A review of articles and comments emanating from Dunn's (1968) criticisms of the education of the mildly retarded is presented to analyze some of the facets of the current controversy. Many writings prior and subsequent to Dunn's are cited to show a growing disenchantment with the current course of special education and the lack of viable alternatives currently available. The review is concluded with an emphasis on change rather than reaction and on the desire that inappropriate practices be altered rather than abolished as advocated by some writers.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BlattB.Some persistently recurring assumptions concerning the mentally subnormal. Training School Bulletin, 1960, 57, 48–59.
2.
BlattB.Public policy and the education of children with special needs. Proceedings of the Conference on the Categorical/Non-Categorical Issue in Special Education. Columbia: Special Education Department, University of Missouri, 1971. Pp. 49–62.
3.
ChristoplosF., & RenzP.A critical examination of special education programs. Journal of Special Education, 1969, 3, 371–379.
4.
ConnorF. P.Excellence in special education. Exceptional Children, 1964, 30, 206–209.
5.
DunnL. M.Special education for the mildly retarded—Is much of it justifiable?Exceptional Children, 1968, 35, 5–22.
6.
EngelM.The tin drum revisited. Journal of Special Education, 1969, 3, 380–382.
7.
FisherH. K.What is special education?Special Education in Canada, 1967, 41, 9–16.
8.
FranksD. J.Ethnic and social status characteristics of children in EMR and LD classes. Exceptional Children, 1971, 37, 537–538.
9.
GoldsteinH., MossJ. W., & JordonL. J.The efficacy of special class training on the development of mentally retarded children. Cooperative Research Project 619. Washington, D.C.: HEW, Office of Education. 1965.
10.
GuskinS. L., & SpickerH. H.Educational research in mental retardation. In EllisN. (Ed.), International review of research in mental retardation. Vol. 3. New York: Academic Press, 1968. Pp. 217–278.
11.
HurleyO. L.A categorical/non-categorical issue: Implications for teacher trainers. Proceedings of the Missouri Conference on the Categorical/Non-Categorical Issue in Special Education. Columbia: Special Education Department, University of Missouri1971 Pp. 39–40.
12.
HurleyR.Poverty and mental retardation—A causal relationship. New York: Random House. 1969.
13.
JohnsonG. O.Special education for the mentally retarded—A paradox. Exceptional Children. 1962. 29, 62–69.
14.
JohnsonJ. L.Special education and the inner city: A challenge of the future or another means for cooling the mark out?Journal of Special Education, 1969, 3, 241–251.
15.
JohnsonG. O.Why special education for the mentally retarded: A rebuttal of criticisms. In Exceptional Children Conference Papers: Trends and Issues in Special Education. Papers presented at the 49th Annual Convention of The Council for Exceptional Children, Miami Beach, April, 1971. Pp. 127–134.
16.
LillyM. S.Special education: A teapot in a tempest. Exceptional Children, 1970, 37, 43–49.
17.
LillyM. S.A training based model for special education. Exceptional Children, 1971, 37, 745–749.
18.
LucasC. J.The use and abuse of educational categories. Proceedings of the Conference on the Categorical/Son-Categorical Issue in Special Education. Columbia: Special Education Department, University of Missouri, 1971 Pp. 14–22.
19.
MacMillanD. L. Issues. In JonesR. L. (Chm.), Special education for the mildly retarded-How justifiable? Symposium presented at the International Conference of The Council for Exceptional Children, Miami Beach, April, 1971.
20.
MillerJ. G., & SchoenfelderD. S.A rational look at special class placement. Journal of Special Education, 1969, 3, 397–403.
21.
NelsonC. C., & SchmidtL. J.The question of the efficacy of special classes. Exceptional Children, 1971, 37, 381–384.
22.
RegerA., SchroederW., & UscholdD.Special education: Children with learning problems. New York: Oxford University Press, 1968.
23.
ReynoldsM. C.What is special education? In JonesR. L.(Chm.), Special education for the mildly retarded—How justifiable? Symposium presented at the International Conference of The Council for Exceptional Children, Miami Beach, April, 1971.
24.
ReynoldsM. C., & BalowB.Categories and variables in special education. Proceedings of the Conference on the Categorical/Non-Categorical Issue in Special Education. Columbia: Special Education Department, University of Missouri, 1971. Pp. 82–96.
25.
SchwartzR. H.Toward a meaningful education for the retarded adolescent. Mental Retardation, 1968, 6 (2), 34–35.
