Cost-effectiveness analysis of an alternative tuberculosis management strategy for permanent farm dwellers in South Africa amidst health service contraction

Abstract

Aim: To establish the cost-effectiveness of lay health workers (LHWs) in conjunction with the current, local tuberculosis (TB) control programme, amidst health service contraction. Method: A cost-effectiveness analysis, comparing direct time costs of the current TB management strategy among permanent farm dwellers, with an intervention, whereby LHWs are involved in TB control activities on farms. Measure of effectiveness was case finding and cure rates of adult new smear-positive (NSP) TB cases, alongside a randomized control trial (RCT): Results: The observed cost reduction to the Boland Health District was 74% per case detected and cured on the intervention farms relative to the control farms. Intervention farms reached 83% successful treatment completion rate, control farms 65%. Although the successful treatment adherence was significantly different (18% letter). The improved case detection and cure rates were not statistically significant (chisquared test). Direct LHW costs are borne by farmers. Farmers were motivated to bear costs by reduced job absenteeism and other positive side-effects. Even without outcome improvements costs per case cured were 59% lower on the intervention farms. Conclusion: TB control has suffered from budget reductions in South Africa. It is critically important to develop cost-effective strategies to reduce the TB burden. Costs to public budgets can be substantially reduced while maintaining or improving case detection and treatment outcomes, by using farm-based LHWs.

Keywords

Agriculture cost-effectiveness analysis lay health workers farms farmers farm dwellers farm workers tuberculosis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Squire SB , Tang S.

How much of China's success in tuberculosis control is really due to DOTS?

Lancet 2004;364:391—2.

Grange JM The Global Burden of Tuberculosis. In: Porter JDH , Grange JM , editors. Tuberculosis — an interdisciplinary perspective. London: Imperial College, 1999: 3—32.

National Tuberculosis Control Programme , South Africa, Report on Tuberculosis Recording and Reporting: 1995— 2001. Pretoria: Department of Health , 2003.

Dick J. , Mbewu A. , Matji . What obstacles to TB control? S Afr Med J 1999;89:132—3.

International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease (IUATLD) and the Royal Netherlands Tuberculosis Association (KNCV) , Revised international definitions in tuberculosis control. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2001;5:213—15.

Frieden TR , Sterling TR , Munsiff SS , Watt CJ , Dye C. Tuberculosis. Lancet 2003;362:887—98.

Dick J. , Henchie S. A Cost Analysis of the tuberculosis control programme in Elsies River, Cape Town. S Afr Med J 1998;88:380—3.

Department of Health, The South African Tuberculosis Programme. Practical Guidelines 1996. Pretoria: Department of Health, 1996.

World Health Organizsation , Status of Tuberculosis in the 22 high-burdened Countries and Global Constraints to TB Control. WHO/TB/98.242. Geneva: WHO, 1998.

10.

Wilkinson D. , Floyd K. , Gilks CF Costs and cost-effectiveness of alternative tuberculosis management strategies in South Africa — implications for policy. S Afr Med J 1997;87:451—5.

11.

Floyd K. Cost and cost-effectiveness — the impact of economic studies on TB control . Tuberculosis 2003;83:187—200.

12.

Maher D. The role of the community in the control of tuberculosis. Tuberculosis 2003;83:177—82.

13.

World Health Organization , Community contribution to TB care: Practice and policy. WHO/CDS/TB/2003.312. Geneva: WHO, 2003.

14.

Fast H. Farm workers in the Western Cape: Current conditions and options for change . Unpublished Report: Surplus People Project; 1997. p 13—18.

15.

Department of Health, Western Cape , The Provincial and District HIV Antenatal Survey. Cape Town: Department of Health Western Cape, 2001: 7—18.

16.

Boland District Council. TB information: areas 6—14. Unpublished memorandum, 12 May 2003.

17.

Dick J. , Clarke M. , Tibbs J. , Schoeman JH Combating TB — lessons learnt from a rural community project in the Klein Drakenstein area of the Western Cape. S Afr Med J 1997;87:1042—7.

18.

Clarke M. , Dick J. , Zwarenstein M. , Lombard C. , Diwan V. Lay health workers with patient choice of DOT superior to standard TB care systems in a commercial farming area of South Africa amidst health service contraction: A cluster randomised control trial . Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2005; 9(6): in press.

19.

Lewin S. , Dick J. , Pond P. , Zwarenstein M. , Aja G. , Van Wyk B. , Bosch-Capblanch X. , Patrick M. Lay Health workers in primary care and community health: A systematic review . Article in submission.

20.

Drummond MF , O'Brien B. , Stoddart GL , Torrance GW Methods for the economic evaluation of health care programmes. 2nd ed, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997.

21.

Johnston MP , Rifkin SB , editors. Health care together: Training exercises for health workers in community based programmes. London: Macmillan, 1987.

22.

Favish J. , Plasket M. Practitioner training course for Adult Basic Education and Training. Module 4. Pretoria: UNISA, 1997.

23.

Reuters. Rand steadies ahead of US Federal Reserve meeting. Cape Times, Business Report 30 June 2004. p 9.

24.

Pharmacy services, Provincial Administration Western Cape. Cost analysis of medicine needed to treat a MDR TB patient. Unpublished Circular, 18 March 2004.

25.

Weyer K. , Lancaster J. , Brand J. , Van der Walt M. , Levin J. Survey of tuberculosis drug resistance in the Western Cape, 2001—2002 . Medical Research Council, Pretoria .

26.

Helbling P.

HIV-related tuberculosis in sub-Saharan Africa: more drugs or more of the same?

Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2003;7:609—10.

27.

Hurtig AK , Porter JDH , Ogden JA Tuberculosis control and directly observed therapy from the public health/human rights perspective . Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 1999;3:553—60.

28.

Daniels K. , Van Zyl H. , Clarke M. , Dick J. , Johansson E. Ear to the ground: Listening to farm dwellers talk about the experience of becoming lay health workers. Health Policy. in press.

29.

Clarke M. , Dick J. , Van Zyl H. , Johansson E. Farmers' perceptions of the lay health worker on farms in the Western Cape, South Africa. Agrekon 2004;43:465—83.