This paper seeks to critically assess the contemporary approaches to radicalisation and violent extremism in culturally diverse societies, and suggests an alternative approach drawing on the insights provided by two streams of contemporary democratic theory: deliberative democracy and agonistic pluralism. This approach puts the inevitability of conflict rather than the goal of consensus at the heart of democratic communication and offers a constructive way of dealing with such conflict in the face of deep disagreements. The paper focuses particularly on the example of Australia as a multicultural society facing the challenge of religious extremism and identifies the conditions under which the deliberative approach can address this form of extremism constructively and effectively.
AggestamK., CristianoF. & StrömbomL.2015, ‘Towards Agonistic Peacebuilding? Exploring the Antagonism–Agonism Nexus in the Middle East Peace Process’ in Third World Quarterly36: 9: 1736–1753.
2.
AkbarzadehS.2013, ‘Investing in Mentoring and Educational Initiatives: The Limits of De-Radicalisation Programmes in Australia’ in Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs33: 4: 451–463.
3.
Al-MomaniK., DadosN., MaddoxM. & WiseA.2010, ‘Political Participation of Muslims in Australia’, Final Report, Macquarie University, Centre for Research on Social Inclusion, Sydney.
4.
Alternatives to Violence Project2017, ‘AVP in Australia’: http://www.avp.org.au, accessed 27 February 2017.
5.
Australian Government2015a, ‘Review of Australia's Counter-terrorism Machinery’, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, Canberra.
6.
Australian Government2015b, ‘Preventing Violent Extremism and Radicalisation in Australia’, Report, Attorney-General's Department, Canberra.
7.
BenhabibS.1996, ‘Toward a Deliberative Model of Democratic Legitimacy’ in BenhabibS. ed., Democracy and Difference, Princeton: Princeton University Press: 67–94.
8.
BenhabibS.2002, The Claims of Culture: Equality and Diversity in the Global Era, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
9.
BlairK.2015, ‘Young Adults’ Attitudes Towards Multiculturalism in Australia: Tensions between the Multicultural State and the Intercultural Citizen’ In Journal of Intercultural Studies36: 4: 431–449.
ConnollyW.E.1993, ‘Beyond Good and Evil: The Ethical Sensibility of Michel Foucault’ in Political Theory21: 365–389.
12.
ConnollyW.E.2002, Identity\Difference: Democratic Negotiations of Political Paradox, Expanded Edition, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
13.
ConnollyW.E.2005, Pluralism, Durham: Duke University Press.
14.
DeveauxM.2006, Gender and Justice in Multicultural Liberal States, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
15.
DeveauxM. forthcoming, ‘Deliberative Democracy and Multiculturalism’ in BächtigerA., DryzekJ.S., MansbridgeJ. & WarrenM.E., eds, The Oxford Handbook of Deliberative Democracy, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
16.
DobsonA.2014, Listening for Democracy: Recognition, Representation, Reconciliation, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
DryzekJ.S.2005, ‘Deliberative Democracy in Divided Societies: Alternatives to Agonism and Analgesia’ in Political Theory33: 2: 218–242.
19.
DunnK., AtieR. & MapedzahamaV.2016, ‘Ordinary Cosmopolitans: Sydney Muslims’ in Attitudes to Diversity’ In Australian Geographer47: 3: 281–294.
20.
DunnK. & KampA.2015, ‘The Virtues and Challenges of Comparative Analyses of Immigration, Migrant Settlement and Transnationalism’ in CastlesS., OzkulD. & CubasM. eds, Social Transformation and Migration: National and Local Experiences in South Korea, Turkey, Mexico and Australia, London: Palgrave Macmillan: 33–44.
21.
ErcanS.A.2011, ‘The Deliberative Politics of Cultural Diversity: Beyond Interest and Identity Politics’ in MonsouriF. & LoboM. eds, Migration, Citizenship and Intercultural Relations: Looking through the Lens of Social Inclusion, Farnham: Ashgate: 75–88.
22.
ErcanS.A.2017, ‘From Polarisation to Pluralisation: A Deliberative Democratic Approach to Illiberal Cultures’ in International Political Science Review38: 1: 114–127.
23.
ErcanS.A. & DryzekJ.S.2015, ‘The Reach of Deliberative Democracy’ in Policy Studies36: 3: 241–248.
24.
GloverR.W.2011, ‘Games without Frontiers? Democratic Engagement, Agonistic Pluralism, and the Question of Exclusion’ in Philosophy and Social Criticism38: 1: 81–104.
25.
GoiS.2005, ‘Agonism, Deliberation, and the Politics of Abortion’ in Polity37: 1: 54–81.
26.
GozdeckaD., ErcanS.A. & KmakM.2014, ‘From Multiculturalism to Post-multiculturalism: Trends and Paradoxes’ in Journal of Sociology50: 51–64.
27.
GutmannA. & ThompsonD.1996, Democracy and Disagreement, Cambridge: The Belknap Press.
28.
GutmannA. & ThompsonD.2004, Why Deliberative Democracy?, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
29.
HarrisA.2010, ‘Young People, Everyday Civic Life and the Limits of Social Cohesion’ in Journal of Intercultural Studies31: 5: 573–589.
HoC.2013, ‘From Social Justice to Social Cohesion: A History of Australian Multicultural Policy’ in JakubowiczA. & HoC. eds, ‘For Those Who've Come Across the Seas …’: Australian Multicultural Theory, Policy and Practice, Melbourne: Australian Scholarly: 31–41.
32.
HuntingtonS.P.1993, ‘The Clash of Civilizations?’ in Foreign Affairs73: 3: 22–49.
33.
IlardiG.J.2013, ‘Interviews with Canadian Radicals’ in Studies in Conflict & Terrorism36: 713–738.
34.
IvisonD.2002, Postcolonial Liberalism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
JakubowiczA. & HoC.2013 eds, ‘For Those Who've Come Across the Seas …’: Australian Multicultural Theory, Policy and Practice, Melbourne: Australian Scholarly.
36.
KanraB.2009, Islam, Democracy, and Dialogue in Turkey: Deliberating in Divided Societies, Farnham: Ashgate.
37.
KymlickaW.1995, Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights, New York: Oxford University Press.
38.
KymlickaW.2001, Politics in the Vernacular: Nationalism, Multiculturalism, and Citizenship, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
39.
LuskinC.R., O'FlynnI., FishkinJ.S. & RussellD.2014, ‘Deliberating Across Deep Divides’ in Political Studies62: 116–135.
40.
MadisonS.2015, ‘Relational Transformation and Agonistic Dialogue in Divided Societies’ in Political Studies63: 1014–1030.
41.
MalikM.2008, ‘Engaging with Extremists’ in International Relations22: 1: 85–104.
42.
Ministerial Council on Immigration and Multicultural Affairs2007, A National Action Plan to Build on Social Cohesion, Harmony and Security, Ministerial Council on Immigration and Multicultural Affairs: Canberra.
43.
MouffeC.2000, The Democratic Paradox, London: Verso.
44.
MouffeC.2013, Agonistics: Thinking the World Politically, London: Verso.
45.
PhillipsA.2007, Multiculturalism without Culture, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
46.
RichardsonJ.T.2013, ‘Managing Minority Religious and Ethnic Groups in Australia: Implications for Social Cohesion’ in Social Compass60: 4: 579–590.
47.
RooseJ.M. & HarrisA.2015, ‘Muslim Citizenship in Everyday Australian Civic Spaces’ in Journal of Intercultural Studies36: 4: 468–486.
48.
SchaapA.2006, ‘Agonism in Divided Societies’ in Philosophy and Social Criticism32: 2: 255–277.
49.
ShinkoR.E.2008, ‘Agonistic Peace: A Postmodern Reading’ in Millennium: Journal of International Studies36: 3: 473–491.
50.
SiuA. & StanisevskiD.2012, ‘Deliberation in Multicultural Societies: Addressing Inequality, Exclusion, and Marginalization’ in NabatchiT., GastilJ., LeighningerM. & WeiksnerG.M. eds, Democracy in Motion: Evaluating the Practice and Impact of Deliberative Civic Engagement, Oxford: Oxford University Press: 83–102.
51.
TullyJ.1999, ‘The Agonic Freedom of Citizens’ in Economy and Society28: 2: 161–182.
52.
VasilevG.2015, Solidarity Across Divides: Promoting the Moral Point of View, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
53.
VastaE.2013, ‘Do We Need Social Cohesion in the 21st Century? Multiple Languages of Belonging in the Metropolis’ in Journal of Intercultural Studies34: 2: 196–213.
54.
VertovecS. & WessendorfS.2010 eds, The Multiculturalism Backlash: European Discourses, Policies and Practices, London: Routledge.
55.
WalshK.C.2007, ‘The Democratic Potential of Civic Dialogue’ in RosenbergS.W. ed., Deliberation, Participation and Democracy: Can the People Govern?Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan: 45–63.
56.
WydraH.2008, ‘The Recurrence of Violence’ in Sociology Compass2: 1: 183–194.
