Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Pairs of high frequency English words, orthographically acceptable pseudo-words, and non-word letter strings were presented in a “same”-“different” task. The mean reaction times for “same” judgments were ordered; real words were faster than pseudo-words, and pseudo-words were faster than non-words. The RTs for the “different”, judgments showed no differences among the three types of words, except in the first two days of practice in a blocked presentation condition when the difference between the real words and non-words was marginally significant. These and other results suggest that “same” judgments are based upon a comparison process which efficiently uses higher order semantic and orthographic information in words, whereas “different” judgments are based upon comparison process which performs a self-terminating search of the graphemic information in words. The results were also discussed with reference to hierarchical models of word perception and reading.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bamber

(1969). Reaction times and error rates for “same”-“different” judgment of multidimensional stimuli. Perception and Psychophysics 6, 169–74.

Baron

Thurston

(1973). An analysis of the word-superiority effect. Cognitive Psychology 4, 207–28.

Cattell

J. M.

(1885). Ueber die Zeit der Erkennung und Bennenung von Schriftzeichen Bildern und Farben. Philosophische Studien 2, 635–50(On the time required for recognizing and naming letters and words, pictures and colors.) Trans. by R. S. Woodworth. In A. T. Poffenberger (Ed.) James McKeen Cattell: Man of Science (1947). Vol. 1, pp. 13–25. Lancaster, Pa.: The Science Press.

Cohen

(1968). A comparison of semantic, acoustic and visual criteria for matching of word pairs. Perception and Psychophysics 4, 203–4.

Egeth

Blecker

(1971). Differential effects of familiarity on judgments of sameness and difference. Perception and Psychophysics 9, 321–6.

Eichelman

W. H.

(1970). Familiarity effects in a simultaneous matching task. Journal of Experimental Psychology 86, 275–82.

Gibson

E. J.

(1971). Perceptual learning and the theory of word perception. Cognitive Psychology 2, 351–68.

Gibson

E. J.

(1972). Reading to some purpose. Language by Eye and by Ear Kavanaugh

J. F.

Mattingly

I. G.

Cambridge, Mass.: M.I.T. Press 3–19.

Gibson

E. J.

Shurcliff

Yonas

(1970). Utilization of spelling patterns by deaf and hearing subjects. Basic Studies in Reading Levin

Williams

J. P.

New York: Basic Books 57–73.

10.

Gibson

E. J.

Tenney

Y. J.

Barron

R. W.

Zaslow

(1972). The effect of orthographic structure on letter search. Perception and Psychophysics 11, 183–6.

11.

Gough

P. G.

(1972). One second of reading. Language by Eye and by Ear Kavanaugh

J. F.

Mattingly

I. G.

Cambridge, Mass.: M.I.T. Press 330–58.

12.

Henderson

(1974). A word superiority effect without orthographic assistance. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 26, 301–11.

13.

Klapp

(1971). Implicit speech inferred from response latencies in same-different decisions. Journal of Experimental Psychology 91, 262–7.

14.

Krueger

L. W.

(1973). Effect of irrelevant surrounding material on speed of same-different judgment of two adjacent letters. Journal of Experimental Psychology 98, 252–9.

15.

Mayzner

M. S.

Tresselt

M. E.

(1965). Tables of single-letter and digram frequency counts for various word length and letter position combinations. Psychonomic Science Monograph Supplements 1, 13–32.

16.

Mayzner

M. S.

Tresselt

M. E.

Wolin

B. R.

(1965). Tables of trigram frequency counts for various word length and position combinations. Psychonomic Science Monograph Supplements 1, 33–78.

17.

Nickerson

R. W.

(1972). Binary classification reaction time: a review of some studies of human information-processing capabilities. Psychonomic Science Monographs 4, 275–318.

18.

Posner

M. I.

Lewis

J. L.

Conrad

(1972). Component processes in reading: a performance analysis. Language by Eye and by Ear Kavanaugh

J. F.

Mattingly

I. G.

Cambridge, Mass.: M.I.T. Press 152–92.

19.

Reicher

G. M.

(1969). Perceptual recognition as a function of meaningfulness of stimulus material. Journal of Experimental Psychology 81, 275–80.

20.

Spoehr

K. T.

Smith

E. E.

(1972). Perceptual units and parsing processes in word perception St. Louis Paper presented at the Psychonomic Society.

21.

Thorndike

E. L.

Lorge

(1944). The Teacher's Word Book of 30,000 Words New York: Teachers College, Columbia University, Bureau of Publications.

22.

Wheeler

D. D.

(1970). Processes in word recognition. Cognitive Psychology 1, 59–85.

The Effect of Orthographic Structure and Lexical Meaning on “Same-different” Judgments

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References