Examining the Relationship Between Cognitive Ability and Arrest Using a Differential Offenses Hypothesis: Evidence of Inconsistent Mediation

Abstract

The current study assessed the role of differential offense category involvement in the link between cognitive ability and arrest. Using structural equation modeling, the current study relied on data from the Pathways (n = 1,354) and Add Health (n = 3,605) to address three research questions on the differential etiology of offending category (aggressive and property), the mediating effects of disaggregated offending on the relationship between IQ and arrest, and how those effects vary across samples. The results suggested the negative association between IQ and arrest masked more complex processes encompassing opposing indirect paths through aggressive (negative) and property (positive) offending, suggesting inconsistent mediation. As a result, the total indirect effect of IQ on arrest through offending was suppressed when an aggregated offending measure was used, highlighting the value of disaggregating offending categories.

Keywords

aggression arrest disaggregated offending inconsistent mediation intelligence IQ

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altikriti

(2021). Toward integrated processual theories of crime: Assessing the developmental effects of executive function, self-control, and decision-making on offending. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 48, 215–233.

Andrews

D. A.

Dowden

(2007). The risk–need–responsivity model of assessment and human service in prevention and corrections: crime-prevention jurisprudence. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 49(4), 439–464.

Barker

E. D.

Séguin

J. R.

White

H. R.

Bates

M. E.

Lacourse

Carbonneau

Tremblay

R. E.

(2007). Developmental trajectories of male physical violence and theft: Relations to neurocognitive performance. Archives of General Psychiatry, 64, 592–599.

Barnes

J. C.

(2014). Catching the really bad guys: An assessment of the efficacy of the U.S. Criminal justice system. Criminal Justice Journal, 42, 338–346.

Batty

G. D.

Deary

I. J.

Gottfredson

L. S.

(2007). Premorbid (early life) IQ and later mortality risk: Systematic review. Annals of Epidemiology, 17, 278–288.

Baumer

E. P.

Lauritsen

J. L.

(2010). Reporting crime to the police, 1973-2005: A multivariate analysis of long-term trends in the National Crime Survey (NCS) and National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS). Criminology, 48, 131–185.

Beaver

K. M.

Schwartz

J. A.

Nedelec

J. L.

Connolly

E. J.

Boutwell

B. B.

Barnes

J. C.

(2013). Intelligence is associated with criminal justice processing: Arrest through incarceration. Intelligence, 41, 277–288.

Bernat

E. M.

Hall

J. R.

Steffen

B. V.

Patrick

C. J.

(2007). Violent offending predicts P300 amplitude. International Journal of Psychophysiology, 66, 161–167.

Boccio

C. M.

Beaver

K. M.

Schwartz

J. A.

(2018). The role of verbal intelligence in becoming a successful criminal: Results from a longitudinal sample. Intelligence, 66, 24–31.

10.

Brown

(2006). Confirmatory factor analysis for applied research. Guildford.

11.

Dohmen

Falk

Huffman

Sunde

(2018). On the relationship between cognitive ability and risk preference. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 32, 115–134.

12.

Dunn

L. M.

Dunn

L. M.

(1981). Peabody picture vocabulary test-revised. American Guidance Service, Inc.

13.

Farrington

D. P.

(1998). Predictors, causes, and correlates of male youth violence. Crime and Justice, 24, 421–475.

14.

Federal Bureau of Investigation. (2017). 2017 crime in the United States: Clearances. FBI Uniform Crime Reporting. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2017/crime-in-the-u.s.-2017/topic-pages/clearances.

15.

Firebaugh

(2018). Seven rules for social research. Princeton University Press.

16.

Gendreau

Little

Goggin

(1996). A meta-analysis of the predictors of adult offender recidivism: What works! Criminology, 34, 575–608.

17.

Harris

K. M.

Halpern

C. T.

Whitsel

Hussey

Tabor

Entzel

Udry

J. R.

(2009). The national longitudinal study of adolescent to adult health: Research design.

18.

Herrnstein

R. J.

Murray

(1994). The bell curve: Intelligence and class structure in American life. Free Press.

19.

Hirschi

Hindelang

M. J.

(1977). Intelligence and delinquency: A revisionist review. American Sociological Review, 42, 571–587.

20.

Huizinga

Esbensen

F. A.

Weiher

A. W.

(1991). Are there multiple paths to delinquency? The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 82, 83–118.

21.

Bentler

P. M.

(1999). Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis: Conventional criteria versus new alternatives. Structural Equation Modeling A Multidisciplinary Journal, 6, 1–55.

22.

Juhn

Y. J.

Beebe

T. J.

Finnie

D. M.

Sloan

Wheeler

P. H.

Yawn

Williams

A. R.

(2011). Development and initial testing of a new socioeconomic status measure based on housing data. Journal of Urban Health, 88, 933–944.

23.

Lie

S. A.

Tveito

T. H.

Reme

S. E.

Eriksen

H. R.

(2017). IQ and mental health are vital predictors of work drop out and early mortality. Multi-state analyses of Norwegian male conscripts. PLoS One, 12, e0180737.

24.

MacKinnon

D. P.

Fairchild

A. J.

Fritz

M. S.

(2007). Mediation Analysis. Annual Review of Psychology, 58, 593–614.

25.

McCrimmon

A. W.

Smith

A. D.

(2013). Review of the Wechsler abbreviated scale of intelligence, second edition (WASI-II). Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment, 31, 337–341.

26.

Mcgeehan

Ndip

Mcgill

R. J.

(2017). Exploring the multidimensional structure of the WASI-II: Further insights from Schmid-Leiman higher-order and exploratory bifactor solutions. Archives of Assessment Psychology, 7, 7–27.

27.

McGloin

J. M.

Pratt

T. C.

(2003). Cognitive ability and delinquent behavior among inner-city youth: A life-course analysis of main, mediating and interaction effects. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 47, 253–271.

28.

McGloin

J. M.

Pratt

T. C.

Maahs

(2004). Rethinking the IQ-delinquency relationship: A longitudinal analysis of multiple theoretical models. Justice Quarterly, 21, 603–635.

29.

Mears

D. P.

Cochran

J. C.

(2013). What is the effect of IQ on offending? Criminal Justice and Behavior, 40, 1280–1300.

30.

Moffitt

T. E.

(1993). Adolescence-limited and life-course-persistent antisocial behavior: A developmental taxonomy. Psychological Review, 100, 674–701.

31.

Moffitt

T. E.

Gabrielli

W. F.

Mednick

S. A.

Schulsinger

(1981). Socioeconomic status, IQ, and delinquency. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 90, 152–156.

32.

Mulvey

E. P.

Schubert

C. A.

Piquero

(2014). Pathways to desistance: Final technical report. National Institute of Justice.

33.

Nagin

D. S.

Paternoster

(1993). Enduring individual differences and rational choice theories of crime. Law & Society Review, 27, 467–496.

34.

Piquero

Tibbetts

(1996). Specifying the direct and indirect effects of low self-control and situational factors in offenders’ decision making: Toward a more complete model of rational offending. Justice Quarterly, 13, 481–510.

35.

Piquero

A. R.

Farrington

D. P.

Blumstein

(2007). Key issues in criminal career research: New analyses of the cambridge study in delinquent development. Cambridge University Press.

36.

Piquero

A. R.

Schubert

C. A.

Brame

(2014). Comparing official and self-report records of offending across gender and race/ethnicity in a longitudinal study of serious youthful offenders. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 51, 526–556.

37.

Protzko

(2015). The environment in raising early intelligence: A meta-analysis of the fadeout effect. Intelligence, 53, 202–210.

38.

Pyrooz

D. C.

Gartner

Smith

(2017). Consequences of incarceration for gang membership: A longitudinal study of serious offenders in Philadelphia and Phoenix. Criminology, 55, 273–306.

39.

Raine

Moffitt

T. E.

Caspi

Loeber

Stouthamer-Loeber

Lynam

(2005). Neurocognitive impairments in boys on the life-course persistent antisocial path. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 114, 38–49.

40.

Reitan

Wolfson

(1986). The Halstead-Reitan neuropsychological test battery. In Wedding

MacNeill

H. A. J.

Webster

(Eds.), The neuropsychology handbook: Behavioral and clinical perspectives (pp. 251–279). Springer.

41.

Rosseel

(2012). lavaan: AnRPackage for structural equation modeling. Journal of Statistical Software, 48, 1–36.

42.

Savage

Ferguson

C. J.

Flores

(2017). The effect of academic achievement on aggression and violent behavior: A meta-analysis. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 37, 91–101.

43.

Savage

Wozniak

K. H.

(2016). Thugs and thieves: The differential etiology of violence. Oxford University Press.

44.

Schwartz

J. A.

Beaver

K. M.

(2019). A longitudinal examination of the association between intelligence and rearrest using a latent trait–state–occasion modeling approach in a sample of previously adjudicated youth. Developmental Psychology, 55, 2678–2691.

45.

Schwartz

J. A.

Savolainen

Aaltonen

Merikukka

Paananen

Gissler

(2015). Intelligence and criminal behavior in a total birth cohort: An examination of functional form, dimensions of intelligence, and the nature of offending. Intelligence, 51, 109–118.

46.

Silver

I. A.

(2019). Linear and non-linear: An exploration of the variation in the functional form of verbal IQ and antisocial behavior as adolescents age into adulthood. Intelligence, 76, 101375.

47.

Silver

I. A.

Nedelec

J. L.

Pompoco

(2020). Specific responsivity: An assessment of the effect of verbal and math cognitive abilities on the completion of prison programs. Corrections, 5, 130–148.

48.

Simos

P. G.

Kasselimis

Mouzaki

(2011). Age, gender, and education effects on vocabulary measures in Greek. Aphasiology, 25, 475–491.

49.

Stadler

Becker

Gödker

Leutner

Greiff

(2015). Complex problem solving and intelligence: A meta-analysis. Intelligence, 53, 92–101.

50.

Stekhoven

D. J.

Bühlmann

(2012). MissForest–non-parametric missing value imputation for mixed-type data. Bioinformatics, 28, 112–118.

51.

Sweeten

(2012). Scaling criminal offending. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 28, 533–557.

52.

Taxman

F. S.

Pattavina

Caudy

M. S.

Byrne

Durso

(2013). The empirical basis for the RNR model with an updated RNR conceptual framework. In Taxman

F. S.

Pattavina

(Eds.), In Simulation strategies to reduce recidivism (pp. 73–111). Springer.

53.

Waljee

A. K.

Mukherjee

Singal

A. G.

Zhang

Warren

Balis

Marrero

Zhu

Higgins

P. D.

(2013). Comparison of imputation methods for missing laboratory data in medicine. BMJ Open, 3, e002847–7.

54.

Walsh

(1987). Cognitive functioning and delinquency: Property versus violent offenses. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 31, 285–289.

55.

Wechsler

(1999). Manual for the Wechsler abbreviated intelligence scale (WASI). The Psychological Corporation.

56.

Weinberger

D. A.

Schwartz

G. E.

(1990). Distress and restraint as superordinate dimensions of self-reported adjustment: A typological perspective. Journal of Personality, 58, 381–417.

57.

West

D. J.

Farrington

D. P.

(1973). Who becomes delinquent? Second report of the cambridge study in delinquent development. Who becomes delinquent? Second report of the cambridge study in delinquent development. Heinemann.

58.

Wolfgang

M. E.

Figlio

R. M.

Sellin

(1972). Delinquency in a birth cohort. University of Chicago Press.

59.

Yun

Lee

(2013). IQ and delinquency: The differential detection hypothesis revisited. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 11, 196–211.

60.

Zaboski

B. A.

2nd Kranzler

J. H.

Gage

N. A.

(2018). Meta-analysis of the relationship between academic achievement and broad abilities of the Cattell-horn-Carroll theory. Journal of School Psychology, 71, 42–56.