Free accessResearch articleFirst published online 2000-4
Better,Worse or Different? A Critique of ‘Using Language Policies to Highlight and Contrast the Values that Shape Multicultural Societies: Examples from Singapore and Australia’ by Beatrice Boufoy-Bastick (1997)
This paper examines the argument of a previous article published in this journal by Boufoy-Bastick (1997). In that article, Boufoy-Bastick made some comparisons between the language policies of Australia's and Singapore's education systems. The author claimed that Australia's language policies are more egalitarian and promote multiculturalism, whereas Singapore's policies produce only superficial harmony and are, in fact, discriminatory. The present article questions these claims on the grounds that they are either untrue, contradictory or lacking in evidence to substantiate such serious allegations about the educational and social policies of one of Australia's closest neighbours in Asia.
BeswickD. (1987). Trends in higher education. In KeevesJ. P. (Ed.). Australian education. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
2.
Boufoy-BastickB. (1997). Using language policies to highlight and contrast the values that shape multicultural societies: Examples from Singapore and Australia. Australian Journal of Education, 41 (1), 59–76.
3.
ChiewS. K. (1991). Social mobility in Singapore. In QuahS. R.ChiewS. K.KoY. C.LeeS. M. (Eds.), Social class in Singapore. Singapore: Times Academic Press.
4.
ConnellR. W. (1995). Poverty and education. Harvard Educational Review, 64 (2), 126–149.
5.
ConnellR. W. (1997). Schools, markets, justice: Education in a fractured world. Forum of Education, 52 (1), 1–13.
6.
GopinathanS. (1994). Language policy changes 1979–1992: Politics and pedagogy. In GopinathanS.ParkerA.HoW. K.SaravanV. (Eds.), Language, society and education in Singapore: Issues and trends. Singapore: Times Academic Press.
7.
GopinathanS. (1997a). Education and development in Singapore. In TanJ.GopinathanS.HoW. K. (Eds.), Education in Singapore, Singapore: Prentice Hall.
8.
GopinathanS. (1997b). Educational development in Singapore: Connecting the national, regional and the global. Australian Educational Researcher, 24 (1), 1–12.
9.
KwongJ. Y. S.PeckE. S.ChinJ. Y. Y. (1997). 25 years of educational reform. In TanJ.GopinathanS.HoW. K. (Eds.), Education in Singapore. Singapore: Prentice Hall.
10.
PhilpH.DebusR. L.VeidemanisV.ConnellW. F. (1964). The university and its community. Sydney: Novak.
11.
PooleM. E. (1987). Youth in transition. In KeevesJ. P. (Ed.), Australian education. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
12.
SharpeL.GopinathanS. (1997). Effective island, effective schools: Repair and restructuring in the Singapore school system. In TanJ.GopinathanS.HoW. K. (Eds.), Education in Singapore. Singapore: Prentice Hall.
13.
YipJ. S. K.EngS. P.YapJ. Y. C. (1997). 25 years of educational reform. In TanJ.GopinathanS.HoW. K. (Eds.), Education in Singapore. Singapore: Prentice Hall.
14.
YoungR. E. (1989). A critical theory of education: Habermas and our children's future. New York: Teachers College Press.
