Although research has examined the effectiveness of juvenile transfer on recidivism, there has been a lack of research done in assessing how well juvenile waiver to adult court meets the criteria necessary for deterrence to occur (i.e., certainty, severity, and swiftness of punishment). The purpose of this study is to assess how well juvenile transfer meets these criteria, using data on 345 youths legislatively waived to adult court in Pennsylvania. The findings indicate that there is greater punishment severity in adult court, but there is no difference in punishment certainty between the two court systems. In addition, court processing occurred more quickly in juvenile court. In other words, only one element of deterrence theory is achieved with juvenile transfer. Implications for subsequent research and policy are discussed.
Barnes, C.W., & Franz, R.S. ( 1989). Questionably adult: Determinants and effects of the juvenile waiver decision. Justice Quarterly, 6(1), 117-135.
2.
Beccaria, C. ( 1963). On crimes and punishments. Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill. (Original work published 1764)
3.
Bishop, D.M., & Frazier, C.E. ( 1991). Transfer of juveniles to criminal court: A case study and analysis of prosecutorial waiver. Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics and Public Policy, 5, 281-302.
4.
Bishop, D.M., Frazier, C.E., & Henretta, J.C. (1989). Prosecutor waiver: Case study of a questionable reform. Crime & Delinquency, 35, 179-201.
5.
Bishop, D.M., Frazier, C.E., Lanza-Kaduce, L., & Winner, L. ( 1996). The transfer of juveniles to criminal court: Does it make a difference? Crime & Delinquency, 42(2), 171-191.
6.
Burruss, G., & Kempf-Leonard, K. (2002). The questionable advantage of defense counsel in juvenile court. Justice Quarterly, 19, 37-67.
7.
Bushway, S., Johnson, B.D., & Slocum, L.A. ( 2007). Is the magic still there? The use of the Heckman two-step correction for selection bias in criminology. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 23, 151-178.
8.
Champion, D.J. ( 1989). Teenage felons and waiver hearings: Some recent trends, 1980-1988. Crime & Delinquency, 35(4), 577-585.
9.
Cook, P.J., & Laub, J.H. ( 1998). The unprecedented epidemic in youth violence. In M. Tonry & M. H. Moore (Eds.), Crime and justice: A review of research (Vol. 24, pp. 27-64). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
10.
Dilulio, J.J. ( 1995, November 27). The coming of the super-predators. Weekly Standard, 1, pp. 23-28.
11.
Eigen, J.P. ( 1981a). The determinants and impact of jurisdictional transfer in Philadelphia. In J. C. Hall, D. M. Hamparian, J. M. Pettibone , & J. L. White (Eds.), Major issues in the juvenile justice information and training: Readings in public policy (pp. 333-350). Columbus, OH: Academy for Contemporary Problems.
12.
Eigen, J.P. ( 1981b). Punishing youth homicide offenders in Philadelphia. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 72(3), 1072-1093.
13.
Engen, R.L., Steen, S., & Bridges, G.S. ( 2002). Racial disparities in the punishment of youth. A theoretical and empirical assessment of the literature. Social Problem , 49(2), 194-220.
14.
Fagan, J. ( 1995). Separating the men from the boys: The comparative advantage of juvenile versus criminal court sanctions on recidivism among adolescent felony offenders. In J. C. Howell, B. Krisberg, J. D. Hawkings , & J. J. Wilson (Eds.), A sourcebook: Serious, violent, and chronic juvenile offenders (pp. 238-260). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
15.
Fagan, J. ( 1996). The comparative advantage of juvenile versus criminal court sanctions on recidivism among adolescent felony offenders. Law and Policy, 18, 79-113.
16.
Fagan, J., & Deschenes, E.P. (1990). Determinants of judicial waiver decisions for violent juvenile offenders. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 81(2), 314-347.
17.
Fagan, J., Forst, M., & Vivona, T.S. ( 1987). Racial determinants of the judicial transfer decision: Prosecuting violent youth in criminal court. Crime & Delinquency , 33(2), 259-286.
18.
Feld, B.C. ( 1995). The social context of juvenile justice administration: Racial disparities in an urban juvenile court. In K. K. Leonard, C. E. Pope, & W. H. Feyerherm (Eds.), Minorities in juvenile justice (pp. 66-97). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
19.
Frazier, C.E., & Bishop, D.M. ( 1995). Reflections on race effects in juvenile justice. In K. K. Leonard, C. E. Pope, & W. H. Feyerherm (Eds.), Minorities in juvenile justice (pp. 16-46). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
20.
Fritsch, E.J., Caeti, T.J., & Hemmens, C. ( 1996). Spare the needle but not the punishment: The incarceration of waived youth in Texas prisons. Crime & Delinquency , 42(4), 593-609.
21.
Gillespie, L.K., & Norman, M.D. ( 1984). Does certification mean prison: Some preliminary findings from Utah. Juvenile and Family Court Journal, 35(13), 23-34.
22.
Heckman, J.J. ( 1976). The common structure of statistical models of truncation, sample selection and limited dependent variables. Annals of Economic and Social Measurement, 5, 475-492.
23.
Houghtalin, M., & Mays, G.L. ( 1991). Criminal dispositions of New Mexico juveniles transferred to adult court. Crime & Delinquency, 37(3), 393-407.
24.
Jensen, E.J., & Metsger, L.K. ( 1994). A test of the deterrent effect of legislative waiver on violent juvenile crime. Crime & Delinquency, 40(1), 96-104.
25.
Jordan, K.J. ( 2006). Violent youth in adult court: The decertification of transferred offenders. New York: LFB Scholarly.
26.
Kinder, K., Veneziano, C., Fichter, M., & Azuma, H. ( 1995). A comparison of the dispositions of juvenile offenders certified as adults with juvenile offenders not certified. Juvenile and Family Court Journal, 46, 37-42.
27.
Kupchik, A. ( 2006). The decision to incarcerate in juvenile and criminal courts. Criminal Justice Review, 31(4), 309-336.
28.
Langley, M. ( 1972). The juvenile court: The making of a delinquent. Law and Society Review, 7, 273-298.
29.
Leiber, M.J., Johnson, J., Fox, K., & Lacks, R. ( 2007). Differentiating among racial/ ethnic groups and its implications for understanding juvenile justice decision making. Journal of Criminal Justice, 35, 471-484.
30.
Lemmon, J.H., Austin, T.L., Verrecchia, P.J., & Fetzer, M. ( 2005). The effect of legal and extralegal factors on statutory exclusion of juvenile offenders. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 3(3), 214-234.
31.
Leonard, K.K., & Sontheimer, H. (1995). The role of race in juvenile justice in Pennsylvania. In K. K. Leonard , C. E. Pope, & W. H. Feyerherm (Eds.), Minorities in juvenile justice (pp. 98-127). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
32.
Lewis-Beck, M.S. ( 1980). Applied regression: An introduction. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
33.
Mears, D. ( 2003). A critique of waiver research. Critical next steps in assessing the impacts of laws for transferring juveniles to the criminal justice system. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 1(2), 156-172.
Mertler, C.A., & Vannatta, R.A. (2005). Advanced and multivariate statistical methods: Practical application and interpretation (3rd ed.). Los Angeles: Pyrczak.
36.
Minor, K.I., Hartmann, D.J., & Terry, S. ( 1997). Predictors of juvenile court actions and recidivism. Crime & Delinquency, 43(3), 328-334.
37.
Myers, D.L. ( 2001). Excluding violent youths from juvenile court: The effectiveness of legislative waiver. New York: LFB Scholarly.
38.
Myers, D.L. ( 2003a). Adult crime, adult time: Punishing violent youth in the adult criminal justice system. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 1(2), 173-197.
39.
Myers, D.L. ( 2003b). The recidivism of violent youths in juvenile and adult court: A consideration of selection bias. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 1(1), 79-101.
40.
Pennsylvania Juvenile Court Judges’ Commission. ( 1996). The Juvenile Act. 42 Pa.C.S. Sec. 6301 et seq. Harrisburg, Author.
41.
Podkopacz, M.R., & Feld, B.C. ( 1996). The end of the line: An empirical study of judicial waiver . Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 86(2), 449-492.
42.
Risler, E.A., Sweatman, T., & Nakerud, L. ( 1998). Evaluating the Georgia legislative waiver’s effectiveness in deterring juvenile crime. Research on Social Work Practice , 8(6), 657-667.
43.
Rudman, C., Hartstone, E., Fagan, J., & Moore, M. ( 1986). Violent youth in adult court: Process and punishment . Crime & Delinquency, 32(1), 75-96.
44.
Shadish, W.R., Cook, T.D., & Campbell, D.T. (2002). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
45.
Singer, S.I., & McDowall, D. ( 1988). Criminalizing delinquency: The deterrent effects of the New York Juvenile Offender Law. Law and Society Review, 22(3), 521-535.
46.
Snyder, H.N. ( 1998). Juvenile arrests 1997 (Report No. NCJ 173938). Washington, DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
47.
Spohn, C.C. ( 2002). How do judges decide? The search for fairness and justice in punishment. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
48.
Sridharan, S., Greenfield, L., & Blakley, B. ( 2004). A study of prosecutorial certification practice in Virginia . Criminology and Public Policy, 3(4), 605-632.
49.
Taylor, R.W., Fritsch, E.J., & Caeti, T.J. ( 2002). Juvenile justice: Policies, programs, and practices (2nd ed.). Woodland Hills, CA: Glencoe/McGraw-Hill.
50.
Thomas, C.W., & Bilchik, S. ( 1985). Prosecuting juveniles in criminal courts: A legal and empirical analysis. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology , 76(2), 439-479.
51.
Torbet, P., Gable, R., Hurst, H.I., Montgomery, I., Szymanski, L., & Thomas, D. ( 1996). State responses to serious and violent juvenile crime (Report No. NCJ-161565). Washington, DC: Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
52.
Winner, L., Lanza-Kaduce, L., Bishop, D.M., & Frazier, C.E. ( 1997). The transfer of juveniles to criminal court: Reexamining recidivism over the long term. Crime & Delinquency, 43(4), 548-563.
53.
Wordes, M., Bynum, T.S., & Corley, C.J. ( 1994). Locking up youth: The impact of race on detention decisions . Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 31(2), 149-165.
54.
Zimring, F.E. ( 1998). American youth violence. New York : Oxford University Press.
