Should We Defund “Bad Police” or Reform “Bad Policing”? Examining Person-Centered and Act-Based Moral Evaluations of Police and Policing Policy Preferences

Abstract

Despite widespread calls to defund or reform police, little research has explored the factors shaping public support for these proposals. We draw from person-centered morality theory to argue that person-centered moral evaluations of police (moral character beliefs) drive support for defunding police, while act-based moral evaluations of police (procedural justice) drive support for reforming police. Using data from a national survey (N = 1,225), exploratory factor analyses showed that these moral evaluations of police were empirically distinct. OLS regression results indicated that perceptions of “bad police” (negative person-centered evaluations) more strongly predicted support for defunding policies (abolition and reduced funding of police), while perceptions of “bad policing” (negative act-based evaluations) more strongly predicted support for due process and racial justice reforms.

Keywords

defund police reform police person-centered morality procedural justice public perceptions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agee

C. L.

(2020). Crisis and redemption: The history of American police reform since World War II. Journal of Urban History, 46(5), 951–960.

Akbar

A. A.

(2020). An abolitionist horizon for (police) reform. California Law Review, 108, 1781–1846.

Alexander

(2010). The new Jim Crow: Mass incarceration in the age of colorblindness. The New Press.

Ansolabehere

Rivers

(2013). Cooperative survey research. Annual Review of Political Science, 16, 307–329.

Baranauskas

A. J.

(2022). Racial resentment, crime concerns, and public attitudes toward defunding the police. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 20(1), 48–72.

Beetham

(2013). The legitimation of power. Bloomsbury Publishing.

Bell

M. C.

(2017). Police reform and the dismantling of legal estrangement. The Yale Law Journal, 126(7), 2054–2150.

Bell

M. C.

Beckett

Stuart

(2020). Investing in alternatives: Three logics of criminal system replacement. UC Irvine Law Review, 11, 1291–1326.

Bittner

(1970). The functions of the police in modern society: A review of background factors, current practices, and possible role models. National Institute of Mental Health, Center for Studies of Crime and Delinquency.

10.

Cobbina-Dungy

J. E.

Jones-Brown

(2023). Too much policing: Why calls are made to defund the police. Punishment & Society, 25(1), 3–20.

11.

Dai

(2021). Training police for procedural justice: An evaluation of officer attitudes, citizen attitudes, and police-citizen interactions. The Police Journal, 94(4), 481–495.

12.

Dattalo

(2013). Analysis of multiple dependent variables. Oxford University Press.

13.

Davies

E. J.

Jackson

J. M.

Streeter

(2021). Bringing abolition in: Addressing carceral logics in social science research. Social Science Quarterly, 102(7), 3095–3102.

14.

Diphoorn

Leyh

B. M.

Slooter

(2021). Transforming police reform: Global experiences through a multidisciplinary lens. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice, 15(1), 340–347.

15.

Drakulich

Denver

(2022). The partisans and the persuadables: Public views of Black Lives Matter and the 2020 protests. Perspectives on Politics, 20(4), 1191–1208.

16.

Duxbury

S. W.

(2021). Who controls criminal law? Racial threat and the adoption of state sentencing law, 1975 to 2012. American Sociological Review, 86(1), 123–153.

17.

Enns

P. K.

Ramirez

M. D.

(2018). Privatizing punishment: Testing theories of public support for private prison and immigration detention facilities. Criminology, 56(3), 546–573.

18.

Epp

C. R.

Maynard-Moody

Haider-Markel

(2014). Pulled over: How police stops define race and citizenship. University of Chicago Press.

19.

Ferraro

K. F.

(1995). Fear of crime: Interpreting victimization risk.State University of New York Press.

20.

Fine

A. D.

Del Toro

(2022). Adolescents’ views of defunding the police, abolishing the police, and “the talk.” Journal of Community Psychology, 50(7), 2993–3005.

21.

Friess

(2022, May 24). ‘Defund the police’ is dead but other reform efforts thrive in U.S. cities. Newsweek. https://www.newsweek.com/2022/06/24/defund-police-dead-other-reform-efforts-thrive-us-cities-1709393.html

22.

Gau

J. M.

(2014). Procedural justice and police legitimacy: A test of measurement and structure. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 39(2), 187–205.

23.

Graham

Pickett

J. T.

Cullen

F. T.

(2021). Advantages of matched over unmatched opt-in samples for studying criminal justice attitudes: A research note. Crime & Delinquency, 67(12), 1962–1981.

24.

Groundwater

(2020, June 10). A brief history of ACAB. GQ. https://www.gq.com/story/history-of-acab

25.

Haidt

(2012). The righteous mind: Why good people are divided by politics and religion. Vintage.

26.

Hamlin

J. K.

Wynn

Bloom

(2007). Social evaluation by preverbal infants. Nature, 450(7169), 557–559.

27.

Hanink

P. A.

Dunbar

(2022). Protesting the police: An analysis of the correlates of support for police reform following the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests. Social Movement Studies. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/14742837.2022.2067842

28.

Headley

A. M.

Wright

J. E.

(2019). National police reform commissions: Evidence-based practices or unfulfilled promises? The Review of Black Political Economy, 46(4), 277–305.

29.

Hughes

J. S.

Harpster

R. D.

Gonzales

N. C.

(2020). The government receives moral license to commit transgressions when compared to other entities. Basic and Applied Social Psychology, 42(2), 98–114.

30.

Huq

A. Z.

Jackson

Trinkner

(2017). Legitimating practices: Revisiting the predicates of police legitimacy. British Journal of Criminology, 57(5), 1101–1122.

31.

Jackson

(2018). Norms, normativity, and the legitimacy of justice institutions: International perspectives. Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 14, 145–165.

32.

Jackson

Bradford

Hough

Myhill

Quinton

Tyler

(2012). Why do people comply with the law? Legitimacy and the influence of legal institutions. British Journal of Criminology, 52, 1051–1071.

33.

Jackson

Fine

Bradford

Trinkner

(2023). Social identity and support for defunding the police in the aftermath of George Floyd’s murder. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations, 26(4), 833–858.

34.

Kapsis

R. E.

(1978). Black ghetto diversity and anomie: A sociopolitical view. American Journal of Sociology, 83(5), 1132–1153.

35.

Kennedy

Mercer

Keeter

Hatley

McGeeney

Gimenez

(2016). Evaluating online nonprobability surveys. Pew Research. https://www.pewresearch.org/methods/2016/05/02/evaluating-online-nonprobability-surveys/

36.

Koziarski

Huey

(2021). #Defund or #Re-Fund? Re-examining Bayley’s blueprint for police reform. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 45(3), 269–284.

37.

Landy

J. F.

Uhlmann

E. L.

(2018). Morality is personal. In Gray

Graham

(Eds.), Atlas of moral psychology (pp. 121–132). Guilford Publications.

38.

Manthey

Esposito

Hernandez

(2022, October 19). Despite ‘defunding’ claims, police funding has increased in many U.S. cities. ABC7 New York. https://abc7ny.com/where-police-departments-defunded-how-does-funding-impact-crime-defund-the-budgets/12324846/

39.

McDowell

M. G.

Fernandez

L. A.

(2018). ‘Disband, disempower, and disarm’: Amplifying the theory and practice of police abolition. Critical Criminology, 26(3), 373–391.

40.

McLean

Nix

(2022). Understanding the bounds of legitimacy: Weber’s facets of legitimacy and the police empowerment hypothesis. Justice Quarterly, 39(6), 1287–1309.

41.

Morrison

(2023, July 13). Black Lives Matter movement marks 10 years of activism and renews its call to defund the police. AP News. https://apnews.com/article/black-lives-matter-10th-anniversary-trayvon-martin-c2d79ae4639934ca1eb77d6b54c16f8b

42.

Moule

R. K.

Jr. Fox

B. H.

Parry

M. M.

(2019). The long shadow of Ferguson: Legitimacy, legal cynicism, and public perceptions of police militarization. Crime & Delinquency, 65(2), 151–182.

43.

Newheiser

A. K.

Sawaoka

Dovidio

J. F.

(2012). Why do we punish groups? High entitativity promotes moral suspicion. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 48(4), 931–936.

44.

Novick

Pickett

J. T.

(2022). Black Lives Matter, protest policing, and voter support for police reform in Portland, Oregon. Race and Justice. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/21533687221117281

45.

Parry

M. M.

Moule

R. K.

Jr. Dario

L. M.

(2019). Technology-mediated exposure to police–citizen encounters: A quasi-experimental assessment of consequences for citizen perceptions. Justice Quarterly, 36(3), 412–436.

46.

Patnaude

Lomakina

C. V.

Patel

Bizel

(2021). Public emotional response on the Black Lives Matter movement in the summer of 2020 as analyzed through Twitter. International Journal of Marketing Studies, 13(1), 1–69.

47.

Pickett

J. T.

(2019). Public opinion and criminal justice policy: Theory and research. Annual Review of Criminology, 2, 405–428.

48.

Pickett

J. T.

Graham

Cullen

F. T.

(2022). The American racial divide in fear of the police. Criminology, 60(2), 291–320.

49.

Pickett

J. T.

Nix

Roche

S. P.

(2018). Testing a social schematic model of police procedural justice. Social Psychology Quarterly, 81(2), 97–125.

50.

Pickett

J. T.

Ryon

S. B.

(2017). Procedurally just cooperation: Explaining support for due process reforms in policing. Journal of Criminal Justice, 48, 9–20.

51.

Pizarro

D. A.

Tannenbaum

(2012). Bringing character back: How the motivation to evaluate character influences judgments of moral blame. In Mikulincer

Shaver

P. R.

(Eds.), The social psychology of morality: Exploring the causes of good and evil (pp. 91–108). American Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/13091-005

52.

President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. (2015). Final report of the president’s task force on 21st century policing. Office of Community Oriented Policing Services.

53.

Rai

T. S.

Diermeier

(2015). Corporations are cyborgs: Organizations elicit anger but not sympathy when they can think but cannot feel. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 126, 18–26.

54.

Rubinstein

Mays

J. C.

(2020, June 30). Nearly $1 billion is shifted from police in budget that pleases no one. New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/30/nyregion/nypd-budget.html

55.

Silver

Goff

Iceland

(2022). Social order and social justice: Moral intuitions, systemic racism beliefs, and Americans’ divergent attitudes toward Black Lives Matter and police. Criminology, 60(2), 342–369.

56.

Silver

J. R.

(2017). Moral foundations, intuitions of justice, and the intricacies of punitive sentiment. Law & Society Review, 51(2), 413–450.

57.

Silver

J. R.

(2020). Moral motives, police legitimacy and acceptance of force. Policing: An International Journal, 43(5), 799–815.

58.

Silver

J. R.

Berryessa

C. M.

(2023). Remorse, perceived offender immorality, and lay sentencing preferences. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 19(2), 425–463.

59.

Skogan

W. G.

(2006). Police and community in Chicago: A tale of three cities. Oxford University Press.

60.

Sunshine

Tyler

T. R.

(2003). The role of procedural justice and legitimacy in shaping public support for policing. Law & Society Review, 37(3), 513–548.

61.

Tang

Gray

(2023). Do companies think and feel? Mind perception of organizations. Cognitive Science, 47(8), e13320.

62.

Tankebe

(2013). Viewing things differently: The dimensions of public perceptions of police legitimacy. Criminology, 51(1), 103–135.

63.

Tannenbaum

Uhlmann

E. L.

Diermeier

(2011). Moral signals, public outrage, and immaterial harms. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 47(6), 1249–1254.

64.

Thacher

(2022). Shrinking the police footprint. Criminal Justice Ethics, 41(1), 62–85.

65.

Thacher

(2023). Two kinds of problem-solving. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice, 17, paac073.

66.

Tyler

T. R.

(2006). Why people obey the law. Princeton University Press.

67.

Uhlmann

E. L.

Pizarro

D. A.

Diermeier

(2015). A person-centered approach to moral judgment. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 10(1), 72–81.

68.

Uhlmann

E. L.

Zhu

Diermeier

(2014). When actions speak volumes: The role of inferences about moral character in outrage over racial bigotry. European Journal of Social Psychology, 44(1), 23–29.

69.

Uhlmann

E. L.

Zhu

L. L.

Tannenbaum

(2013). When it takes a bad person to do the right thing. Cognition, 126(2), 326–334.

70.

Vaughn

P. E.

Peyton

Huber

G. A.

(2022). Mass support for proposals to reshape policing depends on the implications for crime and safety. Criminology & Public Policy, 21(1), 125–146.

71.

Verhaeghen

Aikman

S. N.

(2022). Police as threat: The influence of race and the summer of Black Lives Matter on implicit and explicit attitudes towards the police. Journal of Community Psychology, 50(8), 3354–3370.

72.

Vitale

A. S.

(2017). The end of policing. Verso Books.

73.

Walker

(1993). Taming the system: The control of discretion in criminal justice, 1950-1990. Oxford University Press.

74.

Walker

(2012). Institutionalizing police accountability reforms: The problem of making police reforms endure. Saint Louis University Public Law Review, 32, 57.

75.

Weber

(1947). The theory of social and economic organization ( Henderson

A. M.

Parsons

, Trans.). The Free Press.

76.

Willis

Todorov

(2006). First impressions: Making up your mind after a 100-ms exposure to a face. Psychological Science, 17(7), 592–598.

77.

Wozniak

K. H.

Pickett

J. T.

Brown

E. K.

(2022). Judging hardworking robbers and lazy thieves: An experimental test of act-vs. person-centered punitiveness and perceived redeemability. Justice Quarterly, 39(7), 1565–1591.

78.

Zahniser

(2021, August 28). L.A. Cut the police budget, then put $47 million in overtime on the city’s credit card. Los Angeles Times. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-08-28/lapd-overtime-budget-was-slashed-now-the-city-owes-47-million-dollars

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.03 MB