The shift to more time-intensive and child-centered parenting in the United States is widely assumed to be positively linked to healthy child development, but implications for adult well-being are less clear. We assess multiple dimensions of parents’ subjective well-being in activities with children and explore how the gendered nature of time potentially contributes to differences in mothers’ and fathers’ parenting experiences. Relying on nationally representative time diary data linked to respondents’ feelings in activities from the 2010, 2012, and 2013 well-being module of the American Time Use Survey (N = 12,163 persons and 36,036 activities), we find that parents consistently report greater subjective well-being in activities with children than without. Mothers, however, report less happiness, more stress, and greater fatigue in time with children than do fathers. These gaps are relatively small and can be accounted for by differences in the activities that mothers and fathers engage in with children, whether other adults are present, and the quality of their sleep and leisure. We go beyond prior work on parental happiness and life satisfaction to document how contemporary parenting is woven differently into the lives of mothers and fathers.
AassveArnsteinGoisisAliceSironiMaria. 2012. “Happiness and Childbearing across Europe.”Social Indicators Research108(1):65–86.
2.
AbrahamKatharine G.HelmsSaraPresserStanley. 2009. “How Social Processes Distort Measurement: The Impact of Survey Nonresponse on Estimates of Volunteer Work in the United States.”American Journal of Sociology114(4):1129–64.
3.
AguiarMarkHurstErik. 2007. “Measuring Trends in Leisure: The Allocation of Time over Five Decades.”Quarterly Journal of Economics122(3):969–1006.
4.
AllenSarah M.HawkinsAlan J.1999. “Maternal Gatekeeping: Mothers’ Beliefs and Behaviors that Inhibit Greater Father Involvement in Family Work.”Journal of Marriage and Family61(1):199–212.
5.
AllisonPaul D.2009. Fixed Effects Regression Models. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
6.
BianchiSuzanne M.2000. “Maternal Employment and Time with Children: Dramatic Change or Surprising Continuity?”Demography37(4):401–414.
7.
BianchiSuzanne M.2011. “Change and Time Allocation in American Families.”ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science638(1):21–44.
8.
BianchiSuzanne M.RobinsonJohn. 1997. “What Did You Do Today? Children’s Use of Time, Family Composition, and the Acquisition of Social Capital.”Journal of Marriage and the Family59(2):332–44.
9.
BirdChloe E.1997. “Gender Differences in the Social and Economic Burdens of Parenting and Psychological Distress.”Journal of Marriage and the Family59(4):809–823.
10.
BirdChloe E.FremontAllen M.1991. “Gender, Time Use, and Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior32(2):114–29.
11.
BittmanMichaelWajcmanJudy. 2000. “The Rush Hour: The Character of Leisure Time and Gender Equity.”Social Forces79(1):165–89.
12.
Blair-LoyMary. 2001. “Cultural Constructions of Family Schemas: The Case of Women Finance Executives.”Gender & Society15(5):687–709.
13.
Blair-LoyMary. 2003. Competing Devotions: Career and Family among Women Executives. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
14.
BoeckmannIreneMisraJoyaBudigMichelle J.2015. “Cultural and Institutional Factors Shaping Mothers’ Employment and Working Hours in Postindustrial Countries.”Social Forces93(4):1301–33.
15.
Bureau of Labor Statistics and U.S. Census Bureau. 2016. American Time Use Survey User’s Guide: Understanding ATUS 2003 to 2015. Retrieved July15, 2016 (http://www.bls.gov/tus/atususersguide.pdf).
16.
BurgardSarah A.AilshireJennifer A.2013. “Gender and Time for Sleep among U.S. Adults.”American Sociological Review78(1):51–69.
17.
BuxtonOrfeu M.MarcelliEnrico. 2010. “Short and Long Sleep Are Positively Associated with Obesity, Diabetes, Hypertension, and Cardiovascular Disease among Adults in the United States.”Social Science & Medicine71(5):1027–36.
18.
CamposBelindaWangShu-wenPlaksinaTatyanaRepettiRena L.SchoebiDominikOchsElinorBeckMargaret E.2013. “Positive and Negative Emotion in the Daily Life of Dual-Earner Couples with Children.”Journal of Family Psychology27(1):76–85.
19.
ConnellyRachelKimmelJean. 2015. “If You’re Happy and You Know It: How Do Mothers and Fathers in the US Really Feel about Caring for Their Children?”Feminist Economics21(1):1–34.
20.
CorrellShelley J.BenardStephenPaikIn. 2007. “Getting a Job: Is There a Motherhood Penalty?”American Journal of Sociology112(5):1297–1339.
21.
CraigLyn. 2007. Contemporary Motherhood: The Impact of Children on Adult Time. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate Publishing.
22.
CraigLynMullanKillian. 2011. “How Mothers and Fathers Share Childcare: A Cross-National Time-Use Comparison.”American Sociological Review76(6):834–61.
23.
CraigLynMullanKillian. 2013. “Parental Leisure Time: A Gender Comparison in Five Countries.”Social Politics20(3):329–57.
24.
DalyKerry J.2001. “Deconstructing Family Time: From Ideology to Lived Experience.”Journal of Marriage and Family63(2):283–94.
25.
DeatonAngus. 2012. “The Financial Crisis and the Well-Being of Americans.”Oxford Economic Papers64(1):1–26.
DeemRosemary. 1996. “No Time for a Rest? An Exploration of Women’s Work, Engendered Leisure and Holidays.”Time & Society5(1):5–25.
28.
DoucetAndrea. 2015. “Parental Responsibilities: Dilemmas of Measurement and Gender Equality.”Journal of Marriage and Family77(1):224–42.
29.
DunifonRachelKalilArielCrosbyDanielle A.SuJessica Houston. 2013. “Mothers’ Night Work and Children’s Behavior Problems.”Developmental Psychology49(10):1874–85.
30.
EdinKathrynKefalasMaria. 2005. Promises I Can Keep: Why Poor Women Put Motherhood Before Marriage. Berkeley: University of California Press.
31.
FloodSarahGenadekKatie. 2016. “Time for Each Other: Work and Family Constraints among Couples”Journal of Marriage and Family78(1):142–64.
32.
FolbreNancyYoonJayoungFinnoffKadeFuligniAllison Sidle. 2005. “By What Measure? Family Time Devoted to Children in the United States.”Demography42(2):373–90.
33.
FreysingerValeria J.1994. “Leisure with Children and Parental Satisfaction: Further Evidence of a Sex Difference in the Experience of Adult Roles and Leisure.”Journal of Leisure Research26(3):212–26.
34.
GauthierAnne H.SmeedingTimothy M.FurstenbergFrank F.Jr.2004. “Are Parents Investing Less Time in Children? Trends in Selected Industrialized Countries.”Population and Development Review30(4):647–71.
35.
GershunyJonathan. 2013. “National Utility: Measuring the Enjoyment of Activities.”European Sociological Review29(5):996–1009.
36.
GlassJenniferSimonRobin W.AnderssonMathew A.Forthcoming. “Parenthood and Happiness: Effects of Work-Family Reconciliation Policies in 22 OECD Countries.”American Journal of Sociology.
37.
GoldscheiderFrancesBernhardtEvaLappegårdTrude. 2015. “The Gender Revolution: A Framework for Understanding Changing Family and Demographic Behavior.”Population and Development Review41(2):207–239.
38.
GornickJanet C.MeyersMarcia K.2005. Families That Work: Policies for Reconciling Parenthood and Employment. New York: Russell Sage.
39.
GuryanJonathanHurstErikKearneyMelissa. 2008. “Parental Education and Parental Time with Children.”Journal of Economic Perspectives22(3):23–46.
40.
HansenThomas. 2012. “Parenthood and Happiness: A Review of Folk Theories versus Empirical Evidence.”Social Indicators Research108(1):29–64.
HaysSharon. 1996. The Cultural Contradictions of Motherhood. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
43.
HerbstChris M.IfcherJohn. Forthcoming. “The Increasing Happiness of U.S. Parents.”Review of Economics of the Household.
44.
HislopJennyArberSara. 2003. “Sleepers Wake! The Gendered Nature of Sleep Disruption among Mid-Life Women.”Sociology37(4):695–711.
45.
HochschildArlie Russell (with MachungAnne). 1989. The Second Shift: Working Parents and the Revolution at Home. New York: Viking Penguin. (Re-issued 2003, 2011).
46.
HofferthSandra L.FloodSarah M.SobekMatthew. 2013. American Time Use Survey Data Extract System: Version 2.4 [Machine-readable database]. Maryland Population Research Center, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, and Minnesota Population Center, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN.
47.
KahnemanDanielDeatonAngus. 2010. “High Income Improves Evaluation of Life but Not Emotional Well-Being.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America107(38):16489–93.
48.
KahnemanDanielKruegerAlan B.2006. “Developments in the Measurement of Subjective Well-Being.”Journal of Economic Perspectives20(1):3–24.
49.
KahnemanDanielKruegerAlan B.SchkadeDavid A.SchwarzNorbertStoneArthur A.2004. “A Survey Method for Characterizing Daily Life Experience: The Day Reconstruction Method.”Science306(5702):1776–80.
50.
KalilArielRyanRebeccaChorElise. 2014. “Time Investments in Children across Family Structures.”ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 654(1):150–68.
51.
KalilArielRyanRebeccaCoreyMichael. 2012. “Diverging Destinies: Maternal Education and Investments in Children.”Demography49(4):1361–83.
52.
KapteynArieLeeJinkookTassotCarolineVonkovaHanaZamarroGema. 2013. Dimensions of Subjective Well-Being. Center for Economic and Social Research, University of Southern California. Retrieved June21, 2015 (https://cesr.usc.edu/documents/WP_2013_005.pdf).
53.
KaufmanGayle. 2013. Superdads: How Fathers Balance Work and Family in the 21st Century. New York: NYU Press.
54.
KimmelJeanConnellyRachel. 2007. “Mothers’ Time Choices: Caregiving, Leisure, Home Production, and Paid Work.”Journal of Human Resources42(3):643–81.
55.
KohlerHans-PeterBehrmanJere R.SkyttheAxel. 2005. “Partner + Children = Happiness? The Effects of Partnerships and Fertility on Well-Being.”Population and Development Review31(3):407–445.
56.
KronholmErkkiSallinenMikaelSuutamaTimoSulkavaRaimoEraPerttiPartonenTimo. 2009. “Self-Reported Sleep Duration and Cognitive Functioning in the General Population.”Journal of Sleep Research18(4):436–46.
57.
KruegerAlan B.KahnemanDanielFischlerClaudeSchkadeDavidSchwarzNorbertStoneArthur A.2009. “Time Use and Subjective Well-Being in France and the US.”Social Indicators Research93(1):7–18.
58.
LareauAnnette. 2002. “Invisible Inequality: Social Class and Childrearing in Black Families and White Families.”American Sociological Review67(5):747–76.
59.
LareauAnnette. 2003. Unequal Childhoods: Race, Class, and Family Life. Berkeley: University of California Press.
60.
LareauAnnette. 2011. Unequal Childhoods: Race, Class, and Family Life, 2nd Edition with an Update a Decade Later. Berkeley: University of California Press.
61.
LarsonReed W.RichardsMaryse H.Perry-JenkinsMaureen. 1994. “Divergent Worlds: The Daily Emotional Experience of Mothers and Fathers in the Domestic and Public Spheres.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology67(6):1034–46.
62.
LawrenceErikaCobbRebecca J.RothmanAlexia D.RothmanMichael T.BradburyThomas N.2008. “Marital Satisfaction across the Transition to Parenthood.”Journal of Family Psychology22(1):41–50.
63.
LatshawBeth E.HaleStephanie I.2016. “‘The Domestic Handoff’: Stay-at-Home Fathers’ Time Use in Female Breadwinner Families.”Journal of Family Studies22(2):97–120.
64.
LucasRichard E.ClarkAndrew E.GeorgellisYannisDienerEd. 2003. “Reexamining Adaptation and the Set Point Model of Happiness: Reactions to Changes in Marital Status.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology84(3):527–39.
65.
MarcussenKristenPiattLiz. 2005. “Race Differences in the Relationship between Role Experiences and Well-Being.”Health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health, Illness and Medicine9(3):379–402.
66.
MargolisRachelMyrskylaMikko. 2011. “A Global Perspective on Happiness and Fertility.”Population and Development Review37(1):29–56.
67.
MarsiglioWilliamRoyKevin. 2012. Nurturing Dads: Fatherhood Initiatives beyond the Wallet. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
68.
MattinglyMarybeth J.BianchiSuzanne M.2003. “Gender Differences in the Quantity and Quality of Free Time: The US Experience.”Social Forces81(3):999–1030.
69.
MattinglyMarybeth J.SayerLiana C.2006. “Under Pressure: Gender Differences in the Relationship between Free Time and Feeling Rushed.”Journal of Marriage and Family68(1):205–221.
70.
MaumeDavid J.SebastianRachel A.BardoAnthony R.2009. “Gender Differences in Sleep Disruption among Retail Food Workers.”American Sociological Review74(6):989–1007.
71.
McLanahanSaraAdamsJulia. 1987. “Parenthood and Psychological Well-Being.”Annual Review of Sociology13:237–57.
72.
MeierAnnMusickKellyFloodSaraDunifonRachel. 2016. “Mothering Experiences: How Single Parenthood and Employment Structure the Emotional Valence of Parenting.”Demography53(3): 649–74.
73.
MilkieMelissa A.DennyKathleen E.2014. “Changes in the Cultural Model of Father Involvement: Descriptions of Benefits to Fathers, Children, and Mothers in Parents’ Magazine, 1926–2006.”Journal of Family Issues35(2):223–53.
74.
MilkieMelissa A.KendigSarah M.NomaguchiKei M.DennyKathleen E.2010. “Time with Children, Children’s Well-being and Work-Family Balance among Employed Parents.”Journal of Marriage and the Family72(5):1329–43.
75.
MilkieMelissa A.MattinglyMarybeth J.NomaguchiKei M.BianchiSuzanne M.RobinsonJohn P.2004. “The Time Squeeze: Parental Statuses and Feelings about Time with Children.”Journal of Marriage and Family66(3):739–61.
76.
MilkieMelissa A.NomaguchiKei M.DennyKathleen. 2015. “Does the Amount of Time Mothers Spend with Children or Adolescents Matter?”Journal of Marriage and Family77(2):355–72.
77.
MilkieMelissa A.RaleySara B.BianchiSuzanne M.2009. “Taking on the Second Shift: Time Allocations and Time Pressures of U.S. Parents with Preschoolers.”Social Forces88(2):487–518.
78.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.2002. “Depression, Parenthood, and Age at First Birth.”Social Science and Medicine54(8):1281–98.
79.
MorganS. PhilipKingRosalind Berkowitz. 2001. “Why Have Children in the 21st Century?”European Journal of Population17(1):3–20.
80.
MusickKellyBumpassLarry. 1999. “How Do Prior Experiences in the Family Affect Transitions to Adulthood?” Pp. 69–102 in Transitions to Adulthood in a Changing Economy: No Work, No Family, No Future, edited by BoothA.CrouterA. C.ShanahanM. J.Westport, CT: Praeger Publishers.
81.
MusickKellyBumpassLarry. 2012. “Re-Examining the Case for Marriage: Union Formation and Changes in Well-Being.”Journal of Marriage and Family74(1):1–18.
82.
MusickKellyMeierAnn. 2014. “(How) Do the Strains and Joys of Mothering Change as Children Age?”Presented at the Society for Longitudinal and Life Course Studies International Conference, October 9, Lausanne, Switzerland.
83.
MyrskylaMikkoMargolisRachel. 2014. “Happiness: Before and After the Kids.”Demography51(5):1843–66.
84.
National Institute on Aging, Bureau of Labor Statistics, and U.S. Census Bureau.2014. American Time Use Survey (ATUS) Data Dictionary: 2010, 2012, and 2013 Well-Being Module Data. Retrieved July15, 2016 (http://www.bls.gov/tus/wbmintcodebk.pdf).
85.
National Research Council (NRC) Panel on Measuring Subjective Well-Being in a Policy-Relevant Framework. 2012. The Subjective Well-Being Module of the American Time Use Survey: Assessment for Its Continuation. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. Retrieved September15, 2014 (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK109558/).
86.
NelsonS. KatherineKushlevKostadinEnglishTammyDunnElizabeth W.LyubomirskySonja. 2013. “In Defense of Parenthood: Children Are Associated With More Joy than Misery.”Psychological Science24(1):3–10.
87.
NelsonS. KatherineKushlevKostadinLyubomirskySonja. 2014. “The Pains and Pleasures of Parenting: When, Why, and How Is Parenthood Associated with More or Less Well-Being?”Psychological Bulletin140(3):846–95.
88.
NomaguchiKei M.2012. “Parenthood and Psychological Well-Being: Clarifying the Role of Child Age and Parent–Child Relationship Quality.”Social Science Research41(2):489–98.
89.
NomaguchiKei M.MilkieMelissa A.2003. “Costs and Rewards of Children: The Effects of Becoming a Parent on Adults’ Lives.”Journal of Marriage and Family65(2):356–74.
90.
NomaguchiKei M.MilkieMelissa A.BianchiSuzanne M.2005. “Time Strains and Psychological Wellbeing: Do Dual-Earner Mothers and Fathers Differ?”Journal of Family Issues26(6):759–92.
OfferShira. 2014. “Time with Children and Employed Parents’ Emotional Well-Being.”Social Science Research47:192–203.
93.
OfferShiraSchneiderBarbara. 2011. “Revisiting the Gender Gap in Time-Use Patterns: Multitasking and Well-Being among Mothers and Fathers in Dual-Earner Families.”American Sociological Review76(6):809–833.
PickertKate. 2012. “Are You Mom Enough? Why Attachment Parenting Drives Some Mothers to Extremes—and How Dr. Bill Sears Became Their Guru.”Time Magazine, May10. Retrieved July1, 2015 (http://time.com/606/the-man-who-remade-motherhood/).
97.
Pollmann-SchultMatthias. 2014. “Parenthood and Life Satisfaction: Why Don’t Children Make People Happy?”Journal of Marriage and Family76(2):319–36.
98.
RaleySara. 2014. “Time Use, Inequality, and Child Well-Being.” Pp. 999–1031 in Handbook of Child Well-Being: Theories, Methods and Policies in Global Perspective, edited by Ben-AriehA.CasasF.FrønesI.KorbinJ. E.Dordrecht, the Netherlands: Springer.
99.
RaleySaraBianchiSuzanne M.WangWendy. 2012. “When Do Fathers Care? Mothers’ Economic Contribution and Fathers’ Involvement in Child Care.”American Journal of Sociology117(5):1422–59.
100.
RizzoKathryn M.SchiffrinHolly H.LissMiriam. 2013. “Insight into the Parenthood Paradox: Mental Health Outcomes of Intensive Mothering.”Journal of Child and Family Studies22(5):614–20.
101.
RossCatherine E.Van WilligenMarieke. 1996. “Gender, Parenthood, and Anger.”Journal of Marriage and the Family58(3):572–84.
102.
RussellJames A.1980. “A Circumplex Model of Affect.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 39(6):1161–78.
103.
RussellJames A.2003. “Core Affect and the Psychological Construction of Emotion.”Psychological Review110(1):145–72.
104.
SayerLiana C.2005. “Gender, Time and Inequality: Trends in Women’s and Men’s Paid Work, Unpaid Work and Free Time.”Social Forces84(1):285–303.
105.
SayerLiana C.BianchiSuzanne M.RobinsonJohn P.2004. “Are Parents Investing Less in Children? Trends in Mothers’ and Fathers’ Time with Children.”American Journal of Sociology110(1):1–43.
106.
SeniorJennifer. 2010. “All Joy and No Fun: Why Parents Hate Parenting.”New York Magazine, July4. Retrieved July1, 2015 (http://nymag.com/news/features/67024/).
107.
SeniorJennifer. 2014. All Joy and No Fun: The Paradox of Modern Parenthood. New York: HarperCollins.
108.
SimonRobin W.1992. “Parental Role Strains, Salience of Parental Identity and Gender Differences in Psychological Distress.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior33(1):25–35.
109.
SimonRobin W.1995. “Gender, Multiple Roles, Role Meaning, and Mental Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior36(2):182–94.
110.
SimonRobin W.2008. “The Joys of Parenthood, Reconsidered.”Contexts: Understanding People in Their Social Worlds7(2):40–45.
111.
SimonRobin W.NathLeda E.2004. “Gender and Emotion in the United States: Do Men and Women Differ in Self-Reports of Feelings and Expressive Behavior?”American Journal of Sociology109(5):1137–76.
112.
StancaLuca. 2012. “Suffer the Little Children: Measuring the Effect of Parenthood on Well-Being Worldwide.”Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization81(3):742–50.
113.
StoneArthur A.MackieChristopher, eds. 2013. Subjective Well-Being: Measuring Happiness, Suffering, and Other Dimensions of Experience. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
114.
StoneArthur A.SchneiderStefanHarterJames K.2012. “Day-Of-Week Mood Patterns in the United States: On the Existence of ‘Blue Monday’, ‘Thank God it’s Friday’ and Weekend Effects.”Journal of Positive Psychology7(4):306–314.
115.
SullivanOriel. 2013. “What Do We Learn about Gender by Analyzing Housework Separately From Child Care? Some Considerations from Time-Use Evidence.”Journal of Family Theory and Review5(2):72–84.
ThoitsPeggy A.2010. “Stress and Health: Major Findings and Policy Implications.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(1):S41–S53.
118.
TwengeJean M.CampbellW. KeithFosterCraig A.2003. “Parenthood and Marital Satisfaction: A Meta-Analytic Review.”Journal of Marriage and Family65(3):574–83.
119.
UmbersonDebraPudrovskaTetyanaReczekCorinne. 2010. “Parenthood, Childlessness, and Well-Being: A Life Course Perspective.”Journal of Marriage and Family72(3):612–29.
120.
VennSusanArberSaraMeadowsRobertHislopJenny. 2008. “The Fourth Shift: Exploring the Gendered Nature of Sleep Disruption among Couples with Children.”British Journal of Sociology59(1):79–97.
WarrenElizabethTyagiAnne. 2003. The Two-Parent Trap: Why Middle-Class Parents Are Going Broke. New York: Basic.
123.
WooHyeyoungRaleyR. Kelly. 2005. “A Small Extension to ‘Costs and Rewards of Children: The Effects of Becoming a Parent on Adults’ Lives.’”Journal of Marriage and Family67(1):216–21.
124.
YeungW. JeanSandbergJohn F.Davis-KeanPamela E.HofferthSandra L.2001. “Children’s Time with Fathers in Intact Families.”Journal of Marriage and Family63(1):136–54.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
