This article refutes the claim that positive empirical findings for the "Transylvania Hypothesis" are examples of Type I errors. The author shows such a claim as unproven, unlikely, and implausible. The claim is a form of statistical guesswork that hinders the open-minded scientific inquiry that might reveal the subtle relationships between human behavior and the cosmic environment. The author points out the omissions, misrepresentations, and failures to comprehend the complexities of lunar influence. The tables are turned on critics Campbell and Beets (1978) when the author supports the possibility that negative findings are the probable result of the Type II error.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BAUER, S. F. and E. J. HORNICK (1968) "Lunar effect on mental illness: the relationship of moon phase to psychiatric emergencies."Amer. J. of Psychiatry125: 696-697.
2.
BLACKMAN, S. and D. CATALINA (1973) "The moon and the emergency room."Perceptual and Motor Skills37: 624-626.
3.
BROWN, F. A. and Y. H. PARK (1967) "Synodic monthly modulation of the diurnal rhythm of hamsters."Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine125: 712-715.
4.
CAMPBELL, D. E. and J. L. BEETS (1978) "Lunacy and the moon."Psych. Bull.85: 1123-1129.
5.
CHAPMAN, L. J. (1961) "A search for lunacy."J. of Nervous and Mental Disease132, 2: 171-174.
6.
CROOKS, C. (1977) "The shine of the moon."Arizona Magazine, March 27: 26-27.
7.
DE VOGE, S. D. and J. K. MIKAWA (1977) "Moon phases and crisis calls: a spurious relationship."Psych. Reports40: 387-390.
8.
GALE, M. (1980) Moonpower. New York: Warner.
9.
GARZINO, S. (1982) The Rhythm Factor in Human Behavior: The Challenge of Our Inner Rhythms, Clocks, and Cycles. New York: Libra.
10.
GARZINO, S. (1981a) "Moon madness."Southwest Airlines Magazine (June): 74-82.
11.
GARZINO, S. (1981b) "Case for lunar effects."Mesa Magazine4 (June): 36-37, 70-70.
12.
GELLER, S. H. and H. W. SHANNON (1976) "The moon, weather and mental hospital contacts: confirmation and explanation of the Transylvania effect."J. of Psychiatric Nursing and Mental Health Services14: 13-17.
13.
HOVERSON, E. T. (1935) "The meteorologic factor in mental disease."Amer. J. of Psychiatry92: 131-141.
14.
KELLEY, D. M. (1942) "Mania and the moon."Psychoanalytic Rev.29: 406-426.
15.
LESTER, D. , G. W. BROCKOPP, and K. PRIEBE (1969) "Association between a full moon and completed suicide."Psych. Reports25: 598.
16.
LIEBER, A. L. (1978) The Lunar Effect: Biological Tides and Human Emotions. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
17.
LIEBER, A. L. and C. R. SHERIN (1972) "Homicides and the lunar cycle: toward a theory of lunar influence on human emotional disturbance."Amer. J. of Psychiatry129: 101 -106.
18.
LILIENFELD, D. M. (1969) "Lunar effect on mental illness."Amer. J. of Psychiatry125: 1454-1454.
19.
McDANIEL, W. B. (1950) "The moon, werewolves, and medicine."Transactions and Studies of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia18: 113-122.
20.
MILLS, C. A. (1934) "Suicides and homicides and their relation to weather changes."Amer. J. of Psychiatry91: 669-677.
21.
OLIVEN, J. F. (1943) "Moonlight and nervous disorders."Amer. J. of Psychiatry99: 579-584.
22.
OSBORN, R. D. (1968) "The moon and mental hospital: an investigation of one area of folklore."J. of Psychiatric Nursing and Mental Health Services6: 88-93.
23.
OSSENKOPP, K. P. and M. D. OSSENKOPP (1973) "Self-inflicted injuries and the lunar cycle: a preliminary report."J. of Interdisciplinary Cycle Research4: 337-348.
24.
PALMER, J. D. (1975) "Biological clocks of the tidal zone."Scientific Amer.232:70-79.
25.
POKORNY, A. D. (1968) "Moon phases and mental hospital admissions."J. of Psychiatric Nursing and Mental Health Services6: 325-327.
26.
POKORNY, A. D. (1964) "Moon phase, suicide, and homicide.'"Amer. J. of Psychiatry121: 66-67.
27.
POKORNY, A. D. and J. JACHIMCZYK (1974) "The questionable relationship between homicides and the lunar cycle."Amer. J. of Psychiatry131: 827-829.
28.
SARTON, G. (1939) "Lunar influences on living things."Isis30: 495-507.
29.
SHAPIRO, J. L. , D. L. STREINER, A. L. GRAY, N. L. WILLIAMS, and C. SOBLE(1970) "The moon and mental illness: a failure to confirm the Transylvania effect."Perceptual and Motor Skills30: 827-830.
30.
STAHL, W. H. (1937) "Moon madness."Annals of Medical History9: 248-263.
31.
TASSO, J. and E. MILLER (1976) "The effects of the full moon on human behavior."J. of Psychology93: 81-83.
32.
TAYLOR. L. J. and D. D. DIESPECKER (1972) "Moon phases and suicide attempts in Australia."Psych. Reports31: 110.
33.
TRAPP, C. E. (1937) "Lunacy and the moon."Amer. J. of Psychiatry34: 339-343.
34.
WALTERS, E. , R. P. MARKLEY, and D. W. TIFFANY (1975) "Lunacy: a Type I error?"J. of Abnormal Psychology84: 715-717.
35.
WEISKOTT, G. N. (1974) "Moon phases and telephone counseling calls."Psych. Reports35: 752-754.
36.
WEISKOTT, G. N. and G. B. TIPTON (1975) "Moon phases and state hospital admissions."Psych. Reports37: 486-486.
