Recent work highlights the importance of pre-modern political practices for explaining persistent institutional features, including representative democracy. Typically, this argument is institutional in nature—pre-industrial practices are hypothesized to either bolster or retard the transmission of democratic institutions. This article proposes a separate channel through which legacies of early statehood continue to impact the prospects of democratic governance. Using survey data from Africa, we document a positive relationship between early statehood development and support for autocratic rule among ordinary Africans. This finding is robust to a wide range of pre- and post-treatment covariates, country and survey round fixed effects, as well as an instrumental-variable design. The identified relationship is particularly prominent in respondents from precolonially centralized ethnic groups in former British colonies, suggesting the importance of locally surviving traditional institutions for propagation of norms that owe their origins to precolonial autocratic socialization.
AcemogluD.JohnsonS.RobinsonJ. A. (2001). The colonial origins of comparative development: An empirical investigation. American Economic Review, 91(5), 1369–1401.
2.
AcemogluD.JohnsonS.RobinsonJ. A.YaredP. (2008). Income and democracy. American Economic Review, 98(3), 808–842.
3.
AcemogluD.RobinsonJ. (2019). The narrow corridor: States, societies, and the fate of Liberty. Penguin.
4.
AhmedA. T.StasavageD. (2020). Origins of early democracy. American Political Science Review, 114(2), 502–518.
5.
AliM.FjeldstadO. H.ShifaA. B. (2020). European colonization and the corruption of local elites: The case of chiefs in Africa. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 179, 80–100.
6.
AlsanM. (2015). The effect of the tsetse fly on African development. American Economic Review, 105(1), 382–410.
7.
AlvarezR. M.BrehmJ. (2002). Hard choices, easy answers: Values, information, and American public opinion. Princeton University Press.
8.
AndersonB. (2006). Imagined communities: Reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism. Verso Books.
9.
ApterD. (1960). The organization of a Zande kingdom. Cahiers d’e´tudes Africaines, 1(4), 5–37.
10.
ApterD. (1997). The political kingdom in Uganda: A study in bureaucratic nationalism. Frank Cass.
BandyopadhyayS.GreenE. (2016). Precolonial political centralization and contemporary development in Uganda. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 64(3), 471–508.
13.
BarbourK. M. (1961). A geographical analysis of boundaries in inter-tropical Africa. In: BarbourK. M.ProtheroR. M. (Eds.), Essays on African population (pp. 303–323). Routledge & Kegan Paul.
BeckerS. O.BoeckhK.HainzC.WoessmannL. (2016). The empire is dead, long live the empire! Long‐run persistence of trust and corruption in the bureaucracy. The Economic Journal, 126(590), 40–74.
16.
Ben-amos GirshickP.ThorntonJ. (2001). Civil war in the Kingdom of Benin, 1689-1721: Continuity or political change?The Journal of African History, 42(3), 353–376.
17.
BenYishayA.RotbergR.WellsJ.LvZ.GoodmanS.KovacevicL.RunfolaD. (2017). Geocoding Afrobarometer rounds 1-6: Methodology & data quality. AidData at William & Mary.
18.
BesleyT.PerssonT. (2011). Pillars of prosperity: The political economics of development clusters. Princeton University Press.
19.
BesleyT.PerssonT. (2019). Democratic values and institutions. American Economic Review: Insights, 1(1), 59–76.
20.
BesleyT.Reynal-QuerolM. (2014). The legacy of historical conflict: Evidence from Africa. American Political Science Review, 108(2), 319–336.
21.
BiranM. (2013). Qaidu and the rise of the independent Mongol state in Central Asia. Routledge.
BoothJ. A.SeligsonM. A. (2009). The legitimacy puzzle in Latin America: Political support and democracy in eight nations. Cambridge University Press.
24.
BowlesS. (2016). The moral economy: Why good incentives are no substitute for good citizens. Yale University Press.
25.
BowlesS.Polanía-ReyesS. (2012). Economic incentives and social preferences: Substitutes or complements?Journal of Economic Literature, 50(2), 368–425.
26.
BroichT.SzirmaiA.ThomssonK. (2015). Precolonial centralisation, foreign aid, and modern state capacity in Africa. UNU-MERIT Working Paper. Maastricht, The Netherlands.
27.
CanningJ. (2014). A history of medieval political thought: 300–1450. Routledge.
28.
CedermanL.-E.WimmerA.MinB. (2010). Why do ethnic groups rebel? New data and analysis. World Politics, 62(1), 87–119.
29.
ChaudharyL.Jared RubinS. I.ShrivastavaA. (2018). Cultural transmission and the colonial legacy: Evidence from public good games along a historical border. Working Paper. Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, CA.
30.
ChloubaV. (2020). Traditional authority and state legitimacy: Evidence from Namibia. The Journal of the Middle East and Africa, 11(3), 251–272.
31.
ChloubaV.SmithD. S.WagnerS. (2021). Replication data for: Early Statehood and support for autocratic rule in Africa, https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/O6L4UX, Harvard Dataverse, V1, UNF:6:j7h/zfE2jUpJunSRw6sooQ== [fileUNF].
32.
ChloubaV.WibbelsE.PierskallaJan H. (2018) Historical exposure to state hood, ethnic exclusion, and government legitimacy. Working paper. The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH.
33.
ClaassenC. (2020). Does public support help democracy survive?American Journal of Political Science, 64(1), 118–134.
34.
ClaessenH. (1996). Ideology and the formation of early states. (Vol. 11). Brill.
35.
CogneauD.MoradiA. (2014). Borders that divide: Education and religion in Ghana and Togo since colonial times. The Journal of Economic History, 74(3), 694–729.
36.
CrowderM. (1968). West Africa under colonial rule. Hutchinson.
37.
DaltonR. J. (1994). Communists and democrats: Democratic attitudes in the two Germanies. British Journal of Political Science, 24, 469–493.
38.
De JuanA., 2017. “Traditional” resolution of land conflicts: the survival of precolonial dispute Settlement in Burundi. Comparative Political Studies, 50(13), 1835–1868.
39.
De JuanA.KoosC. (2019). The historical roots of cooperative behavior-Evidence from eastern Congo. World Development, 116, 100–112.
40.
DeMarraisE.CastilloL. J.EarleT. (1996). Ideology, materialization, and power Strategies. Current Anthropology, 37(1), 15–31.
41.
Depetris-ChauvinE. (2014). State history and contemporary conflict: Evidence from Sub-Saharan Africa. mimeo, Brown University.
42.
Di CosmoN. (1999). State formation and periodization in inner Asian history. Journal of World History, 10, 1–40.
43.
DiamondL. (1999). Developing democracy: Toward consolidation. Johns Hopkins University Press.
44.
DowningB. M. (1989). Medieval origins of constitutional government in the west. Theory and Society, 18(2), 213–247.
45.
DowningB. (1992). The military revolution and political change. Princeton University Press.
46.
DreherA.FuchsA.KammerlanderA.KaplanL.RobertC.UnfriedK. (2020). The political leaders’ Affiliation database (PLAD). V5. Harvard Dataverse.
47.
EngermanS. LSokoloffK. L. (2002). Factor endowments, inequality, and paths of development among New World economies. National Bureau of Economic Research.
48.
ErtmanT. (1997). Birth of the Leviathan: Building states and regimes in medieval and early modern Europe. Cambridge University Press.
49.
FenskeJ. (2013). Does land abundance explain African institutions?The Economic Journal, 123(573), 1363–1390.
50.
FenskeJ.KalaN. (2017). 1807: Economic shocks, conflict and the slave trade. Journal of Development Economics, 126, 66–76.
51.
FergusonN. (2003). Empire: The rise and demise of the British World Order and the lessons for global power. Basic Books.
52.
FergusonN. (2012). Empire: How Britain made the modern world. Penguin.
53.
FoaR. S. (2017). Persistence or reversal of fortune? Early state inheritance and the legacies of colonial rule. Politics & Society, 45(2), 301–324.
54.
FortesM.Evans-PritchardE. E. (1940). African political systems. Oxford University Press.
55.
FukuyamaF. (2014). Political order and political decay. From the industrial revolution to the globalization of democracy. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
56.
GennaioliN.RainerI. (2006). Precolonial centralization and institutional quality in Africa. In: GradsteinM.KonradK. (Eds.), Institutions and norms in economic development. MIT Press.
57.
GennaioliN.RainerI. (2007). The modern impact of precolonial centralization in Africa. Journal of Economic Growth, 12(3), 185–234.
58.
GerringJ.ZiblattD.van GorpJ.ArévaloJ.ArévaloJ. (2011). An institutional theory of direct and indirect rule. World Politics, 63(3), 377–433.
59.
GigerenzerG. (2007). Gut feelings: The intelligence of the unconscious. Penguin.
60.
GiulianoP.NunnN. (2013. The transmission of democracy: From the village to the nation-state. American Economic Review, 103(3), 86–92.
61.
GogoiL. (1991). The history of the system of Ahom administration. Penguin.
62.
GrayJ. P. (1999). A corrected ethnographic atlas. World Cultures, 10(1), 24–85.
63.
GreenE. (2018). Ethnicity, national identity and the state: Evidence from sub-Saharan Africa. British Journal of Political Science14, 1–23.
64.
GreenbaumL. (1977. Cross-cultural study of the Use of elections for selection of the village headman. Behavior Science Research, 12, 45–53.
65.
GuhaA. (1983). The Ahom political system: An enquiry into the state formation process in Medieval Assam (1228-1714). Social Scientist, 11(12), 2–34.
66.
HallbergJ. D. (2012). PRIO conflict site 1989–2008: A geo-referenced dataset on armed conflict. Conflict Management and Peace Science, 29(2), 137.
67.
HaririJ. G. (2012). The autocratic legacy of early statehood. American Political Science Review, 106(3), 471–494.
68.
HayekF. A. (1979). Law, legislation, and liberty. Vol. 3. Routledge and Kegan Paul.
69.
HeldringL. (2016). Violence and the state: Evidence from Rwanda’s ‘Decade of Atrocities’. mimeo, Harvard University, MA.
70.
HerbstJ. (2014). States and power in Africa. Princeton,Princeton University Press.
71.
HjortJ. (2010). Pre-colonial culture, postcolonial economic success? The Tswana and the African economic miracle. The Economic History Review, 63(3), 688–709.
72.
HobsbawmERangerT. (1983). The invention of tradition. Cambridge University Press.
73.
HodgsonG. M. (2006). What are institutions?Journal of Economic Issues, 40(1), 1–25.
74.
InglehartR.WelzelC. (2005). Modernization, cultural change, and democracy: The human development sequence. Cambridge University Press.
75.
InglehartR.WelzelC. (2008). The role of ordinary people in democratization. Journal of Democracy, 19(1), 97–111.
76.
JamalA. A.TesslerM. A. (2008). Attitudes in the Arab world. Journal of Democracy, 19(1), 97–110.
77.
JedwabR.StoreygardA. (2017). Economic and political factors in infrastructure investment: Evidence from railroads and roads in Africa 1960–2015. Institute for International Economic Policy Working Paper.
78.
JoasH. (1993). Pragmatism and social theory. University of Chicago Press.
79.
KilpinenE. (2000). The enormous fly wheel of society: Pragmatism’s habitual conception of action and social theory. University of Helsinki.
80.
KilsonM. L. (1966). Political change in a West African state: A study in the modernization process. Harvard University Press.
81.
KiszewskiA.SachsS. E.MellingerA.MalaneyP.SachsJ.SpielmanA.SachsJ. (2004). A global index representing the stability of malaria transmission. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 70(5), 486–498.
82.
KiwanukaM. S. (1967). Muteesa of Uganda. East African Literature Bureau.
83.
KnightJ. (1992). Institutions and social conflict. Cambridge University Press.
84.
LechlerM.McNameeL. (2018). Indirect colonial rule undermines support for democracy: Evidence from a natural experiment in Namibia. Comparative Political Studies17, 1–41.
85.
LetsaN. W.WilfahrtM. (2018). Popular support for democracy in autocratic regimes: A micro-level analysis of preferences. Comparative Politics, 50(2), 231–273.
86.
LeviM. (1989). Of rule and revenue. University of California Press.
87.
LewisI. (1961). A pastoral democracy: A study of pastoralism and politics among the Northern Somali of the Horn of Africa. Oxford University Press.
88.
LewisP. M. (Ed.). (2009). Ethnologue: Languages of the World. SIL International.
89.
LipsetS. M.SeongK.-R.TorresJ. C. (1993). A comparative-analysis of the social requisites of democracy. International Social Science Journal, 45(2), 154–175.
90.
LoganC. (2013). The roots of resilience: Exploring popular support for African traditional authorities. African Affairs, 112(448), 353–376.
91.
LowesS.NunnN.RobinsonJ. A.WeigelJ. L. (2017). The evolution of culture and institutions: Evidence from the Kuba Kingdom. Econometrica, 85(4), 1065–1091.
92.
LubanD. (2020). What is spontaneous order?American Political Science Review, 114(1), 68–80.
93.
LundC. (2006). Twilight institutions: Public authority and local politics in Africa. Development and Change, 37(4), 685–705.
94.
MahoneyJ.ThelenK. (2009). Explaining institutional change: Ambiguity, agency, and power. Cambridge University Press.
MamdaniM. (1996). Citizen and subject: Contemporary Africa and the legacy of late colonialism. Princeton University Press.
97.
MarshallM. G.JaggersK. (2016). Polity IV project: Political regime characteristics and transitions, 1800–2016. Cambridge University Press.
98.
MartinezA. P. (2009). The Cambridge history of inner Asia: The Chinggisid age. Cambridge University Press.
99.
MaselandR. (2018). Is colonialism history? The declining impact of colonial legacies on African institutional and economic development. Journal of Institutional Economics, 14(2), 259–287.
100.
MattesR.BrattonM. (2007). Learning about democracy in Africa: Awareness, performance, and experience. American Journal of Political Science, 51(1), 192–217.
101.
McGovernM. (2013). Unmasking the state: Making Guinea modern. University of Chicago Press.
102.
McIntoshS. K. (1999). Pathways to complexity: An African perspective. Cambridge University Press, York.
103.
MengerC. (1981). Principles of economics, In: DingwallJ. (Ed.) and Translated by B. F. Hoselitz from the German edition of 1871. New York University Press.
104.
MessierR. A. (2010). The Almoravids and the meanings of Jihad. ABC-CLIO.
MichalopoulosS.PapaioannouE. (2015). On the ethnic origins of African development: Chiefs and precolonial political centralization. Academy of Management Perspectives, 29(1), 32–71.
107.
MigdalJ. S. (1988). Strong societies and weak states: State-society relations and state capabilities in the third World. Princeton University Press.
108.
MilesW. F. S. (1987). Partitioned royalty: The evolution of Hausa chiefs in Nigeria and Niger. The Journal of Modern African Studies, 25(2), 233–258.
109.
MilesW. F. S. (1993). Traditional rulers and development administration: Chieftaincy in Niger, Nigeria, and Vanuatu. Studies in Comparative International Development, 28(3), 31–50.
110.
MishlerW.RoseR. (2007). Generation, age, and time: The dynamics of political learning during Russia’s transformation. American Journal of Political Science, 51(4), 822–834.
111.
MonteroJ. R.GuntherR.TorcalM. (1997). Democracy in Spain: legitimacy, discontent, and disaffection. Studies in Comparative International Development, 32(3), 124–160.
112.
Müller-CreponC. (2020). Continuity or change? (In) Direct rule in British and French colonial Africa (pp. 1–35). International Organization.
113.
Müller-CreponC.PenglY.BormannN.-C. (2020). Linking ethnic data from Africa. University of Pittsburgh Press.
114.
MurdockG. P. (1967). Ethnographic atlas: A summary. University of Pittsburgh Press.
115.
NeundorfA.GerschewskiJ.OlarR.-G. (2020). How do inclusionary and exclusionary autocracies affect ordinary people?Comparative Political Studies, 53(12), 1890–1925.
116.
NorthD. C.WeingastB. R. (1989). Constitutions and commitment: The evolution of institutions governing public choice in seventeenth-century England. The Journal of Economic History, 49(4), 803–832.
117.
NunnN. (2008). The long-term effects of Africa’s slave trades*. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 123(1), 139–176.
118.
NunnN.WantchekonL. (2011). The slave trade and the origins of mistrust in Africa. American Economic Review, 101(7), 3221–3252.
119.
Pop-ElechesG.TuckerJ. A. (2017). Communism’s shadow: Historical legacies and contemporary political attitudes. Princeton University Press.
120.
Pop-ElechesG.TuckerJ. A. (2020). Communist legacies and left-authoritarianism. Comparative Political Studies, 53(12), 1861–1889.
121.
PrzeworskiA. (2010). Democracy and the limits of Self-Government. (Vol. 9). Cambridge University Press.
122.
RangerT. (1983). The invention of tradition in colonial Africa. In: HobsbawmE. J.RangerT., (Eds.), The invention of tradition. Cambridge University Press.
123.
ReidR. (2002). Political power in pre Colonial Buganda: Economy society and warfare in the nineteenth century. Oxford University Press.
124.
RichensP. (2009). The economic legacies of the “thin white line”: Indirect rule and the comparative development of sub-Saharan Africa. African Economic History, 37, 33–102.
125.
RolandG. (2004). Understanding institutional change: Fast-moving and slow-moving institutions. Studies in Comparative International Development, 38(4), 109–131.
126.
SabettiF. (2004). Local roots of constitutionalism. Perspectives on Political Science, 33(2), 70–78.
127.
SchulzJ. F.Bahrami-RadD.BeauchampJ. P., (2019). The church, intensive kinship, and global psychological variation. Science, 366(6466), 3221–3252.
128.
ScottJ. C. (2008). Weapons of the weak. Yale University Press.
129.
ScottJ. C. (2017). Against the grain: A deep history of the earliest states. Yale University Press.
130.
SeidlerV. (2018). Copying informal institutions: the role of British colonial officers during the decolonization of British Africa. Journal of Institutional Economics, 14, 2, 289–312.
131.
SherwaniH. KJoshiP.M. (1973). History of the Medieval Deccan. Yale University Press.
132.
BentzenJ.HaririJ. G.RobinsonJ. A. (2019). Power and persistence: The indigenous roots of representative democracy. The Economic Journal, 129(618), 678–714.
133.
StanishC. (1996). The origin of state societies in South America. Annual Review of Anthropology, 37(1), 15–31.
134.
StasavageD. (2010). When distance mattered: geographic scale and the development of European representative assemblies. American Political Science Review, 7, 625–643.
135.
StasavageD. (2016). Representation and consent: Why they arose in Europe and not else- where. Annual Review of Political Science, 19, 145–162.
136.
StasavageD. (2020). The decline and rise of democracy: A global history from antiquity to today. Columbia University Press.
137.
SteinG. (1994). Economy, ritual, and power in ‘Ubaid Mesopotamia. Prehistory Press.
138.
StevensonR. (1968). Population and political systems in tropical Africa. Columbia University Press.
139.
TillyC. (1985). War-making and state-making as organized crime. In: EvansP.RueschemeyerD.SkocpolT. (Eds.), Bringing the state back in (pp. 169–187). Cambridge University Press.
140.
TillyC. (1990). Capital, coercion and European States. Basil Blackwell.
141.
TocquevilleA. D. (2000). Democracy in America. Chicago University Press.
142.
TollefsenA. F.StrandH.BuhaugH. (2012). PRIO−GRID: Auni f iedspatialdatastructure. Journal of PeaceResearch, 49(2), 363−374.
143.
TurchinP. (2016). Ultrasociety: How 10,000 years of war made humans the greatest cooperators on Earth. Beresta Books.
144.
VansinaJ. (1962). A comparison of African Kingdoms. Africa, 32(4), 324–335.
145.
VansinaJ. (1978). The children of Woot: A history of the Kuba peoples. University of Wisconsin Press.
146.
VedderH. (1966). South West Africa in early times. Frank Cass & Co. (Reprint of 1938 edition).
147.
VengroffR. (1976). Population density and state formation in Africa. African Studies Review, 19(1), 67–74.
148.
VogtM. A. (2017). Ethnic stratification and the equilibrium of inequality: Ethnic conflict in post-colonial states. International organization, 72(1), 105–137.
149.
WhatleyW. (2012). The transatlantic slave trade and the evolution of political authority in West Africa. Africa’s Development in Historical Perspective13, 460–488.
150.
WigT. (2016). Peace from the past: Pre-colonial political institutions and civil wars in Africa. Journal of Peace Research, 53(4), 509–524.
151.
WilfahrtM. (2018). Precolonial legacies and institutional congruence in public goods delivery: Evidence from decentralized West Africa. World Politics, 70(2), 239–274.
152.
WilliamsF.-N. (1991). Precolonial communities of Southwestern Africa: A history of Owambo Kingdoms, 1600–1920. National Archives of Namibia.
153.
WoodberryR. D. (2012). The missionary roots of liberal democracy. American Political Science Review, 106(2), 244–274.
154.
WuW.-C.ChangY.-T.PanH.-H. (2017). Does China’s middle class prefer (liberal) democracy?Democratization, 24(2), 347–366.
155.
WucherpfennigJ.HunzikerP.CedermanL.-E. (2016). Who inherits the state? Colonial rule and postcolonial conflict. American Journal of Political Science, 60(4), 882–898.
156.
YoungC. (1994). The African Colonial state in comparative perspective. Yale University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
