Sanctuary jurisdictions have existed in the United States since the 1980s. They have recently reentered U.S. politics and engendered contentious debates regarding their legality and influence on public safety. Critics argue that sanctuary jurisdictions create conditions that threaten local communities by impeding federal immigration enforcement efforts. Proponents maintain that the policies improve public safety by fostering institutional trust among immigrant communities and by increasing the willingness of immigrant community members to notify the police after they are victimized. In this study, we situate expectations from the immigrant sanctuary literature within a multilevel, contextualized help-seeking framework to assess how crime-reporting behavior varies across immigrant sanctuary contexts. We find that Latinos are more likely to report violent crime victimization to law enforcement after sanctuary policies have been adopted within their metropolitan areas of residence. We argue that social policy contexts can shift the nature of help-seeking experiences and eliminate barriers that undermine crime victims’ willingness to mobilize the law. Overall, this study highlights the unique role social policy contexts can serve in structuring victims’ help-seeking decisions.
AbregoLeisyColemanMatMartínezDaniel E.MenjívarCeciliaSlackJeremy. 2017. “Making Immigrants into Criminals: Legal Process of Criminalization in the Post-IIRIRA Era.”Journal on Migration and Human Security5(3):694–715.
2.
AllisonPaul D.2009. Fixed Effects Regression Models. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
3.
AndersonElijah. 1999. Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner City. New York: WW Norton.
4.
ArmentaAmada. 2017. Protect, Serve, and Deport: The Rise of Policing as Immigration Enforcement. Berkeley: University of California Press.
5.
AuspurgKatrinBrüderlJoseWöhlerThomas. 2019. “Does Immigration Reduce the Support for Welfare Spending? A Cautionary Tale on Spatial Panel Data Analysis.”American Sociological Review84(4):754–63.
6.
AvakameEdem F.FyfeJames J.McCoyCandace. 1999. “‘Did You Call the Police? What Did They Do?’ An Empirical Assessment of Black’s Theory of Mobilization of Law.”Justice Quarterly16(4):765–92.
7.
BarrDale J.LevyRogerScheepersChristophTilyHarry J.2013. “Random Effects Structure for Confirmatory Hypothesis Testing: Keep It Maximal.”Journal of Memory and Language68(3):1–43.
8.
BauIgnatius. 1994. “Cities of Refuge: No Federal Preemption of Ordinances Restricting Local Government Cooperation with the INS.”Berkeley La Raza Law Journal7(1):50–71.
9.
BauerDaniel J.CurranPatrick J.2005. “Probing Interactions in Fixed and Multilevel Regression: Inferential and Graphical Techniques.”Multivariate Behavioral Research40(3):373–400.
10.
BaumerEric P.2002. “Neighborhood Disadvantage and Police Notification by Victims of Violence.”Criminology40(3):579–616.
11.
BaumerEric P.LauritsenJanet L.2010. “Reporting Crime to the Police, 1973–2005: A Multivariate Analysis of Long-Term Trends in the National Crime Survey (NCS) and National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS).”Criminology48(1):131–86.
12.
BersaniBianca E.LoughranThomas A.PiqueroAlex R.2014. “Comparing Patterns and Predictors of Immigrant Offending among a Sample of Adjudicated Youth.”Journal of Youth and Adolescence43(11):1914–33.
13.
BlackDonald. 1973. “The Mobilization of Law.” Journal of Legal Studies2(1):125–49.
14.
BlackDonald. 1976. The Behavior of Law. New York: Academic Press.
15.
CappsRandyRosenblumMarc R.RodriguezChristinaChishtiMuzaffar. 2011. “Delegation and Divergence: A Study of 287(g) State and Local Immigration Enforcement.” Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute.
16.
CarrPatrick J.2003. “The New Parochialism: The Implications of the Beltway Case for Arguments Concerning Informal Social Control.”American Journal of Sociology108(6):1249–91.
17.
CarrPatrick J.NapolitanoLauraKeatingJessica. 2007. “We Never Call the Cops and Here Is Why: A Qualitative Examination of Legal Cynicism in Three Philadelphia Neighborhoods.”Criminology45(2):445–80.
18.
ColemanMathew. 2007. “Immigration Geopolitics beyond the Mexico-US Border.”Antipodes39(1):54–76.
19.
CollingwoodLorenEl-KhatibStephenO’BrienBenjamin Gonzalez. 2019. “Sustained Organizational Influence: American Legislative Exchange Council and Diffusion of Anti-Sanctuary Policy.”Policy Studies Journal47(3):735–73.
20.
CollingwoodLorenO’BrienBenjamin Gonzalez. 2019. “Public Opposition to Sanctuary Cities in Texas: Criminal Threat or Immigration Threat?”Social Science Quarterly100(4):1182–96.
21.
CollingwoodLorenGonzalez O’BrienBenjaminTafoyaJoe R.2020. “Partisan Learning or Racial Learning: Opinion Change on Sanctuary City Policy Preferences in California and Texas.”Journal of Race and Ethnic Politics5(1):92–129.
22.
CopesHeathKerleyKent R.MasonKaren A.Van WykJudy. 2001. “Reporting Behavior of Fraud Victims and Black’s Theory of Law: An Empirical Assessment.”Justice Quarterly18(2):343–63.
23.
De GenovaNicholas P.2002. “Migrant ‘Illegality’ and Deportability in Everyday Life.”Annual Review of Anthropology31:419–47.
24.
DesmondMathewPapachristosAndrew V.KirkDavid S.2016. “Police Violence and Citizen Crime Reporting in the Black Community.”American Sociological Review81(5):857–76.
25.
Executive Order No. 13768, 3 C.F.R. 8799-8803. 2017.
26.
FairbrotherMalcolm. 2014. “Two Multilevel Modeling Techniques of Analyzing Comparative Longitudinal Survey Datasets.”Political Science Research and Methods2(1):119–40.
27.
FelsonRichard B.MessnerSteven F.HoskinAnthony W.DeaneGlenn. 2002. “Reasons for Reporting and Not Reporting Domestic Violence to the Police.”Criminology40(3):617–48.
28.
FixMichaelZimmermanWendy. 2001. “All Under One Roof: Mixed-Status Families in an Era of Reform.”International Migration Review35(2):397–419.
29.
FussellElizabeth. 2011. “The Deportation Threat Dynamic and Victimization of Latino Migrants: Wage Theft and Robbery.”The Sociological Quarterly52(4):593–615.
GiesselmannMarcoSchmidt-CatranAlexander W.2019. “Getting the Within Estimator of Cross-Level Interactions in Multilevel Models with Pooled Cross-Sections: Why Country Dummies (Sometimes) Do Not Do the Job.”Sociological Methodology49(1):190–219.
32.
Golash-BozaTanyaHondagneu-SoteloPierrette. 2013. “Latino Immigrant Men and the Deportation Crisis: A Gendered Racial Removal Program.”Latino Studies11(3):271–92.
33.
GonzalezBenjaminCollingwoodLorenOmar El-KhatibStephen. 2017. “The Politics of Refuge: Sanctuary Cities, Crime, and Undocumented Immigration.”Urban Affairs Review55(1):3–40.
34.
GottfredsonMichael R.GottfredsonDon M.1988. Decision-Making in Criminal Justice: Toward the Rational Exercise of Discretion. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
35.
GottfredsonMichael R.HindelangMichael J.1979. “A Study of the Behavior of Law.”American Sociological Review44(1):3–18.
36.
GoudriaanHeikeNieuwbeertaPaul. 2007. “Contextual Determinants of Juveniles’ Willingness to Report Crimes.”Journal of Experimental Criminology3(2):89–111.
37.
GutierrezCarmen M.KirkDavid S.2017. “Silence Speaks: The Relationship between Immigration and the Underreporting of Crime.”Crime and Delinquency63(8):926–50.
38.
HaganJacquelineEschbachKarlRodriguezNestor. 2008. “U.S. Deportation Policy, Family Separation, and Circular Migration.”International Migration Review42(2):64–88.
39.
HernándezDavidEasonJohn M.AbelRichardMcNeelyAndrewRubio- GoldsmithPatrick. 2018. “With Mass Deportation Comes Mass Punishment: Punitive Capacity, Health, and Standards in US Immigrant Detention.” In Routledge Handbook on Immigration and Crime, edited by MillerH. V.PegueroA.New York: Routledge.
40.
HoynesHilary W.PageMarianne E.StevensAnn Huff. 2006. “Poverty in America: Trends and Explanations.”Journal of Economic Perspectives20(1):47–68.
41.
HoxJoop J.2010. Multilevel Analysis Techniques and Applications. New York: Routledge.
42.
Kahn-LangAriellaLangKevin. 2020. “The Promises and Pitfalls of Differences-in-Differences: Reflections on16 and Pregnant and Other Applications.” Journal of Business & Economic Statistics38(3):613–20.
43.
KanstroomDaniel. 2007. Deportation Nation: Outsiders in American History. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
44.
KindermannCharlesLynchJames P.CantorDavid. 1997. The Effects of the Redesign on Victimization Estimates. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs.
45.
KirkDavidPapachristosAndrew V.FaganJefferyTylerTom R.2012. “The Paradox of Law Enforcement in Immigrant Communities: Does Tough Immigration Enforcement Undermine Public Safety?”The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science641(1):79–98.
46.
KittrieOrde F.2006. “Federalism, Deportation and Crime Victims Afraid to Call the Police.”Iowa Law Review91:1449–508.
47.
KubrinCharis E.2014. “Secure or Insecure Communities?”Criminology & Public Policy13(2):323–38.
LaHuisDavid M.FergusonMatthew W.2009. “The Accuracy of Significance Tests for Slope Variance Components in Multilevel Random Coefficient Models.”Organizational Research Methods12(3):418–35.
50.
LauritsenJanet L.SchaumRobin J.2005. “Crime and Victimization in the Three Largest Metropolitan Areas, 1980–98.” Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
Long, J.ScottMustilloSarah A.2018. “Using Predictions and Marginal Effects to Compare Groups in Regression Models for Binary Outcomes.”Sociological Methods and Research (https://doi.org/10.1177/0049124118799374).
53.
LynchMichael J.2016. “The Ecological Distribution of Community Advantage and Disadvantage: Power Structures, Political Economy, Communities, and Green-State Crime and Justice.”Critical Criminology24:247–62.
54.
LyonsChristopher J.VélezMaria B.SantoroWayne A.2013. “Neighborhood Immigration, Violence, and City-Level Immigrant Political Opportunities.”American Sociological Review78(4):604–32.
55.
MartínezDaniel E.Martínez-SchuldtRicardo D.CantorGuillermo. 2018. “Providing Sanctuary or Fostering Crime? A Review of the Research on ‘Sanctuary Cities’ and Crime.”Sociology Compass12(1):1–13.
56.
MartinezRamiroJr.2006. “Coming to America: The Impact of the New Immigration on Crime.” Pp. 1–19 in Immigration and Crime: Race, Ethnicity, and Violence, edited by MartinezAJr.ValenzuelaRJr.New York: New York University Press.
57.
Martínez-SchuldtRicardo D.MartínezDaniel E.2019. “Sanctuary Policies and City-Level Incidents of Violence, 1990 to 2010.” Justice Quarterly36(4):567–93.
58.
MeissnerDorisKerwinDonald M.ChishtiMuzaffarBergeronClaire. 2013. “Immigration Enforcement in the United States: The Rise of a Formidable Machinery.” Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute.
MenjívarCeciliaBejaranoCynthia. 2004. “Latino Immigrants’ Perceptions of Crime and Police Authorities in the United States: A Case Study from the Phoenix Metropolitan Area.”Ethnic and Racial Studies27(1):120–48.
61.
MenjívarCeciliaSimmonsWilliam PaulAlvordDanielValdezElizabeth Salerno. 2018. “Immigration Enforcement, the Racialization of Legal Status, and Perceptions of the Police.”Du Bois Review15(1):107–28.
62.
MoodCatrina. 2010. “Logistic Regression: Why We Cannot Do What We Think We Can Do, and What We Can Do About It.”European Sociological Review26(1):67–82.
63.
OuseyGraham C.KubrinCharis E.2014. “Immigration and the Changing Nature of Homicide in US Cities, 1980–2010.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology30:453–83.
64.
OuseyGraham C.KubrinCharis E.2018. “Immigration and Crime: Assessing a Contentious Issue.”Annual Review of Criminology1:63–84.
65.
PasselJeffrey S.CohnD’Vera. 2016. “Overall Number of U.S. Unauthorized Immigrants Holds Steady since 2009.” Washington, DC: Pew Research Center.
66.
PedrazaFrancisco I.ZhuLing. 2015. “The ‘Chilling Effect’ of American’s New Immigration Enforcement Regime.”Pathways Spring:13–17.
67.
PhillipsScottHaganJacqueline MariaRodriguezNestor. 2006. “Brutal Borders? Examining the Treatment of Deportees during Arrest and Detention.”Social Forces85(1):93–109.
68.
PowellDarciPerreiraKrista M.HarrisKathleen Mullan. 2010. “Trajectories of Delinquency from Adolescence to Adulthood.”Youth and Society41(4):475–502.
69.
ReissAlbert J.1992. “Police Organization in the Twentieth Century.”Crime and Justice15:51–97.
70.
RidgleyJennifer. 2008. “Cities of Refuge: Immigration Enforcement, Police, and the Insurgent Genealogies of Citizenship in US Sanctuary Cities.”Urban Geography29(1):53–77.
71.
RugglesStevenGenadekKatieGoekenRonaldGroverJosiahSobekMatthew. 2015. “Integrated Public Use Microdata Series: Version 6.0 [dataset].” Minneapolis: University of Minnesota (http://doi.org/10.18128/D010.V6.0).
72.
SampsonRobert J.2012. Great American City: Chicago and the Enduring Neighborhood Effect. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
73.
Schmidt-CatranAlexander W.FairbrotherMalcom. 2016. “The Random Effects in Multilevel Models: Getting Them Wrong and Getting Them Right.”European Sociological Review32(1):23–38.
74.
Schmidt-CatranAlexander W.SpiesDennis C.2019. “Immigration and Welfare Support in Germany: Methodological Reevaluations and Substantive Conclusions.”American Sociological Review84(4):764–68.
75.
SharkeyPatrickTorrats-EspinosaGerardTakyarDelaram. 2017. “Community and the Crime Decline: The Causal Effect of Local Nonprofits on Violent Crime.”American Sociological Review82(6):1214–40.
SkoganWesley G.1984. “Reporting Crimes to the Police: The Status of World Research.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency21(2):113–37.
78.
SkoganWesleyFrydlKathleen. 2004. Fairness and Effectiveness in Policing: The Evidence. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
79.
StuartForrestArmentaAmadaOsborneMelissa. 2015. “Legal Control of Marginal Groups.”Annual Review of Law and Social Science11:235–54.
80.
SunshineJasonTylerTom R.2003. “The Role of Procedural Justice and Legitimacy in Shaping Public Support for Policing.”Law & Society Review 37(3):513–48.
81.
TankebeJustice. 2013. “Viewing Things Differently: The Dimensions of Public Perceptions of Police Legitimacy.”Criminology51(1):103–35.
82.
TheodoreNikHabansRobert. 2016. “Policing Immigrant Communities: Latino Perceptions of Police Involvement in Immigration Enforcement.”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies42(6):970–88.
83.
U.S. Department of Justice. 2007. “Cooperation of SCAAP Recipients in the Removal of Criminal Aliens from the United States (Audit Report 07-07).” Washington, DC: Office of the Inspector General Audit Division.
84.
U.S. Department of Justice. 2019. “Criminal Victimization, 2018.” Washington, DC: Office of Justice Program, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
85.
VargasEdward D.2015. “Immigration Enforcement and Mixed-Status Families: The Effects of Risk of Deportation on Medicaid Use.”Children and Youth Services Review57:83–89.
86.
VargasEdward D.PirogMaureen A.2016. “Mixed-Status Families and WIC Uptake: The Effects of Risk of Deportation on Program Use.”Social Science Quarterly97(3):555–72.
87.
WilliamsRichard. 2009. “Using Heterogeneous Choice Models to Compare Logit and Probit Coefficients across Groups.”Sociological Methods and Research37(4):531–59.
88.
WongTom K.2017. “The Effects of Sanctuary Policies on Crime and the Economy.” Washington, DC: Center for American Progress.
89.
XieMinBaumerEric P.2019a. “Crime Victims’ Decisions to Call the Police: Past Research and New Directions.”Annual Review of Criminology2:217–40.
90.
XieMinBaumerEric P.2019b. “Neighborhood Immigrant Concentration and Violent Crime Reporting to the Police: A Multilevel Analysis of Data from the National Crime Victimization Survey.”Criminology57(2):237–67.
91.
XieMinLauritsenJanet L.2012. “Racial Context and Crime Reporting: A Test of Black’s Stratification Hypothesis.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology28(2):265–93.
92.
XieMinLauritsenJanet L.HeimerKaren. 2012. “Intimate Partner Violence in U.S. Metropolitan Areas: The Contextual Influences of Police and Social Services.”Criminology50(4):961–92.
93.
YeeVivian.2017. “Judge Blocks Trump Effort to Withhold Money from Sanctuary
