Over the past decade, public health researchers have been advancing the Intersectionality-Based Policy Analysis (IBPA) framework to examine differential impacts of health policy. This article extends an equity-oriented policy agenda by applying the IBPA framework to three domains of the criminal justice system: policing, corrections, and legislation. I present case studies of algorithmic policing, the housing of transgender persons in carceral settings, and U.S. firearm legislation as examples of this approach. Through these cases, I argue for equitable processes and outcomes in the creation and application of criminal justice policy and practice.
Act 94: An act relating to the disposition of unlawful and abandoned firearms. 2018 (enacted). Act 94 (S.55), 2017–2018 Vermont General Assembly. Available from https://legislature.vermont.gov/bill/status/2018/s.55.
2.
American Civil Liberties Union. 13June2024. Trump on LGBTQ rights: Rolling back protections and criminalizing gender nonconformity. Available from www.aclu.org.
3.
Bennett MosesLyriaChanJanet. 2018. Algorithmic prediction in policing: Assumptions, evaluation, and accountability. Policing & Society28(7): 806–822.
4.
BhuiyanJohana. 8November2021. LAPD ended predictive policing programs amid public outcry. A new effort shares many of their flaws. Guardian (US).
5.
BragaAnthony A.TurchanBrandonPapachristosAndrew V.HureauDavid M.2019. Hot spots policing of small geographic areas effects on crime. Campbell Systematic Reviews15(3): e1046.
6.
BrantinghamP. JeffreyValasikMatthewMohlerGeorge O.2018. Does predictive policing lead to biased arrests? Results from a randomized controlled trial. Statistics and Public Policy5(1): 1–6.
7.
BrunsonRod K.WadeBrian A.2019. “Oh hell no, we don’t talk to police”: Insights on the lack of cooperation in police investigations of urban gun violence. Criminology & Public Policy18(3): 623–648.
8.
CharlesSam. 27January2020. CPD decommissions “Strategic Suspect List.”Chicago Sun-Times. Available from chicago.suntimes.com.
ChoSumiCrenshawKimberlé WilliamsMcCallLeslie. 2013. Toward a field of intersectionality studies: Theory, application, and praxis. Signs38(4): 785–810.
11.
ColeElizabeth R.DuncanLauren E.2023. Better policy interventions through intersectionality. Social Issues and Policy Review17(1): 62–78.
12.
CollinLindsayReisnerSari L.TangprichaVinGoodmanMichael. 2016. Prevalence of transgender depends on the “case” definition: A systematic review. Journal of Sexual Medicine13(4): 613–626.
ComackElizabeth. 2012. Racialized policing: Aboriginal people’s encounters with the police. Fernwood Publishing.
15.
ConnealyNathan T.PizaEric L.AriettiRachael A.MohlerGeorge O.CarterJeremy G.2024. Staggered deployment of gunshot detection technology in Chicago, IL: A matched quasi-experiment of gun violence outcomes. Journal of Experimental Criminology, ahead of print. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11292-024-09617-w
Correctional Service Canada. 2023. Commissioner’s directive 100: Gender diverse offenders. Government of Canada. Available from www.canada.ca.
19.
CrenshawKimberle. 1989. Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A Black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum1989(1): 139–167.
20.
DegelingMartinBerendtBettina. 2018. What is wrong about robocops as consultants? A technology-centric critique of predictive policing. AI & Society33(3): 347–356.
21.
Degli EspostiMichelleWiebeDouglas J.GravelJasonHumphreysDavid K.2020. Increasing adolescent firearm homicides and racial disparities following Florida’s “Stand Your Ground” self-defence law. Injury Prevention26(2): 187–190.
22.
DiazJaclyn. 7February2025. “Everything is changing every minute”: New prison rules for trans women on hold. NPR. Available from www.npr.org.
23.
DolovichSharon. 2011. Strategic segregation in the modern prison. American Criminal Law Review48(1): 1–110.
GelmanAndrewFaganJeffreyKissAlex. 2007. An analysis of the New York City Police Department’s “stop-and-frisk” policy in the context of claims of racial bias. Journal of the American Statistical Association102(479): 813–823.
GossKristin A.2006. Disarmed: The missing movement for gun control in America. Princeton University Press.
29.
GribkoffElizabeth. 15May2018. Top 10 bills approved by the Vermont legislature this 2018. Barton Chronicle. Available from bartonchronicle.com.
30.
GrinshteynErinHemenwayDavid. 2019. Violent death rates in the US compared to those of the other high-income countries, 2015. Preventive Medicine123: 20–26.
31.
HabermanCory P.GroffElizabeth R.RatcliffeJerry H.SorgEvan T.2016. Satisfaction with police in violent crime hot spots: Using community surveys as a guide for selecting hot spots policing tactics. Crime and Delinquency62(4): 525–557.
32.
HankivskyOlenaGraceDanielHuntingGemmaGiesbrechtMelissaFridkinAlyciaRudrumSarahFerlatteOlivierClarkNatalie. 2014. An intersectionality-based policy analysis framework: Critical reflections on a methodology for advancing equity. International Journal for Equity in Health13(1): 119.
33.
HarrellErika. 2021. Crime against persons with disabilities, 2009–2019 – Statistical tables. U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics. Available from bjs.ojp.gov.
34.
HuntPriscilliaSaundersJessicaHollywoodJohn S.2014. Evaluation of the Shreveport predictive policing experiment. RAND Corporation. Available from www.rand.org.
35.
JennessValerie. 2021. The social ecology of sexual victimization against transgender women who are incarcerated: A call for (more) research on modalities of housing and prison violence. Criminology & Public Policy20(1): 3–18.
36.
JennessValerieMaxsonCheryl L.MatsudaKristy N.SumnerJennifer Macy. 2007. Violence in California correctional facilities: An empirical examination of sexual assault. The Bulletin2(2): 1–4.
37.
JennessValerieSextonLoriSumnerJennifer. 2019. Sexual victimization against transgender women in prison: Consent and coercion in context. Criminology57(4): 603–631.
38.
KarpAaron. 2018. Estimating global civilian-held firearms numbers. Small Arms Survey Briefing Paper, Geneva. Available from smallarmssurvey.org.
39.
KnopovAnitaSiegelMichaelXuanZimingRothmanEmily F.CroninShea W.HemenwayDavid. 2019. The impact of state firearm laws on homicide rates among Black and white populations in the United States, 1991–2016. Health & Social Work44(4): 232–240.
40.
KoganIrenaWeißmannMarkusDollmannJörg. 2024. Police discrimination and police distrust among ethnic minority adolescents in Germany. Frontiers in Sociology9: 1231774.
41.
LacombeMatthew J.2021. Firepower: How the NRA turned gun owners into a political force. Princeton University Press.
42.
LenningEmilyBuistCarrie L.2013. Social, psychological and economic challenges faced by transgender individuals and their significant others: Gaining insight through personal narratives. Culture, Health & Sexuality15(1): 44–57.
43.
LeongNancy. 2013. Racial capitalism. Harvard Law Review126(8): 2151–2226.
44.
LernerJennifer S.LiYeValdesoloPiercarloKassamKarim S.2015. Emotion and decision making. Annual Review of Psychology66: 799–823.
45.
LumKristianIsaacWilliam. 2016. To predict and serve?Significance13(5): 14–19.
46.
MalkinMichelle L.DeJongChristina. 2019. Protections for transgender inmates under PREA: A comparison of state correctional policies in the United States. Sexuality Research and Social Policy16(4): 393–407.
47.
MatychukAmy. 7September2023. Trans women in federal custody: We know the headlines, but what are the facts?Law360 Canada. Available from www.law360.ca.
48.
MaycockMatthew. 2022. “She was just like a lassie”: Analysing the views of cis-women in custody about their experiences of living with transgender women in the Scottish prison estate. British Journal of Criminology62(4): 1000–1018.
49.
McCauleyErinEckstrandKristenDestaBethlehemBouvierBenBrockmannBradBrinkley-RubinsteinLauren. 2018. Exploring healthcare experiences for incarcerated individuals who identify as transgender in a southern jail. Transgender Health3(1): 34–41.
50.
McClellanChandlerTekinErdal. 2017. Stand Your Ground laws, homicides, and injuries. Journal of Human Resources52(3): 621–653.
51.
MehrotraDhruvCameronDell. 27September2023. The maker of ShotSpotter is buying the world’s more infamous predictive policing tech. Wired. Available from www.wired.com.
52.
MohlerGeorge O.ShortMartin B.MalinowskiSeanJohnsonMarkTitaGeorge E.BertozziAndrea L.BrantinghamP. Jeffrey. 2015. Randomized controlled field trials of predictive policing. Journal of the American Statistical Association110(512): 1399–1411.
53.
MorozovEvgeny. 2013. To save everything, click here: The folly of technological solutionism. PublicAffairs.
54.
MurphyKristinaMazerolleLorraineBennettSarah. 2014. Promoting trust in police: Findings from a randomised experimental field trial of procedural justice policing. Policing & Society24(4): 405–424.
55.
National Prison Rape Elimination Commission. 2009. National Prison Rape Elimination Commission report. Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice. Available from https://www.ojp.gov/pdffiles1/226680.pdf.
56.
OosterlooSerenavan SchieGerwin. 2018. The politics and biases of the “Crime Anticipation System” of the Dutch police. CEUR Workshop Proceedings2103: 30–41.
57.
ParkerKimHorowitzJuliana MenasceIgielnikRuthOliphantJ. BaxterBrownAnna. 2017. America’s complex relationship with guns. Pew Research Center. Available from www.pewresearch.org.
PFLAG. n.d. PFLAG national glossary. Available from https://pflag.org/glossary (accessed 16 December 2024).
60.
PizaEric L.ConnealyNathan T.2022. The effect of the Seattle police-free CHOP zone on crime: A microsynthetic control evaluation. Criminology & Public Policy21(1): 35–58.
ReisnerSari L.BaileyZinziSeveliusJae. 2014. Racial/ethnic disparities in history of incarceration, experiences of victimization, and associated health indicators among transgender women in the U.S. Women & Health54(8): 750–767.
63.
ResnickShelbySmithRandi N.BeardJessica H.HolenaDanielReillyPatrick M.SchwabC. WilliamSeamonMark J.2017. Firearm deaths in America: Can we learn from 462,000 lives lost?Annals of Surgery266(3): 432–440.
64.
RobertsonKateKhooCynthiaSongYolanda. 2020. To surveil and predict: A human rights analysis of algorithmic policing in Canada. Citizen Lab and International Human Rights Program, University of Toronto. Available from citizenlab.ca.
65.
RosenbergRaeOswinNatalie. 2015. Trans embodiment in carceral space: Hypermasculinity and the US prison industrial complex. Gender, Place and Culture: A Journal of Feminist Geography22(9): 1269–1286.
66.
SchuilenburgMarcSoudijnMelvin. 2023. Big data policing: The use of big data and algorithms by the Netherlands Police. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice17: paad061.
67.
SeveliusJaeJennessValerie. 2017. Challenges and opportunities for gender-affirming healthcare for transgender women in prison. International Journal of Prisoner Health13(1): 32–40.
StrongJustin D.ReiterKerametGonzalezGabrielaTublitzRebeccaAugustineDallasBarraganMelissaChesnutKelsieDashtgardPashaPiferNatalieBlairThomas R.2020. The body in isolation: The physical health impacts of incarceration in solitary confinement. PLOS One15(10): e0238510.
VepřekLibuše HannahSibertLynnSehnLinusKöppLeoFriedrichDaphne. 2020. Beyond effectiveness: Legitimising predictive policing in Germany. Criminology – The Online Journal2(3): 423–443.
73.
WebsterSteven W.AlbertsonBethany. 2022. Emotion and politics: Noncognitive psychological biases in public opinion. Annual Review of Political Science25: 401–418.
74.
WeisburdDavidTelepCody W.HinkleJoshua C.EckJohn E.2010. Is problem-oriented policing effective in reducing crime and disorder? Findings from a Campbell systematic review. Criminology & Public Policy9(1): 139–172.
75.
WortleyScotOwusu-BempahAkwasi. 2011. The usual suspects: Police stop and search practices in Canada. Policing & Society21(4): 395–407.
