Is There a (Pre)Trial Penalty? Assessing the Joint Impacts of Pretrial Detention and Trial Conviction on Sentencing

Abstract

This study examines the joint sentencing penalty experienced by defendants detained pretrial and convicted via jury trial. The focal concerns and cumulative disadvantage frameworks suggest these defendants are sentenced most severely because early case decisions make them appear especially culpable, dangerous, and irredeemable during later case decisions. We use propensity-score regression analyses to test this hypothesis, analyzing data on defendants processed in urban jurisdictions over two decades. Findings provide evidence of a (pre)trial penalty. Detained defendants convicted via jury trials have the highest probability of being sentenced to prison and are sentenced to the longest prison and jail terms, net of numerous controls. Moreover, detained defendants’ guilty plea discounts are generally similar in magnitude to released defendants’ trial penalties.

Keywords

pretrial detention mode of conviction sentencing disparity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alschuler

A. W.

(1976). The trial judge’s role in plea bargaining, Part I. Columbia Law Review, 76, 1059.

Bergin

Ropac

Randolph

Joseph

(2022). The initial collateral consequences of pretrial detention: Employment, residential stability, and family relationships. Social Science Research Network. https://ssrn.com/abstract=4216882

Bibas

(2004). Plea bargaining outside the shadow of trial. Harvard Law Review, 117, 2463–2547.

Blumstein

Cohen

Martin

S. E.

Tonry

M. H.

(1983). Research on sentencing: The search for reform (Vol. 1). National Academy Press. https://doi.org/10.1016/0047-2352(84)90034-5

Bureau of Justice Statistics. (2014). State court processing statistics, 1990-2009: Felony defendants in large urban counties. Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research. https://doi.org/10.3886/ICPSR02038.v5

Campbell

C. M.

Labrecque

R. M.

Weinerman

Sanchagrin

(2020). Gauging detention dosage: Assessing the impact of pretrial detention on sentencing outcomes using propensity score modeling. Journal of Criminal Justice, 70, Article 101719. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2020.101719

Chevrier

(2021). Why individuals who are held pretrial have worse case outcomes: How our reliance on cash bail degrades our criminal legal system. In Scott-Hayward

C. S.

Copp

J. E.

Demuth

(Eds.), Handbook on pretrial justice systems (Vol. 6). Routledge.

Didwania

S. H.

(2020). The immediate consequences of federal pretrial detention. American Law and Economics Review, 22(1), 24–74.

DiPrete

T. A.

Eirich

G. M.

(2006). Cumulative advantage as a mechanism for inequality: A review of theoretical and empirical developments. Annual Review of Sociology, 32(1), 271–297.

10.

Euvrard

Leclerc

(2017). Pre-trial detention and guilty pleas: Inducement or coercion? Punishment & Society, 19(5), 525–542.

11.

Freiburger

T. L.

Jordan

K. L.

Hilinski-Rosick

C. M.

(2019). A multivariate analysis of incarceration and sentence length decisions for older defendants. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 30(7), 1064–1085.

12.

Griffin

B. A.

Schuler

M. S.

Cefalu

Ayer

Godley

Greifer

Coffman

D. L.

McCaffrey

D. F.

(2023). A tutorial for propensity score weighting for moderation analysis with categorical variables: An application examining smoking disparities among sexual minority adults. Medical Care, 61(12), 836–845.

13.

Guo

Fraser

M. W.

(2014). Propensity score analysis: Statistical methods and applications (Vol.11). SAGE Publications.

14.

Heaton

(2022). The effects of misdemeanor bail reform. Quattrone Center for the Fair Administration of Justice. https://www.law.upenn.edu/live/files/12290-the-effects-of-misdemeanor-bail-reformpdf

15.

Holleran

Spohn

(2004). On the use of the total incarceration variable in sentencing research. Criminology, 42(1), 211–240.

16.

Holsinger

A. M.

(2018). Analyzing bond supervision survey data: The effects of pretrial detention on self-reported outcomes. Federal Probation, 82(2), 39–45.

17.

Huber

(2019). In the spotlight: Interpreting models for log-transformed outcomes. Stata News, 34(2).

18.

Imbens

G. W.

Wooldridge

J. M.

(2009). Recent developments in the econometrics of program evaluation. Journal of Economic Literature, 47(1), 5–86.

19.

Johnson

B. D.

(2003). Racial and ethnic disparities in sentencing departures across modes of conviction. Criminology, 41(2), 449–490.

20.

Johnson

B. D.

(2019). Trials and tribulations: The trial tax and the process of punishment. Crime and Justice, 48(1), 313–363.

21.

Johnson

(2023). Plea bargain task force report. American Bar Association. https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/publications/criminaljustice/plea-bargain-tf-report.pdf

22.

Kellough

Wortley

(2002). Remand for plea: Bail decisions and plea bargaining as commensurate decisions. The British Journal of Criminology, 42(1), 186–210.

23.

Kurlychek

M. C.

Johnson

B. D.

(2019). Cumulative disadvantage in the American criminal justice system. Annual Review of Criminology, 2, 291–319.

24.

LaFree

G. D.

(1985). Adversarial and nonadversarial justice: A comparison of guilty pleas and trials. Criminology, 23(2), 289–312.

25.

Lee

J. G.

Richardson

R. L.

(2020). Race, ethnicity, and trial avoidance: A multilevel analysis. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 31(3), 422–451.

26.

Long

J. S.

Freese

(2014). Regression models for categorical dependent variables using Stata (3rd ed.). Stata Press.

27.

Lynch

(2019). Focally concerned about focal concerns: A conceptual and methodological critique of sentencing disparities research. Justice Quarterly, 36(7), 1148–1175.

28.

Martinez

B. P.

Petersen

Omori

(2020). Time, money, and punishment: Institutional racial-ethnic inequalities in pretrial detention and case outcomes. Crime & Delinquency, 66(6–7), 837–863. https://doi.org/10.1177/0011128719881600

29.

Metcalfe

Chiricos

(2018). Race, plea, and charge reduction: An assessment of racial disparities in the plea process. Justice Quarterly, 35(2), 223–253.

30.

Mize

T. D.

(2019). Best practices for estimating, interpreting, and presenting nonlinear interaction effects. Sociological Science, 6, 81–117.

31.

National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. (2018). The trial penalty: The Sixth Amendment right to trial on the verge of extinction and how to save it. https://www.nacdl.org/getattachment/95b7f0f5-90df-4f9f-9115-520b3f58036a/the-trial-penalty-the-sixth-amendment-right-to-trial-on-the-verge-of-extinction-and-how-to-save-it.pdf

32.

Omori

(2018). “Nickel and dimed” for drug crime: Unpacking the process of cumulative racial inequality. The Sociological Quarterly, 60(2), 287–313. https://doi.org/10.1080/00380253.2018.1526049

33.

Ottone

Scott-Hayward

C. S.

(2018). Pretrial detention and the decision to impose bail in Southern California. Criminology, Criminal Justice, Law & Society, 19, 24.

34.

Peduzzi

Concato

Kemper

Holford

T. R.

Feinstein

A. R.

(1996). A simulation study of the number of events per variable in logistic regression analysis. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 49(12), 1373–1379.

35.

Petersen

(2020). Do detainees plead guilty faster? A survival analysis of pretrial detention and the timing of guilty pleas. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 31(7), 1015–1035. https://doi.org/10.1177/0887403419838020

36.

Petersen

Omori

(2020). Is the process the only punishment? Racial–ethnic disparities in lower-level courts. Law & Policy, 42(1), 56–77. https://doi.org/10.1111/lapo.12140

37.

Petersen

St. Louis

(2024). Decreased Bi-Partisan Support for Pretrial Detention in Less Serious Cases: Evidence From an Experimental Survey. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 00938548241297690.

38.

Piehl

Bushway

(2007). Measuring and explaining charge bargaining. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 23(2), 105–125.

39.

Reaves

B. A.

(2013). Felony defendants in large urban counties, 2009: Statistical tables. Bureau of Justice Statistics. https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fdluc09.pdf

40.

Rosenbaum

P. R.

Rubin

D. B.

(1985). Constructing a control group using multivariate matched sampling methods that incorporate the propensity score. The American Statistician, 39(1), 33–38.

41.

Spohn

DeLone

(2000). When does race matter? An analysis of conditions under which race affects sentence severity. In Ulmer

(Ed.), Sociology of crime, law, and deviance (Vol.2, pp. 3–37). Elsevier.

42.

St. Louis

. (2022). Bail denied or bail too high? Disentangling cumulative disadvantage by pretrial detention type. Journal of Criminal Justice, 82, Article 101971. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2022.101971

43.

St. Louis

. (2024). The pretrial detention penalty: A systematic review and meta-analysis of pretrial detention and case outcomes. Justice Quarterly, 41, 347–370. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2023.2193624

44.

St. Louis

Petersen

(2024). Political Ideology and Attitudes Toward Pretrial Justice: Exploring the Mediating Role of Racial Resentment. Justice Quarterly, 1–24. https://doi.org/ 10.1080/07418825.2024.2361719

45.

Steffensmeier

Ulmer

Kramer

(1998). The interaction of race, gender, and age in criminal sentencing: The punishment cost of being young, black, and male. Criminology, 36(4), 763–798.

46.

Sutton

J. R.

(2013). Structural bias in the sentencing of felony defendants. Social Science Research, 42(5), 1207–1221. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssresearch.2013.04.003

47.

Ulmer

J. T.

(1997). Social worlds of sentencing: Court communities under sentencing guidelines. SUNY Press.

48.

Ulmer

J. T.

(2012). Recent developments and new directions in sentencing research. Justice Quarterly, 29(1), 1–40.

49.

Ulmer

J. T.

(2019). Criminal courts as inhabited institutions: Making sense of difference and similarity in sentencing. Crime and Justice, 48(1), 483–522.

50.

Ulmer

J. T.

Silver

Hanrath

L. S.

(2023). Back to basics: A critical examination of the focal concerns framework from the perspective of judges. Justice Quarterly, 40, 813–836. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2022.2132274

51.

Wooldredge

Frank

Goulette

Travis

(2015). Is the impact of cumulative disadvantage on sentencing greater for black defendants? Criminology & Public Policy, 14(2), 187–223.

52.

McDowall

(2023). Does bail reform increase crime in New York State: Evidence from interrupted time-series analyses and synthetic control methods. Justice Quarterly, 41(3), 371–399. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2023.2209145

53.

Yip

P. S.

Tsang

E. W.

(2007). Interpreting dummy variables and their interaction effects in strategy research. Strategic Organization, 5(1), 13–30.

54.

Zane

S. N.

Pupo

J. A.

(2021). Disproportionate minority contact in the juvenile justice system: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Justice Quarterly, 38(7), 1293–1318. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2021.1915364

55.

Zottoli

T. M.

Daftary-Kapur

Winters

G. M.

Hogan

(2016). Plea discounts, time pressures, and false-guilty pleas in youth and adults who pleaded guilty to felonies in New York City. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 22(3), 250.