What Went Wrong: A Comparison of Unsuccessful and Completed Extreme Far-Right Plots in the United States

Abstract

Terrorism plots fail more often than they succeed, and while understanding why a plot comes to fruition can inform prevention strategies not considered before, it is equally important to identify the factors that most frequently lead to unsuccessful outcomes. To address this, the study draws from a situational crime prevention (SCP) framework to examine the structured opportunities of far-right plots in the United States using data from the Extremist Crime Database (ECDB). Our findings show significant variation between completed, failed, and foiled far-right plot characteristics and demonstrate that pre-incident conduct plays a major role in the commission of a crime, which subsequently has implications for both future terrorism-related research and law enforcement officials interested in informing measures to reduce the likelihood of extremist violence.

Keywords

terrorism violent extremism extreme far-right situational crime prevention

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asal

V. H.

Rethemeyer

R. K.

Anderson

Stein

Rizzo

Rozea

(2009). The softest of targets: A study on terrorist target selection. Journal of Applied Security Research, 4(3), 258–278.

Benson

M. L.

Madensen

T. D.

(2007). Situational crime prevention and white-collar crime. In Pontell

H. N.

Geis

(Eds.), International handbook of white-collar and corporate crime (pp. 609–626). Springer.

Berris

P. G.

Foster

M. A.

Gaffney

J. M.

(2021). Domestic terrorism: Overview of federal criminal law and Constitutional issues (CRS Report No. R46829). Hein Online.

Besinger

Garrison

(2021, July 20). The FBI says it thwarted a plan to kidnap Michigan’s Governor. The suspects say it was a setup. BuzzFeed News. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/kenbensinger/michigan-kidnapping-gretchen-whitmer-fbi-informant

Boba

(2009). Evil done. In Frelich

J. D.

Newman

(Eds.), Reducing terrorism through situational crime prevention: Crime prevention studies (Vol. 25, pp. 71–91). Criminal Justice Press.

Brantingham

(1984). Patterns in crime. Macmillan.

Brantingham

(2008). Crime pattern theory. In Wortley

Mazzerole

(Eds.), Environmental criminology and crime analysis (pp. 78–93). Willian Publishing.

Brantingham

P. J.

Brantingham

P. L.

(1993). Environment, routine, and situation: Toward a pattern theory of crime. Advances in Criminological Theory, 5(2), 259–294.

Carter

D. L.

Carter

J. G.

(2009). Intelligence-led policing: Conceptual and functional considerations for public policy. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 20(3), 310–325.

10.

Chermak

S. M.

Carter

McGarrell

E. F.

Drew

(2013). Law enforcement’s information sharing infrastructure: A national assessment. Police Quarterly, 16(2), 211.

11.

Clarke

R. V. G.

(1980). “Situation” crime prevention: Theory and practice. The British Journal of Criminology, 20(2), 136–147.

12.

Clarke

R. V.

(1995). Situational crime prevention. Crime and Justice, 19, 91–150.

13.

Clarke

R. V.

(2008). Situational crime prevention. In Wortley

Mazzerole

(Eds.), Environmental criminology and crime analysis (pp. 178–194). Willan Publishing.

14.

Clarke

R. V.

Cornish

(1985). Modeling offenders’ decisions: A framework for research and policy. In Tonry

Morris

(Eds.), Crime and justice: A review of research (Vol. 6., pp. 147–185). University of Chicago Press.

15.

Clarke

R. V.

Newman

G. R.

(2006). Outsmarting the terrorists. Greenwood.

16.

Clarke

R. V.

Newman

G. R.

(2007). Police and the prevention of terrorism. Policing, 1(1), 9–20.

17.

Cohen

L. E.

Felson

(1979). Social change and crime rate trends: A routine activity approach. American Sociological Review, 44(4), 588–608.

18.

Cornish

D. B.

Clarke

R. V.

(2003). Opportunities, precipitators, and criminal decisions: A reply to Wortley’s critique of situational crime prevention. Crime Prevention Studies, 16, 41–96.

19.

Cornish

D. B.

(1994). The procedural analysis of offending and its relevance for situational crime prevention. In Clarke

R. V.

(Ed.), Crime prevention studies (Vol. 3, pp. 151–196). Criminal Justice Press.

20.

Cornish

D. B.

Clarke

R. V.

(1986). The reasoning criminal. Springer-Verlag.

21.

Cornish

D. B.

Clarke

R. V.

(1987). Understanding crime displacement: An application of rational choice theory. Criminology, 25(4), 933–948.

22.

Cornish

D. B.

Clarke

R. V.

(2002). Analyzing organized crimes. In Piquero

A. R.

Tibbets

S. G.

(Eds.), Rational choice and criminal behavior: Recent research and future challenges (pp. 41–61). Routledge.

23.

Cothren

Smith

B. L.

Roberts

Damphousse

K. R.

(2008). Geospatial and temporal patterns of preparatory conduct among American terrorists. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 32, 23–41.

24.

Dahl

E. J.

(2011). The plots that failed: Intelligence lessons learned from unsuccessful terrorist attacks against the United States. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 34, 621–648.

25.

Domestic Terrorism Prevention Act of 2019, S. 894, 116^th Cong., 1^st Sess. (2019).

26.

Ekblom

(2017). Crime, situational prevention and technology: The nature of opportunity and how it evolves. In McGuire

M. R.

Holt

. (Eds.), The routledge handbook of technology, crime and justice (pp. 1–19). Routledge.

27.

Ekici

Ozkan

Celik

Maxfield

M. G.

(2008). Outsmarting terrorists in Turkey. Crime Prevention & Community Safety, 10, 126–139.

28.

Felson

Cohen

L. E.

(1980). Human ecology and crime: A routine activity approach. Human Ecology, 8(4), 389–406.

29.

Freilich

J. D.

Chermak

S. M.

(2009). Preventing deadly encounters between law enforcement and American far-rightists. Crime Prevention Studies, 25, 141–172.

30.

Freilich

J. D.

Chermak

S. M.

Belli

Gruenewald

Parkin

W. S.

(2014). Introducing the United States Extremist Crime Database (ECDB). Terrorism and Political Violence, 26(2), 372–384.

31.

Freilich

J. D.

Chermak

S. M.

Gruenewald

Parkin

W. S.

Klein

B. R.

(2019). Patterns of fatal extreme-right Crime in the United States. Perspectives on Terrorism, 12(6), 38–51.

32.

Freilich

J. D.

Chermak

S.M.

Klein

B.K.

(2020). Investigating the applicability of situational crime prevention to the public mass violence context. Criminology & Public Policy, 19, 271–293.

33.

Freilich

J. D.

Greene-Colozzi

E. A.

(2024). The ideological and theoretical positionality of situational crime prevention in criminology. Crime & Delinquency, 00(0), 1.

34.

Freilich

J. D.

Gruenewald

Mandala

(2018). Situational crime prevention and terrorism: An assessment of 10 years of research. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 30(9), 1283–1311.

35.

Gilmour

(2016). Preventing money laundering: A test of situational crime prevention. Journal of Money Laundering Control, 19(4), 376–396.

36.

Greene-Colozzi

(2022). Mitigating the harm of public mass shooting incidents through situational crime prevention (Publication No. 29259507) [Doctoral dissertation, City University of New York]. ProQuest Dissertations and Theses Global.

37.

Gruenewald

Allison-Gruenewald

Klein

(2015). Assessing the attractiveness and vulnerability of eco-terrorism targets. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 38(6), 433–455.

38.

Gruenewald

Chermak

Freilich

J. D.

(2013a). Distinguishing loner attacks from other domestic extremist violence: A comparison of far-right homicide incident and offender characteristics. Criminology & Public Policy, 12(1), 65–92.

39.

Gruenewald

Chermak

Freilich

J. D.

(2013b). Far-right lone wolf homicides in the United States. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 36(12), 1005–1024.

40.

Gruenewald

Drawve

Smith

B. L.

(2019). The situated contexts of American terrorism: A conjunctive analysis of case configurations. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 46(6), 884–901.

41.

Gruenewald

Klein

B. R.

Drawve

Smith

B. L.

Ratcliff

(2019). Suspicious preoperational activities and law enforcement interdiction of terrorist plots. Policing: An International Journal, 42(1), 89–107.

42.

Gruenewald

Klein

B. R.

Freilich

J. D.

Chermak

(2016). American jihadi terrorism: A comparison of homicides and unsuccessful plots. Terrorism and Political Violence, 31(3), 516–535.

43.

Mazerolle

(2022). Situational crime prevention (SCP) techniques to prevent and control cybercrimes: A focused systematic review. Computers & Security, 115, Article 102611.

44.

Hsu

H. Y.

Vasquez

B. E.

McDowall

(2018). A time-series analysis of terrorism: Intervention, displacement, and diffusion of benefits. Justice Quarterly, 35, 557–583.

45.

Jones

S. G.

Doxsee

Harringing

(2020). The escalating terrorism problem in the United States. Center for Strategic & International Studies. https://www.csis.org/analysis/escalating-terrorism-problem-united-states.

46.

Kleemans

E. R.

Soudijn

M. R. J.

Weenink

A. W.

(2010). Situational crime prevention and cross-border crime. In Clarke

Tilley

(Eds.), Situational prevention of organised crimes (pp. 17–34). Willan.

47.

Klein

B. R.

Gruenewald

Smith

B. L.

(2017). Opportunity, group structure, temporal patterns, and successful outcomes of far-right terrorism incidents in the United States. Crime & Delinquency, 63(10), 1224–1249.

48.

Kurland

Pires

S. F.

Marteache

(2018). The spatial pattern of redwood burl poaching and implications for prevention. Forest Policy and Economics, 94, 46–54.

49.

Legault

R. L.

Hendrickson

(2009). Weapon choice and American political violence: A comparison of terrorists and other felons in federal custody. Criminology and Public Policy, 8, 531–559.

50.

Levi

Maquire

(2004). Reducing and preventing organised crime: An evidence-based critique. Crime, Law, and Social Change, 41, 397–491.

51.

Mandala

Freilich

J. D.

(2017). Preventing successful assassination attacks by terrorists: An environmental criminology approach. Journal of Criminological Research, Policy and Practice, 3(3), 173–191.

52.

Mandala

Freilich

J. D.

(2018). Disrupting terrorist assassinations through situational crime prevention. Crime & Delinquency, 64(12), 1515–1537.

53.

Matsueda

R. L.

Kreager

D. A.

Huizinga

(2006). Deterring delinquents: A rational choice model of theft and violence. American Sociological Review, 71(1), 95–122.

54.

McCleskey

McCord

Leetz

Markey

(2007). Underlying reasons for success and failure of terrorist attacks: Selected case studies (Final report prepared for the Department of Homeland Security Science and Technology Directorate). http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a494447.pdf.

55.

McGarrell

E. F.

Freilich

J. D.

Chermak

S. M.

(2007). Intelligence-led policing as a framework for responding to terrorism. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 23(2), 142–158.

56.

Newman

G. R.

Clarke

R. V.

(2013). Superhighway robbery: Preventing e-commerce crime. Willan.

57.

Petrossian

G. A.

Clarke

R. V.

(2014). Explaining and controlling illegal commercial fishing an application of the CRAVED theft model. British Journal of Criminology, 54(1), 73–90.

58.

Pires

S. F.

Moreto

W. D.

(2011). Preventing wildlife crimes: Solutions that can overcome the ‘tragedy of the commons’. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research, 17(2), 101–124.

59.

Scrivens

Osuma

A. I.

Chermak

S. M.

Whitney

M. A.

Frank

(2023). Examining online indicators of extremism in violent right-wing extremist forums. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 46(11), 2149–2173.

60.

Shukla

R. K.

Bartgis

E. E.

(2009). Responding to clandestine methamphetamine manufacturing: A case study for situational crime prevention. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 21(3), 338–362.

61.

Smith

B. L.

(2008). A look at terrorist behavior: How they prepare, where they strike. NIJ Journal, 260, 1–6.

62.

Wortley

(2010). Critiques of situational crime prevention. In Fisher

Lab

(Eds.) Encyclopedia of victimology and crime prevention. Sage.

63.

Yang

Jen

(2017). An evaluation of displacement and diffusion effects on eco-terrorist activities after police interventions. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 34, 1103–1123.