This article uses the transcripts from an abused woman’s trial in Canada for first-degree murder of her husband to explore the expert testimony provided by Dr Evan Stark to support a potential defence of self-defence. His evidence focused on coercive control theory and provoked extreme resistance from Crown prosecutors, such that self-defence was ultimately removed from the jury’s consideration. The trial illustrates the advantages and challenges of using coercive control theory as well as its future potential.
BaronE (2006) Death of ‘bully’ not a surprise to many people. The [British Columbia] Province, 4April, A3.
2.
CampbellJCWebsterDKoziol-McLainJ, et al. (2003) Risk factors for femicide in abusive relationships: Results from a multisite case control study. American Journal of Public Health93(7): 1089–1097.
3.
Canada (1985) Criminal Code. Revised Statutes, c. C-46, s. 34.
4.
Canada (2012) An Act to Amend the Criminal Code (citizen’s arrest and the defence of property and persons). Statutes of Canada, c. 9, s. 34.
5.
CloughP (2006) BC islanders come to aid of accused. The Ottawa Citizen, 3July, C1.
6.
GoodmanLEpsteinD (2008) Listening to Battered Women: A Survivor-Centered Approach to Advocacy, Mental Health, and Justice. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
7.
HannaC (2009) The paradox of progress: Translating Evan Stark’s coercive control into legal doctrine for abused women. Violence Against Women15(12): 1458–1476.
8.
MacDonnellV (2013) The new self-defence law: Progressive development or status quo?Canadian Bar Review92: 301–326.
9.
MidsonB (2016) Coercive control and criminal responsibility: Victims who kill their abusers. Criminal Law Forum27: 414–442.
10.
OgleRJacobsS (2002) Self-Defense and Battered Women Who Kill: A New Framework. Westport, CT: Praeger.
11.
ParfettJ (2001) Beyond Battered Woman Syndrome evidence: An alternative approach to the use of abuse evidence in spousal homicide cases. Windsor Review of Legal & Social Issues12: 55–96.
12.
R v Craig (2008) Trial transcript. Ottawa: Superior Court of Ontario, 14April–15June, 37 volumes.
13.
R v Craig (2011) Ontario Court of Appeal Decision No. 142.
14.
R v Lavallee (1990) Supreme Court Reports 1: 842.
15.
R v Morgentaler (1988) Supreme Court Reports 1: 30.
16.
RandallM (2004) Domestic violence and the construction of the ‘ideal victim’: Assaulted women’s ‘image problems’ in law. St Louis University Public Law Review23: 107–154.
17.
SheehyE (2014) Defending Battered Women on Trial: Lessons from the Transcripts. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press.
18.
StarkE (1995) Re-presenting woman battering: From Battered Woman Syndrome to coercive control. Albany Law Review58(4): 973–1026.
19.
StarkE (1999–2000) A failure to protect: Unraveling ‘the battered mother’s dilemma’. Wayne State University Law Review27: 29–110.
20.
StarkE (2007) Coercive Control: How Men Entrap Women in Personal Life. New York: Oxford University Press.
