Few studies have analyzed the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool's (SCAT) utility among athletes whose concussion assessment is challenging. Using a previously published algorithm, we identified possible and probable concussions at <6 h (n = 393 males, n = 265 females) and 24–48 h (n = 323 males, n = 236 females) post-injury within collegiate student-athletes and cadets from the Concussion Assessment, Research, and Education (CARE) Consortium. We applied cluster analysis to characterize performance on the Standard Assessment of Concussion (SAC), Balance Error Scoring System (BESS), and the SCAT symptom checklist for these athletes. Among the cluster sets that best separated acute concussions and normal performances, total symptom number raw score and change and post-traumatic migraine raw score and change score were the most frequent clustering variables across males and females at <6 h and 24–48 h. Similarly, total symptom number raw score and change score and post-traumatic migraine raw score and change score were most significantly different between clusters for males and females at <6 h and 24–48 h. Our results suggest that clinicians should focus on total symptom number, post-traumatic migraine symptoms, and cognitive-fatigue symptoms when assessing possible and probable concussions, followed by the SAC and BESS scores.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2016). Centers for Disease Control and Prevention - Injury Prevention & Control: Traumatic Brain Injury & Concussion. http://www.cdc.gov/traumaticbraininjury/ (Last accessed August31, 2016).
2.
McCroryP., MeeuwisseW.H., KutcherJ.S., JordanB.D., and GardnerA. (2013). What is the evidence for chronic concussion-related changes in retired athletes: behavioural, pathological and clinical outcomes?. Br. J. Sports Med. 47, 327–330.
3.
RandolphC., KarantzoulisS., and GuskiewiczK. (2013). Prevalence and characterization of mild cognitive impairment in retired national football league players. J. Int. Neuropsychol. Soc. 19, 873–80.
4.
GuskiewiczK.M., MarshallS.W., BailesJ., McCreaM., CantuR.C., RandolphC., and JordanB.D. (2005). Association between recurrent concussion and late-life cognitive impairment in retired professional football players. Neurosurgery, 57, 719–726.
5.
KerrZ.Y., MarshallS.W., HardingH.P., and GuskiewiczK.M. (2012). Nine-year risk of depression diagnosis increases with increasing self-reported concussions in retired professional football players. Am. J. Sports Med. 40, 2206–2212.
6.
GuskiewiczK.M., MarshallS.W., BailesJ., McCreaM.A., HardingH.P., MatthewsA., Register-MihalikJ.K., and CantuR.C. (2007). Recurrent concussion and risk of depression in retired professional football players. Med. Sci. Sport. Exerc. 39, 903–909.
7.
MakdissiM., DavisG., and McCroryP. (2015). Clinical challenges in the diagnosis and assessment of sports-related concussion. Neurol. Clin. Pract. 5, 2–5.
8.
PutukianM., RafteryM., GuskiewiczK., HerringS., AubryM., CantuR.C., and MolloyM. (2013). Onfield assessment of concussion in the adult athlete. Br. J. Sports Med. 47, 285–288.
9.
McCroryP., MeeuwisseW., DvorakJ., AubryM., BailesJ., BroglioS., CantuR.C., CassidyD., EchemendiaR.J., CastellaniR.J., DavisG.A., EllenbogenR., EmeryC., EngebretsenL., Feddermann-DemontN., GizaC.C., GuskiewiczK.M., HerringS., IversonG.L., JohnstonK.M., KissickJ., KutcherJ., LeddyJ.J., MaddocksD., MakdissiM., ManleyG.T., McCreaM., MeehanW.P., NagahiroS., PatriciosJ., PutukianM., SchneiderK.J., SillsA., TatorC.H., TurnerM., and VosP.E. (2017). Consensus statement on concussion in sport—the 5th international conference on concussion in sport held in Berlin, October 2016. Br. J. Sports Med. 51, 838–847.
10.
HarmonK.G., ClugstonJ.R., DecK., HainlineB., HerringS., KaneS.F., KontosA.P., LeddyJ.J., McCreaM., PoddarS.K., PutukianM., WilsonJ.C., and RobertsW.O. (2019). American Medical Society for Sports Medicine position statement on concussion in sport. Br. J. Sports Med. 53, 213–225.
11.
EchemendiaR.J., MeeuwisseW., McCroryP., DavisG.A., PutukianM., LeddyJ., MakdissiM., SullivanS.J., BroglioS.P., RafteryM., SchneiderK., KissickJ., McCreaM., DvorakJ., SillsA.K., AubryM., EngebretsenL., LoosemoreM., FullerG., KutcherJ., EllenbogenR., GuskiewiczK., PatriciosJ., and HerringS. (2017). The Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 5th Edition (SCAT5). Br. J. Sports Med. 5, 1–3.
12.
GarciaG.-G.P., BroglioS.P., LavieriM.S., McCreaM., and McAllisterT. (2018). Quantifying the value of multidimensional assessment models for acute concussion: an analysis of data from the NCAA-DoD CARE Consortium. Sport Med. 48, 1739–1749.
13.
ReschJ.E., BrownC.N., SchmidtJ., MacciocchiS.N., BlueittD., CullumC.M., and FerraraM.S. (2016). The sensitivity and specificity of clinical measures of sport concussion: three tests are better than one. BMJ Open Sport Exerc. Med. 2, e000012.
14.
ChinE.Y., NelsonL.D., BarrW.B., McCroryP., and McCreaM.A. (2016). Reliability and validity of the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool-3 (SCAT3) in high school and collegiate athletes. Am. J. Sports Med. 44, 2276–2285.
15.
Register-MihalikJ.K., GuskiewiczK.M., MihalikJ.P., SchmidtJ.D., KerrZ.Y., and McCreaM. a. (2013). Reliable change, sensitivity, and specificity of a multidimensional concussion assessment battery. J. Head Trauma Rehabil. 28, 274–283.
16.
BroglioS.P., MacciocchiS.N., and FerraraM.S. (2007). Sensitivity of the concussion assessment battery. Neurosurgery, 60, 1050–1057.
17.
DowneyR.I., HutchisonM.G., and ComperP. (2018). Determining sensitivity and specificity of the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 3 (SCAT3) components in university athletes. Brain Inj. 32, 1345–1352.
18.
GarciaG.-G.P., LavieriM.S., JiangR., McAllisterT.W., McCreaM.A., and BroglioS.P. (2019). A data-driven approach to unlikely, possible, probable, and definite acute concussion assessment. J. Neurotrauma, 36, 1571–1583.
19.
BroglioS.P., McCreaM., McAllisterT., HarezlakJ., KatzB., HackD., and HainlineB. (2017). A national study on the effects of concussion in collegiate athletes and us military service academy members: the NCAA–DoD Concussion Assessment, Research and Education (CARE) Consortium structure and methods. Sport Med. 47, 1437–1451.
20.
CarneyN., GhajarJ., JagodaA., BedrickS., Davis-O'ReillyC., Du CoudrayH., HackD., HelfandN., HuddlestonA., NettletonT., and RiggioS. (2014). Concussion guidelines step 1: Systematic review of prevalent indicators. Neurosurgery, 75, 3–15.
21.
McCreaM., KellyJ.P., RandolphC., KlugeJ., BartolicE., FinnG., and BaxterB. (1998). Standardized assessment of concussion (SAC): on-site mental status evaluation of the athlete. J. Head Trauma Rehabil. 13, 27–35.
22.
RiemannB.L., GuskiewiczK.M., and ShieldsE.W. (1999). Relationship between clinical and forceplate measures of postural stability. J. Sport Rehabil. 8, 71–82.
23.
Concussion in Sport Group (2013). Sport Concussion Assessment Tool - 3rd Edition. Br. J. Sports Med. 47, 259.
24.
GarciaG.-G.P., YangJ., LavieriM.S., McAllisterT.W., McCreaM.A., and BroglioS.P. (2020). Optimizing components of the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool for acute concussion assessment. Neurosurgery, 87, 971–981.
RoystonP. (2004). Multiple imputation of missing values. Stata J. 4, 224–241.
28.
AzurM.J., StuartE.A., FrangakisC., and LeafP.J. (2011). Multiple imputation by chained equations: what is it and how does it work?. Int. J. Methods Psychiatr. Res. 20, 40–49.
29.
EfronB., and TibshiraniR.J. (1993). An Introduction to the Bootstrap. Chapman & Hall: New York.
30.
GarciaG.-G.P., LavieriM.S., JiangR., McCreaM.A., McAllisterT.W., and BroglioS.P. (2020). Data-driven stochastic optimization approaches to determine decision thresholds for risk estimation models. IISE Trans. 52, 1098–1121.
31.
JainA.K. (2010). Data clustering: 50 years beyond K-means. Pattern Recognit. Lett. 31, 651–666.
32.
FormannA.K. (1984). Die latent-class-analyse: Einführung in Theorie und Anwendung [Latent Class Analysis: Introduction to Theory and Application]. Beltz:. Weinheim.
33.
RousseeuwP.J. (1987). Silhouettes: a graphical aid to the interpretation and validation of cluster analysis. J. Comput. Appl. Math. 20, 53–65.
34.
CowellF.A. (2000). Measurement of inequality, in: Handbook of Income Distribution. Elsevier Science & Technology: Amsterdam. pps. 87–166.
35.
McCreaM.A., BarrW.B., GuskiewiczK.M., RandolphC., MarshallS.W., CantuR.C., OnateJ.A., and KellyJ.P. (2005). Standard regression-based methods for measuring recovery after sport-related concussion. J. Int. Neuropsychol. Soc. 11, 58–69.
36.
BroglioS.P., HarezlakJ., KatzB., ZhaoS., McAllisterT., McCreaM., HazzardJ., KellyL., CampbellD., JacksonJ., McGintyG., O'DonnellP., CameronK., SusmarskiA., GoldmanJ., GizaC., BuckleyT., KaminskiT., ClugstonJ., SchmidtJ., FeigenbaumL., EcknerJ.T., AndersonS., MasterC., KontosA., ChrismanS., and BrooksA. (2019). Acute sport concussion assessment optimization: a prospective assessment from the CARE Consortium. Sport. Med. 49, 1977–1987.
37.
PutukianM., EchemendiaR., Dettwiler-DanspeckgruberA., DulibaT., BruceJ., FurtadoJ.L., and MurugavelM. (2015). Prospective clinical assessment using sideline concussion assessment tool-2 testing in the evaluation of sport-related concussion in college athletes. Clin. J. Sport Med. 25, 36–42.
38.
SchmidtJ.D., Register-MihalikJ.K., MihalikJ.P., KerrZ.Y., and GuskiewiczK.M. (2012). Identifying impairments after concussion. Med. Sci. Sport. Exerc. 44, 1621–1628.
39.
EchemendiaR.J., BruceJ.M., BaileyC.M., SandersJ.F., ArnettP., and VargasG. (2012). The utility of post-concussion neuropsychological data in identifying cognitive change following sports-related MTBI in the absence of baseline data. Clin. Neuropsychol. 26, 1077–1091.
CovassinT., SchatzP., and SwanikC.B. (2007). Sex differences in neuropsychological function and post-concussion symptoms of concussed collegiate athletes. Neurosurgery, 61, 345–350.
42.
CovassinT., ElbinR.J., HarrisW., ParkerT., and KontosA. (2012). The role of age and sex in symptoms, neurocognitive performance, and postural stability in athletes after concussion. Am. J. Sports Med. 40, 1303–1312.
43.
CovassinT., SavageJ.L., BretzinA.C., and FoxM.E. (2018). Sex differences in sport-related concussion long-term outcomes. Int. J. Psychophysiol. 132, 9–13.
44.
MoranR.N., MeekJ., AllenJ., and RobinsonJ. (2020). Sex differences and normative data for the m-CTSIB and sensory integration on baseline concussion assessment in collegiate athletes. Brain Inj. 34, 20–25.
45.
DickR.W. (2009). Is there a gender difference in concussion incidence and outcomes?. Br. J. Sports Med. 43, i46–i50.
46.
KutcherJ.S., and GizaC.C. (2014). Sports concussion diagnosis and management. Continuum (N. Y). 20, 1552–1569.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
