Differential Runway Performance Using Goal Box Placement and Running Trials as Discriminative Stimuli

Abstract

Two experiments compared the effects of reinforced, partially reinforced and nonreinforced intertrial goal box placements (ITR, ITP, and ITN respectively) on runway performance. In Experiment I differential responding (animals running slower on nonreinforced (N) trials than on reinforced (R) trials) was observed during acquisition for subjects receiving ITP preceding N trials or subjects receiving ITP before R trials, and also for subjects receiving ITR preceding N trials. No differential responding was observed in subjects receiving ITP prior to both N and R trials or ITN prior to N trials. In extinction, the subjects which had responded differentially during acquisition demonstrated reduced resistance to extinction in comparison to the subjects which had not. In Experiment II, a 2 × 2 factorial design was utilized with placement schedule (ITN and ITP) and type of trial predicted by placement (N and R) serving as the factors. Differential responding was observed in all four groups. The apparent contradiction between the results and the discrimination hypothesis proposed by Capaldi and Olivier (1967) to explain the attenuation of ITR and ITN effects on resistance to extinction is discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Black

R. W.

Spence

K. W.

(1965). Effects of intertrial reinforcement on resistance to extinction following extended training. Journal of Experimental Psychology 70, 559–63.

Brown

R. T.

Logan

F. A.

(1965). Generalized partial reinforcement effect. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 60, 64–9.

Campbell

P. E.

Knouse

S. B.

Wroten

J. D.

(1970). Resistance to extinction in the rat following regular and irregular schedules of partial reward. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 72, 210–15.

Capaldi

E. J.

(1967). A sequential hypothesis of instrumental learning. In Spence

K. W.

Spence

J. T.

(Eds), The Psychology of Learning and Motivation: Advances in Research and Theory New York: Academic Press Vol. 1.

Capaldi

E. J.

(1971). Memory and learning: A sequential viewpoint. In Honig

W. K.

James

P. H. R.

(Eds), Animal memory New York: Academic Press.

Capaldi

E. J.

Haggbloom

S. J.

(1975). Response events as well as goal events as sources of animal memory. Animal Learning and Behaviour 3, 1–10.

Capaldi

E. J.

Hart

Stanley

L. R.

(1963). Effect of intertrial reinforcement on the aftereffect of nonreinforcement and resistance to extinction. Journal of Experimental Psychology 65, 70–74.

Capaldi

E. J.

Olivier

W. P.

(1967). Effect of intertrial reinforcement following a substantial number of consistently rewarded trials. Journal of Experimental Psychology 75, 135–8.

Homzie

M. J.

Gohmann

Hall

S. W.

(1971). Runway performance in rats as determined by the predictive values of intertrial reinforcements. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 74, 90–95.

10.

Homzie

M. J.

Rudy

J. W.

(1971). Effect on runway performance of reinforcement contingencies established to empty goal box placements. Learning and Motivation 2, 95–101.

11.

Homzie

M. J.

Rudy

J. W.

Carter

E. N.

(1970). Runway performance in rats as a function of goal box placements and goal event sequence. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 71, 283–91.

12.

Rudy

J. W.

(1971). Sequential variables as determiners of the rat's discrimination of reinforcement events: Effects on extinction performance. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 77, 476–81.

13.

Rudy

J. W.

Homzie

M. J.

(1970). Within-subject partial reinforcement with rats: Sequence and discriminability of reinforcement events. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 73, 445–69.

14.

Seybert

J. A.

Gerard

I. C.

Myers

J. F.

Baer

L. P.

Clipper

R. C.

(1976). Effects of intertrial partial reinforcement and level of acquisition on resistance to extinction. Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society 8, 7–9.

15.

Spence

K. W.

Platt

J. R.

Matsumoto

(1965). Intertrial reinforcement and the partial reinforcement effect as a function of number of training trials. Psychonomic Science 3, 205–6.

16.

Theios

Polson

(1962). Instrumental and goal responses in nonresponse partial reinforcement. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 55, 987–91.