This study presents a cost analysis of and comparison between laser cordotomy and external beam irradiation for the treatment of early glottic carcinoma. It compares the curative results of the two modalities from data of a retrospective study at my institution and a literature review of published cure rates. It also reviews the results of objective voice assessments in cases representing both treatments. The findings of this study indicate that the cure rates are equivalent and that voice quality obtained after laser cordotomy is comparable to that obtained after irradiation, yet the total cost of external beam radiotherapy is significantly higher than that of laser surgery. Hence, the findings of this study provide strong support for initially treating early glottic tumors with laser surgery.
US Bureau of Labor Statistics. Consumer Price Index, December 1997. Washington, DC: US Department of Labor, 1997.
2.
LynchRC. Intrinsic carcinoma of the larynx with a second report of the cases operated on by suspension and dissection. Trans Am Laryngol Assoc1920; 42: 119–26.
3.
LillieJCDeSantoLW. Transoral surgery of early cordal carcinoma. Trans Am Acad Ophthalmol Otolaryngol1973; 77: ORL92–ORL96.
4.
StrongMSJakoGJ. Laser surgery in the larynx. Early clinical experience with continuous CO2 laser. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol1972; 81: 791–8.
5.
VaughanDWStrongMSShapshaySM. Treatment of T1 and in situ glottic carcinoma: The transoral approach. Otolaryngol Clin North Am1980; 13: 509–13.
6.
DavisRKJakoGJHyamsVJShapshaySM. The anatomic limitations of CO2 laser cordectomy. Laryngoscope1982; 92: 980–4.
7.
BlakesleeDVaughanCWShapshaySMSimpsonGTStrongMS. Excisional biopsy in the selective management of T1 glottic cancer: A three-year follow-up study. Laryngoscope1984; 94: 488–94.
8.
LehmanJJBlessDMBrandenburgJH. An objective assessment of voice production after radiation therapy for stage I squamous cell carcinoma of the glottis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1988; 98: 121–9.
9.
CragleSPBrandenburgJH. Laser cordectomy or radiotherapy: Cure rates, communication, and cost. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1993; 108: 648–54.
10.
FooteRLBuskirkSJGradoGLBonnerJA. Has radiotherapy become too expensive to be considered a treatment option for early glottic cancer?Head Neck1997; 19: 692–700.
11.
MorrisMRCanonicoDBlankC. A critical review of radiotherapy in the management of T1 glottic carcinoma. Am J Otolaryngol1994; 15: 276–80.
12.
KaiserTNSessionsDGHarveyJE. Natural history of treated T1N0 squamous carcinoma of the glottis. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol1989; 98: 217–9.
13.
JoseBCalhounDLMohammedA. Recurrences after irradiation in early vocal cord cancer with literature review. J Surg Oncol1984; 27: 224–7.
14.
WoodhouseRJQuiveyJMFuKKSienPSDedoHHPhillipsTL. Treatment of carcinoma of the vocal cord: A review of 20 years experience. Laryngoscope1981; 91: 1155–62.
15.
MittalBRaoDVMarksJEPerezCA. Role of radiation in the management of early vocal cord carcinoma. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys1983; 9: 997–1002.
16.
Van Den BogaertWOstynFVan Der SchuerenE. Glottic carcinoma limited to the vocal cords. Acta Radiol Oncol1982; 21: 33–7.
17.
MinjaBMvan den BroekPHuygenPLKazemI. Primary radiation therapy for T1 glottic cancer. Factors influencing local control. Clin Otolaryngol1984; 9: 93–8.
18.
FletcherGH. Textbook of radiotherapy. 3rd ed.Philadelphia, Pa: Lea and Febiger, 1980: 330–63.
19.
HarwoodAR. Cancer of the larynx — the Toronto experience. J Otolaryngol1982; 11(suppl 11): 1–21.
20.
WetmoreSJKeyJMSuenJY. Laser therapy for T1 glottic carcinoma of the larynx. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1986; 112: 853–5.
21.
KoufmanJA. The endoscopic management of early squamous carcinoma of the vocal cord with the carbon dioxide surgical laser: Clinical experience and a proposed subclassification. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1986; 95: 531–7.
22.
ElnerAFexS. Carbon dioxide laser as primary treatment of glottic T1S and T1A tumours. Acta Otolaryngol Suppl (Stockh)1988(suppl 449): 135–9.
23.
SteinerW. Results of curative laser microsurgery of laryngeal carcinomas. Am J Otolaryngol1993; 14: 116–21.
24.
MyersENWagnerRLJohnsonJT. Microlaryngoscopic surgery for T1 glottic lesions: A cost-effective option. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol1994; 103: 28–30.
25.
ThomasJVOlsenKDNeelHBIIIDeSantoLWSumanVJ. Recurrences after endoscopic management of early (T1) glottic carcinoma. Laryngoscope1994; 104: 1099–104.
26.
WolfensbergerMDortJC. Endoscopic laser surgery for early glottic carcinoma: A clinical and experimental study. Laryngoscope1990; 100: 1100–5.
27.
DelsupeheKGZinkILejaegereMBastianRW. Voice quality after narrow-margin laser cordectomy compared with laryngeal irradiation. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1999; 121: 528–33.
28.
McGuirtWFBlacockDKoufmanJA. Comparative voice results after laser resection or irradiation of T1 vocal cord carcinoma. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg1994; 120: 951–5.
29.
HoffmanHTKarnellLH. Laryngeal cancer. In: SteeleGDJessupJMWinchesterDPMenckHRMurphyGPNational Cancer Data Base Annual Review of Patient Care 1995. Atlanta, Ga: American Cancer Society, 1995: 84–99.
