In this contribution, we examine whether and why there is a gap in the use of formal childcare services between immigrant and native families across 21 European countries. We focus on three sets of potential determinants: (1) social class, education and labour market position; (2) immigrant-specific factors such as norms in the region of origin, citizenship acquisition and length of stay in the country of residence; and (3) contextual factors such structural constraints impeding access to childcare and traditional norms on motherhood in the region of origin. Drawing on data from the 2010 ad hoc module of the EU Labour Force Survey, we find evidence for an immigrant-native gap in formal childcare use. Adjusted for social class position, education and maternal employment, immigrant families are less likely to use childcare compared to native families across European countries. However, there are important cross-country differences in the size of this gap. The study also provides evidence for immigrant-specific explanations: acquiring citizenship and staying longer in the country of residence increases the probability to use childcare, while the strength of traditional norms in the region of origin reduces the probability to use childcare. Finally, we find that structural barriers to childcare use negatively affect childcare use for both native and immigrant families. Removing barriers to childcare use in terms of availability and affordability will benefit everyone.
AbrassartABonoliG (2015) Availability cost or culture? Obstacles to childcare services for low-income families. Journal of Social Policy44(4): 787–806.
2.
AllenSF (2003) Working parents with young children: cross-national comparisons of policies and programmes in three countries. International Journal of Social Welfare12(4): 261–273.
3.
ArlottiMGambardellaDPavoliniE (2015) L’investimento sociale alle prese con diseguaglianze sociali e territoriali. In AscoliURanciCSgrittaG (eds) Investire nel sociale. La difficile Innovazione del Welfare Italiano. Bologna: Il Mulino, 45–73.
4.
BerghA (2017) Explaining the labor market gaps between immigrants and natives in the OECD. Migration Letters14(2): 251–262.
5.
BiedingerNBeckerBRohlingI (2008) Early ethnic educational inequality: The influence of duration of preschool attendance and social composition. European Sociological Review24(2): 243–256.
6.
BlossfeldHPKulicNSkopekJ, et al. (2017) Childcare Early Education and Social Inequality – An International Perspective. Cheltenham UK: Edward Elgar.
7.
BorgnaCContiniD (2014) Migrant achievement penalties in Western Europe: Do educational systems matter?European Sociological Review30(5): 670–683.
8.
BreenRBerntKKHolmA (2018) Interpreting and understanding logits probits and other nonlinear probability models. Annual Review of Sociology44: 39–54.
9.
BreidahlKNLarsenCA (2016) The myth of unadaptable gender roles: attitudes towards women’s paid work among immigrants across 30 European countries. Journal of European Social Policy26(5): 387–401.
10.
BrilliYKulicNTriventiM (2017) Who cares for the children? Family social position and childcare arrangements in Italy, 2002–12. In: Blossfeld P, Kulic N, Skopek J. and Triventi M (eds) Childcare, Early Education and Social Inequality. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing, 31–48.
11.
BryanMLJenkinsSP (2016) Multilevel modelling of country effects: A cautionary tale. European Sociological Review32(1): 3–22.
12.
BurgerK (2010) How does early childhood care and education affect cognitive development?Early Childhood Research Quarterly25(2): 140–165.
13.
Cebolla-BoadoHFinotelliC (2015) Is there a north–south divide in integration outcomes? A comparison of the integration outcomes of immigrants in southern and Northern Europe. European Journal of Population31(1): 77–102.
14.
DriessenGW (2004) A large-scale longitudinal study of the utilization and effects of early childhood education and care in the Netherlands. Early Child Development and Care174(7–8): 667–689.
15.
LesemanP (2009) The impact of high quality education and care on the development of young children: A review of the literature. In: EACEA (Ed.) Early Childhood Education and Care: Tackling Social and Cultural Inequalities. Brussels: EACEA, 17–50.
16.
ElffMHeisigJPSchaefferM, et al. (2021) Multilevel analysis with few clusters: Improving likelihood-based methods to provide unbiased estimates and accurate inference. British Journal of Political Science51(1): 412−426.
FramMSKimJ (2008) Race/ethnicity and the start of childcare: A multi-level analysis of factors influencing first childcare experiences. Early Childhood Research Quarterly23(4): 575–590.
19.
GarritzmannJLBusemeyerMRNeimannsE (2018) Public demand for social investment: New supporting coalitions for welfare state reform in Western Europe?Journal of European Public Policy25(6): 844–861.
20.
GottfriedMAKimHY (2015) Formal versus informal prekindergarten care and school readiness for children in immigrant families: A synthesis review. Educational Research Review16: 85–101.
21.
GreenbergJP (2011) The impact of maternal education on children’s enrollment in early childhood education and care. Children and Youth Services Review33(7):1049–1057.
22.
HainmuellerJHangartnerDPietrantuonoG (2015) Naturalization fosters the long-term political integration of immigrants. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences112(41): 12651–12656.
23.
HeathAFRothonCKilpiE (2008) The second generation in Western Europe: education unemployment and occupational attainment. Annual Review of Sociology34: 211–235.
24.
HoxJJ (2010) Multilevel Analysis: Techniques and Applications. 2nd ed. New York: Routledge.
25.
JehlesN (2017) Development of participation in early childhood education and care in Europe in relation to social inequality and migration. In BanuÇ, et al. The New Diversity of Family Life in Europe. Wiesbaden: Springer VS Wiesbaden, 61–80.
26.
JohnsonADPadillaCMVotruba-DrzalE (2017) Predictors of public early care and education use among children of low-income immigrants. Children and Youth Services Review73: 24–36.
27.
KahnJMGreenbergJP (2010) Factors predicting early childhood education and care use by immigrant families. Social Science Research39(4): 642–651.
28.
KaoGThompsonJS (2003) Racial and ethnic stratification in educational achievement and attainment. Annual Review of Sociology29(1): 417–442.
29.
KleinOBeckerB (2017) Preschools as language learning environments for children of immigrants. Differential effects by familial language use across different preschool contexts. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility48: 20–31.
30.
KoganI (2006) Labor markets and economic incorporation among recent immigrants in Europe. Social Forces85(2): 697–721.
31.
KrapfS (2014) Who uses public childcare for 2-year-old children? Coherent family policies and usage patterns in Sweden Finland and western Germany. International Journal of Social Welfare23(1): 25–40.
32.
KulicNSkopekJTriventiM, et al. (2019) Social background and children's cognitive skills: The role of early childhood education and care in a cross-national perspective. Annual Review of Sociology45: 557–579.
33.
LevelsMDronkersJKraaykampG (2008) Immigrant children’s educational achievement in western countries: Origin destination and community effects on mathematical performance. American Sociological Review73(5): 835–853.
34.
LokhandeM (2013) Hürdenlauf zur Kita: Warum Eltern mit Migrationshintergrund ihr Kind Seltener in die Frühkindliche Tagesbetreuung Schicken. Berlin: Sachverständigenrat deutscher Stiftungen für Integration und Migration GmbH (SVR).
35.
MagnusonKLahaieCWaldfogelJ (2006) Preschool and school readiness of children of immigrants. Social Science Quarterly87(5): 1241–1262.
36.
MelzerSMTomaskovic-DeveyDSchunckR (2018) A relational inequality approach to first-and second-generation immigrant earnings in German workplaces. Social Forces97(1): 91–128.
37.
MillerPVotruba-DrzalELevine ColeyR (2015) Predictors of early care and education type among preschool-aged children in immigrant families: The role of region of origin and characteristics of the immigrant experience. Children and Youth Services Review35: 1342–1355.
38.
MollDe TBetzF (2014) Inequality in pre-school education and care in Germany: An analysis by social class and immigrant status. International Studies in Sociology of Education24: 237–271.
39.
NorrisPInglehartRF (2012) Muslim integration into western cultures: Between origins and destinations. Political Studies60(2): 228–251.
40.
OECD (2006) Starting Strong II. Early Childhood Education and Care. Paris: OECD Publishing.
41.
OECD (2011) Naturalisation: A Passport for the Better Integration of Immigrants?Paris: OECD Publishing.
42.
PavoliniEVan LanckerW (2018) The Matthew effect in childcare use: A matter of policies or preferences?Journal of European Public Policy25(6): 878–893.
43.
PortesAZhouM (1993) The new second generation: Segmented assimilation and its variants. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science530: 74–96.
44.
ProsserT (2016) Dualization or liberalization? Investigating precarious work in eight European countries. Work Employment And Society30(6): 949–965.
45.
ReeskensTvan OorschotW (2015) Immigrants’ attitudes towards welfare redistribution. An exploration of role of government preferences among immigrants and natives across 18 European welfare states. European Sociological Review31(4): 433–445.
46.
SainsburyD (2019) Policy constructions immigrants’ social rights and gender: The case of Swedish childcare policies. Journal of European Social Policy29(2): 213–227.
47.
SchoberPSSpiessCK (2013) Early childhood education activities and care arrangements of disadvantaged children in Germany. Child Indicators Research6(4): 709–735.
48.
SeibelVHedegaardTF (2017) Migrants’ and natives’ attitudes to formal childcare in the Netherlands Denmark and Germany. Children and Youth Services Review78: 112–121.
49.
SirénSDoctrinalLVan LanckerW, et al. (2020) Childcare indicators for the Next Generation of Research. In: Nieuwenhuis, Rense, Van Lancker, Wim, (eds.), The Palgrave Handbook of Family Policy. Palgrave Macmillan, 627–655
50.
StahlJFSchoberPSSpiessCK (2018) Parental socio-economic status and childcare quality: Early inequalities in educational opportunity?Early Childhood Research Quarterly44(3): 304–317.
51.
UunkWKalmijnMMuffelsR (2005) The impact of young children on women’s labour supply: A reassessment of institutional effects in Europe. Acta Sociologica48(1): 41–62.
52.
VandenbroeckMDe VisscherSVan NuffelK, et al. (2008) Mothers’ search for infant childcare: The dynamic relationship between availability and desirability in a continental European welfare state. Early Childhood Research Quarterly23(2): 245–258.
53.
van KersbergenKKraftJ (2017) De-universalization and selective social investment in Scandinavia? In HemerijckA (ed) The Uses of Social Investment. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 216–226.
54.
Van LanckerW (2013) Putting the child-centred investment strategy to the test: Evidence for EU27. European Journal of Social Security15(1): 4–27.
55.
Van LanckerW (2018) Reducing inequality in childcare service use across European countries: What (if any) is the role of social spending. Social Policy & Administration52(1): 271–292.
56.
Van LanckerWGhyselsJ (2016) Explaining patterns of inequality in childcare service use across 31 developed economies: A welfare state perspective. International Journal of Comparative Sociology57(5): 310–337.
57.
Van TubergenF (2007) Religious affiliation and participation among immigrants in a secular society: A study of immigrants in the Netherlands. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies33(5): 747–765.
58.
VeselyCK (2013) Low-income African and Latina immigrant mothers’ selection of early childhood care and education (ECCE): Considering the complexity of cultural and structural influences. Early Childhood Research Quarterly28(3): 470–486.
59.
WallKJoseJS (2004) Managing work and care: A difficult challenge for immigrant families. Social Policy and Administration38: 591–621.
60.
WimmerAThomas SoehlT (2014) Blocked acculturation: Cultural heterodoxy among Europe’s immigrants. American Journal of Sociology120(1): 146–186.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
