In this article, I discuss how Locke's account of virtuous moral obligation fits with his theory of individual rights, with specific attention to his account of ownership. I suggest that the best way to make sense of the relationship between the competing concepts of rights and virtue in Locke's thought is through the idea of imperfect duties: moral duties that do not necessarily have a legal equivalent. These duties indicate how a teleological account of morality can exist within the framework of a commitment to individual rights while also raising questions about how a Lockean government should act in regard to them. I identify the imperfect duties involved in the ownership of property and tentatively explore Locke's scattered recommendations for ‘the art of governing’ individuals.
BuchananA. (1987) ‘Justice and charity’, Ethics, 97, 558–575.
2.
BuckleS. (1991) Natural Law and the Theory of Property: Grotius to Hume (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
3.
CohenG. A. (1995) Self-Ownership, Freedom and Equality (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
4.
ColemanJ. (2005) ‘Pre-modern property and self-ownership before and after Locke’, European Journal of Political Theory, 4:2, 125–145.
5.
DunnJ. (1969) The Political Thought of John Locke (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
6.
FabreC. (2006) Whose Body Is It Anyway? Justice and the Integrity of the Person (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
7.
FordeS. (2009) ‘The charitable John Locke’, The Review of Politics, 71:3, 428–458.
8.
GoldieM. (1997) “Introduction”, in Locke: Political Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), xi–xxvii.
9.
HohfeldW. N. (1923) Fundamental Legal Conceptions (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).
10.
HsuehV. (2008) ‘Unsettling colonies: Locke, “Atlantis” and New World knowledges’, History of Political Thought, 29:2, 295–319.
11.
KramerM. (1998) ‘Rights without trimmings’, in KramerM.SimmondsN. and SteinerH. (eds), A Debate about Rights (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 7–111.
12.
LambR. and ThompsonB. (2009) ‘The meaning of charity in Locke's political thought’, European Journal of Political Theory, 8:2, 229–252.
13.
LockeJ. (1983) A Letter Concerning Toleration (ed. TullyJ.) (Indianapolis, IN: Hackett).
14.
LockeJ. (1988) Two Treatises of Government (ed. LaslettP.) (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
15.
LockeJ. (1997a) ‘An essay on the poor law’, in GoldieM. (ed.), Political Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 182–198.
16.
LockeJ. (1997b) ‘Atlantis’, in GoldieM. (ed.), Political Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 252–259.
17.
LockeJ. (1997c) ‘Essays on the law of nature’, in GoldieM. (ed.), Political Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 79–133.
18.
LockeJ. (1997d) ‘Morality’, in GoldieM. (ed.), Political Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 267–269.
19.
LockeJ. (1997e) ‘Pacific Christians’, in GoldieM. (ed.), Political Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 304–306.
20.
LockeJ. (1997f) ‘Some thoughts concerning reading and study for a gentleman’, in GoldieM. (ed.), Political Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 348–355.
21.
LockeJ. (1997g) ‘Venditio’, in GoldieM. (ed.), Political Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 339–343.
22.
LockeJ. (1997h) ‘An essay on toleration’, in GoldieM. (ed.), Political Essays (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 134–159.
23.
MacphersonC. B. (1962) The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
24.
NozickR. (1974) Anarchy, State and Utopia (Oxford: Basil Blackwell).
25.
OtsukaM. (2003) Libertarianism without Inequality (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
26.
SigmundP. (2005) ‘The religious turn in Locke studies’, The Review of Politics, 67:3, 407–418.
27.
SimmonsA. J. (1992) The Lockean Theory of Rights (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
28.
SmithA. (1982) Lectures on Jurisprudence (ed. MeekR. L.RaphaelD. D. and SteinP. G.) (Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Fund).
29.
StantonT. (2008) ‘Hobbes and Locke on natural law and Jesus Christ’, History of Political Thought, 29:1, 65–88.
30.
ThalerR. H. and SunsteinC. (2008) Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth and Happiness (London: Penguin).
31.
TullyJ. (1980) A Discourse on Property: John Locke and his Adversaries (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
32.
WaldronJ. (1988) The Right to Private Property (Oxford: Clarendon Press).
33.
WaldronJ. (2002) God, Locke, and Equality: Christian Foundations in Locke's Political Thought (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
