This article examines trends in the resolution of homicide cases involving battered women defendants from 2000 to 2010 in Australia, Canada and New Zealand. Australia and Canada appear to have some commonalities in their treatment of such cases with higher acquittal rates and a greater reliance on plea bargaining to produce manslaughter verdicts, as compared with New Zealand. Although New Zealand’s small number of cases makes it difficult to generalise, its overall trends appear to be different from those observed in Australia and Canada, in both the high proportion of cases proceeding to trial and those resulting in conviction for murder. The authors conclude that there is a need to re-examine prosecutorial practices of proceeding to trial on murder rather than manslaughter charges even when manslaughter would be ultimately satisfactory to the prosecution, and of accepting guilty pleas to manslaughter verdicts in circumstances where the battered woman appears to have a strong self-defence case.
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Women’s Taskforce on Violence (2000) Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander Women’s Taskforce on Violence Report Brisbane, Queensland Department of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Policy and Development.
2.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2010) Population Characteristics, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians, 2006, Catalogue 4713.0.
3.
Australian Law Reform Commission/New South Wales Law Reform Commission (ALRC/NSWLRC) (2010) Family Violence – A National Legal Response, Final Report volume 1.
4.
BradfieldR (1998) Is near enough good enough? Why isn’t self-defence appropriate for the battered woman?Psychiatry, Psychology and Law5: 71–85.
5.
BradfieldR (2001) Women who kill: Lack of intent and diminished responsibility as the other defences to spousal homicid?Current Issues in Criminal Justice13(2): 143–167.
6.
Bradfield R (2002) The Treatment of Women Who Kill Their Violent Male Partners Within the Australian Criminal Justice System, Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of Tasmania.
7.
Cherry, P (2004) Drug-crazed boyfriend threatened to rape daughter, woman claims. The [Montreal] Gazette, A6.
8.
Fraser K (2009) Wife confesses to murder. Third trial averted as wife admits she shot hubby. The [Vancouver] Province, 5 November.
9.
FVDRC (2011) Family Violence Death Review Committee, Second Report. Health and Quality Safety Commission, New Zealand.
10.
GuzAMcMahonM (2011) Is imminence still necessary? Current approaches to imminence in the laws governing self-defence in Australi?Flinders Law Journal13: 79–124.
11.
MaguiganH (1991) Battered women and self-defence: Myths and misconceptions in current reform proposal?University of Pennsylvania Law Review140: 379–486.
12.
Mahony T (2011) Homicide in Canada, 2010 Juristat Statistics Canada, catalogue no. 85-002-X.
13.
MartinJPritchardR (2008) Learning from Tragedy: Homicide within Families in New Zealand 2002–2006. Wellington, New Zealand: Ministry of Social Development.
14.
New Zealand Herald (2010) Detention for wife who killed husband. 21 December. Available at: http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10695705, (last accessed 20 April 2012).
15.
Nouvelles Télé-Radio (2003) Micheline Veilleux est acquitée de meurtre de son ex-conjoint. 11 November.
16.
R v Besim [2004] VSC 168 (17 February 2004).
17.
R v Burke [2000] NSWSC 356.
18.
R v Byrd (2005), unreported, Man QB, 14 November 2005, McKelvey, J.
19.
R v Cloughessy (2008), unreported, NSWSC, 5 September 2008, Barr J.
20.
R v Dimitrovski (2009), 6 May 2009, case dismissed at committal by Magistrate Hawkins.
21.
R v Dunn (2007) Unreported SASC (20 June 2007), Nyland J.
22.
R v Duncan [2010] NSWSC 615.
23.
R v Falls, unreported, Supreme Court of Queensland, 1 June 2010, Applegarth J.
24.
R v Ferguson [2008] NSWSC 761.
25.
R v Graveline, [2006] 1 SCR 609.
26.
R v Hernando, 2009 MNQB 214.
27.
R v Kelly (2003), unreported, NSWSC, 6 August 2003, Newman AJ.
28.
R v Kennedy [2000] NSWSC 109.
29.
R v King, HC Hamilton, CRI 2004-019-003825, 16 December 2005.
30.
R v Kirkwood [2000] NSWSC 184.
31.
R v Kontinnen, unreported, Supreme Court of South Australia, 30 March 1992.
32.
R v Lavallee, [1990] 1 SCR 852.
33.
R v MacDonald (2006), unreported, VSC, 3 March 2006, Nettle J.
34.
R v Mabbott [2002] NSWSC 502.
35.
R v Mahari, HC Rotorua, CRI 2006-070-8179, 14 November 2007.
36.
R v Melrose [2001] NSWSC 847 revised – 14/-5/2002.
37.
R v Mercy [2004] NSWSC 472.
38.
R v Morgan (2005), unreported, NSWSC, 16 June 2005, Wood J.
39.
R v Neale, HC Auckland, CRI-2007-004-3059, 12 June 2009.
40.
R v Pétel, [1994] 1 SCR 3.
41.
R v Rain (2000), unreported, Alta QB, 27-31 March 2000, Belzil, J.
42.
R v Reti [2009] NZCA 271.
43.
R v Russell [2006] NSWSC 722.
44.
R v Scott [2003] NSWSC 627.
45.
R v Secretary [1996] 5 NTLR 96.
46.
R v Spurr (2005), unreported, NSWSC, 16 June 2005, Wood J.
47.
R v Stephens, HC Whangarei, T 01 1676, 8-12 April 2002.
48.
R v Stjernqvist, unreported, Northern Territory Circuit Court, 18 June 1996.
49.
R v Tassone, unreported, Supreme Court of the Northern Territory, 20 April 1994.
50.
R v Trevenna [2003] NSWSC 463.
51.
R v Wickham HC Auckland, CRI 2009-090010723, October 2010.
52.
R v Wright (2002), unreported, NSWSC, 26 June 2002, Hulme J.
53.
R v Yeoman [2003] NSWSC 194.
54.
Zecevic v DPP (1987) 162 CLR 645.
55.
Ratushny, Her Honour Judge L (1997) The Self-Defence Review: Final Report, Submitted to the Minister of Justice and the Solicitor General of Canada.
56.
Rupert J (2003) Gil ‘relieved’ as Crown drops murder charge. The Ottawa Citizen, 8 August, B1.
57.
SeuffertN (1997) Battered women and self-defenc?New Zealand Universities Law Review17: 292–328.
58.
SheehyE (2001) Battered women and mandatory minimum sentencin?Osgoode Hall Law Journal39: 529–551.
59.
Sheehy E, Stubbs J and Tolmie J (forthcoming) Defences to homicide for battered women: A comparative analysis of laws in Australia, Canada and New Zealand. Sydney Law Review (accepted March 2012).
60.
StarkE (2007) Coercive Control. New York: Oxford University Press.
61.
Statistics New Zealand, (2008) Measuring New Zealand’s Progress Using a Sustainable Development Approach. Available at: www.stats.govt.nz (last accessed 20 April 2012).
62.
StubbsJTolmieJ (2005) Defending battered women on charges of homicide: The structural and systemic versus the personal and particula? In: ChanWChunnDEMenziesR (eds) Women, Madness and the Law: A Feminist Reader. London: Glasshouse Press, pp. 191–210.
63.
StubbsJTolmieJ (2008) Battered women charged with homicide: Advancing the interests of indigenous wome?Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology41(1): 138–161.
64.
US Department of Justice and US Department of Health and Human Services (1996) The Validity and Use of Evidence Concerning Battering and Its Effects in Criminal Trials: Report Responding to Section 40507 of the Violence Against Women Act.
65.
Victorian Law Reform Commission (VLRC) (2004) Defences to Homicide, Final Report. Melbourne: VLRC.
66.
Victorian Department of Justice (2010) Review of the Offence of Defensive Homicide Discussion Paper. Melbourne: Victorian Dept of Justice.
67.
Virueda M and Payne J (2010) Homicide in Australia: 2007–08 National Homicide Monitoring Program Annual Report, Monitoring Reports No. 13 Canberra, Australian Institute of Criminology.
