(2): 275–83.

32.

Lee

. Preventive Health Messages For Cardiovascular Disease: The Role of Abstract Text and Concrete Animation. University of Auckland, 2007.