In the phenomenon of transfer along a continuum (TAC), initial training on easy items facilitates later learning of a harder discrimination. TAC is a widely replicated cross-species phenomenon that is well predicted by certain kinds of associative theory. A recent report of an approximately opposite phenomenon (i.e., facilitation by initial training on hard items) poses a puzzle for such theories, but is predicted by a dual-system model (COVIS). However, across four experiments, we present substantial evidence that this counterintuitive finding was in error. Rather, the result appears to be a false positive and, as such, should not form part of the evidence base for COVIS nor be considered as a counter-example to the pervasive TAC phenomenon.
AhissarM.HochsteinS. (1997). Task difficulty and the specificity of perceptual learning. Nature, 387, 401–406.
2.
AshbyF. G.Alfonso-ReeseL. A.TurkenA. U.WaldronE. M. (1998). A neuropsychological theory of multiple systems in category learning. Psychological Review, 105, 442–481.
3.
AshbyF. G.PaulE. J.MaddoxW. T. (2011). COVIS. In PothosE. M.WillsA. J. (Eds.), Formal approaches in categorization (pp. 65–87). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
4.
BaguleyT. (2012). Calculating and graphing within-subject confidence intervals for ANOVA. Behavior Research Methods, 44, 158–175.
5.
BaguleyT.KayeD. (2010). Book review: Understanding psychology as a science: An introduction to scientific and statistical inference. British Journal of Mathematical & Statistical Psychology, 63, 695–698.
6.
BrainardD. H. (1997). The psychophysics toolbox. Spatial Vision, 10, 433–436.
7.
CarpenterK. L.WillsA. J.BenattayallahA.MiltonF. (2016). A comparison of the neural correlates that underlie rule-based and information-integration category learning. Human Brain Mapping, 37, 3557–3574.
8.
ChurchB. A.MercadoE.WisniewskiM. G.LiuE. H. (2013). Temporal dynamics in auditory perceptual learning: Impact of sequencing and incidental learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 39, 270–276.
9.
DienesZ. (2011). Bayesian versus orthodox statistics: Which side are you on?Perspectives on Psychological Science, 6, 274–290.
10.
DoaneS.SohnY.SchreiberB. (1999). The role of processing strategies in the acquisition and transfer of cognitive skill. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 5, 1390–1410.
11.
DonkinC.NewellB. R.KalishM.DunnJ. C.NosofskyR. M. (2015). Identifying strategy use in category learning tasks: A case for more diagnostic data and models. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 41, 933–948.
12.
EdmundsC. E. R.MiltonF.WillsA. J. (2015). Feedback can be superior to observational training for both rule-based and information-integration category structures. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 68, 1203–1222.
13.
EdmundsC. E. R.MiltonF.WillsA. J. (2017). Due process in dual-process: Model recovery simulations of general recognition theory analysis. Manuscript submitted for publication.
14.
EllS. W.AshbyF. G. (2006). The effects of category overlap on information-integration and rule-based category learning. Perception & Psychophysics, 68, 1013–1026.
15.
FiloteoJ. V.LauritzenS.MaddoxW. T. (2010). Removing the frontal lobes: The effects of engaging executive functions on perceptual category learning. Psychological Science, 21, 415–423.
16.
HornsbyA. N.LoveB. C. (2014). Improved classification of mammograms following idealized training. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, 3, 72–76.
17.
JeffreysH. (1961). The Theory of Probability (3rd ed.). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
18.
KonstantinidisE.ShanksD. R. (2014). Don’t bet on it! Wagering as a measure of awareness in decision making under uncertainty. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 143, 2111–2134.
19.
LawrenceD. H. (1952). The transfer of a discrimination along a continuum. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 45, 511–516.
20.
LeeE. S.MacGregorJ. N.BavelasA.MirlinL.LamN. (1988). The effects of error transformations on classification performance. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 14, 66–74.
21.
Le PelleyM. E.MitchellC. J.BeesleyT.GeorgeD. N.WillsA. J. (2016). Attention and associative learning in humans: An integrative review. Psychological Bulletin, 142, 1111–1140.
22.
MackintoshN. J. (1975). A theory of attention: Variations in the associability of stimuli with reinforcement. Psychological Review, 82, 276–298.
23.
MackintoshN. J.LittleL. (1970). An analysis of transfer along a continuum. Canadian Journal of Psychology, 24, 362–369.
24.
MaddoxW. T.AshbyF. G. (1993). Comparing decision bound and exemplar models of categorization. Perception & Psychophysics, 53, 49–70.
McLarenI. P. L.MackintoshN. J. (2002). Associative learning and elemental representation: II. Generalization and discrimination. Animal Learning & Behavior, 30, 177–200.
27.
NewellB. R.DunnJ. C.KalishM. (2010). The dimensionality of perceptual category learning: A state-trace analysis. Memory & Cognition, 38, 563–581.
28.
NewellB. R.MooreC.WillsA. J.MiltonF. (2013). Reinstating the frontal lobes? Having more time to think improves ‘implicit’ perceptual categorization. A comment on Filoteo, Lauritzen and Maddox (2010). Psychological Science, 24, 386–389.
29.
NewellB. R.ShanksD. R. (2014). Unconscious influences on decision making: A critical review. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 37, 1–19.
30.
NosofskyR. M.KruschkeJ. K. (2002). Single-system models and interference in category learning: Commentary on Waldron and Ashby (2001).Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 9, 169–174.
31.
NosofskyR. M.StantonR. D.ZakiS. R. (2005). Procedural interference in perceptual classification: Implicit learning or cognitive complexity?Memory & Cognition, 33, 1256–1271.
32.
PelliD. G. (1997). The VideoToolbox software for visual psychophysics: Transforming numbers into movies. Spatial Vision, 10, 437–442.
33.
PittM. A.MyungI. J.ZhangS. (2002). Toward a method of selecting among computational models of cognition. Psychological Review, 109, 472–491.
34.
R Core Team. (2017). R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Available from https://www.r-project.org/
35.
RoederJ. L.AshbyF. G. (2016). What is automatized during perceptual categorization?Cognition, 154, 22–33.
36.
SchwarzG. (1978). Estimating the dimension of a model. The Annals of Statistics, 6, 461–464.
37.
ShanksD. R.St. JohnM. F. (1994). Characteristics of dissociable human learning-systems. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 17, 367–395.
38.
SmithJ. D.ZakrzewskiA. C.HerbergerE. R.BoomerJ.RoederJ. L.AshbyF. G.ChurchB. A. (2015). The time course of explicit and implicit categorization. Attention, Perception & Psychophysics, 77, 2476–2490.
39.
SpieringB. J.AshbyF. G. (2008). Initial training with difficult items facilitates information-integration but not rule-based category learning. Psychological Science, 19, 1169–1177.
40.
StantonR. D.NosofskyR. M. (2007). Feedback interference and dissociations of classification: Evidence against the multiple-learning-systems hypothesis. Memory & Cognition, 35, 1747–1758.
41.
StantonR. D.NosofskyR. M. (2013). Category number impacts rule-based and information-integration category learning: A reassessment of evidence for dissociable category-learning systems. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 39, 1174–1191.
42.
SuretM.McLarenI. P. L. (2003). Representation and discrimination on an artificial dimension. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section B: Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 56, 30–42.
43.
SutherlandN. S.MackintoshN. J. (1971). Mechanisms of animal discrimination learning. New York, NY: Academic Press.
44.
WagenmakersE.-J.FarrellS. (2004). AIC model selection using Akaike weights. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 11, 192–196.
45.
WillsA. J.MiltonF.LongmoreC. A.HesterS.RobinsonJ. (2013). Is overall similarity classification less effortful than single-dimension classification?Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 66, 299–318.
46.
YeatesF.JonesF.WillsA.AitkenM.McLarenI. (2013). Implicit learning: A demonstration and a revision of a novel SRT paradigm. In KnauffM.PauenM.SebanzN.WachsmuthI. (Eds.), Proceedings of the 35th annual conference of the cognitive science society (Vol. 1, pp. 3829–3834). Austin, TX: Cognitive Science Society.
47.
ZakiS. R.KleinschmidtD. F. (2014). Procedural memory effects in categorization: Evidence for multiple systems or task complexity?Memory & Cognition, 42, 508–524.
48.
ZeithamovaD.MaddoxW. T. (2006). Dual-task interference in perceptual category learning. Memory & Cognition, 34, 387–398.
