Asian Americans, even those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, achieve extraordinary educational outcomes, defying the expectations of the well-established status attainment theory that family background is strongly associated with educational attainments. This phenomenon is known as the Asian American Achievement Paradox (AAAP). Positive selectivity of Asian immigrants and cultural accounts are two competing explanations, but they are rarely disentangled empirically due to the high collinearity between immigrant selectivity and culture. This study offers a modified version of cultural explanations, clarifies the distinctions between competing explanations based on the same criteria, and tests them by investigating the educational achievements of second-generation Asian Americans using the full-count 1940 Census matched to the 1930 Census. During this period, Asian immigrants were not hyper-selected, so the entanglement of immigrant selectivity and culture is less of a concern. The results are largely consistent with the cultural explanation, revealing the AAAP to be a century-old phenomenon with a previously unknown complexity. The transmission of culture from the society of origin is further evident in that the AAAP is limited to East Asians and does not apply to Filipino Americans, even though contextual selectivity in education is similar across Asian ethnic groups in 1940.
AbadaTeresaHouFengRamBali. 2009. “Ethnic Differences in Educational Attainment among the Children of Canadian Immigrants.” Canadian Journal of Sociology34:1–28.
2.
AcharyaAviditBlackwellMatthewSenMaya. 2016. “The Political Legacy of American Slavery.” The Journal of Politics78:621–41.
3.
AlesinaAlbertoGiulianoPaola. 2015. “Culture and Institutions.” Journal of Economic Literature53:898–944.
4.
AokiKeith. 1998. “No Right to Own: The Early Twentieth-Century ‘Alien Land Laws’ as a Prelude to Internment.” Boston College Law Review40:37–72.
5.
AshrafJaved. 1994. “Differences in Returns to Education: An Analysis by Race.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology53:281–90.
6.
BarroRobert J.LeeJong Wha. 2013. “A New Data Set of Educational Attainment in the World, 1950–2010.” Journal of Development Economics104:184–98.
7.
BarrowLisaRouseCecilia Elena. 2005. “Do Returns to Schooling Differ by Race and Ethnicity?” American Economic Review95:83–87.
8.
BenolielPascaleBerkovichIzhak. 2018. “A Cross-National Examination of the Effect of the Schwartz Cultural Dimensions on PISA Performance Assessments.” Social Indicators Research139:825–45.
9.
BisinAlbertoVerdierThierry. 2001. “The Economics of Cultural Transmission and the Dynamics of Preferences.” Journal of Economic Theory97:298–319.
10.
BlauPeter M.DuncanOtis Dudley. 1967. The American Occupational Structure. New York: The Free Press.
11.
BonacichEdna. 1973. “A Theory of Middleman Minorities.” American Sociological Review38:583–94.
12.
BonacichEdnaModellJohn. 1980. The Economic Basis of Ethnic Solidarity: Small Business in the Japanese American Community. Berkeley: University of California Press.
13.
BucciAlbertoSegreGiovanna. 2011. “Culture and Human Capital in a Two-Sector Endogenous Growth Model.” Research in Economics65:279–93.
14.
CagéJuliaRuedaValeria. 2016. “The Long-Term Effects of the Printing Press in Sub-Saharan Africa.” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics8:69–99.
15.
CaicedoFelipe Valencia. 2019. “The Mission: Human Capital Transmission, Economic Persistence, and Culture in South America.” Quarterly Journal of Economics134:507–56.
16.
CalviRossellaHoehn-VelascoLaurenMantovanelliFederico G.2022. “The Protestant Legacy: Missions, Gender, and Human Capital in India.” Journal of Human Resources57:1946–80.
17.
ChenTingKungJames Kai-singMaChicheng. 2020. “Long Live Keju! The Persistent Effects of China’s Civil Examination System.” Economic Journal130:2030–64.
18.
ChouRosalind S.FeaginJoe R.2015. The Myth of the Model Minority: Asian Americans Facing Racism. New York: Routledge.
19.
ChoyCatherine Ceniza. 2022. Asian American Histories of the United States. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
20.
CioniMartinaFedericoGiovanniVastaMichelangelo. 2022. “Persistence Studies: A New Kind of Economic History?” Review of Regional Research42:227–48.
21.
CironeAlexandraPepinskyThomas B.2022. “Historical Persistence.” Annual Review of Political Science25:241–59.
22.
DiMaggioPaul. 1982. “Cultural Capital and School Success: The Impact of Status Culture Participation on the Grades of U.S. High School Students.” American Sociological Review47:189–201.
23.
DulayDean C.2022. “The Search for Spices and Souls: Catholic Missions as Colonial State in the Philippines.” Comparative Political Studies55:2050–85.
24.
EspirituYen Le. 1992. Asian American Panethnicity: Bridging Institutions and Identities. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
25.
FelicianoCynthia. 2005. “Does Selective Migration Matter? Explaining Ethnic Disparities in Educational Attainment among Immigrants’ Children.” International Migration Review39:841–71.
26.
FelicianoCynthia. 2020. “Immigrant Selectivity Effects on Health, Labor Market, and Educational Outcomes.” Annual Review of Sociology46:315–34.
27.
FelicianoCynthiaLanuzaYader R.2017. “An Immigrant Paradox? Contextual Attainment and Intergenerational Educational Mobility.” American Sociological Review82:211–41.
28.
FiglioDavidÖzekUmut. 2020. “Cross-Generational Differences in Educational Outcomes in the Second Great Wave of Immigration.” Education Finance and Policy15:648–74.
29.
FishmanSamuel H.2020. “Educational Mobility among the Children of Asian American Immigrants.” American Journal of Sociology126:260–317.
30.
GambolBrenda. 2023. “Multi-Dimensional Hyper-Selectivity and Divergent Mobilities: Second-Generation Filipinos and Chinese.” Ethnic and Racial Studies46:898–920.
31.
GiannelliGianna ClaudiaRapalliniChiara. 2016. “Immigrant Student Performance in Math: Does It Matter Where You Come From?” Economics of Education Review52:291–304.
32.
GiavazziFrancescoPetkovIvanSchiantarelliFabio. 2019. “Culture: Persistence and Evolution.” Journal of Economic Growth24:117–54.
33.
GillbornDavidGippsC. V.1996. Recent Research on the Achievements of Ethnic Minority Pupils. London, UK: H.M. Stationery Office.
34.
GoldbergerArthur Stanley. 1991. A Course in Econometrics. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
35.
GoyetteKimberlyXieYu. 1999. “Educational Expectations of Asian American Youths: Determinants and Ethnic Differences.” Sociology of Education72:22–36.
36.
GreenmanEmily. 2013. “Educational Attitudes, School Peer Context, and the ‘Immigrant Paradox’ in Education.” Social Science Research42:698–714.
HanushekEric A.KinneLaviniaLegetporerPhilippWoessmannLudger. 2022. “Patience, Risk-Taking, and Human Capital Investment across Countries.” Economic Journal132:2290–307.
39.
HarrisAngel L.JamisonKenneth M.TrujilloMonica H.2008. “Disparities in the Educational Success of Immigrants: An Assessment of the Immigrant Effect for Asians and Latinos.” ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science620:90–114.
40.
HelgertzJonasRugglesStevenWarrenJohn RobertFitchCatherine A.GoekenRonaldHackerJ. DavidNelsonMatt A.PriceJoseph P.RobertsEvanSobekMatthew. 2020. “IPUMS Multigenerational Longitudinal Panel: Version 1.0 [dataset].” Minneapolis: University of Minnesota.
41.
HenrichJoseph. 2020. The WEIRDest People in the World: How the West Became Psychologically Peculiar and Particularly Prosperous. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
42.
HilgerNathaniel. 2016. “Upward Mobility and Discrimination: The Case of Asian Americans.” NBER Working Paper w22748 (https://doi.org/10.3386/w22748).
43.
HirschmanCharlesWongMorrison G.1986. “The Extraordinary Educational Attainment of Asian-Americans: A Search for Historical Evidence and Explanations.” Social Forces65:1–27.
HsinAmyXieYu. 2014. “Explaining Asian Americans’ Academic Advantage Over Whites.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America111:8416–21.
46.
HuntJenniferNunnRyan. 2019. “Is Employment Polarization Informative about Wage Inequality and Is Employment Really Polarizing?” NBER Working Paper w26064.
47.
JerrimJohn. 2015. “Why Do East Asian Children Perform So Well in PISA? An Investigation of Western-Born Children of East Asian Descent.” Oxford Review of Education41:310–33.
48.
KaoGraceTiendaMarta. 1998. “Educational Aspirations of Minority Youth.” American Journal of Education106:349–84.
49.
KiharaTate. 2022. “Socioeconomic Selectivity of Japanese Migration to the Continental United States during the Age of Mass Migration.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies48:2577–600.
50.
KiharaTate. 2024. “Social Mobility across the Pacific: An Analysis of Japanese Americans in the Continental United States.” Demography61:849–78.
51.
KimChangHwanKimAndrew Taeho. 2023. “Is Hyper-Selectivity a Root of Asian American Children’s Success?” Social Science Research113:102886.
52.
KimChangHwanKimAndrew Taeho. 2024. “Persistent Educational Advantages of Asian Immigrants’ Children, 1940 to 2015–2019.” International Migration Review (https://doi.org/10.1177/01979183241267983).
53.
KimChangHwanZhaoYang. 2014. “Are Asian American Women Advantaged? Labor Market Performance of College Educated Female Workers.” Social Forces93:623–52.
54.
KitanoHarry H. L.SueStanley. 1973. “The Model Minorities.” Journal of Social Issues29:1–9.
55.
LandesDavid S.1999. The Wealth and Poverty of Nations: Why Some Are So Rich and Some So Poor. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.
56.
LankinaTomilaGetachewLullit. 2012. “Mission or Empire, Word or Sword? The Human Capital Legacy in Postcolonial Democratic Development.” American Journal of Political Science56:465–83.
57.
LareauAnnetteWeiningerElliot B.2003. “Cultural Capital in Educational Research: A Critical Assessment.” Theory and Society32:567–606.
58.
LeeErika. 2016. The Making of Asian America: A History. New York: Simon & Schuster.
59.
LeeJenniferGoyetteKimberlySongXiXieYu. 2024. “Presumed Competent: The Strategic Adaptation of Asian Americans in Education and the Labor Market.” Annual Review of Sociology50:455–74.
60.
LeeJenniferZhouMin. 2015. The Asian American Achievement Paradox. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
61.
LeeJenniferZhouMin. 2020. “The Reigning Misperception about Culture and Asian American Achievement.” Ethnic and Racial Studies43:508–15.
62.
LeeJong-WhaLeeHanol. 2016. “Human Capital in the Long Run.” Journal of Development Economics122:147–69.
63.
LeeJoung-HunIwasaYohDieckmannUlfSigmundKarl. 2019. “Social Evolution Leads to Persistent Corruption.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America116:13276–281.
64.
LevelsMarkDronkersJaap. 2008. “Educational Performance of Native and Immigrant Children from Various Countries of Origin.” Ethnic and Racial Studies31:1404–25.
65.
LevineGene N.MonteroDarrel M.1973. “Socioeconomic Mobility among Three Generations of Japanese Americans.” Journal of Social Issues29:33–48.
66.
LiuAiranXieYu. 2016. “Why Do Asian Americans Academically Outperform Whites? The Cultural Explanation Revisited.” Social Science Research58:210–26.
67.
LiuJohn M.OngPaul M.RosensteinCarolyn. 1991. “Dual Chain Migration: Post-1965 Filipino Immigration to the United States.” International Migration Review25:487–513.
68.
LouieVivian. 2001. “Parents’ Aspirations and Investment: The Role of Social Class in the Educational Experiences of 1.5- and Second-Generation Chinese Americans.” Harvard Educational Review71:438–74.
69.
MaiaAlexandre GoriSakamotoArthurWangSharron Xuanren. 2015. “Socioeconomic Attainments of Japanese Brazilians and Japanese Americans.” Sociology of Race and Ethnicity1:547–63.
70.
MinPyong Gap, ed. 2006a. Asian Americans: Contemporary Trends and Issues. London, UK: Sage Publications.
71.
MinPyong Gap. 2006b. “Asian Immigration: History and Contemporary Trends.” Pp. 7–31 in Asian Americans: Contemporary Trends and Issues, edited by MinP. G.London, UK: Sage Publications.
72.
MinPyong Gap. 2008. Ethnic Solidarity for Economic Survival: Korean Greengrocers in New York City. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
73.
NunnNathan. 2010. “Religious Conversion in Colonial Africa.” American Economic Review100:147–52.
74.
OkuraKeitaro. 2022. “Stereotype Promise: Racialized Teacher Appraisals of Asian American Academic Achievement.” Sociology of Education95:302–19.
75.
ParkHoon. 2014. How Was the Meiji Restoration Possible?Seoul, South Korea: Seoul National University Press.
76.
PetersenWilliam. 1971. Japanese Americans: Oppression and Success. New York: Random House.
77.
PidoEric J.2016. “Property Relations: Alien Land Laws and the Racial Formation of Filipinos as Aliens Ineligible to Citizenship.” Ethnic and Racial Studies39:1205–22.
78.
PolaviejaJavier G.2015. “Capturing Culture: A New Method to Estimate Exogenous Cultural Effects Using Migrant Populations.” American Sociological Review80:166–91.
79.
SakamotoArthurGoyetteKimberly A.KimChanghwan. 2009. “Socioeconomic Attainments of Asian Americans.” Annual Review of Sociology35:255–76.
80.
SakamotoArthurKimChangHwanTakeiIsao. 2012. “The Japanese-American Family.” Pp. 252–76 in Ethnic Families in America: Patterns and Variations, edited by WrightR.Jr.MindelC. H.Van TranT.HabensteinR. W.Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education.
81.
SakamotoArthurWangSharron Xuanren. 2021. “Deconstructing Hyper-Selectivity: Are the Socioeconomic Attainments of Second-Generation Asian Americans Only Due to Their Class Background?” Chinese Journal of Sociology7:3–21.
82.
SchneiderBarbaraLeeYongsook. 1990. “A Model for Academic Success: The School and Home Environment of East Asian Students.” Anthropology & Education Quarterly21:358–77.
83.
SewellWilliam H.1992. “A Theory of Structure: Duality, Agency, and Transformation.” American Journal of Sociology98:1–29.
84.
ShamsTahseen. 2020. “Successful Yet Precarious: South Asian Muslim Americans, Islamophobia, and the Model Minority Myth.” Sociological Perspectives63:653–69.
85.
ShiaoJiannbin Lee. 2024. “Over-Educated or Overly Invested in Education? The Role of Educational Commitment in Asian American Socioeconomic Attainment.” Race and Social Problems16:167–84.
86.
SueStanleyKitanoHarry H. L.1973. “Stereotypes as a Measure of Success.” Journal of Social Issues29:83–98.
87.
TakakiRonald T.1998. Strangers from a Different Shore: A History of Asian Americans, Updated and Revised. New York: Back Bay Books.
88.
TalhelmThomasZhangXueminOishiShigehiroShiminChenDuanDongyuanLanXuezhaoKitayamaShinobu. 2014. “Large-Scale Psychological Differences within China Explained by Rice versus Wheat Agriculture.” Science344:603–08.
89.
TongGuangyuHarrisAngel L.2021. “Immigrant Selectivity, Academic Culture and College Enrollment among Asian Americans.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies47:4058–80.
90.
TongGuangyuPersonsEmilyHarrisAngel L.2021. “Getting Ready Ahead: Socioeconomic Status and Parenting Strategies among Chinese Adolescents with Emigration Intentions.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies47:4405–27.
91.
TramonteLuciaWillmsJ. Douglas. 2010. “Cultural Capital and Its Effects on Education Outcomes.” Economics of Education Review29:200–213.
92.
TranVan C.LeeJenniferHuangTiffany J.2019. “Revisiting the Asian Second-Generation Advantage.” Ethnic and Racial Studies42:2248–69.
93.
U.S. Census Bureau. 1943. “1940 Census of Population: Characteristics of the Nonwhite Population by Race.” U.S. Census Bureau, Washington, DC.
94.
van de WerfhorstHerman G.2010. “Cultural Capital: Strengths, Weaknesses and Two Advancements.” British Journal of Sociology of Education31:157–69.
95.
WaldingerMaria. 2017. “The Long-Run Effects of Missionary Orders in Mexico.” Journal of Development Economics127:355–78.
96.
WeberMax. 1958. “The Chinese Literati.” Pp. 416–44 in From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. New York: Oxford University Press.
97.
WeinbergMeyer. 1997. Asian American Education: Historical Background and Current Realities. New York: Routledge.
98.
WeinbergerCatherine J.1998. “Race and Gender Wage Gaps in the Market for Recent College Graduates.” Industrial Relations37:67–84.
99.
WilliamsonJoy AnnRhodesLoriDunsonMichael. 2007. “A Selected History of Social Justice in Education.” Review of Research in Education31:195–224.
100.
WoodberryRobert D.2012. “The Missionary Roots of Liberal Democracy.” American Political Science Review106:244–74.
101.
XieYuGoyetteKimberly. 2003. “Social Mobility and the Educational Choices of Asian Americans.” Social Science Research32:467–98.
102.
ZhouMin. 1992. Chinatown: The Socioeconomic Potential of an Urban Enclave. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
103.
ZhouMinLeeJennifer. 2017. “Hyper-Selectivity and the Remaking of Culture: Understanding the Asian American Achievement Paradox.” Asian American Journal of Psychology8:7–15.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
