Africa is a region characterised by state fragility based largely on the failure
of Western-style institutions. This article argues that local/hybrid political
order can emerge as a response to lack of access and persistent sub-national
concentrations (decentralisation) of power in post-colonial states. The role of
sharia in producing political trust in three states in Nigeria is examined and
the argument advanced that even in divided states it can function to increase
trust, thereby providing legitimacy. The study finds broad support for the
contention that hybrid political orders produce greater legitimacy, with trust
in local and national governments reflected in Kebbi, Kaduna, and Zamfara states
that generally exceed national averages.
AbduH.UmarL. (2002).
Ethnic and Religious Crisis in Kaduna.
Hope Betrayed: A Report on Impunity and State-sponsored Violence in
NigeriaGeneva: World Organisation
Against Torture83–104.
2.
AbramsonP. (1983). Political
Attitudes in America: Formation and ChangeSan Francisco: W.H.
Freeman.
3.
AlmondG.VerbaS. (1963). The Civic
Culture: Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five CountriesPrinceton: Princeton University
Press.
4.
AshcroftB.GriffithsG.TiffenH. (2006). The
Post-Colonial Studies ReaderNew York:
Routledge.
5.
BatesR. (2008). When
Things Fell Apart: State Failure in Late-century AfricaNew York: Cambridge University
Press.
6.
BelloniR. (2012).
Hybrid Peace Governance: Its Significance and
Emergence. Global Governance18, 121–38.
7.
BlenchR.LongtauS.HassanU.WalshM. (2006). The Role
of Traditional Rulers in Conflict Prevention and Mediation in
Nigeria Report prepared for DFID, Nigeria.
8.
BoegeV.BrownA.ClementsK.NolanA. (2008). On Hybrid
Political Orders and Emerging States: State Formation in the Context of
FragilityLeiden: Berghof Research Centre
for Constructive Crisis Management.
9.
BrempongA. (2001).
Transformations in Traditional Rule in Ghana (1951–1966)Accra: SEDCO
Enterprise.
10.
BrownM.E. (2001).
Nationalism and Ethnic ConflictCambridge: MIT University
Press.
11.
CollierP.HoefflerA. (2004).
Greed & Grievance in Civil War.
Oxford Economic Papers56, 4563–595.
12.
CoreyA.JoiremanS.F. (2004).
Redistributive Justice: The Gacaca Courts in
Rwanda. African Affairs103, 41073–89.
Private Authority and International
AffairsCutlerC.HauflerV.PorterT.Albany: State University of New
York Press1999.
15.
De WaalA. (2010). An
Emancipatory Imperium? Power and Principle in the Humanitarian
International. Contemporary States of Emergency: The
Politics of Military and Humanitarian InterventionsFassinD.PandolfiM.Boston: Zone
Books.
16.
Di JohnJ. (2008).
Conceptualising The Causes and Consequences of Failed States: A
Critical Review of the LiteratureLondon: Crisis States Research
Centre.
17.
DoyleM.SambanisN. (2006). United
Nations Peace Operations: Making War and Building PeacePrinceton: Princeton University
Press.
18.
EllisS. (2005). How
to Rebuild Africa. Foreign Affairs
September/October.
19.
EnglebertP. (2000). State
Legitimacy and Development in AfricaLondon: Lynne
Rienner.
20.
EnglebertP.TullD. (2008).
Postconflict Reconstruction in Africa: Flawed Ideas about
Failed States. International Security32, 4106–139.
21.
FearonJ.LaitinD. (2003).
Ethnicity, Insurgency, and Civil War.
American Political Science Review97, 175–90.
22.
FierensJ. (2005).
Gacaca Courts: Between Fantasy and
Reality. Journal of International Criminal
Justice3, 896–919.
23.
FjelstadO.IversenV.BahiigwaG.EllisR.JamesR. (2006).
Private Tax Collection – Remnant of the Past or a Way
Forward? Evidence from Rural Uganda. Public
Administration and Development26, 4317–328.
Complex Sovereignty. Reconstituting
Political Authority in the Twenty-first CenturyGrandeE.PaulyL.Toronto: Toronto University
Press2005.
26.
GervanosiC. (2010). A
Rentier Theory of Subnational Regimes: Fiscal Federalism, Democracy, and
Authoritarianism in the Argentine Provinces. World
Politics62, 2Special Issue: Hybridity in Peacebuilding and Development302–340.
27.
HarnischefegerJ. (2008).
Democratisation and Islamic Law: The Sharia Conflict in
NigeriaFrankfurt: Campus
Vertag.
28.
HesselbeinG.Golooba-MutebiF. (2006). Economic
and Political Foundations of State-making in Africa: Understanding State
ReconstructionLondon: Crisis States Research
Network.
29.
HetheringtonM. (1998). The
Political Relevance of Political Trust. American
Political Science Review92, 4791–808.
30.
HetheringtonM. (2005). Why Trust
Matters: Declining Political Trust and the Demise of American
LiberalismPrinceton: Princeton University
Press.
HutchisonM.JohnsonK. (2005).
Capacity to Trust? Institutional Capacity, Conflict, and
Political Trust in Africa, 2000–2005. Journal of
Peace Research48, 6737–752.
33.
JosephR.KewD. (2008).
Nigeria Confronts Obasanjo's Legacy.
Current History107, 708167.
34.
JarstadA.BelloniR. (2012).
Introducing Hybrid Governance: Impacts and Prospects of
Liberal Peacebuilding. Global Governance18, 11–6.
35.
KuglerJ.TammenR.L. (2012).
Performance of NationsNew York: Rowman &
Littlefield.
36.
KukahM. (2003). Human
Rights in Nigeria: Hopes and HindrancesAachen:
Missio.
37.
KumarC.de la HayeD. (2012).
Hybrid Peacekeeping: Building National “Infrastructures” For
Peace. Global Governance18, 113–20.
38.
LieseA.BeisheimM. (2010).
Transnational Public-private Partnerships and the Provision
of Collective Goods in Developing Countries.
Governance without a State? Policies and Politics in Areas of
Limited StatehoodRisseT.New York: Columbia University
Press.
MayerA.E. (1990).
Current Muslim Thinking on Human Rights.
Human Rights in Africa: Cross-cultural PerspectivesAn-Na'imA.DengF.Washington, DC: Brookings
Institution133–156.
41.
MenkhausK. (2006).
Governance without Government in Somalia: Spoilers,
Statebuilding, and the Politics of Coping.
International Security31, 374–106.
42.
MillerN.N. (1968).
The Political Survival of Traditional
Leadership. The Journal of Modern African
Studies6, 2Special Issue: Hybridity in Peacebuilding and Development183–198.
43.
Minorities at Risk
Project (2009). Minorities at Risk
Dataset. College Park, MD: Centre for International
Development and Conflict Management: www.cidcm.umd.edu/mar/, accessed September 1, 2011.
44.
MishlerW.RoseR. (2001).
What Are the Origins of Political Trust? Testing
Institutional and Cultural Theories in Post-communist
Societies. Comparative Political Studies34, 130–62.
45.
NewtonK. (2001).
Trust, Social Capital, Civil Society, and
Democracy. International Political Science
Review22, 2Special Issue: Hybridity in Peacebuilding and Development201–214.
46.
NewtonK. (2007).
Social and Political Trust. Oxford
Handbook of Political BehaviourDaltonR.KlingemannH.New York: Oxford University
Press.
47.
NewtonK.NorrisP. (2000).
Confidence in Public Institutions: Faith, Culture, or
Performance?. Disaffected DemocraciesPharrS.PutnamR.Princeton: Princeton University
Press.
48.
NnoliO. (1978). Ethnic
Politics in NigeriaEnugu: Fourth
Dimension.
49.
OkpanachiO. (2010).
Ethno-religious Identity and Conflict in Northern Nigeria:
Understanding the Dynamics of Sharia in Kaduna and Kebbi StatesIbadan: French Institute for
Research in Africa.
50.
OsteinP. (2007). Sharia
Implementation in Northern Nigeria, 1999–2006: A Sourcebook. Volumes
I–VIbadan: Spectrum
Books.
51.
OtiteO. (1990). Ethnic
Pluralism and Ethnicity in NigeriaIbadan:
Shancson.
52.
PadenJ. (2005). Muslim
Civic Cultures and Conflict Resolution: The Challenge of Democratic
Federalism in NigeriaWashington, DC: Brookings
Institution Press.
53.
ParisR. (2004). At War's
End: Building Peace after Civil ConflictNew York: Cambridge University
Press.
54.
RidleyM. (1997). The
Origins of Virtues: Human Instincts and the Evolution of
CooperationNew York:
Viking.
55.
Tabi'uM. (1987).
Controlling the Crime Rate in Nigeria: The Relevance of
Shari'ah. Shari'a, Social Change and Indiscipline in
NigeriaRashidS.Sokoto: University of Sokoto
Press.
