The victim devaluation thesis posits that crimes against minorities are less likely to be cleared than those against White victims. Tests of the victim devaluation thesis on violent crimes are inconclusive, and either focuses on homicides or non-lethal violent crimes. Using data from the National Incident-Based Reporting System, this study estimated the effect a victim’s race has on lethal and non-lethal (rape, robbery, and aggravated assault) violent crime arrests. The results provide partial support for the victim devaluation thesis. Although non-lethal violent crimes against Blacks were less likely to be cleared than those against Whites, homicides against Blacks were more likely to be cleared than those against Whites. Further, extralegal variables and the seriousness of the crime affected arrest outcomes.
AddingtonL. A. (2006). Using national incident-based reporting system murder data to evaluate clearance predictors. Homicide Studies, 10, 140–152.
2.
AddingtonL. A. (2007). Hot vs. cold cases: Examining time to clearance for non-lethal violent crime using NIBRS data. Justice Research and Policy, 9, 87–112.
3.
AddingtonL. A. (2015). Introduction to special issue on innovative uses of NIBRS crime data to inform policy. Justice Research and Policy, 16(2), 123–128.
4.
AddingtonL. A. (2019). NIBRS as the new normal: What fully incident-based crime data mean for researchers. In Handbook on crime and deviance (pp. 21–33). Springer.
5.
AddingtonL.RennisonC. (2008). Rape co-occurrence: Do additional crimes affect victim reporting and police clearance of rape?Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 24, 205–206.
6.
AlderdenM. A.LaveryT. A. (2007). Predicting non-lethal violent crime clearances in Chicago: Investigating disparities in predictors across different types of homicide. Homicide Studies, 11(2), 115–132.
7.
AkersR. L.SellersC. S.JenningsW. G. (2021). Criminological theories: Introduction, evaluation, and application (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
8.
ApelR.NaginD. S. (2011). General deterrence: A review of recent evidence. Crime and Public Policy, 4, 411–436.
9.
BardM.ZackerJ. (1974). Assaultiveness and alcohol use in family disputes: Police perceptions. Criminology, 12(3), 281–292.
10.
BeckerG. S. (1968). Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach. Journal of Political Economy, 76(2), 169–217.
11.
BeckerG. S. (2007). Race and violent offender propensity: Does the intraracial nature of violent crime persist on the local level?Justice Research and Policy, 39, 53–86.
12.
BlackD. (1970). The production of crime rates. American Sociological Review, 35, 733–748.
13.
BlackD. (1976). The behavior of law. Academic.
14.
BradfordB.JacksonJ.HoughM. (2017). Ethnicity, group position, and police legitimacy: Early findings from the European Social Survey 1. In OberwittlerD.RochéS. (Eds.), Police–citizen relations across the world (pp. 46–72). Routledge.
BriggsS.OpsalT. (2012). The influence of victim ethnicity on arrest in violent crimes. Criminal Justice Studies, 25(2), 177–189.
17.
BrownB.BenedictW. R. (2002). Perceptions of the police: Past findings, methodological issues, conceptual issues, and policy implications. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 25, 543–580.
18.
BrunsonR. K.MillerJ. (2006). Young black men and urban policing in the United States. British Journal of Criminology, 46(4), 613–640.
19.
CarrP. J.NapolitanoL.KeatingJ. (2007). We never call the police, and here is why: A qualitative examination of legal cynicism in three Philadelphia neighborhoods. Criminology, 45, 445–480.
20.
CarterD. L.CarterJ. G. (2016). Effective police homicide investigations: Evidence from seven cities with high clearance rates. Homicide Studies, 20, 150–176.
21.
ChalfinA.McCraryJ. (2017). Criminal deterrence: A review of the literature. Journal of Economic Literature, 55(1), 5–48.
22.
ChristieN. (1986). The ideal victim. In FattahE. A. (Ed.), From crime policy to victim policy (pp. 17–30). Palgrave Macmillan.
23.
CooneyM. (1994). Evidence as partisanship. Law and Society Review, 28, 833–58.
24.
CorsianosM. (2003). Discretion in detectives’ decision-making and “high profile” cases. Police Practice & Research, 4, 301–314.
25.
CullenF. T.AgnewR.WilcoxP. (2014). Criminological theory: Past to present: Essential readings (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.
26.
D’AlessioS. J.StolzenbergL. (2003). Race and the probability of arrest. Social Forces, 81, 1381−1397.
27.
De AngelisJ.KupchikA. (2009). Ethnicity, trust, and acceptance of authority among police officers. Journal of Criminal Justice, 37(3), 273–279.
28.
EitleD.StolzenbergL.D’AlessioS. J. (2005). Police organizational factors, the racial composition of the police, and the probability of arrest. Justice Quarterly, 22, 30−57.
29.
Federal Bureau of Investigation. (2013). National incident-based reporting system user manual: Version 1.0. U.S. Department of Justice.
GarnerJ. H.MaxwellC. D.LeeJ. (2021). The specific deterrent effects of criminal sanctions for intimate partner violence: A meta-analysis. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 111, 227–271.
33.
GeberthV. J. (1996). Practical non-lethal violent crime investigation: Tactics, procedures, and forensic techniques. CRC Press.
34.
GottfredsonM. R.HindelangM. J. (1979). A study of behavior of law. American Sociological Review, 44(1), 3–18.
35.
HirschiT. (1969). Causes of delinquency. University of California Press.
36.
JarvisJ. P.RegoecziW. C. (2009). Homicides clearances: An analysis of arrest versus exceptional outcomes. Homicide Studies, 13(2), 174–188.
37.
JarvisJ. P.MancikA.RegoecziW. C. (2017). Police responses to violent crime: Reconsidering the mobilization of law. Criminal Justice Review, 42(1), 5–25.
38.
KochelT. R.WilsonD. B.MastrofskiS. D. (2011). Effect of suspect race on officers’ arrest decisions. Criminology, 49, 473–512.
39.
LaFreeG. (1989). Rape and criminal justice: The social construction of sexual assault. Wadsworth Publishing Company.
40.
LeeC. (2005). The value of life in death: Multiple regression and event history analyses of non-lethal violent crime clearance in Los Angeles County. Journal of Criminal Justice, 33(6), 527–553.
41.
LitwinK. J. (2004). A multilevel multivariate analysis of factors affecting non-lethal violent crime clearance. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 41, 327–351.
42.
LitwinK. J.XuY. (2007). The dynamic nature of non-lethal violent crime clearances: A multilevel model comparison of three time periods. Homicide Studies, 11, 94–114.
43.
LoFasoC. A. (2020). Solving homicides: The influence of neighborhood characteristics and investigator caseload. Criminal Justice Review, 45(1), 84–103.
44.
LumC. M.KoperC. S.GillC.HibdonJ.TelepC.RobinsonL. (2016). An evidence-assessment of the recommendations of the President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing: Implementation and research priorities. International Association of Chiefs of Police.
45.
LytleD. J. (2014). The effects of suspects characteristics on arrest: A meta-analysis. Journal of Criminal Justice, 42, 589–597.
46.
MarchéG. E. (1994). The production of non-lethal violent crime solutions: An empirical analysis. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 53, 385–401.
47.
McCarthyJ. (2014). Non-whites less likely to feel police protect and serve them. Gallup Poll News Service.
48.
McCormackP. D.HirschelD. (2021). Race and the likelihood of intimate partner violence arrest and dual arrest. Race and Justice, 11(4), 434–453.
49.
McEwenT.RegoecziW. (2015). Forensic evidence in homicide investigations and prosecutions. Journal of Forensic Sciences, 60(5), 1188–1198.
50.
McFarlandM. J.TaylorJ.McFarlandC. A.FriedmanK. L. (2018). Perceived unfair treatment by police, race, and telomere length: A Nashville community-based sample of black and white men. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 59(4), 585–600.
51.
McKimmieB. M.MasserB. M.BongiornoR. (2014). What counts as rape? The effect of offense prototypes, victim stereotypes, and participant gender on how the complainant and defendant are perceived. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 29(12), 2273–2303.
52.
MinhasR.WalshD. (2018). Influence of racial stereotypes on investigative decision-making in criminal investigations: A qualitative comparative analysis. Cogent Social Sciences, 4(1), 1–18.
53.
MorabitoM. S.PattavinaA.WilliamsL. M. (2019). It all just piles up: Challenges to victim credibility accumulate to influence sexual assault case processing. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 34(15), 3151–3170.
54.
MurphyK.CherneyA. (2012). Understanding cooperation with police in a diverse society. The British Journal of Criminology, 52(1), 181–201.
55.
NaginD. S. (2013). Deterrence in the twenty-first century. Crime and Justice, 42(1), 199–263.
O’NealE. N.BeckmanL. O.CassiaS. (2019). The sexual stratification hypothesis: Is the decision to arrest influenced by the suspect/victim racial/ethnic dyad?Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 34(6), 1287–1310.
58.
OuseyG. C.LeeM. R. (2010). To know the unknown: The decline in non-lethal violent crime clearance rates, 1980 –2000. Criminal Justice Review, 35, 141–158.
59.
PampelF. C. (2020). Logistic regression: A primer (Vol. 132). Sage publications.
60.
PhillipsS.SteidleyT. (2020). A systematic lottery: The Texas death penalty, 1976 to 2016. Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 51(3).
61.
PickettJ. T.GrahamA.CullenF. T. (2021). The American racial divide in fear of the police. Criminology, 60(2), 291–320.
62.
PuckettJ. L.LundmanR. J. (2003). Factors affecting non-lethal violent crime clearances: Multivariate analysis of a more complete conceptual framework. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 40, 171–193.
63.
RegoecziW. C.JarvisJ. P. (2013). Beyond the social production of non-lethal violent crime rates: Extending social disorganization theory to explain non-lethal violent crime case outcomes. Justice Quarterly, 30, 983–1014.
64.
RegoecziW. C.JarvisJ. P.RiedelM. (2008). Clearing murders: Is it about time?Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 45, 142–162.
65.
RegoecziW. C.KennedyL.W.SilvermanR. A. (2000). Uncleared homicides: A Canada/United States comparison. Homicide Studies, 4, 135−161.
66.
RiedelM. (2008). Homicide arrest clearances: A review of the literature. Sociology Compass, 2, 1145–1164.
67.
RiedelM.JarvisJ. P. (1998). The decline of arrest clearances for criminal homicide: Causes, correlates, and third parties. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 9, 279–305.
68.
RiedelM.RinehartT. A. (1996). Murder clearances and missing data. Journal of Crime and Justice, 19(2), 83–102.
69.
RobertsA. (2007). Predictors of non-lethal violent crime clearance by arrest: An event history analysis of National Incident Based Reporting System (NIBRS) incidents. Homicide Studies, 11, 82–93.
70.
RobertsA. (2008). The influences of incident and contextual characteristics on crime clearance of nonlethal violence: A multilevel event history analysis. Journal of Criminal Justice, 36(1), 61–71.
71.
RobertsA. (2009). Contribution of the National Incident-Based Reporting System to substantive knowledge in criminology: A review of research. Sociology Compass, 3, 433–458.
72.
RobertsA.LyonsC. J. (2009). Victim-offender racial dyads and clearance of lethal and nonlethal assault. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 46(3), 301–326.
73.
RobertsA.LyonsC. J. (2011). Hispanic victims and homicide clearance by arrest. Homicide Studies, 15(1), 48–73.
74.
RydbergJ.PizarroJ. M. (2014). Victim lifestyle as a correlate of homicide clearance. Homicide Studies, 18(4), 342–362.
75.
ShermanL. W. (1980). Causes of police behavior: The current state of quantitative research. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 17(1), 69–100.
76.
ShermanL. W.BerkR. A. (1984). The specific deterrent effects of arrest for domestic assault. American Sociological Review, 49(2), 261–272.
77.
SnyderH. N. (1999). The overrepresentation of juvenile crime proportions in robbery clearance statistics. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 15, 151−161.
78.
StaceyM.MartinK. H.BrickB. T. (2017). Victim and suspect race and the police clearance of sexual assault. Race and Justice, 7(3), 226–255.
79.
SteffensmeierD.Painter-DavisN.UlmerJ. (2017). Intersectionality of race, ethnicity, gender, and age on criminal punishment. Sociological Perspectives, 60(4), 810–833.
80.
TabachnickB. G.FidellL. S. (2001). Using multivariate statistics. (4th ed.). Allyn and Bacon.
81.
TatumK. M.PenceR. (2015). Factors that affect the arrest decision in domestic violence cases. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 38(1), 56−70.
82.
TaylorT. J.HolleranD.TopalliV. (2009). Racial bias in case processing: Does victim race affect police clearance of violent crime incidents?Justice Quarterly, 26(3), 562−591.
83.
TerranovaV. A.VandiverD. M.StaffordM. C. (2021). Likelihood of arrest for robberies, assaults, and sexual offenses committed by group and lone offenders. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 36(19–20), 106–131.
84.
TrusslerT. (2010). Explaining the changing nature of non-lethal violent crime clearance in Canada. International Criminal Justice Review, 20, 366–383.
85.
TurkA. T. (1969). Criminality and legal order. Rand-McNally.
86.
TylerT. R. (2006). Restorative justice and procedural justice: Dealing with rule-breaking. Journal of Social Issues, 62(2), 307–326.
VaughnP. E. (2020). The effects of devaluation and solvability on crime clearance. Journal of Criminal Justice, 68, 1−15.
89.
WeisburdD.MastrofskiS. D.McNallyA. M.GreenspanR.WillisJ. J. (2003). Reforming to preserve: Compstat and strategic problem solving in American policing. Criminology & Public Policy, 2(3), 421–456.
90.
WeitzerR. (2010). Race and policing in different ecological contexts. In RiceS. K.WhiteM. D. (Eds.), Race, ethnicity, and policing: New and essential readings (pp. 118–139). New York University Press.
