Public Opinion on Criminal Records and Employment: A Test of Competing Theoretical Models

Abstract

Much prior research has examined the sources of individuals’ attitudes toward the application of punishment via the justice system. Some findings from this literature suggest that punitive attitudes are expressive, retributive, and closely connected to racial resentment. Other research, however, emphasizes that these sentiments are instrumental, utilitarian, and associated with the management of perceived risk. To date, little research has explored public attitudes regarding employment as a reentry barrier, and it is unclear which of these perspectives is more salient for understanding support for employers’ use of criminal records in hiring decision-making. Using survey data on a national sample of American adults (N = 1,202), the current study finds stronger support for an instrumental model than an expressive model.

Keywords

public opinion employment reentry punishment attitudes

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Applegate

B. K.

Cullen

F. T.

Turner

M. G.

Sundt

J. L.

(1996). Assessing public support for three-strikes-and-you’re-out laws: Global versus specific attitudes. Crime & Delinquency, 42, 517-534.

Baker

Brick

J. M.

Bates

N. A.

Battaglia

Couper

M. P.

Dever

J. A.

. . .Tourangeau

(2013). Summary report of the AAPOR task force on non-probability sampling. Journal of Survey Statistics and Methodology, 1, 90-143.

Baker

Falco Metcalfe

Berenblum

Aviv

Gertz

(2015). Examining public preferences for the allocation of resources to rehabilitative versus punitive crime policies. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 26, 448-462.

Barkan

S. E.

Cohn

S. F.

(2005). Why whites favor spending more money to fight crime: The role of racial prejudice. Social Problems, 52, 300-314.

Baumer

E. P.

Martin

K. H.

(2013). Social organization, collective sentiment, and legal sanctions in murder cases. American Journal of Sociology, 119, 131-182.

Baumer

E. P.

Messner

S. F.

Rosenfeld

(2003). Explaining spatial variation in support for capital punishment: A multilevel analysis. American Journal of Sociology, 108, 844-875.

Beckett

Sasson

(2000). The politics of injustice: Crime and punishment in America. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.

Bentham

(1962). Principles of penal law. In Bowring

(Ed.), The works of Jeremy Bentham (p. 396). Edinburgh, UK: W. Tait. (Original work published 1843)

Bohm

R. M.

(1992). Retribution and capital punishment: Toward a better understanding of death penalty opinion. Journal of Criminal Justice, 23, 227-236.

10.

Bottoms

A. E.

(1995). The philosophy and politics of punishment and sentencing. In Clarkson

Morgan

(Eds.), The politics of sentencing reform (pp. 17-49). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

11.

Brame

Bushway

S. D.

Paternoster

Turner

M. G.

(2014). Demographic patterns of cumulative arrest prevalence by ages 18 and 23. Crime & Delinquency, 60, 471-486.

12.

Brown

E. K.

Socia

K. M.

(2017). Twenty-first century punitiveness: Social sources of punitive American views reconsidered. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 33, 935-959.

13.

Carlsmith

K. M.

(2006). The roles of retribution and utility in determining punishment. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 42, 437-451.

14.

Carlsmith

K. M.

(2008). On justifying punishment: The discrepancy between words and actions. Social Justice Research, 21, 119-137.

15.

Carlsmith

K. M.

Darley

J. M.

(2008). Psychological aspects of retributive justice. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 40, 193-236.

16.

Carlsmith

K. M.

Darley

J. M.

Robinson

P. H.

(2002). Why do we punish? Deterrence and just deserts as motives for punishment. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83, 284-299.

17.

Chiricos

Barrick

Bales

Bontrager

(2007). The labeling of convicted felons and its consequences for recidivism. Criminology, 45, 547-581.

18.

Chiricos

Welch

Gertz

(2004). Racial typification of crime and support for punitive measures. Criminology, 42, 358-390.

19.

Chiu

C. Y.

Dweck

C. S.

Tong

J. Y. Y.

J. H. Y.

(1997). Implicit theories and conceptions of morality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73, 923-940.

20.

Chiu

C. Y.

Hong

Y. Y.

Dweck

C. S.

(1997). Lay dispositionism and implicit theories of personality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73, 19-30.

21.

Costelloe

M. T.

Chiricos

Gertz

(2009). Punitive attitudes toward criminals: Exploring the relevance of crime salience and economic insecurity. Punishment & Society, 11, 25-49.

22.

Cullen

F. T.

Fisher

B. S.

Applegate

B. K.

(2000). Public opinion about punishment and corrections. Crime and Justice, 27, 1-79.

23.

Darley

J. M.

Carlsmith

K. M.

Robinson

P. H.

(2000). Incapacitation and just deserts as motives for punishment. Law and Human Behavior, 24, 659-683.

24.

Dawson-Edwards

(2008). Enfranchising convicted felons: Current research on opinions towards felon voting rights. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 46,13-29.

25.

Denver

Pickett

J. T.

Bushway

S. D.

(2017). The language of stigmatization and the mark of violence: Experimental evidence on the social construction and use of criminal record stigma. Criminology, 55, 664-690.

26.

Denver

Pickett

J. T.

Bushway

S. D.

(2018). Criminal records and employment: A survey of experiences and attitudes in the United States. Justice Quarterly, 35, 584-613.

27.

Denver

Siwach

Bushway

S. D.

(2017). A new look at the employment and recidivism relationship through the lens of a criminal background check. Criminology, 55, 174-204.

28.

Dum

C. P.

Socia

K. M.

Rydberg

(2017). Public support for emergency shelter housing interventions concerning stigmatized populations: Results from a factorial survey. Criminology & Public Policy, 16, 835-877.

29.

Durkheim

(1982). The rules of sociological method. New York, NY: The Free Press. (Original work published 1895)

30.

Durkheim

(1997). The division of labor in society. New York, NY: The Free Press. (Original work published 1893)

31.

Edwards

E. R.

Mottarella

(2015). Perceptions of the previously convicted: The influence of conviction type and therapy participation. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 59, 1358-1377.

32.

Elliott

M. R.

Valliant

(2017). Inference for nonprobability samples. Statistical Science, 32, 249-264.

33.

Enns

P. K.

(2014). The public’s increasing punitiveness and its influence on mass incarceration in the United States. American Journal of Political Science, 58, 857-872.

34.

Enns

P. K.

Ramirez

M. D.

(2018). Privatizing punishment: Testing theories of public support for private prison and immigration detention facilities. Criminology, 56, 546-573.

35.

Finckenauer

J. O.

(1988). Public support for the death penalty: Retribution as just deserts or retribution as revenge? Justice Quarterly, 5, 81-100.

36.

Garland

Wodahl

Cota

(2016). Measuring public support for prisoner reentry options. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 60, 1406-1424.

37.

Garland

Wodahl

Schuhmann

(2013). Value conflict and public opinion toward prisoner reentry initiatives. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 24, 27-48.

38.

Garland

Wodahl

Smith

R. G.

(2017). Religious beliefs and public support for prisoner reentry. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 28, 879-895.

39.

Garland

(2001). The culture of control. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

40.

Gerber

M. M.

Jackson

(2013). Retribution as revenge and retribution as just deserts. Social Justice Research, 26, 61-80.

41.

Giguere

Dundes

(2002). Help wanted: A survey of employer concerns about hiring ex-convicts. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 13, 396-408.

42.

Hardcastle

Bartholomew

Graffam

(2011). Legislative and community support for offender reintegration in Victoria. Deakin Law Review, 16, 111-132.

43.

Henry

P. J.

Sears

D. O.

(2002). The symbolic racism 2000 scale. Political Psychology, 23, 253-283.

44.

Heumann

Pinaire

B. K.

Clark

(2005). Beyond the sentence: Public perceptions of collateral consequences for felony offenders. Criminal Law Bulletin, 41, 24-46.

45.

Hirschfield

P. J.

Piquero

A. R.

(2010). Normalization and legitimation: Modeling stigmatizing attitudes toward ex-offenders. Criminology, 48, 27-55.

46.

Hogan

M. J.

Chiricos

Gertz

(2005). Economic insecurity, blame, and punitive attitudes. Justice Quarterly, 22, 392-412.

47.

Immerwahr

Johnson

(2002). The revolving door: Exploring public attitudes toward prisoner reentry. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press.

48.

Jacobs

J. B.

(2015). The eternal criminal record. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

49.

Johnson

(2001). Punitive attitudes on crime: Economic insecurity, racial prejudice, or both? Sociological Focus, 34, 33-54.

50.

Kaeble

Cowhig

(2018). Correctional populations in the United States, 2016 (NCJ 251211). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics.

51.

Kant

(1952). The science of right. In Hutchins

(Ed.), Great books of the Western world (pp. 397-446). Edinburgh, UK: T & T Clark. (Original work published 1790)

52.

Kelly

N. J.

Enns

P. K.

(2010). Inequality and the dynamics of public opinion: The self-reinforcing link between economic inequality and mass preferences. American Journal of Political Science, 54, 855-870.

53.

King

Maruna

(2009). Is a conservative just a liberal who has been mugged? Exploring the origins of punitive views. Punishment & Society, 11, 147-169.

54.

King

R. D.

Wheelock

(2007). Group threat and social control: Race, perceptions of minorities and the desire to punish. Social Forces, 85, 1255-1280.

55.

Kleck

Jackson

D. B.

(2017). Does crime cause punitiveness? Crime & Delinquency, 63, 1572-1599.

56.

Krisberg

Marchionna

(2006). Attitudes of U.S. voters toward prisoner rehabilitation and reentry policies. Oakland, CA: National Council on Crime and Delinquency.

57.

Kurlychek

M. C.

Brame

Bushway

S. D.

(2006). Scarlet letters and recidivism: Does an old criminal record predict future offending? Criminology & Public Policy, 5, 483-504.

58.

Lageson

S. E.

(2016). Found out and opting out: The consequences of online criminal records for families. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 665, 127-141.

59.

Lageson

S. E.

Denver

Pickett

J. T.

(2018). Privatizing criminal stigma: Experience, intergroup contact, and public views about publicizing arrest records. Punishment & Society, 21, 315-341. doi:10.1177/1462474518772040

60.

Laub

J. H.

Sampson

R. J.

(2001). Understanding desistance from crime. Crime and Justice, 28, 1-69.

61.

LeBel

T. P.

(2008). Perceptions of and responses to stigma. Sociology Compass, 2, 409-432.

62.

Lee

Valliant

(2009). Estimation for volunteer panel web surveys using propensity score adjustment and calibration adjustment. Sociological Methods & Research, 37, 319-343.

63.

Lehmann

P. S.

Pickett

J. T.

(2017). Experience versus expectation: Economic insecurity, the Great Recession, and support for the death penalty. Justice Quarterly, 34, 873-902.

64.

Leverentz

(2011). Neighborhood context of attitudes toward crime and reentry. Punishment & Society, 13, 64-92.

65.

Liberman

(2006). An eye for an eye: Public support for war against evildoers. International Organization, 60, 687-722.

66.

Liberman

(2013). Retributive support for international punishment and torture. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 57, 285-306.

67.

Loeffler

C. E.

(2013). Does imprisonment alter the life course? Evidence on crime and employment from a natural experiment. Criminology, 51, 137-166.

68.

Lukies

Graffam

Shinkfield

A. J.

(2011). The effect of organisational context variables on employer attitudes toward employability of ex-offenders. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 55, 460-475.

69.

Mancini

Mears

D. P.

(2010). To execute or not to execute? Examining public support for capital punishment of sex offenders. Journal of Criminal Justice, 38, 959-968.

70.

Manza

Brooks

Uggen

(2004). Public attitudes toward felon disenfranchisement in the United States. Public Opinion Quarterly, 68, 275-286.

71.

Maruna

King

(2009). Once a criminal, always a criminal? “Redeemability” and the psychology of punitive public attitudes. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research, 15, 7-24.

72.

Matsueda

R. L.

(1992). Reflected appraisals, parental labeling, and delinquency: Specifying a symbolic interactionist theory. American Journal of Sociology, 97, 1577-1611.

73.

Matsueda

R. L.

(2014). The natural history of labeling theory. In Farrington

D. P.

Murray

(Eds.), Labeling theory: Empirical tests (pp. 13-44). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.

74.

Mears

D. P.

Cochran

J. C.

(2014). Prisoner reentry in the era of mass incarceration. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

75.

Mears

D. P.

Pickett

J. T.

Mancini

(2015). Support for balanced juvenile justice: Assessing views about youth, rehabilitation, and punishment. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 31, 459-479.

76.

Mears

D. P.

Stewart

E. A.

Warren

P. Y.

Craig

M. O.

Arnio

A. N.

(2019). A legacy of lynchings: Perceived Black criminal threat among Whites. Law & Society Review, 53, 487-517.

77.

Mercer

A. W.

Kreuter

Keeter

Stuart

E. A.

(2017). Theory and practice in nonprobability surveys: Parallels between causal inference and survey inference. Public Opinion Quarterly, 81, 250-271.

78.

Messner

S. F.

Baumer

E. P.

Rosenfeld

(2006). Distrust of government, the vigilante tradition, and support for capital punishment. Law & Society Review, 40, 559-590.

79.

Metcalfe

Pickett

J. T.

Mancini

(2015). Using path analysis to explain racialized support for punitive delinquency policies. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 31, 699-725.

80.

Mill

J. S.

(1998). In Crisp

(Ed.), Utilitarianism . New York, NY: Oxford University Press. (Original work published 1861)

81.

Moon

M. M.

Sundt

J. L.

Cullen

F. T.

Wright

J. P.

(2000). Is child saving dead? Public support for juvenile rehabilitation. Crime & Delinquency, 46, 38-60.

82.

Nagin

D. S.

Piquero

A. R.

Scott

E. S.

Steinberg

(2006). Public preferences for rehabilitation versus incarceration of juvenile offenders: Evidence from a contingent valuation survey. Criminology & Public Policy, 5, 627-651.

83.

Nicholson-Crotty

Peterson

D. A.

Ramirez

M. D.

(2009). Dynamic representation(s): Federal criminal justice policy and an alternative dimension of public mood. Political Behavior, 31, 629-655.

84.

Ouellette

H. M.

Applegate

B. K.

Vuk

(2017). The public’s stance on prisoner reentry: Policy support and personal acceptance. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 42, 768-789.

85.

Ousey

G. C.

Unnever

J. D.

(2012). Racial-ethnic threat, out-group intolerance, and support for punishing criminals: A cross-national study. Criminology, 50, 565-603.

86.

Pager

(2003). The mark of a criminal record. American Journal of Sociology, 108, 937-975.

87.

Pager

(2007). Marked: Race, crime, and finding work in an era of mass incarceration. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

88.

Pickett

J. T.

(2016). Reintegrative populism: Public opinion and the criminology of downsizing. Criminology & Public Policy, 15, 131-135.

89.

Pickett

J. T.

(2019). Public opinion and criminal justice policy: Theory and research. Annual Review of Criminology, 2, 405-428.

90.

Pickett

J. T.

Baker

(2017). Punishment and solidarity? An experimental test of the educative-moralizing effects of legal sanctions. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 13, 217-240.

91.

Pickett

J. T.

Baker

Metcalfe

Gertz

Bellandi

(2014). Contact and compromise: Explaining support for conciliatory measures in the context of violent intergroup conflict. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 51,585-619.

92.

Pickett

J. T.

Chiricos

(2012). Controlling other people’s children: Racialized views of delinquency and Whites’ punitive attitudes toward juvenile offenders. Criminology, 50, 673-710.

93.

Pickett

J. T.

Mancini

Mears

D. P.

(2013). Vulnerable victims, monstrous offenders, and unmanageable risk: Explaining public opinion on the social control of sex crime. Criminology, 51, 729-759.

94.

Pinaire

B. K.

Heumann

Bilotta

(2003). Barred from the vote: Public attitudes toward the disenfranchisement of felons. Fordham Urban Law Journal, 30, 1519-1550.

95.

Piquero

A. R.

Steinberg

(2010). Public preferences for rehabilitation versus incarceration of juvenile offenders. Journal of Criminal Justice, 38, 1-6.

96.

Rade

C. B.

Desmarais

S. L.

Burnette

J. L.

(2018). An integrative theoretical model of public support for ex-offender reentry. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 62, 2131-2152.

97.

Rade

C. B.

Desmarais

S. L.

Mitchell

R. E.

(2016). A meta-analysis of public attitudes toward ex-offenders. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 43, 1260-1280.

98.

Ramirez

M. D.

(2013). Punitive sentiment. Criminology, 51, 329-364.

99.

Restivo

Lanier

M. M.

(2015). Measuring the contextual effects and mitigating factors of labeling theory. Justice Quarterly, 32, 116-141.

100.

Reynolds

Craig

L. A.

Boer

D. P.

(2009). Public attitudes towards offending, offenders, and reintegration. In Wood

J. L.

Gannon

T. A.

(Eds.), Public opinion and criminal justice (pp. 166-186). Portland, OR: Willan.

101.

Roberts

J. V.

Stalans

L. J.

(1997). Public opinion, crime, and criminal justice. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

102.

Roberts

J. V.

Stalans

L. J.

Indermaur

Hough

(2002). Penal populism and public opinion: Lessons from five countries. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

103.

Sampson

R. J.

Laub

J. H.

(1993). Crime in the making: Pathways and turning points through life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

104.

Sandys

McGarrell

E. F.

(1995). Attitudes toward capital punishment: Preference for the penalty or mere acceptance? Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 32, 191-213.

105.

Soss

Langbein

Metelko

A. R.

(2003). Why do White Americans support the death penalty? The Journal of Politics, 65, 397-421.

106.

Stewart

E. A.

Mears

D. P.

Warren

P. Y.

Baumer

E. P.

Arnio

A. N.

(2018). Lynchings, racial threat, and Whites’ punitive views toward Blacks. Criminology, 56, 455-480.

107.

Tam

K. P.

Shu

T. M.

H. K. S.

Tong

Y. Y.

(2013). Belief about immutability of moral character and punitiveness toward criminal offenders. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 43, 603-611.

108.

Taylor

D. G.

Scheppele

K. L.

Stinchcombe

A. L.

(1979). Salience of crime and support for harsher criminal sanctions. Social Problems, 26, 413-424.

109.

Thielo

A. J.

Cullen

F. T.

Cohen

D. M.

Chouhy

(2016). Rehabilitation in a red state: Public support for correctional reform in Texas. Criminology & Public Policy, 15, 137-170.

110.

Travis

(2005). But they all come back: Facing the challenges of prisoner reentry. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press.

111.

Tyler

T. R.

Boeckmann

R. J.

(1997). Three strikes and you’re out, but why? The psychology of public support for punishing rule breakers. Law & Society Review, 31, 237-265.

112.

Tyler

T. R.

Weber

(1982). Support for the death penalty; instrumental response to crime, or symbolic attitude? Law & Society Review, 17, 21-45.

113.

Uggen

(2000). Work as a turning point in the life course of criminals: A duration model of age, employment, and recidivism. American Sociological Review, 65, 529-546.

114.

Uggen

Vuolo

Lageson

Ruhland

Whitham

H. K.

(2014). The edge of stigma: An experimental audit of the effects of low-level criminal records on employment. Criminology, 52, 627-654.

115.

Unnever

J. D.

Cullen

F. T.

(2009). Empathetic identification and punitiveness: A middle-range theory of individual differences. Theoretical Criminology, 13, 283-312.

116.

Unnever

J. D.

Cullen

F. T.

(2010a). Racial-ethnic intolerance and support for capital punishment: A cross-national comparison. Criminology, 48, 831-864.

117.

Unnever

J. D.

Cullen

F. T.

(2010b). The social sources of Americans’ punitiveness: A test of three competing models. Criminology, 48, 99-129.

118.

Unnever

J. D.

Cullen

F. T.

(2012). White perceptions of whether African Americans and Hispanics are prone to violence and support for the death penalty. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 49, 519-544.

119.

Unnever

J. D.

Cullen

F. T.

Fisher

B. S.

(2007). “A liberal is someone who has not been mugged”: Criminal victimization and political beliefs. Justice Quarterly, 24, 309-334.

120.

Vidmar

Miller

D. T.

(1980). Social psychological processes underlying attitudes toward legal punishment. Law & Society Review, 14, 565-602.