Caring for patients with progressive illness who need symptomatic and palliative care involves professionals as well as non-professionals. Within the variety of settings that may exist around a patient, education will be constantly needed. A limited systematic review was therefore conducted in order to highlight factors that influence informal adult education.
Methods Eight databases (covering all the years each database covered up to present date), the internet and twenty-two journals were searched. If not available on line, the journals were hand searched. Keywords were ‘professional - instruction - evidence’, combined. The search was augmented by contacting researchers and authors. We included studies describing any adult education setting outside the formally established educational setting (such as classroom/school/university). Outcomes were related to individual responses, not to groups as a whole. We excluded studies including children or those carried out in classroom settings, as well as studies where the outcome referred to the group as a whole. Data were extracted into tables and contrasted, drawing particularly on studies from health care settings. Studies were graded according to their: 1) relevance by using an adjusted Signal score and 2) level of evidence.
Results A total of 81 articles and reviews were found. From these, 28 studies and 5 Cochrane reviews were included. The studies and reviews reflect a spread in design, settings as well as origin. All continents except South America were represented. Many studies indicated that a multi-faceted, personally tailored educational approach gives the best results. This finding was corroborated by the Cochrane reviews. A common finding was that transport (to the educational arena) emerged as an important factor.
Conclusions Multifaceted education, which includes the use of various media, and which is personally tailored is most effective. Examples are such as a combination of verbal and written presentations including information forms, leaflets, alongside a demonstration of practical skills in a real life situation.
Stjernswärd J , Pampallona S.Palliative medicine - a global perspective. In: Doyle D , Hanks GWC , MacDonald N (eds), Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine. 2nd ed. Oxford, New York, Tokyo: Oxford University Press , 1999: 1227-1245.
2.
Goodwin DM , Higginson IJ , Edwards AGK , Finlay IG , Cook AM , Douglas H-Ret al.An evaluation of systematic reviews of palliative care services . J Palliat Care, 2002: 18: 77-83 .
3.
Hospice Information . Hospice Directory, 2005.
4.
Murray CJL , Lopez AD.Alternative projections of mortality and disability by cause 1990-2020: Global Burden of Disease Study . Lancet, 1997: 349: 1498-1504 .
5.
Robbins M.Evaluating Palliative Care: Establishing the Evidence Base. Oxford University Press , 1998.
6.
Daaleman TP , VandeCreek L.Placing religion and spirituality in end-of-life care . JAMA, 2000: 284(19): 2514-2517 .
7.
Higginson IJ , Sen-Gupta GJA.Place of care in advanced cancer: A qualitative systematic literature review of patient preferences . Journal of Palliative Medicine, 2000: 3: 287-300 .
8.
Doyle D , Hanks G , MacDonald N.Introduction. In: Doyle D , Hanks GWC , MacDonald N (eds), Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine. 2nd ed.Oxford, New York, Tokyo: Oxford University Press , 1999: 3-8.
9.
Addington-Hall JM , Higginson IJ.Introduction. In: Addington-Hall JM , Higginson IJ (eds), Palliative Care for Non-Cancer Patients. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press , 2001: 1-10.
10.
Chambers R , Boath E.Clinical Effectiveness and Clinical Governance Made Easy. 2nd ed. Oxford: Radcliffe Primary Care , 2001.
11.
Smestad Wisløff EM. Det handler om å lære. [Om ansvar, kreativitet, frigjøring og reflekterende fortellinger.] Oslo: Tano Aschehoug, 1998.
12.
Knowles MS.The Adult Learner: The Definitive Classic in Adult Education and Human Resource Development. 1998.
13.
Freire P.Pedagogy of the Oppressed. London: Penguin , 1996.
14.
Higginson IJ , Finlay I , Goodwin DM , Cook AM , Hood K , Edwards AGKet al.Do hospital-based palliative teams improve care for patients or families at the end of life ? J Pain Symptom Manage, 2002: 23: 96-106 .
15.
Moore S , Cairns C , Harding G , Craft M.Health promotion in the high street: A study of community pharmacy . Health Education Journal, 1995: 54(3): 275-284 .
16.
Kincey J.Women undergoing colposcopy: Their satisfaction with communication, health knowledge and level of anxiety . (Research). Health Education Journal, 1991: 50(2): 70-72 .
17.
Murphy S , Smith C.An examination of the use of health education leaflets by health promotion officers . Health Education Journal, 1992: 51: 166-170 .
18.
Dixon-Woods M.Dissemination of printed information for patients: A qualitative study of general practices . Health Education Journal, 1998: 57: 16-30 .
19.
Hancock B , Hancock DG.Registered mental nurses’ perceived role in health education about smoking . Health Education Journal, 1993: 52: 85-90 .
20.
McAllister G , Bowling A.Attitudes to mammography among women in ethnic minority groups in three areas of England . Health Education Journal, 1993: 52: 217-220 .
21.
Cohen D , Fowlie S.What life style advice on coronary care is given to older patients ? Health Education Journal, 1992: 51: 109-111 .
22.
McCurry N , Thompson K , Parahoo K.Pregnant women’s perception of the implementation of smoking cessation advice . Health Education Journal, 2002: 61: 20-31 .
23.
Seddon T.Improving the health of drug-using prisoners: An exploratory study of drug information needs in male Young Offender Institutions . Health Education Journal, 2001: 60: 17-35 .
24.
Cupples ME , McKnight A , O’Neill C , Normand C.The effect of personal health education on the quality of life of patients with angina in general practice . Health Education Journal, 1996: 55: 75-83 .
25.
Jordan S , Boston P , MacNamara E , Kozolanka K.Some signposts for medical and nursing educational policy formulation for aboriginal health care . International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 2000: 13: 307-324 .
26.
La Tourette TR , Meeks S.Perceptions of patronizing speech by older women in nursing homes and in the community. Impact of Cognitive Ability and Place of Residence . Journal of Language and Social Psychology, 2000: 19: 463-473 .
27.
Gfeller E.Why should I learn to read? Motivations for literacy acquisition in a rural education programme . International Journal of Educational Development, 1997: 17: 101-112 .
28.
Dyer C , Choksi A.Education is like wearing glasses: Nomad’s view of literacy and empowerment . International Journal of Educational Development, 1998: 18: 405-451 .
29.
Rogers A.Improving the quality of adult literacy programmes in developing countries: ‘The real literacies’ approach . International Journal of Educational Development, 1999: 19: 219-234 .
30.
Monkmann K.Transnational migration and learning processes of Mexican adults constructing lives in California . International Journal of Educational Development, 1999: 19: 367-382 .
31.
Archer L , Pratt SD , Phillips D.Working-class men’s construction of masculinity and negotiations of (non) participation in higher education . Gender and Education, 2001: 13: 431-449 .
32.
Norton M , Falk I.Adults and reading disability: A new field of inquiry . International Journal of Disability, Development and Education, 1992: 39: 185-196 .
33.
Elsey B.Adult education and palliative care: The last journey of life and two main kinds of adult learning . International Journal of Lifelong Education, 1996: 15: 192-201 .
34.
Juarez G , Ferrell B , Borneman T.Cultural considerations in education for cancer pain management . Journal of Cancer Education, 1999: 14: 168-173 .
35.
Mazzuca SA , Vinicor F , Cohen SJ , Norton JA , Fineberg NS , Fineberg SEet al.The Diabetes Education Study: A controlled trial of the effects of intensive instruction of internal medicine residents on the management of diabetes mellitus . J Gen Intern Med, 1988: 3(1): 1-8 .
36.
Baab D , Weinstein P.Longitudinal evaluation of a self-inspection plaque index in periodontal recall patients . Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 1986: 13: 313-318 .
37.
Wilkes L , White K , O’Riordan L.Empowerment through information: Supporting rural families of oncology patients in palliative care . Australian Journal of Rural Health, 2000: 8: 41-46 .
38.
Sellick SM , Charles K , Dagsvik J , Kelley ML.Palliative care providers’ perspectives on service and education needs . J Palliat Care, 1996: 12(2): 34-38 .
39.
Rimer B , Levy MH , Keintz MK , Fox L , Engstrom PF , MacElwee N.Enhancing cancer pain control regimens through patient education . Patient Educ Couns, 1987: 10(3): 267-277 .
40.
McCrone SH , Brendle D , Barton K.A multibehavioral intervention to decrease cardiovascular disease risk factors in older men . AACN Clin Issues, 2001: 12(1): 5-16 .
41.
Nichols S , Waters WE.The practice and teaching of breast self-examination in Southampton . Public Health, 1983: 97: 8-16 .
42.
Jones R , Pearson J , McGregor S , Cawsey AJ , Barrett A , Craig Net al.Randomised trial of personalised computer based information for cancer patients . BMJ, 1999: 319(7219): 1241-1247 .
43.
Renders CM , Valk GD , Griffin S , Wagner EH , Eijk JThM van , Assendelft WJJ.Interventions to improve the management of diabetes mellitus in primary care, outpatient and community settings. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: Reviews 2000, Issue 2. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons , 2000.
44.
Forster A , Smith J , Young J , Knapp P , House A , Wright J.Information provision for stroke patients and their caregivers. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: Reviews 2001, Issue 2. DOI: 10 1002/14651858 C. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons , 2001.
45.
Lancaster T , Silagy C , Fowler G.Training health professionals in smoking cessation. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: Reviews 2000, Issue 3. DOI: 10 1002/14651858 CD000214. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons , 2000.
46.
Gibson PG , Powell H , Coughlan J , Wilson AJ , Hensley MJ , Abramson Met al.Limited (information only) patient education programs for adults with asthma. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: Reviews 2002, Issue 1. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons , 2002.
47.
Gibson PG , Powell H , Coughlan J , Wilson AJ , Abramson M , Haywood Pet al.Self-management education and regular practitioner review for adults with asthma. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: Reviews 2002, Issue 3. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons , 2002.
48.
Monroe B. In: Saunders C , Sykes N (eds), The Management of Terminal Malignant Disease. London: Edward Arnold Publishers , 1993.
49.
Ferrell BR. In: Doyle D , Hanks GWC , MacDonald N (eds), Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine. 2nd ed.Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1999.
50.
Hockey J , Small N.Death, Gender and Ethnicity. London: Routledge , 1997.
51.
Clinch JJ , Schipper H.Quality of life assessment in palliative care. In: Doyle D , Hanks GWC , MacDonald N (eds), Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine. Oxford, New York, Tokyo: Oxford University Press , 1993: 61-70.
52.
Oliviere D.Cross-cultural principles of care. In: Saunders C , Sykes N (eds), The Management of Terminal Disease. 3rd ed.London: Edward Arnold Publishers , 1993.
53.
Jenkins VA , Fallowfield LJ , Souhami A , Sawtell M.How do doctors explain randomised clinical trials to their patients ? Eur J Cancer, 1999: 35(8): 1187-1193 .
54.
Fleissig A , Jenkins V , Fallowfield L.Results of an intervention study to improve communication about randomised clinical trials of cancer therapy . Eur J Cancer, 2001: 37(3): 322-331 .
55.
Joy DJ , MacDonald N. In: Doyle D , Hanks GWC , MacDonald N (eds), Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine. 2nd ed.Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1999.
56.
Fallowfield LJ , Jenkins VA , Beveridge HA.Truth may hurt but deceit hurts more: Communication in palliative care . Palliat Med, 2002: 16(4): 297-303 .
57.
Ford S , Fallowfield L , Lewis S.Doctor-patient interactions in oncology . Soc Sci Med, 1996: 42(11): 1511-1519 .
58.
Costantini M , Higginson IJ , Farsides CC , Toscani F , Wilkinson S.Managing patients with lung cancer: Effective communication, palliative care, and guidelines are needed . BMJ, 2000: 320(7231): 379-379 .
59.
Parsons LC.Transcultural communication: The cornerstone of culturally competent care . SCI Nurs, 2002: 19(4): 160-163 .
60.
Farsides B.Communication with hidden communities . European Journal of Cancer Care, 2000: 9: 115-118 .
61.
Fallowfield L , Jenkins V , Farewell V , Saul J , Duffy A , Eves R.Efficacy of a cancer research UK communication skills training model for oncologists: A randomised controlled trial . Lancet, 2002: 359: 650-656 .
62.
Jenkins V , Fallowfield L.Can communication skills training alter physicians’ beliefs and behavior in clinics ? J Clin Oncol, 2002: 20: 765-769 .
63.
Wilkinson S , Roberts A , Aldridge J.Nurse-patient communication in palliative care: An evaluation of a communication skills programme . Palliat Med, 1998: 12: 13-22 .
64.
Wilkinson S , Bailey K , Aldridge J , Roberts A.A longitudinal evaluation of a communication skills programme . Palliat Med, 1999: 13: 341-348 .
Higginson I.Clinical Audit in Palliative Care. Oxford: Radcliffe Medical Press , 1993.
67.
Ferguson A , Makin W , Walker B , Dublon G.Regional implementation of a national cancer policy: Taking forward multiprofessional, collaborative cancer care . Eur J Cancer Care (Engl), 1998: 7(3): 162-167 .
68.
Robbins MA. In: Doyle D , Hanks GWC , MacDonald N (eds), Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine. 2nd ed.Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1999.
69.
Fraser I.Medicare reimbursement for hospice care: Ethical and policy implications of cost-containment strategies . J Health Polit Policy Law, 1985: 10(3): 565-578 .
70.
Calman K , Hanks G. In: Doyle D , Hanks GWC , MacDonald N (eds), Oxford Textbook of Palliative Medicine. 2nd ed.Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1999.
71.
Checkland P.Systems Thinking and Systems Practice. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons , 1981.
72.
National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services . Opening doors: Improving access to Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services by members of the black and ethnic minority communities. Occasional Paper, 7 ed.London: National Council for Hospice and Specialist Palliative Care Services , 1995.
