The concept of broad-based public participation is a fundamental element of health promotion and citizenship. There is a gap, however, between the promise and reality of citizen participation in health promotion. The purpose of this paper is to illustrate the utility of social marketing concepts in analyzing and better understanding the complexities of citizen participation. The data are drawn from a study on citizen participation during a recent health reform policy designed to foster health promotion in British Columbia, Canada.
A social marketing framework was used to interpret the data and make sense of citizen participation in a post-hoc analysis, particularly using the concepts of understanding the consumer perspective, exchange, marketing mix and segmentation. The results contradict the frequent criticism in health promotion that social marketing tends to ignore the broader context of individual behavior. This paper argues that social marketing yielded new insights into understanding the societal circumstances that inhibited or fostered citizen participation and offers a discussion of the potential of social marketing as a tool for furthering citizen participation in health promotion planning.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllawiS.J. (1997). Five irresistible forces. Healthcare Forum Journal, Jan.-Feb., 48–51.
2.
AndersonM.MeatonJ.PotterC. (1994). Public participation, an approach using aerial photographs at Ashford, Kent. Town Planning Review, 65(1): 41–58.
3.
AndreasenA. R. (1995). Marketing social change.San Francisco, CA: Jossey- Bass.
4.
BeresfordP.TrevillionS. (1995). Developing skills for community care.England: Arena.
5.
BriegerW. R.RamakrishnaJ.AdeniyiJ. D. (1986–87). Community involvement in social marketing: Guinea worm control. International Quarterly of Community Health Education, 7(1): 19–31.
6.
BuchananD.ReddyS.HossainZ. (1994). Social marketing: A critical appraisal. Health Promotion International, 9(1): 49–57.
7.
BuckwalterD.ParsonsR.WrightN. (1993). Citizen participation in local government: The use of incentives and rewards. Public Management, September: 11–15.
8.
CatfordJ. (1995). Health promotion in the market place: Constraints and opportunities. Health Promotion International, 10(1): 41–50.
9.
ChapmanWalsh D.RuddR. E.MoeykensB.A.MoloneyT.W. (1993). Social marketing for public health. Health Affairs, Summer: 104–119.
10.
ChavisD.WandersmanA. (1990). Sense of community in the urban environment: A catalyst for participation and community development. American Journal of Community Psychology, 18(1): 55–81.
11.
ChrislipD. (1995). Pulling together - creating a constituency for change. National Civic Review, Winter. 21–29.
12.
DonovanR. J.OwenN. (1994). Social marketing and population interventions. In DishmanR.K. (Ed), Advances in exercise adherence (pp. 249–290). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
13.
GeorgeW. R.ComptonF. (1990). How to initiate a marketing perspective in a health services organization. In LovelockC.H.WeinbergC.B. (Eds), Public and nonprofit marketing (pp. 251–259). San Francisco, CA: The Scientific Press.
14.
GreenL. W.GeorgeM. A.DanielM.FrankishC. J.HerbertC.BowieW. R.O'NeillM. (1995). Study of participatory research in health promotion. Review and recommendations for the development of participatory research in health promotion in Canada.University of British Columbia, Vancouver B.C.: The Royal Society of Canada.
15.
HastingsG.B.HaywoodA.J. (1994). Social marketing: A critical response. Health Promotion International, 9(1): 59–63.
16.
HawkerM. (1989). Consumer participation as community development: Action in an ambiguous context. Community Development Journal, 24(4): 283–292.
17.
HendersonL. J. (1990). Metropolitan governance: Citizen participation in the urban federation. National Civic Review, 79(2): 105–117.
18.
HildebrandtE. (1994). A model for community involvement in health (CIH) program development. Social Science in Medicine, 39(2): 247–254.
19.
HumeS. (1993). Government sponsored community development initiatives in B.C.: 1988–1993.University of Victoria: SPARC/FHSD Development Research Program.
20.
JewkesR.MurcottA. (1998). Community representatives: Representing the “community?”Social Science and Medicine, 46(7): 843–858.
21.
KellyK.J.Van VlaenderenH. (1996). Dynamics of participation in a community health project. Social Sciences in Medicine, 42(9): 1235–1246.
22.
LarsonP. (1997). Public and private values at odds: Can private sector values be transplanted into public sector institutions?Public Administration and Development, 17: 131–139.
23.
LefebvreR. C. (1992). The social marketing imbroglio in health promotion. Health Promotion International, 7(1): 61–64.
24.
LomasJ.VeenstraG. (1995). If you build it, who will come?Policy Options, November, 37–40.
25.
LovelockC. H.WeinbergC. B. (1989). Public and nonprofit marketing.Redwood City, CA: The Scientific Press.
26.
LovelockC. H.WeinbergC. B. (1990). Public and nonprofit marketing: Themes and issues for the 1990s. In LovelockC.H.WeinbergC.B. (Eds), Public and nonprofit marketing (pp. 3–15). San Francisco, CA: The Scientific Press.
27.
MariniF. (1993). “Can't get no satisfaction”: Customers, citizens, service and satisfaction. Public Administration Review, 53(2): 170–173.
28.
MarshallT. H. (1977). Class, citizenship and social development.Chicago: Chicago University Press.
29.
MontazeriA. (1997). Social marketing: A tool not a solution. Journal of the Royal Society of Health, 117(2): 115–118.
30.
NortonS.WandersmanA.GoldmanC.R. (1993). Perceived costs and benefits of membership in a self-help group: Comparisons of members and nonmembers of the Alliance for the Mentally Ill. Community Mental Health Journal, 29(2): 143–159.
31.
NovelliW.D. (1990). Applying social marketing to health promotion and disease prevention. In GlanzK.MarcusLewis F.RimerB. K. (Eds), Health behavior and health education (pp. 342–369). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
32.
PetermanW. (1996). The meanings of resident empowerment: Why just about everybody thinks it's a good idea and what it has to do with resident management. Housing Policy Debate, 7(3), 473–489.
33.
PriceR. (1990). Whither participation and empowerment?American Journal of Community Psychology, 18(1): 163–167.
34.
PriorD.StewartJ.WalshK. (1995). Citizenship: Rights, community and participation.London: Pitman Publishing.
35.
RifkinS. (1990). Community participation in maternal and child health/family programmes, an analysis based on case study materials.Geneva: World Health Organization.
36.
SearsA. (1996). Something different to everyone: Conceptions of citizenship and citizenship education. Canadian and International Education, 25(2): 1–16.
37.
SeverijnenP. C. A. (1994). Local authorities and market research: Market research incorporated in the policy process of consumer-oriented local authorities. Local Government Studies, 20(1): 34–43.
38.
SmithD. (1995). First person plural, a community development approach to social change.Montreal: Black Rose Books.
39.
SullivanM. J. L.ScattolonY. (1995). Health policy planning: A look at consumer involvement in Nova Scotia. Canadian Journal of Public Health: 86(5): 317–320.
40.
SymeG. J.NancarrowB. E. (1992). Predicting public involvement in urban water management and planning. Environment and Behavior, 24(6): 738–758.
41.
WallackL.DormanL.JerniganD.ThembaM. (1993). Media advocacy and public health.Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
42.
WalshK. (1989). Marketing in local government.U.K.: Longman Group.
43.
WharfHiggins J. (1999). Closer to home: The case for experiential participation in health reform. Canadian Journal of Public Health, 90(1): 30–34.
44.
WharfHiggins J. (1998). Social marketing and MARTIN: Tools for organizing, analyzing and interpreting qualitative data. Qualitative Health Research, 8(6): 867–876.
45.
WharfHiggins J. (1997). Who participates? Citizen participation in health reform in B.C. In WharfB.ClagueM. (Eds), Community organizing: Canadian experiences (pp. 271–301). Toronto, Ont: Oxford University Press.
46.
WolfM. (1993). Involving the community in national service. Social Policy, Fall: 14–20.
47.
World Health Organization. (1984). Health promotion concept and principles, a discussion document.Copenhagen: World Health Organization.
48.
YoungI. M. (1989). Together in difference: Transforming the logic of group political conflict. In KymlickaW. (Ed), The rights of minority cultures (pp. 155–178). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
