Frequency-Dependent Relationship Between Resting-State Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Signal Power and Head Motion Is Localized Within Distributed Association Networks

Abstract

Recent studies have highlighted the importance of analyzing spectral power in resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI) data. Significant modulation of power has been ascribed to the performance of cognitive tasks and has been ascribed clinical significance. However, the role of confounding factors such as head motion on spectral power is not fully understood. Specifically, the spatial distribution of frequency-dependent associations between rs-fMRI power and motion is unknown. We utilized a large rs-fMRI dataset (n=1000) to quantify the influence of head motion on spectral power in different frequency bands. We (1) performed regression analyses across the entire sample and (2) computed difference maps between high- and low-motion groups, more consistent with common experimental designs, and both analyses gave similar results. Greater head motion led to reduced spectral power at lower frequencies (0.007–0.05 Hz), but increased power at higher frequencies (0.12–0.167 Hz). Importantly, our whole-brain voxel-wise analysis showed that brain areas in distributed association networks (e.g., default mode and frontoparietal control networks) were most susceptible to head motion. These results were consistent with or without global signal regression (GSR). Additionally, without GSR, we noted a positive correlation with low-frequency power in the pre- and postcentral gyrus (S1/M1), mid-cingulate cortex, and insula and a negative correlation with mid-frequency (0.05–0.12 Hz) power in S1/M1, visual, and lateral temporal cortices. Hence, head motion significantly affects rs-fMRI power and great care must be taken when assigning a diagnostic marker for clinical populations known to present with greater head motion.