Labor historians describe Right to Work (RTW) as among the most consequential pushbacks against the early twentieth-century ascent of labor unions. Yet research on the economic consequences of RTW remains mixed, with nearly all research centered empirically and theoretically on the time surrounding RTW passage. In the current study, I use 41 waves of longitudinal data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics between 1968 and 2019 to empirically and theoretically extend the mechanisms that link RTW and economic outcomes. First, following the vast majority of research on RTW, I show the demobilizing effects for labor following RTW passage: mean wages decline, wage inequality increases, and the union premium is halved in the middle and lower portion of the wage distribution. Second, I move theoretical focus beyond the time surrounding law enactment, arguing for a second-order effect whereby RTW institutionalizes a logic of polarized economic distributions and low labor power. To test this mechanism, I develop a novel strategy of comparison across respondents who are differentially mobile across state boundaries. I find individuals who cross RTW contexts experience a unique decline in mean wages and increase in wage variance, but this distinct trend can be explained by state-level institutional variation across RTW and non-RTW states. Thus, RTW is not only consequential in the periods around its passage, but also in establishing a long-standing, high-inequality regime. Results reveal multiple mechanisms by which RTW contributes to the long-run processes of union decline and broadly shared inequality growth.
BorjasGeorge J.2019. Labor Economics. New York: McGraw-Hill Education.
4.
BorusyakKirillJaravelXavierSpiess.Jann2021. “Revisiting Event Study Designs: Robust and Efficient Estimation.” arXiv preprint (https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2108.12419).
5.
BradleyDavidHuberEvelyneMollerStephanieNielsenFrançoisStephensJohn D.2003. “Distribution and Redistribution in Postindustrial Democracies.”World Politics55(2):193–228.
6.
BradyDavidBakerRegina S.FinniganRyan. 2013. “When Unionization Disappears: State-Level Unionization and Working Poverty in the United States.”American Sociological Review78(5):872–96.
7.
BradyDavidBlomeAgnesKleiderHanna. 2016. “How Politics and Institutions Shape Poverty and Inequality.” Pp. 117–40 in The Oxford Handbook of the Social Science of Poverty, edited by BradyD.BurtonL. M.New York: Oxford University Press.
8.
BucciLaura C.2018. “Organized Labor’s Check on Rising Economic Inequality in the U.S. States.”State Politics & Policy Quarterly18(2):148–73.
9.
CardDavidLemieuxThomasRiddellW. Craig. 2004. “Unions and Wage Inequality.”Journal of Labor Research25(4):519–59.
10.
CaugheyDevinWarshawChristopher. 2016. “The Dynamics of State Policy Liberalism, 1936–2014.”American Journal of Political Science60(4):899–913.
11.
ChavaSudheerDanisAndrásHsuAlex. 2020. “The Economic Impact of Right-to-Work Laws: Evidence from Collective Bargaining Agreements and Corporate Policies.”Journal of Financial Economics137(2):451–69.
12.
ChettyRajFriedmanJohnHendrenNathanielJonesMaggiePorterSonya. 2018. “The Opportunity Atlas: Mapping the Childhood Roots of Social Mobility.”Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research (https://doi.org/10.3386/w25147).
13.
ClawsonDanClawsonMary Ann. 1999. “What Has Happened to the US Labor Movement? Union Decline and Renewal.”Annual Review of Sociology25:95–119.
14.
ClemensElisabethCookJames. 1999. “Politics and Institutionalism: Explaining Durability and Change.”Annual Review of Sociology25:441–66.
15.
CollinsBenjamin. 2014. “Right to Work Laws: Legislative Background and Empirical Research.” Congressional Report for Congress, 7–5700.
16.
De LeonCedric. 2015. The Origins of Right to Work: Antilabor Democracy in Nineteenth-Century Chicago. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
17.
DenicePatrickRosenfeldJake. 2018. “Unions and Nonunion Pay in the United States, 1977–2015.”Sociological Science5:541–61.
18.
DevinatzVictor G.2011. “The Continuing Controversy over Right-to-Work Laws in the Early Twenty-First Century.”Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal23(4):287–93.
19.
DiMaggioPaulGoldbergAmir. 2018. “Searching for Homo Economicus: Variation in Americans’ Construals of and Attitudes toward Markets.”European Journal of Sociology59(2):151–89.
20.
DiNardoJohnHallockKevinPischkeJorn-Steffen. 1997. “Unions and Managerial Pay.” National Bureau of Economic Research (https://ssrn.com/abstract=226072).
21.
DixonMarc. 2007. “Limiting Labor: Business Political Mobilization and Union Setback in the States.”Journal of Policy History19(3):313–44.
22.
DixonMarc. 2008. “Movements, Countermovements and Policy Adoption: The Case of Right-to-Work Activism.”Social Forces87(1):473–500.
23.
DixonMarc. 2020. Heartland Blues: Labor Rights in the Industrial Midwest. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
24.
DubeArindrajit. 2019. “Minimum Wages and the Distribution of Family Incomes.”American Economic Journal: Applied Economics11(4):268–304.
25.
EidlinBarry. 2018. Labor and the Class Idea in the United States and Canada. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
26.
EllwoodDavid T.FineGlenn. 1987. “The Impact of Right-to-Work Laws on Union Organizing.”Journal of Political Economy95(2):250–73.
27.
ErenOzkanOzbeklikSerkan. 2016. “What Do Right-to-Work Laws Do? Evidence from a Synthetic Control Method Analysis.”Journal of Policy Analysis and Management35(1):173–94.
28.
FarberHenry S.1984. “Right-to-Work Laws and the Extent of Unionization.”Journal of Labor Economics2(3):319–52.
29.
FarberHenry S.1986. “The Analysis of Union Behavior.”Handbook of Labor Economics2:1039–89.
30.
FarberHenry S.HerbstDanielKuziemkoIlyanaNaiduSuresh. 2018. “Unions and Inequality over the Twentieth Century: New Evidence from Survey Data.”Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research (https://doi.org/10.3386/w24587).
31.
FarhangSeanKatznelsonIra. 2005. “The Southern Imposition: Congress and Labor in the New Deal and Fair Deal.”Studies in American Political Development19(1):1–30.
32.
FeigenbaumJamesHertel-FernandezAlexanderWilliamsonVanessa. 2018. “From the Bargaining Table to the Ballot Box: Political Effects of Right to Work Laws.”Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research (https://doi.org/10.3386/w24259).
FirpoSergio P.FortinNicole M.LemieuxThomas. 2018. “Decomposing Wage Distributions Using Recentered Influence Function Regressions.”Econometrics6(2):28 (https://doi.org/10.3390/econometrics6020028).
35.
FortinNicole M.LemieuxThomasFirpoSergio. 2011. “Decomposition Methods in Economics.” Pp. 1–102 in Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 4, edited by AshenfelterO.CardD.Amsterdam: Elsevier.
36.
FortinNicole M.LemieuxThomasLloydNeil. 2021. “Labor Market Institutions and the Distribution of Wages: The Role of Spillover Effects.”Journal of Labor Economics39(S2):S369–412.
GlaeserEdward. 2011. Triumph of the City: How Our Greatest Invention Makes Us Richer, Smarter, Greener, Healthier, and Happier. New York: Penguin.
41.
Goodman-BaconAndrew. 2021. “Difference-in-Differences with Variation in Treatment Timing.”Journal of Econometrics225(2):254–77.
42.
GouskovaElenaAndreskiPatriciaSchoeniRobert F.2010. “Comparing Estimates of Family Income in the Panel Study of Income Dynamics and the March Current Population Survey, 1968–2007.” PSID Technical Series Paper #10-01.
43.
GranovetterMark. 1985. “Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness.”American Journal of Sociology91:481–510.
44.
GranovetterMark. 1995. “Coase Revisited: Business Groups in the Modern Economy.”Industrial and Corporate Change4(1):93–130.
45.
HackerJacob S.Hertel-FernandezAlexanderPiersonPaulThelenKathleen. 2022. “The American Political Economy: Markets, Power, and the Meta Politics of US Economic Governance.”Annual Review of Political Science25:197–217.
46.
HanleyCaroline. 2010. “Earnings Inequality and Subnational Political Economy in the United States, 1970–2000.”Research in Social Stratification and Mobility28(2):251–73.
47.
HeathcoteJonathanPerriFabrizioViolanteGiovanni L.2010. “Unequal We Stand: An Empirical Analysis of Economic Inequality in the United States, 1967–2006.”Review of Economic Dynamics13(1):15–51.
Hertel-FernandezAlexander. 2019a. “Asymmetric Partisan Polarization, Labor Policy, and Cross-State Political Power-Building.”ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science685(1):64–79.
50.
Hertel-FernandezAlexander. 2019b. State Capture: How Conservative Activists, Big Businesses, and Wealthy Donors Reshaped the American States—and the Nation. New York: Oxford University Press.
51.
HoglerRaymond L.2015. The End of American Labor Unions: The Right-to-Work Movement and the Erosion of Collective Bargaining. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger.
52.
HolmesThomas J.1998. “The Effect of State Policies on the Location of Manufacturing: Evidence from State Borders.”Journal of Political Economy106(4):667–705.
53.
HuberEvelyneStephensJohn D.2010. Development and Crisis of the Welfare State: Parties and Policies in Global Markets. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
54.
JacobsDavidDirlamJonathan C.2016. “Politics and Economic Stratification: Power Resources and Income Inequality in the United States.”American Journal of Sociology122(2):469–500.
55.
JacobsDavidDixonMarc. 2006. “The Politics of Labor-Management Relations: Detecting the Conditions That Affect Changes in Right-to-Work Laws.”Social Problems53(1):118–37.
56.
JacobsDavidMyersLindsey. 2014. “Union Strength, Neoliberalism, and Inequality: Contingent Political Analyses of U.S. Income Differences since 1950.”American Sociological Review79(4):752–74.
JeppersonRonald. 1991. “Institutions, Institutional Effects, and Institutionalism.” Pp. 143–63 in The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis, edited by PowellW. W.DiMaggioP. J.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
59.
JohnsonJanna E.KleinerMorris M.2020. “Is Occupational Licensing a Barrier to Interstate Migration?”American Economic Journal: Economic Policy12(3):347–73.
60.
JungJiwook. 2017. “A Struggle on Two Fronts: Labour Resistance to Changing Layoff Policies at Large US Companies.”Socio-Economic Review15(1):213–39.
61.
KerrisseyJasmine. 2015. “Collective Labor Rights and Income Inequality.”American Sociological Review80(3):626–53.
62.
KoganVladimir. 2017. “Do Anti-Union Policies Increase Inequality? Evidence from State Adoption of Right-to-Work Laws.”State Politics & Policy Quarterly17(2):180–200.
63.
KollmeyerChristopher. 2018. “Trade Union Decline, Deindustrialization, and Rising Income Inequality in the United States, 1947 to 2015.”Research in Social Stratification and Mobility57:1–10.
64.
KorpiWalter. 2005. “Power Resources and Employer-Centered Approaches in Explanations of Welfare States and Varieties of Capitalism: Protagonists, Consenters, and Antagonists.”World Politics58(2):167–206.
65.
KorpiWalter. 2018. The Democratic Class Struggle. New York: Routledge.
66.
KorpiWalterPalmeJoakim. 1998. “The Paradox of Redistribution and Strategies of Equality: Welfare State Institutions, Inequality, and Poverty in the Western Countries.”American Sociological Review63(5):661–87.
67.
KristalTali. 2010. “Good Times, Bad Times: Postwar Labor’s Share of National Income in Capitalist Democracies.”American Sociological Review75(5):729–63.
68.
KristalTaliCohenYinon. 2017. “The Causes of Rising Wage Inequality: The Race between Institutions and Technology.”Socio-Economic Review15(1):187–212.
69.
LeeSophia. 2012. “Whose Rights? Litigating the Right-to-Work, 1940–1980.” Pp. 160–80 in The Right and Labor in America, edited by LichtensteinN.ShermerE. T.Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
70.
LemieuxThomasMacLeodW. BentleyParentDaniel. 2009. “Performance Pay and Wage Inequality.”The Quarterly Journal of Economics124(1):1–49.
71.
LichtensteinNelsonShermerElizabeth Tandy. 2016. The Right and Labor in America: Politics, Ideology, and Imagination. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
72.
LobaoLinda. 2016a. “The Sociology of Subnational Development: Conceptual and Empirical Foundations.” Pp. 265–92 in The Sociology of Development Handbook, edited by HooksG.Berkeley: University of California Press (https://doi.org/10.1525/9780520963474-013).
73.
LobaoLinda. 2016b. “The Rising Importance of Local Government in the United States: Recent Research and Challenges for Sociology.”Sociology Compass10(10):893–905.
74.
MahlerVincent A.2008. “Electoral Turnout and Income Redistribution by the State: A Cross-national Analysis of the Developed Democracies.”European Journal of Political Research47(2):161–83.
75.
MarciukaityteDalia. 2015. “Right-to-Work Laws and Financial Leverage.”Financial Management44(1):147–75.
76.
MatsaDavid A.2010. “Capital Structure as a Strategic Variable: Evidence from Collective Bargaining.”The Journal of Finance65(3):1197–232.
77.
MontezJennifer KarasBeckfieldJasonCooneyJulene KempGrumbachJacob M.HaywardMark D.KoytakHuseyin ZeydWoolfSteven H.ZajacovaAnna. 2020. “US State Policies, Politics, and Life Expectancy.”The Milbank Quarterly98(3):668–99.
78.
MooreWilliam J.1998. “The Determinants and Effects of Right-to-Work Laws: A Review of the Recent Literature.”Journal of Labor Research19(3):445–69.
79.
MorettiEnrico. 2012. The New Geography of Jobs. New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
80.
MorettiEnrico. 2013. “Real Wage Inequality.”American Economic Journal: Applied Economics5(1):65–103.
81.
MurphyKevin J.2023. “What Are the Consequences of Right-to-Work for Union Membership?”ILR Review76(2):412–33.
82.
NRTW. 2021. “Janus v. AFSCME: A Case to Protect Public Employees’ First Amendment Rights.”National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation (https://www.nrtw.org/janus/).
83.
OliverChristine. 1992. “The Antecedents of Deinstitutionalization.”Organization Studies13(4):563–88.
84.
ParolinZacharyVanHeuvelenTom. 2023. “The Cumulative Advantage of a Unionized Career for Lifetime Earnings.”ILR Review76(2):434–60.
85.
PiersonPaul. 2004. Politics in Time: History, Institutions, and Social Analysis. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
86.
PortesAlejandro. 2010. Economic Sociology: A Systematic Inquiry. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
87.
RaoHayagreevaYueLori QingyuanIngramPaul. 2011. “Laws of Attraction: Regulatory Arbitrage in the Face of Activism in Right-to-Work States.”American Sociological Review76(3):365–85.
88.
Rios-AvilaFernando. 2019. “Recentered Influence Functions in Stata: Methods for Analyzing the Determinants of Poverty and Inequality.” SSRN Scholarly Paper, ID 3378811. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network.
89.
Rios-AvilaFernando. 2020. “Recentered Influence Functions (RIFs) in Stata: RIF Regression and RIF Decomposition.”The Stata Journal20(1):51–94.
90.
Rios-AvilaFernandoMarotoMichelle Lee. 2022. “Moving beyond Linear Regression: Implementing and Interpreting Quantile Regression Models with Fixed Effects.”Sociological Methods & Research (https://doi.org/10.1177/00491241211036165).
91.
RocaJorge De LaPugaDiego. 2017. “Learning by Working in Big Cities.”The Review of Economic Studies84(1):106–42.
92.
RosenfeldJake. 2014. What Unions No Longer Do. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
93.
RosenfeldJake. 2019. “US Labor Studies in the Twenty-First Century: Understanding Laborism without Labor.”Annual Review of Sociology45(1):449–65.
94.
RosenfeldJakeKleykampMeredith. 2012. “Organized Labor and Racial Wage Inequality in the United States.”American Journal of Sociology117(5):1460–502.
95.
RothJonathanSant’AnnaPedro H. C.BilinskiAlyssaPoeJohn. 2023. “What’s Trending in Difference-in-Differences? A Synthesis of the Recent Econometrics Literature.”Journal of Econometrics235(2):2218–44 (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconom.2023.03.008).
96.
SauerCarstenValetPeterShamsSafiTomaskovic-DeveyDonald. 2021. “Categorical Distinctions and Claims-Making: Opportunity, Agency, and Returns from Wage Negotiations.”American Sociological Review86(5):934–59.
97.
ShinDonggyunSolonGary. 2011. “Trends in Men’s Earnings Volatility: What Does the Panel Study of Income Dynamics Show?”Journal of Public Economics95(7):973–82.
98.
ShinTaekjin. 2014. “Explaining Pay Disparities between Top Executives and Nonexecutive Employees: A Relative Bargaining Power Approach.”Social Forces92(4):1339–72.
99.
SobelRussell S.1995. “Empirical Evidence on the Union Free-Rider Problem: Do Right-to-Work Laws Matter?”Journal of Labor Research16(3):347–65.
100.
StansburyAnnaSummersLawrence H.2020. “The Declining Worker Power Hypothesis: An Explanation for the Recent Evolution of the American Economy.”Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research (https://doi.org/10.3386/w27193).
101.
StanselDeanTorraJoséMcMahonFredCarrión-Tavárez.Ángel2021. “Economic Freedom of North America 2021.”Fraser Institute Canada.
102.
ThelenKathleen. 2012. “Varieties of Capitalism: Trajectories of Liberalization and the New Politics of Social Solidarity.”Annual Review of Political Science15:137–59.
103.
ThorntonPatricia H.OcasioWilliamLounsburyMichael. 2012. The Institutional Logics Perspective: A New Approach to Culture, Structure and Process. New York: Oxford University Press.
104.
VanHeuvelenTom. 2018a. “Moral Economies or Hidden Talents? A Longitudinal Analysis of Union Decline and Wage Inequality, 1973–2015.”Social Forces97(2):495–530.
105.
VanHeuvelenTom. 2018b. “Recovering the Missing Middle: A Mesocomparative Analysis of Within-Group Inequality, 1970–2011.”American Journal of Sociology123(4):1064–116.
106.
VanHeuvelenTom. 2020. “The Right to Work, Power Resources, and Economic Inequality.”American Journal of Sociology125(5):1255–302.
WallaceMichaelHydeAllenVachonTodd E.2022. “States of Inequality: Politics, Labor, and Rising Income Inequality in the U.S. States since 1950.”Research in Social Stratification and Mobility78 (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rssm.2022.100677).
109.
WallaceMichaelRubinBeth A.SmithBrian T.1988. “American Labor Law: Its Impact on Working-Class Militancy, 1901–1980.”Social Science History12(1):1–29.
110.
WallaceMichaelVachonTodd E.HydeAllen. 2021. “Two Roads Diverged: Legal Context and Changing Levels of Private and Public Sector Union Density in the US States, 1984–2019.”Economic and Industrial Democracy43(4):1539–63.
111.
WesternBruce. 1997. Between Class and Market: Postwar Unionization in the Capitalist Democracies. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
112.
WesternBruceRosenfeldJake. 2011. “Unions, Norms, and the Rise in U.S. Wage Inequality.”American Sociological Review76(4):513–37.
113.
WilmersNathan. 2017. “Labor Unions as Activist Organizations: A Union Power Approach to Estimating Union Wage Effects.”Social Forces95(4):1451–78.
114.
WilmersNathan. 2020. “Job Turf or Variety: Task Structure as a Source of Organizational Inequality.”Administrative Science Quarterly65(4):1018–57.
115.
ZelizerViviana. 2010. Economic Lives: How Culture Shapes the Economy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
