A critical review of the available data on the risks and benefits of hexa chlorophene suggests that there is ample evidence for the toxic potential; whereas there is no substantial evidence of its benefit in life-threatening staph 80/81 epidemics, and effective less toxic alternatives are available. In view of its limited usefulness and definite toxicity, the routine use of hexachlorophene is unjustified.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Fahlberg, W.J. , Swan, T.C., and Seastone , C.V.: Studies on the retention of hexachlorophene (G-11) in human skin. J. Bacteriol.56: 323, 1948.
2.
Philips, C.R. , and Warshowsky, B.: Chemical disinfectants. Ann. Rev. Microbiol.12: 525, 1958.
3.
Forfar, J.O. , Gould, J.C., and MacCabe, A.F.: Effect of hexachlorophene on incidence of staphylococcal and gram-negative infections in the newborns. Lancet11: 177, 1968.
4.
Noone, P., Griffiths, R.J., and Taylor, C.E.D.: Hexachlorophene for treating carriers of Staphylococcus aureus. Lancet1: 1202, 1970.
5.
Allers, O.E. , Hubbell, J.P., Jr., and Buck , A.S.: A rapid aseptic scrub technique for nurseries of the newborn. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.60: 431, 1950.
6.
Stoughton, R.B. , and Stoughton, G.S.: Topical control of skin bacterial growth with hexachlorophene in dimethylacetamide. J. Invest. Dermatol.50: 332, 1968.
7.
Fuller, J.R. , Newhall, C.A.Thorne , F.C., and Traub, E.F.: Effectiveness of compound G-11 in reducing pyogenic skin infections. Am. J. Public Health38: 1228, 1948.
8.
Lipschutz, A. , and Fitti, R.M.: New antibacterial agent for common skin disease of children. Use in prophylaxis and treatment. Arch. Dermatol.68: 83, 1953.
9.
Kaessler, H.W. : Dermatitis of the diaper region— a new remedy for an old affliction. Arch. Pediatr.74: 47, 1957.
10.
American Medical Association, Council in Pharmacy and Chemistry: Hexachlorophene. JAMA145: 563, 1951.
11.
Gillespie, W.A., Alder, V.G., Ayliffe , G.A.T., Powell, D.E.B., and Wypkema , W.: Control of staphylococcal cross-infection in surgical wards. A four-and-a half year study . Lancet1: 1299, 1961.
12.
Price, P.B. , and Bonnett, A.: Antibacterial effects of G-5, G-11 and A-151, with special reference to their use in production of a germical soap. Surgery24: 542, 1948.
13.
Glaser, J., Thompson, M.L., and Benson, T.D.: Prevention of minor skin irritation (miliaria) and impetigo in the newborn . Am. J. Dis. Child.81: 329, 1951.
14.
Duncan, W.C. , Dodge, G.B., and Knox, J.M.: Prevention of superficial pyogenic skin infections. Arch. Dermatol.99: 465, 1969.
15.
MacKenzie, A.R.: Effectiveness of antibacterial soap in a healthy population. JAMA211: 973, 1970.
Heinrich, H. : Effective prophylaxis of mastitis without the use of antibiotics. Med. Welt.46: 2470, 1962 .
18.
Plueckhan, V.D., and Banks, J.: Breast abscess and staphylococcal disease in a maternity hospital. Brit. Med. J.2: 414, 1964.
19.
Farquharson. C.D., Penny, S.F., Edwards , H.E., and Barr, E.: The control of staphylococcal skin infections in the nursery. Can. Med. Assoc. J.67: 247, 1952.
20.
Hardyment, A.F., Wilson, R.A., Cockcroft , W., and Johnson, B.: Observation on the bacteriology and epidemiology of nursery infection. Pediatrics25: 907, 1960.
Simon, H.J. , Yaffe, S.J., and Gluck, L.: Effective control of staphylococci in a nursery . N. Engl. J. Med.265: 1171, 1961.
23.
Gluck, L., Simon, H.J., Yaffe, S.J., and Wood, H.F.: Effective control of staphylococci in nurseries. Am. J. Dis. Child.102: 737, 1961.
24.
Reid, D.E., Walter, C.W., and Buck, A.S.: Surgical scrubbing with pHisoderm G-11 as applied to maternity hospital. Surg . Gynecol. Obst.91: 537, 1950.
25.
Havens, I., Beham, R.S., and Clark, D.E.: Hexachlorophene in surgical scrub. Am. J. Med. Technol.23: 76, 1957.
26.
Harrison, E. , and Cockcroft, W.H.: Evaluation of newer techniques in surgical scrub. Can. Med. Assoc. J.66: 110, 1952.
27.
Gluck, L., and Wood, H.F.: Effect of an antiseptic skin care regimen on reducing staphylococcal colonization in newborn infants. N. Eng. J. Med.265: 1177, 1961 .
28.
Herter, W.B. : Hexachlorophene poisoning. Kaiser Foundation Med. Bull.7: 228, 1959.
29.
Gaines, T.B. , and Kimbrough, R.D.: Presentation 10th Annual Meeting of Society of Toxicology. Washington, D.C., March 7-11, 1971.
30.
Kimbrough, R.D., and Gaines, T.B.: Hexachlorophene effects on the rat brain . Arch. Environ. Health. 23: 114, 1971.
31.
Curley, A., Kimbrough, R.D., Nethenson, G., and Finberg, L.: Dermal absorption of hexachlorophene in infants. Lancet2: 296, 1971.
32.
Kimbrough, R.D.: Review of the toxicity of hexachlorophene, including its neurotoxicity. J. Clin. Pharmacol.13: 439, 1973.
33.
Lockhart, J.D. , and Simmons, H.E.: Hexachlorophene decisions at the FDA. Pediatrics51: 431, 1973.
Lockhart, J.D. : How toxic is hexachlorphene?Pediatrics50: 229, 1973.
36.
Kimbrough, R.D.: Review of the toxicity of hexachlorophene . Arch. Environ. Health23: 119, 1971.
37.
Committee on fetus and newborn of the American Academy of Pediatrics; statement on: Hexachlorophene and skin care of newborn infants . Pediatrics49:625, 1972.
38.
Trout, M.E. : Hexachlorophene in perspective. J. Clin. Pharmacol.13: 451, 1973.
39.
Wear, J.B., et al.: Toxicity of ingested hexachlorophene. JAMA818: 587, 1962.
40.
Lockhart, J.D. : Hexachlorophene and the FDA. J. Clin. Pharmacol.13: 445, 1973.
41.
Kimbrough, R.D.: Review of recent evidence of the toxic effects of hexachlorophene. Pediatrics51: 391, 1973.
42.
Mullick, F.G. : Hexachlorophene toxicity—human experience at Armed Forces Institute of Pathology. Pediatrics51: 395, 1973.
43.
Schuman, R.M. , Leech, R.W., and Alvord, E.C.; Jr.: Neurotoxicity of hexachlorophene in the human, clinicopathologic study of 248 children. Pediatrics54: 689, 1974.
44.
Gluck, L.: A perspective on hexachlorophene. Pediatrics, 51: 400, 1973.
45.
Mortimer, E.A. , et al.: Transmission of staphylococci between newborns. Am. J. Dis. Child.104: 289, 1962 .
46.
Simon, H.J. , Yaffe, S.J., and Gluck, L.: Effective control of staphylococci in a nursery . N. Eng. J. Med.265: 1171, 1961.
47.
Gezon, J.M. , Thompson, D.J., Rogers , K.D., Hatch, T.F., and Taylor, P.M.: Hexachlorophene bathing in early infancy and the effect on staphylococcal disease and infection . N. Engl. J. Med.270: 379, 1964.
48.
Plueckhan, V.D.: Hexachlorophene and the control of staphylococcal sepsis in a maternity unit in Gleelony, Australia. Pediatrics51: 368, 1973.
49.
Kwong, M.S. , Loew, A.D., Anthony , B.F., and Oh , W.: The effect of hexachlorophene on staphylococcal colonization rates in the newborn infant; a controlled study using a single bath method. J. Ped.82: 982, 1973.
50.
Light, I.J. , and Sutherland, J.M.: What is the evidence that hexachlorophene is not effective?Pediatrics51: 345, 1973.
51.
Gezon, H.M. : Should nursery environmental control measures be reexamined?Pediatrics44: 636, 1969.
52.
Jessen, D., et al.: Changing staphylococci and staphylococcal infections, a ten year study of bacteria and cases of bacteremia. N. Engl. J. Med.281: 627, 1969.
53.
Light, I.J. , Atherton, H.D., and Sutherland , J.M.: Decreased colonization of newborn infants with staphylococcus aureus, 80/81: Cincinnati General Hospital 1960-1972. J. Infect. Dis.131: 281, 1975.
54.
Forfar, J.O. , Gould, J.C., MacCabe , A.F.: Effect of hexachlorophene on incidence of staphylococcal and gram negative infection in the newborn . Lancet2: 177, 1968.
55.
Campbell, A.G.M. , and Pitkewicz, J.S.: The incidence of infections in nurseries since the discontinuance of hexachlorophene. Pediatrics51: 361, 1972.
56.
Dixon, R.E. , Kaslow, R.A., and Mallison , G.F.: Staphylococcal disease outbreaks in hospital nurseries in the United States, December 1971 through March 1972. Pediatrics51: 413, 1972.
57.
Kaslow, R.A. , et al.: Staphylococcal disease related to hospital nursery bathing practices—a nationwide epidemiologic investigation . Pediatrics51: 418, 1973.
58.
Hyams, P.J. , et al.: Staphylococcal bactermin and hexachlorophene bathing: Epidemic in a newborn nursery. Am. J. Dis. Child.129: 595, 1975.
59.
Najem, G.R. , et al.: Clinical and microbiologic surveillance of neonatal staphylococcal disease: Relationship to hexachlorophene wholebody bathing. Am. J. Dis. Child.129: 297, 1975 .
60.
Gehlbach, S.H. , et al.: Recurrence of skin disease in a nursery: Ineffectuality of hexachlorophene bathing. Pediatrics55: 422, 1975.
Shaffer, T.E. , Baldwin, J.N., Rheins , M.D., and Sylvester , R.F.: Staphylococcal infections in newborn infants: 1. Study of an epidemic among infants and nursery mothers . Pediatrics18: 750, 1956.
63.
Shinefield, H.R., et al.: Bacterial interference: Its effect on nursery acquired infection with staphylococcus aureus V. An analysis and interpretation. Am. J. Dis. Child.105: 683, 1963 .
64.
Mirkin, B.L. : Impact of public policy on the development of drugs for pregnant women and children. Clin. Res.23: 233, 1975.
