Objective: This paper describes psychiatric and psychological defences to murder where the defence of insanity is not applicable. The charges of murder and manslaughter are outlined. Self-defence, sane and insane automatism, provocation, diminished responsibility, duress, necessity and novel defences are discussed.
Conclusions: The complexities of psychological and psychiatric expert evidence are highlighted as well as the fact that legal decisions are not always consistent with medical or scientific theory. It is concluded that this is a controversial and evolving area of mental health law and mental health professionals have an educative role and a responsibility to provide testimony that is supported by the best possible evidence.
BronittSMcSherryB. Manslaughter in Principles of Criminal Law. LBC, Sydney2001.
6.
HowardDWestmoreB. Crime and Mental Health Law in New South Wales: A Practical Guide for Lawyers and Health Care Professionals. LexisNexis Butterworths, Sydney2005.
7.
BluglassR, BowdenP. Principles and Practice of Forensic Psychiatry. London: Churchill Livingstone, 1990.
8.
Bratty v A-G for Northern Ireland {1963, p. 401}.
9.
R v Parks, 1992, 2 SCR 871.
10.
R v Burgess, 1991, Crim LR 548.
11.
Falconer v The Queen, 1990, 171, CLR 30.
12.
Rabey v The Queen(1981)54 CCC (2d) 1.
13.
R v Charlson, [1955]1 All ER 859.
14.
R v Sullivan[1983]2 All ER 673.
15.
R v Quick[1973]QB 910.
16.
Lord Hoffman in Smith[2000]UKHL 49.
17.
Law Reform Commission of Victoria. Provocation and Diminished Responsibility as Defences to Murder, Report No. 12, Melbourne: Law Reform Commission of Victoria, 1982.
18.
R v Mawbridge(1707)Keil 119.
19.
R V Kirkham(1837)8 C & P 115, 119.
20.
R v Welsh(1869)11 Cox CC 336, 339.
21.
Moffa v The Queen(1977)138 CLR 601.
22.
McSherryB. Men behaving badly: current issues in provocation, automatism, mental impairment and criminal responsibility. Psychiatry. Psychology and Law2005; 12: 15–22.
23.
Green v The Queen[1997]191 CLR 334.
24.
Mascianto v The Queen183 CLR 58.
25.
Hart v The Queen(2003)27 WAR 441.
26.
Stingel v The Queen(1990)171 CLR 312.
27.
R v Arden[1975]VR 449.
28.
Phillips v The Queen[1969]2 AC at 137.
29.
Peisley(1990)54 A Crim R 42 at 48.
30.
BrownDFarrierDEggerSMcNamaraLSteelA. Criminal Laws: Materials and Commentary on Criminal Law and Process in NSW4th ed. Federation Press, Sydney2006.
